8 ms·
Why unprecedented birdflu outbreaks sweeping the world are concerning scientists
- sandworm101 4y agoVictoria BC recently imposed social distancing rules on wild birds. People are being told to pull down feeders, to ignore those birds now begging for food at the window. Good luck enforcing that rule.
- eloff 4y agoThat sounds like an article that should be in the Onion. Life imitating art.
- ryanklee 4y agoI've got to squint pretty hard to see this. Seems pretty mundane and non-satirical to me. Birds have viruses and bird sociality contributes to them. Just stands to reason that controlling contributing factors like bird feeders would be among the mitigation strategies.
- myth_drannon 4y agoP.E.I the same rules
- myth_drannon 4y agoIt's actually controversial rule for bird feeders. It's not conclusive that the bird feeders do more harm than help. Some research indicates birds living near bird feeders have better immune system and can cope with diseases better.
- sandworm101 4y agoI'm not sure it would even reduce their social distancing. Maybe being more hungry increases their flocking behaviors.
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoYes, but they can still spread it to birds that don’t have that benefit. So does that make them a more viable disease vector than if they just dropped dead?
- robonerd 4y ago> People are being told to pull down feeders, to ignore those birds now begging for food at the window. Good luck enforcing that rule. "Bird-feeder? No no, that's my squirrel feeder."
- nick_ 4y agoAn upside-down funnel on the pole (into the ground) solves the squirrel feeder issue :)
- wombatpm 4y agoExcept when the squirrels can leap and land on the feeder itself. There are few good squirrel solutions
- sandworm101 4y agoIt might slow them down a few minutes but they will figure it out. There is no such thing as a squirrel-proof bird feeder.
- klyrs 4y agoNot a stable one, anyway. A normal feeder, hung from a drone flying 50' over a field, is squirrel-proof until the battery runs out.
- sandworm101 4y agoFifty feet in the air, swinging below a drones ... such a feeder would also be bird-proof.
- klyrs 4y agobroke: pffft, a trifling concern woke: three drones, to stabilize the swinging, and hanging far enough that the noise wouldn't be a bother. bespoke: a 50' pole interrupted by a 500rpm lawnmower blade at about 15' up, and topped with a bird feeder. The only reason people think squirrel-proof bird feeders are impossible is because they don't want to harm the squirrels. (and, for the record, neither do I)
- steve_adams_86 4y agoI had no idea about this. https://www.cheknews.ca/public-asked-to-remove-bird-feeders-due-to-avian-flu-bc-spca-1024002/ https://www.cheknews.ca/public-asked-to-remove-bird-feeders-... My yard is crawling (hopping?) with birds all day, every day. I don't even have feeders, though. Victoria is bird country.
- colechristensen 4y agoI would just assume any source of food (say, an oak tree) would concentrate birds and not feeding them in one place just means they’ll go somewhere else. Trying to social distance wild animals seems to be the action of a bird brained bureaucrat feeling like they needed to do something with no evidence at all of it being effective.
- robonerd 4y agoIt seems like a manifestation of the old adage that when you only have a hammer, every problem looks like a nail.
- m0llusk 4y agoThe densities are completely different and result in different patterns of use. Bird feeders distribute large amounts of food from a small space. Large flocks of different types of birds gather at feeders and may fight for access. There is a big difference between a feeder having plenty of seed and a tree having maybe some bugs and seeds on its many branches.
- wk_end 4y agoHi fellow Victorian :) To my knowledge, this isn't a "rule" that's "imposed" or "enforced" by the city - the SPCA (which is not a government agency, just a non-profit) has just asked people to do it voluntarily.
- xemoka 4y agoAnother Vancouver Islander here, exactly as you say, there has been no "rules" implemented by anyone in any government position. This is the BC SPCA, a non-profit, asking people with bird feeders to take them down: https://spca.bc.ca/news/bird-salmonella-outbreak/ https://spca.bc.ca/news/bird-salmonella-outbreak/
- sandworm101 4y agoNot actually there myself but was speaking to family there about the issue. While it may not be a law enforced by cops, Canadians are generally pretty good about following announcements by groups like the SPCA.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoI’m worried about my 5 chickens and what happens if they catch it(I know they will die but like does the USDA come knocking and then burn my flock and coop to the ground?). I’ve taken down the feeders and gotten a fake owl to try to get rid of birds in the vicinity but they are still all over the place. There is not really anything more I can do but lock them up in the coop all summer but that would drive them nuts and could stress them out to the point of death anyway. This sucks.
