12 ms·
U.S. court rejects Tether’s bid to conceal reserve records from the public
- jacknews 5y agoAt the risk of igniting a bun fight, perhaps someone with actual knowledge could chime in on the implications of this decision. My personal, completely unsubstantiated view is that Tether is probably a huge scam. Does this decision force it to reveal whether it is or not, um, or not?
- mmerlin 5y agoThe emperor has no clothes, and most crypto seems to be either a scam at worst or delusionally impractical at best. Bullshit turns to dust in the harsh light of the sun, and i reckon a massive dust storm is what will remain of most tokens that were never really needed for any practical purpose whatsoever, except maybe laundering illegally gotten gains from drugs or corruption, IMHO
- ajaimk 5y agoTLDR; NYAG knows where the tether collateral is stored. Now, you can too.
- mywaifuismeta 5y agoI don't think anyone knows for sure. There is a decent chance that Tether is (or was before the crash) decently backed by "stuff" - just not with what it claims to be backed by. I'd imagine other crypto holdings were a significant part of it. In other words, it's not really a stablecoin, but some other complex derivative instrument. So it depends on how you define scam. It's certainly false advertising and has always been.
- nly 5y agoMy money is on it being "backed" by Bitcoin
- CaptainZapp 5y agoIt could as well be backed by nothing, but hot air. Since the company is so evasive and has been for years nobody outside really knows.
- compsciphd 5y agoits fundamentally not then not different than any other DeFi algorithmic stable coin.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoDollar equivalent corporate paper, was the jargon I heard — which sounds like fancy-talk for "Evergrande bonds".
- gregable 5y agoI suspect it's backed by loans to bitfinex. Basically tether mints a bunch of USDT, 'loans' it to bitfinex which then creates an asset on tether's balance sheet of the loan. Bitfinex then goes and buys BTC with the USDT raising the price of BTC. The problem here is that there is no actual USD anywhere in this system. Net, the system is just one where tether is getting minted out of thin air and then sold to the public for BTC or whatever coins.
- lozenge 5y agoThey've already revealed they're a scam, by admitting they're backed by "commercial paper".
- simmerup 5y agoThe fact that they so widely advertised themselves as being back 1:1 with USD and then admitted they were lying ruins all their credibility in my eyes. In addition, I’m surprised so many people defend them by effectively saying ‘this time they’re not lying’ — with no evidence. All I can see it as is wishful thinking than sound judgement.
- headsoup 5y agoThey defend them because they have a vested interest in the whole pyramid not collapsing.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoOn the contrary, many of us (as technologists) have a vested interest in shaking out these gambler-creating factions so the rest of the tech may flourish. Been waiting for Tether to take a K.O. punch for some time, as a cryptocurrency maximalist (eventualist?).
- matthewdgreen 5y agoAccording to Tether's disclosures, they have been of the largest owners of commercial paper in the world. And yet nobody has seen them in the US markets. https://www.ft.com/content/342966af-98dc-4b48-b997-38c00804270a https://www.ft.com/content/342966af-98dc-4b48-b997-38c008042...
- faeriechangling 5y agoI mean we've seen this play out already, bankers have been forced to open their books due to shady dealings as early as the 14th century. What happens is that banks fall both legitimate and crooked, things get stabilised for awhile, time passes, everybody eventually forgets why such regulations came into being, greed happens again, and this continues on until the present day with the chaos becoming less frequent yet simultaneously spawning hilariously large black swan events. I don't know how the fine details of all this will shake out, not well enough to make any money off the affair, but I know the rough outline of exactly what is going to happen. Read up on the early history of fractional reserve banking if you'd like to know too.
- IAmEveryone 5y agoI hate the whole cryptocurrency thing more than most people, but tether may just not be a scam, at least in the legal sense. Holding their reserves in something other than cash is the way they can make money. The community will consider it betrayal because it essentially relies on the existing system they loath. But other than that, there isn’t too much wrong with it. That may also point at a reason why they would want to keep this private, which otherwise seems suspicious. That doesn’t mean people won’t lose all or some of their money with them. Some of these holdings may not be as liquid as needed in a full-on bank run, and they, like all stablecoins, suffer from the mismatch of having no upside by definition but some downside risk.
- pjc50 5y ago> Holding their reserves in something other than cash is the way they can make money Depending on what it is, that's also a way they can lose money. If you think of Tether as an investment organisation that takes $ and hands out claims which they say are worth 1$, while making a bunch of investments, what's that in regular investment land? A money market fund. What can go wrong? https://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/09/money-market-reserve-fund-meltdown.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/09/money-mar...
