14 ms·
Senators Urge FTC to Probe ID.me over Selfie Data
- ziddoap 5y agoID.me has had quite a bit of controversy. Some interesting related non-Krebs (I don't support Krebs after his doxxing of innocent people) reads: https://www.techdirt.com/2022/02/01/idme-finally-admits-it-runs-selfies-against-preexisting-databases-as-irs-reconsiders-partnership-with-company/ https://www.techdirt.com/2022/02/01/idme-finally-admits-it-r... https://www.techdirt.com/2022/02/15/idme-doesnt-have-enough-humans-to-backstop-ai-allowed-guy-bad-wig-to-illegally-obtain-900000-benefits/ https://www.techdirt.com/2022/02/15/idme-doesnt-have-enough-...
- mig39 5y agoCan you elaborate on the Krebs doxxing innocent people thing?
- password4321 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27440675#27448881 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27440675#27448881 > https://itwire.com/business-it-news/security/infosec-researchers-slam-ex-wapo-man-krebs-over-doxxing.html https://itwire.com/business-it-news/security/infosec-researc... (2019) > https://itwire.com/business-it-news/security/krebs-accused-of-doxxing-man-based-on-single-source-in-twitter-scam-yarn.html https://itwire.com/business-it-news/security/krebs-accused-o... (2020) https://hn.algolia.com/?query=krebs%20doxx&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=krebs%20doxx&sort=byDate&type=...
- ziddoap 5y agoThe short of it is during one of his investigative blog posts, he released the real life names of two security researchers who he believed (based on a single source from Twitter) ran a scam. Sean Hollister, a reporter for The Verge (among others) rightfully called out Krebs' actions as extremely misguided and potentially harmful [1]. In another case, he released the names and details of the people he believed were running the Coinhive cryptomining scam. He also compiled and released information on three people who he thought were connected to the Shadow Brokers group, although he has since unpublished that post (some analysis at [2]). There's even an urban dictionary term: 'krebbed' [3]. There's been discussion here, and elsewhere, although it's mainly back-and-forths on Twitter. The issue I take with it is separate from whether or not he was correct, but that he is taking it upon himself to act as the judge, jury and executioner of potentially innocent people by releasing names and personal details of people on his blog and on Twitter. Edit to add: He's even posted someone's passport before, which is kind of wild to think about [4]. [1] https://twitter.com/StarFire2258/status/1283892893539635200 https://twitter.com/StarFire2258/status/1283892893539635200 [2] https://www.emptywheel.net/2017/11/28/the-russian-metadata-in-the-shadow-brokers-dump/ https://www.emptywheel.net/2017/11/28/the-russian-metadata-i... [3] https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=krebbed https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=krebbed [4] See his blog post "Meet the World’s Biggest ‘Bulletproof’ Hoster", where he still has the dudes passport picture (with all info, no redactions) up.
- vorpalhex 5y agoIt should be noted that posting someones identity is distinctly not the same as executing them.
- ziddoap 5y agoIf you need that noted, I'm worried. It's an expression that I thought most people would understand, but to make it abundantly clear: I do not think that Krebs is executing people. Nor do I think he has the legal training to be a judge. He might have been on a jury before, I'm not sure. I am using it as an expression to state that he is taking upon himself the task that is normally reserved for either LEA and/or the court system, which is ascribing guilt.
- chipsa 5y agoHe appears to be acting as an investigative reporter. Such acts have a long history of naming and shaming people, even ones that were not previously public figures. That he writes for his own publication is not really material to the fact that he is acting as a reporter.
- ziddoap 5y agoFunny enough to some, I disagree with any reporter who names private citizens with little proof and no avenue for recourse. Especially when they post things like a persons non-redacted passport, for example, which has plenty of personal information that is not material to the story in any which way. If you have enough information to release a bunch of personal information on someone and tell thousands of people that they are guilty of something, you should go to the appropriate LEA and either take some care writing your story or wait until an actual investigation has happened, reporting on those results. Edit to add: At least in this case, regarding Krebs, it would seem that at least one senior editor and journalist agrees with me that Krebs acted unethically (see the first comment for a link to a tweet by a senior editor at The Verge). Other major news organizations (e.g. CBC) have policies not to named those only accused of a crime, except in extenuating circumstances or after a charge is laid/legal proceedings have begun. They must also report on the outcome of the criminal investigation.