- javajosh 4y agoSo this would be a very HN thing to do, but what about building autonomous turrets that identify birds and shoot them with something that scares them away? (Note that killing them is not only distasteful, but adds another problem: those bird corpses will attract other unwanted animals, so it's a non-starter anyway). EDIT: instead of downvoting, please comment so I can understand why you don't like this idea.
- _Microft 4y agoAnother guess at tomorrow's top submission: "Show HN: I turned my coop into a 3D CAVE to keep my chickens from going crazy" ;)
- javajosh 4y agoWell, now that you mention it, it would be interesting to see if a screen, or the content of the screen, had any impact on the chickens. Probably the easiest thing to measure would be egg production, but you might be able to measure "well-being" in some way. (I don't know much about chickens, but I've heard they are extremely stupid, so it may have no impact.)
- rolph 4y agothey are very responsive to light spectrum; intensity; and periodicity. you can manipulate egg production, and breeding cycles by manipulating lighting parameters, and providing specific nutritional supplements.
- sigspec 4y ago
- rubyist5eva 4y ago[flagged]
- tomatowurst 4y agowhat if you have bird feeders in your garden, do you think they pose a risk? These are small birds, are they susceptible? Maybe I should move it.
- anm89 4y agoIn many of the bird watching facebook groups I'm in people are saying they are taking theirs down unfortunately.
- tomatowurst 4y agoalright think I might end up doing the same, I really enjoyed seeing them feast :( do you think its still dangerous to move the bird house to a remote corner of the garden?
- anm89 4y agoha, I honestly have no idea. I know very little about birds. I just drown my fb out with bird and mushroom groups so at least if I waste time on there I'll learn something or at least look at pictures of nature.
- cheese_van 4y agoIn some gov circles, the scenario often postulated is that a bird flu variant would be globally spread by Hajj pilgrims leaving Mecca to return to their various homes. The average yearly Hajj partipation is about 2.5 million people. It's estimated by some that 500 million migratory birds pass through Saudi Arabia.
- rcohngru 4y agoCouldn't the same be said for any major area that attracts millions of visitors each year? Before covid ~30 million people were visiting Paris each year from all over the world.
- christkv 4y agoI think the concern is how packed people are during the pilgrimage making it a perfect caldron of potential infection. Like a packed concert but with millions.
- onion2k 4y agoI would guess that the combination of migratory birds and temporary visitors is what's important. Paris doesn't have much in the way of migratory birds.
- MengerSponge 4y agoThe temporal distribution matters. Hajj is 2-3 million people over something like 5 days. The next largest global event I can imagine is the World Cup, which is estimated to be 1.5 million people distributed across several venues later this year.
- CommanderData 4y agoWorld Cup has copious amount of hookup culture (just look through Tinder when the season plays in your city), Grindr and general clubbing in these areas. I've been a visitor during a World Cup and its not just the football people go for. There's even a term for it: World Cup fever, not just isolated to world cups, many other sporting events have the same problem of being super spreading events for STIs https://sexualhealthbucks.nhs.uk/latest/world-cup-fever/ https://sexualhealthbucks.nhs.uk/latest/world-cup-fever/ I'd also say prolonged contact and mingling is worse then a short one like above, plenty of time to pub and club crawl, sleep with multiple partners, allowing disease to expell after its normal 5-6day incubation period.
- kurupt213 4y agoA novel human influenza would be way more devastating than covid was. Sure, we know how to make influenza vaccines, but millions could die before vaccines rolled out. And influenza kills healthy young adults in addition to the very young and very old. That is devastating from a demographic standpoint. Covid’s preying on the sick and elderly was tragic, but not a threat that could destabilize countries from a population standpoint.
- charles_kaw 4y ago>millions could die before vaccines rolled out Millions died from covid before vaccines rolled out
- kurupt213 4y agoBut not millions of children and healthy young adults. Those are very different outcomes from a public health standpoint
- mschuster91 4y agoOn the other hand, long-covid is estimated to be at ~7% of all infections, with 5.8% of infected being out of work for longer than 4 weeks [1]. That is a pretty massive amount, given how many people have been infected with covid in total. I personally know two people who have been impacted to the point they can't work even half a year post infection - this virus is nothing to sneeze at. [1] https://www.rki.de/SharedDocs/FAQ/NCOV2019/FAQ_Liste_Gesundheitliche_Langzeitfolgen.html https://www.rki.de/SharedDocs/FAQ/NCOV2019/FAQ_Liste_Gesundh...