- NovemberWhiskey 5y agoYes; I think that's absolutely right and insightful - the right way to think about Tether is that it's an opaque (refuses to disclose asset mix; is not audited), expensive (pays no interest; charges for redemptions), unregulated (not subject to the SEC or any other regulatory body) money market fund. In the real world, literally no-one would own that.
- pjc50 5y agoYou can in theory hold it off-exchange and transmit it without KYC, which has to imply a certain category of use. But most of it is being used as the "float" by exchanges, I believe.
- 5y ago
- WinstonSmith84 5y ago7 or 8B were redeemed yesterday within 24 hours, not bad isn't it? This goes without saying that it's only 10% of the market cap, but still better than many banks ... Speaking of banks, another question: which legacy bank would be able to redeem all money of all account holders? the answer is: none. The money you have on your account is "safe" only because there is no panic. Does that make traditional bank a huge scam?
- InitialLastName 5y agoa) Banks have actual rules they have to follow with respect to fractional reserves. b) Individual bank accounts (in the US) are backstopped by the federal government, via FDIC. It might still be a scam, but it's a scam whose validity is backed by the most expensive military on Earth.
- xuki 5y agoHere is the secret: USD is not backed by anything, and the US can print an unlimited amount of it. That's why they have zero risk of a bank run. Tether is "backed" by USD and they can't print USD, that's where the problem lies.
- eloff 5y agoI wanted to make a comment explaining how banks are different because they lend that money back out - it's not like they don't have it, they just don't have it liquid. Regulations are very strict about what percentage they must keep available. Also there's things like FDIC insurance. But at the of the day they are something akin to a government sanctioned ponzi scheme. It's true that if everyone asks a bank for their money back at the same time, the bank will fail. I imagine you're bringing this up to say that crypto is no worse than traditional banks. I disagree strongly with that.
- karpierz 5y agoAlso, it's not even that debt isn't liquid; debt (much like corporate stocks, bonds, etc.) is very liquid. It's just not something you want to be forced to exit prematurely. So it's not even that the bank can't pay out, it's just that it costs them a little extra.
- akudha 5y agoIf there is nothing shady going on, then why wouldn't they want to share these documents? Are these trade secrets or something similar?
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> why wouldn't they want to share these documents? Are these trade secrets or something similar? Playing devil’s advocate, their users clearly don’t care if they’re backed. As such, they’re running a hedge fund with zero cost of capital. Those typically have good reasons for treating their strategies as proprietary.
- smoovb 5y agoOne reason is that Tether is not a US company and does not itself operate in the USA. Submitting anything to a US court is a willingness to be subject to US rules and laws.
- grumple 5y agoTether is used by Americans, transacting with Americans on American soil, pegging itself to the American dollar, using American dollars as reserves, using the internet which is controlled by America, holding reserves in a banking system largely controlled by America... Tether.to lists a US address and phone number. Their ip returns a cloudflare ip in California. They are definitely subject to US law. Pretty sure the US could do things like have them arrested in their home countries, extradited, have their bank accounts seized, etc. I suspect the US could also seize all US dollars without the consent of any foreign nation as well, seems like a natural way to defend a currency. Hard to claim you're backed by US dollars in that case.
- charcircuit 5y ago>Tether.to lists a US address and phone number Where? >Their ip returns a cloudflare ip in California. Cloudflare uses anycast. Their IPs don't have a single location.
- 5y ago
- grumple 5y agoIf Tether had sufficient reserves, they wouldn't be fighting to hide the details of those reserves. It should be obvious to any observer that they have little reserves and have basically taken the money and run.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoOr technically, or numerically sufficient assets, but based on a subjective (if not controversial) interpretation of the value of those assets.
- simias 5y agoI share your opinion, although apparently over the past week Tether's market cap dropped from $83B to $74B which, if true, means that at least $9B have been redeemed in a few days. In other words, they had at least $9B in liquid, USD-convertible assets they could use to redeem those tokens. USDT is currently trading slightly below its peg (around $0.999) and only dipped very temporarily to $0.98 as the cryptocurrency market was crashing. Now of course they still have $74B to account for and maybe I'm just naive but I have a little more faith in USDT now than I had a week ago, I still think that it's mostly backed by monopoly money but maybe not as much as I thought.