- sandworm101 5y agoYears ago I read about a Russian product based on facial recognition. Their pitch was that you could take a picture of an attractive stranger, send them the picture, and for 100$ they would send you all of her information in a matter of minutes so that you could strike up a conversation. Of course this sound really creepy, but why? The information is public. Is it the amount of money? Police and governments want this sort of tool. We don't bat an eye when a cop uses such tools to pull all of your license/insurance information during a traffic stop. Is it more creepy or less creepy if such tools are also made available to the public?
- Alupis 5y agoIt's difficult to image any level where this doesn't come across as creepy. What data was available? Where they live? Who their parents are? What school they went to? What car they drive? Or even creepier, like hobbies? There is no scenario where walking up to a stranger and starting a conversation about their personal information is going to come across as normal.
- sandworm101 5y agoThere was a scene in one of the Ironman movies. Tony Stark is at a party and his personal assistant is pointing out people for him. She is recognizing faces and telling him who is who before he talks to them. She is telling him their jobs and backgrounds. Just swap out the flesh-and-blood assistant for a service delivered to your phone. Why is the automated system so much more creepy? (Such scenes are in probably 75% of all movies. It is an old device for introducing characters.)
- nerdjon 5y agoThat is massively different though, that is a subset of people that most likely were on an invite list before hand. Would be similar to social media recommending the friends you are already friends with in photos you upload. More of a convenience than anything else. What you mention is any random person identifying any other random person (ignoring the creepiness of taking a picture of someone without their consent). And using that to track down identifying information about them.
- thr0wawayf00 5y agoIt's fashionable to talk about how dystopian social media is, but in my experience, it pales in comparison with the pure hell that is trying to use ID.me and realizing that such a poorly engineered system sits between a loved one of mine and their social security payments. I tried to help set a relative up a while back to receive his payments, which required authenticating with ID.me. Over and over again, the facial recognition feature would fail and prompt to take a new video. It took reaching out to a support line to assist, but they weren't particularly fast or helpful. I couldn't imagine being his age and trying to set this stuff up alone. For every beautiful, artisinal website experience out there that takes UX seriously, there's an equally horrible one that stands between you and something you need and it's pretty clear that the people behind that system don't give a damn about you the user.
- hotpotamus 5y agoIt was pointed out to me, a millenial, that Social Security was created and administered in the Depression era before computers even existed. To think that they somehow created a working system without the tech that we throw at it today is interesting.
- SllX 5y agoYou don’t need computers to administer entitlement programs; but computers are implemented as labor saving devices.
- jfk13 5y agoMy (96 year old) father is quite sure that every such system worked far better before computers got involved. In some cases, perhaps he's right.
- whateveracct 5y agoPaper works great in a lot of ways. I'm using my printer & notebooks more than ever nowadays.
- nerdjon 5y agoDoes anyone else have regrets about being in the tech industry when things like this, privacy issues, leaks, etc seem to be a big thing on a nearly daily or at least weekly basis now? I love what I do, I really do. But stories like this make me want to get a "boring" tech job that I am just maintaining something. Not innovating anymore and at the mercy of not technical people telling me to make horrible decisions. I just find it disheartening. I am just curious if others ever feel this way?
