5 ms·
Crypto assets are ‘worth nothing,’ says ECB’s Christine Lagarde
- throwaway22032 5y agoAwesome. I'll buy all the bitcoin you have at twenty grand a coin then. It's not even good propaganda, they've been waffling for over a decade now. You're just full of shit and everyone knows it.
- baisq 5y agoThat's nice, I hope that means that they still stop taxing crypto!
- belter 5y agoSame Lagarde four years ago: "'Fight fire with fire': IMF's Lagarde calls for bitcoin crackdown" https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/mar/13/imf-christine-lagarde-calls-bitcoin-crackdown-cryptocurrencies https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/mar/13/imf-chris... Also from the article... "... ..Lagarde revealed she had never invested in crypto assets, but her son had — with little luck...A digital euro, however, would be an entirely different ball game, Lagarde explained..." "...The day when we have the central bank digital currency, any digital euro, I will guarantee it," she said. "So the central bank will be behind it. I think that is vastly different from any of those things..."
- iamacyborg 5y agoA digital Euro (or whatever other currencies, the acronym escapes me right now) doesn’t really have all that many similarities to cryptocurrency.
- david-gpu 5y agoI believe the term you are looking for is Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) [0]. I agree they are unrelated to cryptocurrencies. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_bank_digital_currency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_bank_digital_currency
- iamacyborg 5y agoYep, that’s the one!
- woodpanel 5y agoA crypto-euro would of course be "an an entirely different ball game" because what else do eurocrats yearn for if not the holy grail of dystopian surveillance power, with it's "blockchain" being a centralized DB with every single financial transaction of yours. Don't get with the programme du jour? Let's see how much you dare to dissent the latest decree if your ability to pay anything can be eclipsed by a mouse-click. Let alone retrieving any of your savings.
- jsiaajdsdaa 5y agoMathematically, that's a pretty strong argument, since Bitcoin might be worth something like. $0.000001 USD which is still not nothing.
- automatic6131 5y agoI think a single bitcoin is worth about as much as someone interested in owning a piece of financial history, libertarian art and/or a token of mass psychosis would be willing to pay for one of 21 million of them. I think people would pay ~10 USD give or take an order of magnitude, for such a curiosity.
- rglullis 5y agoThere is no point is talking about a "single" bitcoin. It's about the network. To have people paying 10USD for a coin would imply that there are people keeping at least 210M USD worth of mining equipment running 24/7.
- strken 5y agoHow do you get 210M USD from 10 USD? Not a rhetorical question, I'm interested in how the maths works. Are you using the dollar amount to guess how many miners would be active, and where exactly do all the numbers to do that come from?
- throwaway744678 5y agoProbably the cost of operating the computing resources for a functioning network ?
- TacticalCoder 5y agoGP obviously did "21 millions bitcoins ever mined at most times 10 USD a piece", which gives 210 M. No idea if that's correct or not from a game-theory standpoint. All I know is no matter your mining power and no matter if you own 50%+1 of the network or 100% of the network or 0% of the network: this doesn't give you the right to sign transactions moving coins you don't own the private keys to.
- Bubble_Pop_22 5y ago
- orwin 5y agoThey are worth their estate+their productive assets in a perfect world with perfect information. But in the real world, they are worth all that plus their brand, and that's the price of bitcoins. I don't think eth/monero are worth much, but it's still orders of magnitude more useful than btc. I can live with that. I think it is one of the biggest proof of our species stupidity, bias and limitations.
- Bubble_Pop_22 5y ago> But in the real world, they are worth all that plus their brand, and that's the price of bitcoins That's right, so the question is why are central bankers sensitive and genuflecting to POTUS brand, while they are hostile and attacking the crypto brand? It's the same phenomenon.
- orwin 5y agoI don't disagree. In a perfect world, branding does nothing as i said.
- 98Windows 5y agoTaleb has a paper arguing Bitcoins expected long term value is infact 0: https://arxiv.org/abs/2106.14204 https://arxiv.org/abs/2106.14204
- madsbuch 5y ago> In its current version, ... One should be vary careful about not conflating Crypto as a whole and Bitcoin. I agree with Taleb on the assessment of Bitcoins, but I think we need to wait a couple of years before we can assess the success of Crypto as a whole.
- rglullis 5y agoYes, that is key. His call-out is mostly against those saying that crypto works as a "store of value", which has become the party line from BTC maxis after it has become clear that it failed as a currency.
- csomar 5y agoWithout a timeline, this is quite useless. Everything we know and have today will have an expected value of 0 at some point (including you)
- 98Windows 5y agoI believe Taleb's timeline is not as long term as the heat death of the universe or end of civilisation. He's saying that a rational market should value bitcoin at 0 because it has 0 utility. If I buy shares in Walmart I receive a dividend, if I buy shares in Amazon I know they will do share buy backs with their profits and hence increase the value of my investment. Bitcoin has zero value or utility for me, unless I can sell it to someone else before it eventually goes to 0.
- imtringued 5y agoTo be fair, it's the same with fiat. For every dollar there is also a dollar of debt. If all debts were paid off, you would end up with nothing, except everything we created in the real world. Now, the question shouldn't be how much value is in the accounting system, because it obviously stores nothing, it only delegates the management of the store of value in the real world. The question should be, does Bitcoin help the real world economy? I honestly don't know but I am leaning towards no. The lightning story could in theory result in a "happy end" but I haven't seen any real successes or at least I am not being made aware of them. After all, El Salvador isn't the success story that everyone hoped for.