- matthewdgreen 5y agoOr alternatively they "redeemed" a bunch of unbacked tokens that they (or a partner company) owned, in order to give the impression that their redemption window was processing large amounts successfully. I'm sure that's not actually the case, but it would be consistent with the "Tether printing unbacked tokens for its own trading" theory of Tether fraud. This may seem like a conspiracy theory, but: the reason these "conspiracy theories" are so easy to believe is that Tether is unregulated and highly non-transparent.
- shkkmo 5y agoA dropping market cap absolutely doesn't mean that liquid, easily USD convertible assets were used to redeem them. It is quite possible that a number of exhanges which had traded IOUs for Tether, Traded that Tether back to have the IOUs canceled. Edit: Now that I think about it, it really would make sense. They are fighting to keep these records secret, but they may also be cleaning up their books a little in case they lose and have to make their holdings public.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gitfan86 5y agoBeing only 90% backed by cash isn't the problem. A lot of people could afford to lose 10%, if the money was evenly distributed. Tether would still be a scam in that situation, but it wouldn't destroy the crypto ecosystem. The risk is that there could be a bank run. People panic and drive down the price trying to get rid of their tether. Now crypto as a whole has lost a lot of the liquidity used to buy/sell crypto. This causes a further panic across other crypto assets.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> My personal, completely unsubstantiated view is that Tether is probably a huge scam. Tether's not really doing anything different from the what banks do every day. If it crashes the government should just bail them out like they did with the banks in 2008. They will spare banks from the consequences of their actions, so there's no reason why they can't do the same for Tether.
- soared 5y agoBank accounts are FDIC insured up to 250k, coinbase/tether/etc are not.
- mkr-hn 5y agoAlso: the banks were expected to and did pay it back collectively, with profit.[0] I don't see how Tether could do that if it turns out the fundamentals are bogus. [0] https://projects.propublica.org/bailout/ https://projects.propublica.org/bailout/
- MailNerd 5y agoThere's an incentive to bail out the banks to keep up trust in the currency, so government can print more. What would be the incentive for crypto?
- roenxi 5y agoIt doesn't really matter at this point. Anyone dealing with Tether either doesn't care or is so ignorant that new revelations won't matter. Case in point I was buying tether when the peg looked like it was failing a few days ago - so I bought a few dollars for about $0.98. Obviously a tiny trade because I'm not crazy - more for the fun of being able to say I did - but whether the crypto is backed or not was a non-issue. This was to buy a completely different cryptocurrency on a different exchange, and Tether was just a conduit to get fiat money in to the system. Tether failing might be catastrophic for the crypto ecosystem. It also might not be. Technically speaking, the stablecoins look easy to replace. There is a big test of the whole crypto ecosystem coming to find out how it weathers a recession - total collapse? holds some value? most value? heaven help us, makes money? - which will make for interesting times.
- liaukovv 5y agoIf i had any tether I would sell it all right now, on the off chance that tether is in fact not fully backed. In the end there is no upside to holding it, so even small risk is unnecessary
- mhoad 5y agoIt’s not going to be fully backed. I think that’s become increasingly clear at this point.
- smoovb 5y agoLet's say it's 70% or even 50% backed. The withdrawals so far are are about 10% of its holdings. Won't we have to wait for another 40-60% draw down to find out if it's not fully backed? Seems like so far, anyone who wanted out, got out.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y ago...what if it's 20-30%?
- smoovb 5y agoThen time for a class action against the NYAG office for not disclosing this to the public.
- matdehaast 5y agoTethers collapse or fall from the peg would be such a contagion within the entire crypto ecosystem. I would think all crypto holdings are at risk if there are large adverse findings in the disclosure.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoWhy would Tether collapsing bring down USDC? Theoretically, USDC is backed (or more backed) by dollars. I'm not sure why anyone has ever held a Tether for even 1 second. Even if you believe in it 100% - why not hold something other people believe in more?
- Ekaros 5y agoSo if they really had some magic investment strategy why waste it only on storing backing for stable coin? Why not just run it in proper hedge fund or similar and rake even more money?
- viraptor 5y agoBy creating the stablecoin they got the funds to play with (invest, I mean...) Without it, they wouldn't be able to raise a simar amount without being more strictly regulated.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 5y ago> Why not just run it in proper hedge fund or similar and rake even more money? Because hedge funds sometimes collapse, and Tether's original premise was that being something that couldn't happen. It's why they promised every $1 worth of USDT corresponded to $1 USD in a bank account, prominently on their website, for several years after that stopped being true.