- BeefWellington 5y ago> Does anyone else have regrets about being in the tech industry when things like this, privacy issues, leaks, etc seem to be a big thing on a nearly daily or at least weekly basis now? I personally don't but I think the issue here is that things like ClearView AI and ID.me and the related controversies were inevitable. Just as we're seeing with the development of DeepFakes. An astute observer can probably pretty accurately pick out the differences but will that be true in five to ten years? Audio faking is already fairly good. Once any technology is close, there will be people telling you it's solved. Look at self-driving cars. All these "we've solved it, autopilot is the greatest thing since sliced bread" takes are pushed as marketing, meanwhile the capabilities are substantially lower than human drivers. The bar for these kinds of things should be, at minimum better than a human. The issue isn't with the tech itself but the actors involved. It's a tool, and like any others it can be abused. What makes it dangerous is that the limitations of these tools don't appear to be investigated at all, which is a failure of something or someone, I'm just not sure what or who (probably government). Coupling a "not quite ready" tech with some snazzy marketing and shady practices seems to have been par for the course for a lot of technologies that emerged from the post-industrial revolution era, and in some cases even before then. Just chemical examples: Leaded gasoline, CFCs, DDT, Thalidomide, etc. You could look to something like cryptomining and its environmental and social impact as another more modern tech example.
- nerdjon 5y agoI think a lot of what you said emphasizes my view on non technical people making decisions and/or being the public face of a very technical product. I don't mean everyone in this regard. But I imagine many of us have been on the side of being told that marketing/user retention wants a dark pattern introduced. "User Research" wants all kinds of tracking introduced. Finance wants ads. Management wants something quicker so we cut corners (or worse they tell us to release something even though we say its not ready and very buggy but marketing was making a big deal about it... which I have personally been involved in. Will give one guess how that one went and then who was blamed). Or any other decision made by someone non technical that is a bad decision and is another controversy waiting to happen. I still see technology as a great force. I still believe in it. I am lucky that my current job, I don't have to deal with any of these things. But we are not a consumer facing operation. But when I look to the future, I find myself asking myself. Where is the industry going and it feels like it's just constantly getting worse. I worry about being in a position of needing to be involved in that again.
- JumpCrisscross 5y agoDo we have any evidence for why ID.me was chosen over Login.gov?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- megaman821 5y agoJust a guess from using both of them. Login.gov does authentication, ID.me does authentication and visual verification. ID.me would have you take a video to do facial verification when doing any sensitive actions.
- cato_the_elder 5y agoThese are all Democratic senators, but ID.me has quite a few critics among the senate Republicans too: https://www.finance.senate.gov/ranking-members-news/republicans-raise-serious-concerns-with-intrusive-irs-identity-verification-measures https://www.finance.senate.gov/ranking-members-news/republic...
- ImPostingOnHN 5y agofun fact: the correct term is "Democratic" senator, as using "Democrat" as an adjective is a perjorative: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democrat_Party_(epithet) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democrat_Party_(epithet)
- cato_the_elder 5y agoFixed. Sorry, I'm not a native speaker, and I don't always get these things right. Thanks for pointing that out.
- lovich 5y agoYou’re fine. I’m a native English speaker and never knew this. I’ve seen “Democrat” used as a performative but only by their political rivals who do think the name is pejorative but it wouldn’t matter what name was used.
- ImPostingOnHN 5y agono problem, that's why it's a fun fact to share and not me attacking you for it hopefully we all on HN recognize that we know an infinitesimally small fraction of a percentage of all there is to know – at least, I do :)
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y agoIdentification systems that don’t use PKI are fundamentally broken.
- paxys 5y agoIdentification systems that no one will use are fundamentally broken
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y agoIt would t be terribly hard to implement with good ux such that people use it.
- divbzero 5y agoIRS’s use of ID.me [1] is one of the oddest public–private partnerships I’ve seen. Facial recognition aside, why should I provide my personal ID to a private company to verify myself with the government that issued that personal ID in the first place? [1]: https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/new-online-identity-verification-process-for-accessing-irs-self-help-tools https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/new-online-identity-verificatio...
- bogomipz 5y agoAnd similarly in absurdity is that the IRS does not have the ability to accept direct payments via credit card or debit card. There's a separate public-private partnership for that.[1] [1] https://www.fool.com/taxes/2019/04/13/heres-what-happens-when-you-pay-your-taxes-with-a.aspx https://www.fool.com/taxes/2019/04/13/heres-what-happens-whe...
