4 ms·
We've been able to do this for decades. It's a core part of our PKI ecosystem.
by woodruffw 5y ago
We've been able to do this for decades. It's a core part of our PKI ecosystem.
- WFHRenaissance 5y agoSurely, but PKI still relies on cert authorities which have been compromised before
- woodruffw 5y agoDeFi is, after all, notably devoid of serious compromises :-) More seriously: there are cryptographically sound schemes (like CT) that address CA compromise.
- WFHRenaissance 5y agoCT is cool, but who is writing/submitting those logs?
- woodruffw 5y agoThere are multiple, independent entities both maintaining and submitting to the logs. The short answer: CAs submit precertificates to the logs; the logs respond with signed certificate timestamps that are embedded within the ultimate certificate rendered to the user. User agents (i.e., browsers) cross-check against the logs using the SCTs. Third parties ("monitors") additionally watch the logs for suspicious events (unexpected issuances, unusual certificates being signed for, etc.) There's a nice visualization here[1]. [1]: https://certificate.transparency.dev/howctworks/#stepby https://certificate.transparency.dev/howctworks/#stepby
- razemio 5y agoNot without a middlemen that we trust (cert authority in this case).
- vlovich123 5y agoThat's certainly not true. P2P file transfer systems have long provided cryptographic guarantees that the file you receive hasn't been modified by anyone, even though you're fetching it from multiple untrusted sources simultaneously. Merkle trees have made this more efficient and offered maybe more guarantees, but being able to have files be transferred in a distributed fashion but impervious to corruption is not a new invention. The one thing cryptocurrencies have not figured out how to solve is the root problem of all PKI systems, which is establishing trust of identity.
- razemio 5y agoThat is different use case. How would I prove that a file existed without a middlemen? I would gladly switch since the method I am currently using isn't exactly cheap.
- joshstrange 5y agoCould you share you use-case and current method? I have no advice for you I'm just interested in how this is being used and who is providing said services.
- woodruffw 5y ago> How would I prove that a file existed without a middlemen? How are you defining "middleman"? You can do this with any basic commitment scheme: take a cryptographically secure hash of your file and publish it somewhere that's either (1) trivially copyable, or (2) difficult to tamper with. Alternatively, you could do an online scheme where someone asks you for your proof and you present them with your hash after being challenged. That's a gross oversimplification, but it's the general idea. (In general, "prove that a file existed" is not something that you often want to do in the real world. What is it you're actually trying to accomplish?)
- razemio 5y agoI work with ALOT of documents that have a deadline / need to be finished at a certain time. The blockchain helps me to proof mathematical in front of a curt that the file already existed at a given date. It is the most secure way that I know. A simple example of what I need without a middlemen. A student writes a thesis. The last time he is allowed to modify the file is friday evening. He can now send the file via mail or deliver in person to prove that the thesis was finished by then. However he then trusts either the mail server administration or the person at the front desk. This is fine in most cases and works like this since decades. I however do not want to trust a person or company. I do not want ANY possible explanation how I could have archived it in a different way.
- onionisafruit 5y agoPKI is cryptography.
- woodruffw 5y agoWhere was it implied that it wasn't? Of course it's cryptography.
- onionisafruit 5y agoNevermind me. I was being an idiot thinking crypto was cryptography.
- orwin 5y agoFor 30+ year olds who learned by cracking video games, used eMule/limewire and partipated in crypto CTF, crypto is still cryptography, but let's be honest, this usage is loosing.