- forum_ghost 5y agodidn't they just redeem a few billion dollars?
- cycrutchfield 5y agoAll they have proven is that 1 USDT >= $0.1 USD. When the bank run really gets going, we will see just what fraction of the money they actually have.
- cowvin 5y agoWell technically they proved that that WAS true. We don't know how much money they have backing it now after spending $8B.
- pru567 5y agoFor years the major allegation has been that BTC price is artificially propped up by fraudulent Tethers. We finally get to resolve this point.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoThere's really only one Tether, and a couple very recent copycats that gained any real market cap.
- s_Hogg 5y agoYou'd think Tether would be in favour of something like this as an investor confidence thing but they aren't. I struggle to understand how that can be without it throwing some doubt on the viability of tether itself. Does anyone know how to square this circle?
- forum_ghost 5y agofinance is huge on secrecy, because the moats are often non-existent and often strategies can be replicated trivially. ask your own pension fund to show terms of every deal they make with your own money. they'll tell you to take a hike, and tether isn't any different here.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThey will tell you to take a hike because you will see that pension fund managers have been obviated by broad market index funds with 0.03% expense ratios and there is no reason to pay a pension fund manager anymore.
- WJW 5y agoAre you sure? Because my pension fund (ABP) has this page: https://www.abp.nl/over-abp/duurzaam-en-verantwoord-beleggen/waarin-belegt-abp/ https://www.abp.nl/over-abp/duurzaam-en-verantwoord-beleggen... I found it as result #1 when googling ABP investments. As you can see there are several PDFs listing investments of each category: - External fund managers - Engagements with companies - Overview corporate bonds - Overview nation-state bonds - Stocks - Overview top 100 largest investments All contain detailed lists about the country, instrument invested in, sector and how large the stake is rounded to the nearest million euro. All these lists are updated regularly as changes occur. Nobody is asking Tether to disclose every term of every single deal they make, but making disclosures about the composition of your underlying assets is not a very big deal at all. You can find similar documents for almost every pension fund out there.
- forum_ghost 5y ago>External fund managers full legal agreement of their mandate publicly available to the entire world, Y/N? >Engagements with companies full legal terms of engagement public and available to the entire world, Y/N? You are just listing some public information. Actual source of alpha is a very closely guarded trade secret, and will never be made available to you, or anyone not involved directly. Tether is literally being asked to openly disclose confidential business information to the entire world. They've revealed composition a number of times, they have done an attestation, and none of the other stablecoins have produced an audit either. It's just a witch hunt. composition: https://static.seekingalpha.com/uploads/2021/5/19/254888-16214228104575725_origin.png https://static.seekingalpha.com/uploads/2021/5/19/254888-162... full report: https://seekingalpha.com/instablog/254888-sunil-shah/5593034-tether-assurance-moore-cayman-accountants-marminus-2021minus-2 https://seekingalpha.com/instablog/254888-sunil-shah/5593034... for comparison, report from USDC/Circle: https://www.centre.io/hubfs/pdfs/attestation/2021%20Circle%20Internet%20Examination%20Report%20January%202021%20FINAL.pdf?hsLang=en https://www.centre.io/hubfs/pdfs/attestation/2021%20Circle%2... what is the big issue? money market funds your pension invests in have the same composition as Tether.
- floor_ 5y agoI'm trying to think of what would be the funniest thing to be revealed. Nothing backing it or Russian money backing it. (Both the same really)
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoThe 'free floating' crypto is relatively clear - it goes up and down based on demand/speculation, and you can play the game. But these stablecoin, NFT and other smartiepants are clearly making promices they cannot keep
- _fat_santa 5y agoTo an outsider, it seems that one of these cases is true and is the reason why Tether is so resistant to releasing this info: * The currency is not fully backed. * The currency is backed by crypo, commercial paper, or some other backing that is not as secure as hard currency. Either way the "1 Tether -> 1 Dollar" is either a full on lie or a very sly truth.
