5 ms·
I think the “new” (now 39 years old) method is superior overall, but I think it’s entirely factually correct that they took home prices out of the index. They
by sokoloff 4y ago
I think the “new” (now 39 years old) method is superior overall, but I think it’s entirely factually correct that they took home prices out of the index.
They did not take housing expenses out, which is what many people whose sole exposure to economics is via memes seem to think/be encouraged to think.
- lumost 4y agoI think the methodological flaw here is the assumption that nominal housing prices are elastic. Housing expenses fell over the last ~30 years as interest rates fell, however it's highly unlikely that the reverse will hold true to the same tune. If interest rates go to 10%, people will stop trading housing rather than take a nominal hit and be under water on a mortgage. This means that as interest rates rise, housing expenses may spike - forcing employees to demand more money. Given the size of the housing budget in many households, this effect could be surprisingly strong.
- imtringued 4y agoWhat people don't seem to understand is that the interest rate doesn't really change your monthly payment in aggregate for housing as you are competing with other people on the monthly payment who get roughly the same interest rate. If the interest rate goes up, more of your monthly payment goes to the bank and less to the existing homeowner. This is only beneficial if you can buy a house outright with cash i.e. the rich get to buy the dip.
- sokoloff 4y agoI think house sale prices are well understood to be sticky. (Sellers really hate the thought of bringing a check to the closing, so when prices are such that their equity after commission goes negative, housing listings and sales do indeed slow down.) I don't think the CPI methodology makes any assumption about elasticity of any particular component, though; it's a measurement process. People who are making interpretations or predictions based on CPI might be using faulty assumptions.
- gedy 4y agoMany people will, sure. But there's many people who either need or want to sell and that puts pressure on prices. Seen this many times in past decades in California at least.
- mywittyname 4y agoThe new methodology is clearly the better one. But headlines like this serve to reinforce the notion that somehow the "official" inflation figures are wrong. Which gives power to politicians who deliberately push this narrative; which is to day, dishonest ones. The fact is, lots people hear that "housing prices" aren't included in the CPI, and interpret that as housing costs are not included. There is no nuance for most people; for them, housing "prices" and housing "expenses" are the same thing. Normal people who are not economists or interested in economics at all are voters. It behooves people in the industry to speak clearly and plainly about these topics. Failure to do so hands that opportunity over to unscrupulous pundits who will speak plainly, but with a bend that favors their political opinions.
- em500 4y agoHow do you speak clearly and plainly about these topics? It's factually true housing prices aren't included in the CPI, but it's not easy to explain why and how replacing it with the somewhat abstract notion of housing services, estimated by owner equivalent rent is conceptually superior.
- randomdata 4y agoI would say the easiest way to explain it is, as implied by the "C", that CPI is intended to track consumption. Houses aren't normally consumed. Your house a decade from now is expected to be, more or less, the same house you purchased originally. You expect, more or less, to be able to sell it for at least as much as you paid for it originally. Whereas a consumable good, like food, is used up once you eat it and then you have to buy it again. Housing services are more like food. They are consumed. You use it up, to some meaning of use, and then you have to eventually buy it again to use it again. However, I'm not sure that's the struggle people have. From what I observe, they question if CPI is the best metric for measuring inflation, not whether or not durable assets should be considered consumables.
- throwaway_1928 4y ago> Houses aren't normally consumed. That is just a technicality. Housing is the greatest one time and recurring expense most people have and change in prices for housing has the greatest impact on their perception of how expensive things are.
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoThe headline is technically correct, but incredibly misleading to people who don't read past the headline.