- bsimpson 5y agoI'm sure I got fucked this year: one of those sites said in big letters at the top "we attribute all transactions until midnight to today," so I chose them. I gave them thousands of dollars (hoping to get some of it back as credit card points). I immediately got an email saying "Thanks for your payment at 1:30 AM (not my timezone, tomorrow)." I was livid, and I had no recourse. I don't even know how to check for the fine and pay it. I'm just waiting for an IRS nastygram at this point, so I can contest their "processing fee" on my credit card.
- reaperducer 5y agoIn my experience, if you miss the deadline that closely, the fine from the IRS is negligible, or they ignore it entirely and move on because it's not worth the effort to follow up.
- jfk13 5y agoThough why you would leave it that close is something of a mystery to me. After all, you might have connectivity problems or an unexpected personal emergency or something. It's not like you didn't know the deadline was coming up.... just pay a day or two early and avoid the stress! (I'm sure there are people who legitimately have to do it at the last moment for some reason. But I don't believe that's the common case.)
- autoexec 5y agoAccessing government services should never result in your personal data being delivered into the hands of private for profit companies. If they want us to hand over our facial recognition data (something that has never been needed before and isn't actually needed now) the government should create their own service where any data collected is never used for anything else. I think it's just pure laziness and a total lack of concern for the public that government websites are full of Google trackers, but when I see a company like ID.me being used I assume somebody is getting a nice kickback somewhere for handing over the American public's data to a private company to exploit and enrich themselves with and all at the tax payers expense.
- llimllib 5y agoI think from the IRS' perspective, they wanted to reach a NIST-certified level of identity verification (NIST 800-63A IAL2 [1]), and there is no governmental service which offered the ability to do that[2], so they went to a private company. I have a lot of notes around this whole dustup; it's my opinion that: - The IRS acted in good faith trying to secure its website in the best way possible - It's very unfortunate that the US government at the same time promotes a particular standard, but does not provide a service matching that standard and seems to currently have no plans to do so [1]: https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-3/sp800-63a.html https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-3/sp800-63a.html [2]: login.gov is IAL1 but not IAL2 compliant; IAL2 compliance requires biometric verification and login.gov does not do this. I also think the IRS had concerns around scaling login.gov, but that the lack of biometric verification was decisive[3] [3]: https://twitter.com/llimllib/status/1490802056256532480 https://twitter.com/llimllib/status/1490802056256532480
- tomrod 5y agoI think the backlash also pole-vaulted login.gov to the forefront.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoGood!
- yebyen 5y agoI don't know anything personally but I do have a friend who works as an engineer at ID.me and he explained to me that they really don't store any data. The way it was explained to me, (apologies if there's anything factually inaccurate in here, this is my recollection from a while ago, just before the IRS very notably decided to cancel their contract for the 2021 tax year?) they had an army of people whose job was literally to visually compare the person's selfie to the ID they presented, and if I understood correctly, they also had some facility for verifying the presented ID was genuine. And that was it. (Edit: I see from clicking through to the CyberScoop article "ID.me CEO backtracks ... on 1:many recognition use claims" that it may not be the case that's all they do with each selfie, and that in reality they do store the selfies, based on a regulatory requirement that they must do so for 7 years.) I think based on that conversation (and sure, call me biased) the "invasion of privacy" concerns were way overblown. If you think the best way to implement an ID verification system is to hire more permanent government employees and have them do the job in-house, ... I'm on Hacker News, so I'm going to assume that nobody thought that. If you have concerns about the truthfulness of this scheme (does it really happen without permanently storing any selfies?) I think those are fair concerns, and we should know the answer. But is there anything to be really concerned about, if there's no permanent storage? I don't understand. Can someone explain it to me? I think that the "invasion of privacy" ship must have already sailed, the government has your photo ID in a database, and it's already on record there forever. What does it matter if the verification is outsourced to a private company? Is there the capacity to do this already inside of our government? (Would you trust them to implement such a system efficiently and correctly without private help?) What level of oversight would make this scheme appropriate, I guess is my question? Is there any ID verification system that people who are up in arms would accept here? I'm in favor of probing the questions but I am not surprised that wait times are longer and support staffing was evidently reduced, after the IRS cancelled their contract. "You reap what you sow."