- jcranmer 5y agoOkay, the source of information here is completely wrong. Here's the actual source of documents in the case [1]: https://iapps.courts.state.ny.us/nyscef/DocumentList?docketId=ElU4fcHTGn/G3J6IgSe3ag==&PageNum=2&narrow= https://iapps.courts.state.ny.us/nyscef/DocumentList?docketI... The most recent filing is the court's order granting Intervenor-Respondent Coindesk's Motion to File a Sur-Reply, which is a very procedural element. Backing up: usually, in court cases, when there's an argument to do something, one party writes a brief, the opposing party writes its brief, and then the first party rebuts the opposing party's brief. Opposing party usually doesn't get a chance to rebut again. This order is letting the opposing party get that chance, and it was done because the first party made new arguments in its reply brief that it's not procedurally allowed to. The court hasn't rejected Tether's bid to conceal the reserve records... it hasn't reached that point in the case yet. From the current posture of the case, I would guess that it's feeling more sympathetic towards Coindesk than towards Tether, but that really doesn't mean much in terms of what the actual ruling will be. [1] Any news organization that doesn't provide a link to the actual docket when discussing cases should be considered irresponsible.
- cinntaile 5y ago> Any news organization that doesn't provide a link to the actual docket when discussing cases should be considered irresponsible. How else will they keep their "information monopoly"?
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> How else will they keep their "information monopoly"? Because the simplest explanation is a media conspiracy perpetuated by…finbold.com.
- manesioz 5y agoTether failing (which seems inevitable at this point) will cause the entire crypto ecosystem to implode.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoI don't think that's true. It'll certainly shake out a lot of the scammier looking and acting exchanges, though.
- bthrn 5y agoThe most recent “transparency report”[0] for their reserves seems to suggest the near majority of it (35B) is backed by US treasury bills. They are also counting debt by other corporations in their “cash and bank deposits” classification (24B). Is the goal here to establish whether this is factual, or is it to determine what comprises these in greater detail? [0] https://assets.ctfassets.net/vyse88cgwfbl/4hiNJsZ98LlZqCJHKzrLpV/2b6338482ef0093382885f80ba6f1083/Tether_Assurance-12-31-21.pdf https://assets.ctfassets.net/vyse88cgwfbl/4hiNJsZ98LlZqCJHKz...
- DebtDeflation 5y agoThe question they seem to want to dodge is who is the issuer of all that Commercial Paper. They'd like people to believe it's a diverse group of blue chip companies. The reality is it's probably Binance and a few other crypto companies.
- hericium 5y agoSo how exactly is this thing supposed not to look as scam? Every news update I see suggests it is. Requests like this sound to me like "let us have our pretended peg/backing to pretend that out stablecoin is stable for a little longer".
- xwdv 5y agoIf Tether is a fraud, I hope it collapses soon, so it can take down a bunch of other frauds within the crypto space and probably take at least a quarter of the inflated Bitcoin price down with it. Hold their feet to the fire.
- 015UUZn8aEvW 5y agoTether's market cap has declined about $9 billion in the past several weeks, going from ~$83B to ~$74B. If that continues, and its backing really isn't adequate, we will find out.
- smoovb 5y agoSo far they handled a stress test of 10% of holdings. Curious to know what stress an average US Bank is required to handle?
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoDuring what tests..?
- Invictus0 5y agoWhat's the best way to short Tether?
- 323 5y agoThe conventional wrong answer is to short USDT/USD on an exchange like Coinbase. The correct answer is to do a spread trade between BTC/USDT and BTC/USD since this is where the liquidity is. The real answer for you is to stay away from this trade. If you need to ask how to do it, you obviously don't appreciate all the complications of such a trade. Remember that this trade will only make money if Tether implodes, and if that happens there will be crazy volatility all around, and you could end up losing money on a seemingly correct trade like shorting USDT/USD.
- csunbird 5y ago> The conventional wrong answer is to short USDT/USD on an exchange like Coinbase. Is it because the crypto-exchanges tend to go in maintenance mode when a coin is going down?
- samatman 5y agoMost important is that you have to time the implosion, there's no obvious way to make a bet on Tether's eventual disaster without reference to when it happens. So even if you consider it inevitable, backing that conviction with your own cash is a great way to get rekt.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoDo you have to know when, or just "when" in relationship to BTC movement?
- andrewaylett 5y agoAlso: who is going to take the other side of your trade, and do you understand why they would be willing to take that position?
- andrewaylett 5y ago
- jeffrwells 5y agoCan anyone explain in layman’s terms why stablecoins need to exist? What can you do with a stablecoin like tether that is not possible with USD? All of the use cases I read about seem to say “trade tether for Bitcoin” etc, but you can trade USD for bitcoin.