- Quindecillion 5y agoIt's worth whatever people are willing to pay for it. Simple as that. Bureaucrats like Lagarde, or anyone for that matter, don't get to declare from their perch what does and doesn't have worth to others. Her statements are... well, worthless... to millions of other people.
- 98Windows 5y agoThere's a difference between value today and expected value in the future. A loaf of bread has value today but I wouldn't stockpile fresh bread because I know it quickly loses value
- misja111 5y agoI'm not a fan of Bitcoin but this statement is nonsense. A Bitcoin is worth something because some people are willing to pay for it, just like a car is worth something for that same reason. You might say that a car has 'real value' because it can help you to travel from place A to B. But similarly a Bitcoin has real value, at least for some people, because it can help you transfer or store money. One might say that there are better alternatives for Bitcoin, which might make Bitcoin eventually obsolete and worthless. But again similarly, for every car on the market right now, there will be probably a better alternative in the future. It's amazing to hear the chief of ECB make a statement so obviously and fundamentally wrong.
- kgwgk 5y ago> But similarly a Bitcoin has real value, at least for some people, because it can help you transfer or store money. It does that function just as well (not that well, really) at 30’000 dollars per bitcoin as it does at 30’000 bitcoins per dollar.
- tyrfing 5y agoWith a market cap of $700, you would find that it is very poor at both transferring and storing any value. First of all, you're limited to $700, second, a single computer could attack the network.
- kgwgk 5y agoFair enough. But even a small amount could suffice if the turnover was fast enough. How many of the circulating bitcoins are used in transactions anyway?
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>It's amazing to hear the chief of ECB make a statement so obviously and fundamentally wrong. Oh you sweet summer child. Remember when Olaf Scholz said, while he was minister of finance, that the best way to invest is to keep your money in your checking account? Yeah, those are EU politicians and their financial wisdom for you. I'm surprised the EU is still functioning and hasn't yet collapsed with such morons at the helm.
- loxs 5y agoBitcoin is worth something exactly because of people like Lagarde. It is our insurance against them.
- iqkznnft 5y agoMy favorite thing about these kind of statement, is seeing cryptobros reeeeeeeeing.
- rvz 5y agoIt is the other way round. The 'crypto-bros' are actually laughing at her as she is the one 'reeeeing' because she and the ECB knows that they cannot stop all of them and their only option is to put in regulations for tolerating a few compliant crypto assets. For absolutist statements like her's, the only reason they are doing that is to promote their own digital euro in the form of a CBDC, which is good timing when a crash in the crypto markets happen.
- iqkznnft 5y agoI don't get it. What is a "digital euro"? Aren't most euros already digital?
- loxs 5y agoWhen you see cryptobros reeing, it's a great opportunity to buy a little, so that you don't drool on the sides during the next run.
- rpastuszak 5y ago> It is our insurance against them. How?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- loxs 5y agoThey can't block your crypto account/wallet like they did with bank accounts in Greece, Cyprus, Iceland etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_controls_in_Greece https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_controls_in_Greece Even only this is enough, but there are many more ways this insurance works.
- hapticmonkey 5y ago> ”there is no underlying assets to act as an anchor of safety.” As opposed to the Euro. Right?
- kvdveer 5y agoThe underlying asset for euro's is debt. There's a lot to argue about whether debt makes a good asset for this purpose, but at least there's something. If you have a euro, somewhere, a debtor is obligated to give you a euro of value. There is no such obligation for bitcoin.
- tomputer 5y agoFull quote from the article: My very humble assessment is that it is worth nothing. It is based on nothing, there is no underlying assets to act as an anchor of safety.
- pelagicAustral 5y ago'Don't hold back'
- edem 5y agoYeah yeah. We've been hearing this over and over - especially in bear markets - yet crypto is not only still around but it is also getting relentlessly adopted.
- ur-whale 5y agoShe would know, she's after all in charge of the ECB, whose sole purpose is to promote and manage the use of another entirely worthless commodity.
- madsbuch 5y agoMay 21st, interesting... the views appear to be quite outdated. > A digital euro, however, would be an entirely different ball game There exists quite a number of different EUR stable coin projects out there. Most of the active Crypto community have already abandoned Bitcoin. Heck, for more than a year the the hype has been on dApps.
- jimmydeans 5y agoECB is scared. These people will lie to keep control. Crazy.
- 98Windows 5y agoOr they want their citizens to avoid investing in a ponzi scheme which steals their hard earned cash?
- jacknews 5y agoShe must be being facetious, because what is the Euro? It's simply a made-up unit of account that everyone (currently) agrees can be exchanged for good and services, and other units of account (currencies). If her argument is that governments will 'back up' the currency, what will they back it up with? More of the currency? Basically the Euro is 'worth' nothing too, it's only trust. Even though I'm not much of a fan of crypto, it's essentially the same, it's just trust, though cryptos maybe have shakier foundations, and could implode with no-one even attempting to maintain their value. The big difference might be that states can 'back up' their currency by forcing citizens (with violence) to accept, and pay in their currency. An imposed delusion, rather than a shared delusion, perhaps.