- kurupt213 4y agoI’m not trying to imply COVID (literally SARS2) isn’t serious. I’m saying it could have been worse. The hardest hit demographic in Toronto during the Spanish flu was men in their 20s. People died the same day they became symptomatic. That would completely overwhelm our health infrastructure. We don’t have the infrastructure for a pandemic that causes respiratory arrest within hours of symptom onset (the dreaded rapid onset of influenza). Covid gave people days to prepare…and still caught some by surprise.
- AftHurrahWinch 4y agohttps://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.02.11.479922v2.full.pdf https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.02.11.479922v2.... "Intercontinental movement of H5 2.3.4.4 Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza A(H5N1) to the United States, 2021" Bits I found interesting: > The initial US detection was from a sample collected on December 30, 2021 from a wigeon in Colleton County, South Carolina (A/American_wigeon/South_Carolina/AH0195145/2021(H5N1), GISAID [https://www.gisaid.org https://www.gisaid.org] accession no. EPI_ISL_9869760). Immediately following this initial detection, there was an additional wild bird detection in South Carolina (A/bluewinged_teal/South_Carolina/AH0195150/2021(H5N1), GISAID accession no. EPI_ISL_9876777) and detections in neighboring North Carolina (Figure 1). Within six weeks there were 137 additional detections in wild birds, indicating high susceptibility to a novel virus and continued dispersal. All birds were apparently healthy hunter harvested dabbling ducks. There was no detection of North American lineage IAV in any of these samples. ---------------------- State - Wild bird species - Number of Clade 2.3.4.4. HP IAV Detections ---------------------- South Carolina - American wigeon - 7 South Carolina - Blue-winged teal - 9 South Carolina - Gadwall - 7 South Carolina - Northern shoveler - 1 North Carolina - American green-winged teal - 9 North Carolina - Northern shoveler - 3 North Carolina - American wigeon - 51 North Carolina - Gadwall 15 North Carolina - Mallard 4 North Carolina - Northern pintail 3 North Carolina - Wood duck 1 Virginia - American green-winged teal - 2 Virginia - Mallard - 1 Florida - Blue-winged teal - 2 Delaware - American wigeon - 1 Delaware - Northern shoveler - 2 New Hampshire - Mallard - 20 ---------------------- Total Detections: 138
- at_compile_time 4y agoThis wasn't the first virus spawned by animal agriculture, and it won't be the last. I'm sure that people are genuinely concerned, but their concern rarely leads them to question their participation in the systems that cause these problems.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- greazy 4y agoYou're mistaken. These are wild viruses circulating among wild avian populations. When wild birds come into contact with domesticated animals, avian influenza can infect them causing disease and death in the farm animals. But farmed animals can be a factor in zoonic infection of avian influenza into humans.
- at_compile_time 4y agoThey're wild viruses, but we've given them the perfect environment to mutate: massive populations of animals packed as closely together as possible. It's no coincidence this is happening now. We've tripled poultry production over the last 30 years and intensified its production. This allows viruses to evolve in ways that would be incredibly difficult in wild populations. It was only a matter of time until something like this happened.
- greazy 4y agoAgain you are mistaken and wrong. The viruses in domesticated birds aren't somehow different from wild populations. This isn't a breeding ground or the perfect environment for evolution. That's just nonsensical ideas borne of ignorance. Influenza virus can undergo reassortment where the different gene segments from different su types can combine to form a new virus. Eg H5N1 reassorting with H2N8 to result in H5N8. This is one of the possible cases that can result in HPAI. Such situations happen more in the wild. The flow of virus diversity is from wild to domestic bird populations. The article is also about wild birds. Please stop posting nonsense.
- ars 4y ago" the virus killed roughly 10% of the breeding population of barnacle geese" Isn't that a very good thing? !0% is not enough to seriously harm them, but it is enough to make sure that the survivors are resistant. If it stays at 10%, then after a couple years the birds should be immune to it.
- greazy 4y agoWhen highly pathogenic avian influenza outbreaks happen, the death rate is extremely high. What's not quoted is the infection rate. Usually HPAI is extremely deadly. So for wild geese that is a very high death count. Wild birds do not usually survive HPIA, so immunity is not achieved.
- anm89 4y agoI always find this framing of "concerning scientists" to be really strange. Like there is some cabal of scientists who sit around keep track of what is worrying and not. And the fundamental thing that allows you to be worried is that you use the scientific method in your day job? I think as many homesteaders, and poultry farmers, and zoo keepers are worried. Why don't we just say people are worried about this?
- puffoflogic 4y ago"People" can be wrong. Scientists cannot.
- greazy 4y agoBecause the ones surveying the situation and the ones with the most knowledge are scientists. They're also the ones who sound the alarm first. Weird comment. I mean did you see it as Nature article?