- matthewdgreen 5y agoStablecoins are the killer app that everyone has been waiting for. When implemented properly (with reliable and regulated backing) they allow people to build financial apps that easily transact real money, without paying a fortune to a payment provider. Combined with scalable blockchains, I suspect they’re going to be a huge force in the future payment/finance ecosystem. That future ecosystem may not look radically different from what we have today, it might even be most of the same players: but there will be different “rails” moving money at a lower cost, and new players that wouldn’t have been able to start up without this. Disclosure: I don’t care much about stablecoins but I am working on regulatory compliance tech for decentralized currencies, and my instinct is that stablecoins are where all the business interest is.
- 8note 5y ago> without paying a fortune to a payment provider. I'm not sure how you're avoiding that, especially once the stable coins are regulated? You still have payment processors to pay, just with different names
- icapybara 5y agoI don't think this answer's OP's questions. Why can't you easily transact real USD?
- xienze 5y agoUSD isn’t tokenized — it can’t be placed on a crypto wallet and transacted on a blockchain. So essentially you have to create a token that represents $1 in order to use real currency in crypto trading.
- 5y ago
- smoovb 5y agoTether is the BitTorrent of currency. It allows people with less access to financial products to get around the gate keeping institutions and enjoy USD stability in countries where populations are financially restricted. Just like BitTorrent acts as a counterweight to a greedy entertainment industry, Tether acts as a counterweight to regimes who impose financial restrictions on their populations.
- klodolph 5y agoDoesn’t BitTorrent work, though?
- cycrutchfield 5y agoGreat analogy. BitTorrent is used to circumvent copyright protections. Tether is used to circumvent KYC and money laundering protections.
- qgin 5y agoIt’s weird to me that BTC is selling off more on this news. Do people just not realize how much of BTC’s value comes from Tether?
- ParksNet 5y agoIf you want to cut energy consumption, reduce goods inflation, and increase labor supply, the simplest way to to it is to destroy cryptocurrencies.
- axg11 5y agoA great, laconic statement to rally the anti-crypto troops. In reality, destroying cryptocurrencies would have zero effect on any of those three: Estimated total energy usage for all cryptocurrencies: 0.1-1% of global energy usage Inflation: I don't see a link whatsoever - any influence on inflation from crypto is dwarfed by a decade of quantitative easing. Labor supply: estimated number of developers working in crypto is <100,000, whereas estimates for total number of software developers in the world is ~20M, so ~0.5%.
- schroeding 5y agoWhile I agree with you on the last two points, this article from september last year[1], referencing this piece from the NYT[2], says that Bitcoin alone used 0.5% of the global energy used. 0.5% of the global energy consumption is an enourmous amount of energy, for one coin. Even if it is only 1% in total, for all cryptocurrencies - 1/100 of the yearly energy used by the whole planet is a gigantic amount of energy, isn't it? [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/bitcoin-mining-electricity-usage-more-than-google-2021-9 https://www.businessinsider.com/bitcoin-mining-electricity-u... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/09/03/climate/bitcoin-carbon-footprint-electricity.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/09/03/climate/bitco...
- axg11 5y agoI agree that 1% (if true) is not insignificant, but destroying all cryptocurrencies to reduce our energy consumption by 1% isn't a clear tradeoff to me. We also need to account for the fact that renewable energy as a percentage of energy used by crypto is increasing and already at significant proportions.
- soared 5y agoCrypto -> chip shortage -> inflation Seems like there may be other factors at play.
- axg11 5y agoAside from optics, why doesn't a major central bank step in and create a stable-coin? A GBP/CAD/USD stable-coin collateralized by a central bank's reserves would be widely adopted at this point.
- boole1854 5y agoIt's not clear to me why a major central bank would be interested in establishing a distributed currency that competes with their own centrally-managed currency. Maybe it sort of possibly makes sense for a central bank in a small country where the politics are such that policy makers have decided to compete for the attention of the crypto industry. But a major central bank?
- axg11 5y agoUSD collateralized stable-coins are happening whether central banks participate or not. I think the advantage for a central bank would be to bring stability and increase demand for the underlying asset (the centrally controlled currency).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bogomipz 5y agoBloomberg published a piece last year called "Anyone Seen Tether’s Billions?" It's definitely worth a read: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2021-10-07/crypto-mystery-where-s-the-69-billion-backing-the-stablecoin-tether https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2021-10-07/crypto-my...