7 ms·
What does this mean in terms of race being a social construct/concept?
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
What does this mean in terms of race being a social construct/concept?
- dijit 5y agoRace, in terms of physiology has never been regarded by science to be a social construct. In fact it can be medically harmful to think this way.
- PartiallyTyped 5y agoOne of the reasons certain communities were hit harder with Covid was vit D deficiency as a consequence of skin color.
- dijit 5y agoThat is one hypothesised cause for the disparity, social factors in those cases need to be controlled for. A better discussion is around sickle cell anaemia[0] which is exclusively carried by people of African or Afro-Caribbean descent. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sickle_cell_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sickle_cell_disease
- PartiallyTyped 5y agoThat's a better example, thank you. Reminded me that I know quite a few people with Thalassemia/Mediterranean anemia.
- pessimizer 5y agoSickle cell disease is exclusively caused by genetics, not race. The vast majority of people of African or Afro-Caribbean descent aren't carriers, so have the same likelihood as everyone else who is not a carrier to develop it.
- pessimizer 5y agoSkin color isn't race.
- wutbrodo 5y agoUnfortunately, that's not quite true. Here's the AMA[1] with a press release entitled "New AMA policies recognize race as a social, not biological, construct". They discourage using race as a source of any physiological signal. They do allow using genetics, but the relevant situations are the many many ones where genetic testing isn't possible or doesn't yet provide useful signal. Unaccountable institutions get captured very easily, and the race cult that's swept through our educated class has been a very powerful one. [1] https://www.ama-assn.org/press-center/press-releases/new-ama-policies-recognize-race-social-not-biological-construct https://www.ama-assn.org/press-center/press-releases/new-ama...
- tom_ 5y agoSame as it always did, as humans have long claimed to be able to distinguish race simply by looking.
- bb123 5y agoPerhaps there is some quality of the x rays themselves that is different? Maybe white people tend to visit hospitals with newer, better equipment or better trained radiographers and the model is picking up on differences in the exposures from that.
- shortgiraffe 5y agoThey mostly accounted for this: >Race prediction performance was also robust across models trained on single equipment and single hospital location on the chest x-ray and mammogram datasets Sure, it’s possible that bias due to the radiographer is the culprit, but this seems unlikely.
- gbasin 5y agoInteresting hypothesis but I can't tell if you're being serious
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oaktrout 5y agoFrom the paper "Race prediction performance was also robust across models trained on single equipment and single hospital location on the chest x-ray and mammogram datasets"
- polski-g 5y agoIt means that is a lie.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- emddudley 5y agoThere is no scientific, consistent way to define race. The groups we put people into is fairly arbitrary. They don't correlate to appearance, genetics, country of origin, etc. An interesting question in the U.S. is "who is considered white?" There was a Supreme Court case in which someone who was literally from the Caucasus was ruled not white. This is why it's sociological, not scientific. https://www.sceneonradio.org/episode-40-citizen-thind-seeing-white-part-10/ https://www.sceneonradio.org/episode-40-citizen-thind-seeing...
- orangepurple 5y agoAlloco 2007 looked at random locations of single nucleotide polymorphisms(SNPs) and found that, using random SNPs, you still get very good correspondence between self-identification and best fit genetic cluster. Using as few as 100 randomly selected SNPs, they found a roughly 97% correspondence between self-reported ancestry and best-fit genetic cluster. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17349058/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17349058/
- pessimizer 5y agoWere the formulations of genetic clusters created through marking samples with self-reported race? If so, why couldn't you create an entirely different rubric of race by choosing a few arbitrary features to define each of them and find exactly the same thing?
- daenz 5y agoIf there's no scientific, consistent way to define race, how is it that a machine learning model is able to pick the race that somebody self-identifies as consistently? The model is simply using rules based on math to deduce an accurate guess.
- greenthrow 5y agoIt still is. Just because it includes physical signifiers that can be measured doesn't mean it isn't still a social construct. To give a contrived example; if I say people with ring fingers over 3 inches long are Longfings and people wkth ring fingers 3 inches or less are Shortfings, and then out society treats people differently based on being Longfing or Shortfing, this is a social construct that is causing problems for people based on a contrived criteria that has no real meaning. The same is true of race.
- inkblotuniverse 5y agoWhat if shortfings tend to be drastically taller, and the longfings are complaining that they're overrepresented in jumpball?
- pessimizer 5y ago> What if shortfings tend to be drastically taller What does it mean for shortfings to be dramatically taller? Are you saying that shortfings must transmit height along with finger length; some sort of race invariance? Or are you saying that most shortfings you meet are also tall? If a black person is a pale as a white person, they're still considered black (and may share many other characteristics that many black people have.) If some of your shortfings have long fingers, does the distinction still make sense as a scientific category? > the longfings are complaining that they're overrepresented in jumpball? Is admission to jumpball determined by finger measuring, or through social factors?
- mlindner 5y agoScience does not claim that race is a social construct/concept...
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoWhile I agree with you that “social construct” isn’t the right way to think about it, the authors in this very paper say that it is.
