4 ms·
In the end, painting is 99% a practiced skill, and 1% original human thought. And this 1% is arguably comparable in effort to what is provided as input to an AI
by amelius 5y ago
In the end, painting is 99% a practiced skill, and 1% original human thought. And this 1% is arguably comparable in effort to what is provided as input to an AI tool.
- xbar 5y agoIs human thought only at the outset of a piece of art?
- sloan 5y agoThat is far too reductive
- politician 5y agoHuman DNA is only 1% different than chimps. 1% is not that reductive.
- civilized 5y agoThis is a great way to put it.
- andsoitis 5y agoyour behavior and thinking is purely a function of your DNA?
- teawrecks 5y agoI mean, according to a physicalist's view of the human condition, yes. You are a function of the haploid cells your parents conceived you with, and the environment those cells responded to over your lifetime.
- ben_w 5y agoI would say that “and the environment” means “no, not purely a function of your DNA”.
- extrememacaroni 5y agoSometimes I wonder if hackernews ever does anything with the ideas it generates or if it just gets a kick out of generating them.
- dekhn 5y agoactually, that stat is completely and totally wrong. If you take the most similar parts of human and chimp DNA- just the well-aligned proteins- then yes, we differ by 1%. But that's not a metric that means much, if at all, since many aspects of phenotypes are not controlled by the difference in our protein coding regions.
- kingkawn 5y agolmao no
- jedimastert 5y agoI would disagree with that. Much of creating art is a feedback loop. An artist rarely, if ever, has a fully formed picture in their mind of what a finished piece will look like, and it's even more rare that the final piece conforms to that image. In the process of creating, the artist takes in what is in progress and has to adjust accordingly. The final piece is influenced by the medium it's created in, the process of creating it, constraints both momentary and well-known, and the context of the time and whims of the artist.
- amelius 5y agoGood point, I'm guessing there will be successors to Dall-E that will address this and implement support for human feedback.
- User23 5y agoI don’t think 99% of the population or even art students could paint Dürer’s rabbit no matter what training or incentive was offered. Also the history of pigments is fascinating. There’s a whole lot lot more to painting than brush strokes.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> In the end, painting is 99% a practiced skill, and 1% original human thought True, but the line between art and great art is 99% thought and 1% skill.
- meroes 5y agoThe billions of images and its software determine its outputs right? Is there the same analogy for humans? I don’t think so. It’s much harder to imagine a deterministic story of how we developed set theory for example. Nothing empirical forces us into set theory. It’s not needed by physics for example. The billions of images and software plus the entered phrase fully determine the output right? What possibly similar story gave rise to things like set theory?