- aeturnum 5y ago> I think based on that conversation (and sure, call me biased) the "invasion of privacy" concerns were way overblown I mean, that's why this calls for a probe, right? I also suspect they were overblown - but that's why you look into something. > I think that the "invasion of privacy" ship must have already sailed, the government has your photo ID in a database, and it's already on record there forever. I absolutely disagree with this framing of the question. It's false equivalence to suggest that once something exists somewhere "unprivate" that any other system would also be fine. We are going to need to dig into systems and understand if the reduction in privacy fulfills a necessary function and push back on all the systems where that isn't true. There's no magic in "public" v.s. "private" companies - but each new layer introduces new potential for mismanagement and so you need to ask everyone to "get to the bottom" of what happened.
- programmertote 5y agoTangentially related -- My wife recently had to provide her SSN, DoB and her fingerprint scanned by a third-party company [https://www.printscan.com/about-us/ https://www.printscan.com/about-us/], which is "owned, and operated by active and retired Law Enforcement Officers". We both felt really uncomfortable providing such sensitive information to a third party company, but had no choice because Florida board of medicine [https://flboardofmedicine.gov/ https://flboardofmedicine.gov/] uses PrintScan as a partner to do background checks. The fee was $125 for fingerprint scanning at one of their locations. According to that company's 'About Us' page, "PrintScan’s certified fingerprint technicians undergo extensive background checks before being cleared with the FBI, NYS Department of Criminal Justice Services, Florida Department of Law Enforcement, and Homeland Security." I looked up on the FBI website to see if they provide similar background check service, and sure they do for $18! I have a hard time figuring out why FL board of medicine uses a third party service instead of FBI to do background checks, and also wondered why shouldn't FBI background check be enough/sufficient for criminal activity (i.e. don't states share their criminal records with FBI?). All of this is to say that the existence of companies like PrintScan--and the fact that one of the state governments uses it--is definitely concerning to me.
- nikanj 5y agoWhy? Because corruption
- caseysoftware 5y agoI used to work with the FBI fingerprint system IAFIS. It was a very complete system at the time and used in many situations for background checks for everything from LEOs to day care centers for cheap. We also had hard requirements around 99% of responses had to come back within 10 minutes. Anyway, that's changed quite a bit the last few years.. More and more State & Local stopped participating in the system - https://www.washingtonpost.com/crime-law/2021/12/09/fbi-police-shooting-data/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/crime-law/2021/12/09/fbi-poli... - so huge swathes of data just isn't available anymore. Then more DAs are choosing to prosecute fewer crimes and negotiating down serious crimes that would trigger alerts (usually felonies) to lesser crimes so the data that is there may not be representative of the situation. And finally, the overall crime statistics are being characterized as "racist" so the FBI is getting more cautious about what they release and how. So.. less data, incomplete/wrong data, and less access to the data. All of those mean "competitors" have room to operate.
- hahaitsfunny 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Melatonic 5y agoThis is what happens when everything is just contracted out willy nilly with people running systems that have not kept up with the times and (at best) are reaching their own level of incompetence. Or at worst there were big kickbacks involved and something nefarious is going on here. Regardless seems like a good thing to investigate
- rkagerer 5y agoI bet the images and videos collected by facial recognition partners doing KYC for crypto exchanges also wind up in various nations' law enforcement databases.
- monksy 5y agoLets not forget: your license for alcohol acceptance which includes your info on the card + your picture - Drizly and Instacart Collects that. Drizly had a massive databreach as well.
- xbar 5y agoI thought ID.me was a government program.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoWhy would the US run a public service on a Montenegro domain?
- Layke1123 5y agoLet's not forget a huge problem in our modern world, and that is multiple, sovereign nation states willing to do anything and everything to get leverage against one another, including trying to infiltrate and hack every single piece of hardware and software produced. Gone are the days when human fail safes could catch each other. Now, any computer can be hacked so no amount of them will prevent attacks unlike a line of humans who have to vet the information.
- presentation 5y agoI can't even sign up for ID.me since they didn't contemplate the idea that my proof of residency documents would be in Japanese when I live in Japan, and their reps can't read Japanese nor will they accept annotated translations of them.