- inglor_cz 5y agoEver more complicated attempts to bridge the gap by muddying the waters. Frankly, even a freshly arrived alien from Mars or Titan could easily tell Icelanders, Mongols and Xhosa apart, without knowing anything about our culture. The fact that there has been a lot of interbreeding/admixture since the Age of Sail began, does not mean that there aren't meaningful biological differences between the original groups, which still obviously exist. An analogy: much like the existence of twilight does not render the concept of night and day a 'social construct' either. We attach certain social meanings to those natural phenomena, and a 'working day' can easily stretch into 'astronomical night' (all too often!), but that does not mean that 'night' and 'day' do not exist outside of our cultural reference framework. There is a social concept of 'race' which corresponds to the 'working day' concept in this analogy, e.g. 'BIPOC', claiming Asians as 'white adjacent' or classifying North Africans or Jews as 'white', even though they may not necessarily look white. But this is almost certainly not what the AI identified. This social concept of race would confuse a Martian alien unless he started to study the social and racial history of the U.S., and possibly even afterwards. It definitely confuses me, a random observer from Central Europe.
- AlotOfReading 5y agoOne of the major issues with biological race realism is that common race classifications do not form monophyletic groupings. If you already have a set of definitions you need to fit, any sufficiently large set of features can trivially classify those categories. It doesn't matter if the groups are race or "people who like licorice". When the features and population sizes aren't uniformly distributed, you can even get very strong correlations, without there being a meaningful underlying basis. The social definition is used because that's a most scientifically meaningful and useful definition that avoids many of the issues with biological race realism.
- _8j50 5y agoStill is? The AI is correlating biological features with self reported race. There are biological differences between people who have different ancestors. Finns are different from brits. The spanish are different from russians. Nigerians look different than somalians. The Japanese look differnet than filipinos. Race picks specific and arbitrary differences , for example hispanic is a different race in US society but black and white based on skin color are as well, indians and east asians are also one "race". Ethnicities are not social constructs but race is. The AI finds ethnic differences and correlates them with self-percievied social/racial classification. "Race" as the evil social construct it is, takes ethnic differences and intrprets them to mean some ethnicities are different races of humans than others as in not just different ancestors but differently created or evolved despite all evidence and major religion saying all humans are one species (homosapiens) that have a common homosapien ancestor. I thought all this was obvious but the social climate recently is very weird.
- fullstackchris 5y agoRace as an entire concept to me has always been stupid at best. Sure, there are vast swaths of biological similarities (typically, though not necessarily) according to general geographic regions of the globe, but the real mistake was trying to give this vague concept a label. Can anybody give a definition of what "white" or "black" REALLY means? It's an impossible task. If we're talking just visually about skin color, congratulations, that represents citizens of some 100+ odd countries on the planet and just as many (if not many more!) cultures and languages. But leave it to humans to try and over optimize and try to denote evermore meaningless abstractions... Let the social "culture war" rage on. The only war I see going on in the west (U.S. mostly) is a _lack_ of culture.
- _8j50 5y agoTo me it is the epitome of laziness. The ultimate expression of the banality of evil. Similar to prejudice and stereotyping or the worst of lies there is some truth in its reasoning but the untrue part, the lazy part allows people to commit evil and be unjust. A reason to harm others with minimal conscious discomfort.
- 5y ago
- ibejoeb 5y agoI'm just going to abandon the term race because nothing constructive is going to come from it. It is not contentious that there are various physiological developments among groups of humans.
- HKH2 5y agoWhat term are you going to use instead? Subspecies? Breed?
- pessimizer 5y ago> various physiological developments among groups This is a very contrived way to say that people share characteristics with other people. The real question is why people don't say that I belong to the six-foot tall bad-knees race.
- ibejoeb 5y agoReally? It's very contrived? I'm not here to tell you what to do. Use race then. I offered up why I think this article is only generating interest is because race is a loaded word, and if it weren't used, it'd be passed over. > The real question is why people don't say that I belong to the six-foot tall bad-knees race This is an article about ML accurately predicting self-identified race. This is not even on the spectrum of real questions.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- PheonixPharts 5y agoI've noticed people in all parts of the political spectrum have a hard time understanding the term "social construct". It doesn't mean the same as "completely made up". Nations are uncontroversially recognized as a social constructs. However I'm certain that AI could also detect images taken outdoors in Mexico vs those in Finland. Additionally I, a US citizen, cannot simply declare that I am now a citizen of France and expect to get a French passport. However it also means that what a nation is, is not set in stone for eternity. It means that different people can debate about the precise definitions of about what defines a particular nation. It means that Czechoslovakia can become the Czech republic and Slovakia. It means that not everyone agrees if Transnistria is an independent nation. It means that the EU can decide that a German citizen can have the same passport as a French citizen. As a more controversial example, this is also the case when people talk about gender being a "social construct". It doesn't mean that we can simply pretend like the ideas "men" and "women" doesn't exist (as people both declare and fear). But it does mean there is some flexibility in these terms and we as a society can choose how we want these ideas to evolve. Society is a complex and powerful part of our reality, arguably more impactful on us from day to day than most of physics (after all we did survive for hundreds of thousands of years without even understanding the basics of physics). Therefore something being classified as a "social construct" doesn't mean it "isn't real". Even more important is that individuals cannot choose who social construct evolve. I cannot, for example, declare that since taxes are a social construct, I'm not paying them anymore. We can however, as a society, change what and how these constructs are interpreted.