4 ms·
> Nvidia just released their drivers as open source Not at all. They just released the kernel modules which is a tiny part of what is needed to make GPU work.
by ekianjo 5y ago
> Nvidia just released their drivers as open source
Not at all. They just released the kernel modules which is a tiny part of what is needed to make GPU work.
> System76 and Framework
Lenovo has been around for a very long time and their thinkpads have been repairable well before these two brands ever shipped anything.
- BaseballPhysics 5y agoAs a long time ThinkPad/Lenovo fan, suggesting that Lenovo's repairability is in the same league as the Framework suggests to me you've never actually worked with a Framework. It really is on a whole other level.
- h-w 5y agoAre you joking? Thinkpads for decades have had all the parts replaceable with off the shelf components. Framework is barely caught up with my 2008 thinkpad lol.
- RealStickman_ 5y agoHave you looked at any more recent thinkpads?
- Rebelgecko 5y agoFramework's hardware is nice because it takes advantage of CPUs, ports, RAM, screens etc that are more recent than 2008 I know for some old ThinkPads (edit: The IBM branded T60 from 2006) you can get a custom motherboard that works with modern CPUs, but the price for the mobo alone is more than a Framework laptop
- drewzero1 5y agoI also have a 2008 and a 2009 Thinkpad. I've looked at some recent ones and we've lost so much since then.
- smaudet 5y agoCan you custom design parts with pinouts for your 2008 thinkpad? If not, I'm not sure I believe you know what you are talking about - its nice lenovo (in past) has been so rugged, repairable, but using reverse engineered parts is a very different thing to a set of components that can be extended. Put it like this - can you put a lenovo part on a framework laptop? No? Why? Until you can, Framework is in a whole different category....
- sleepymoose 5y ago2008 ThinkPads are machines from a different era. Lenovo doesn't build them the same anymore.
- IE6 5y agoIt's hard to talk about Thinkpads as a monolith because there have been so many different devices sold over the decades and their format has changed quite a bit in that time as well. As a thinkpad enjoyer I do appreciate them still but they have become less repairable in recent time. Personally I have done things like completely swap screens, motherboards, etc. to create franken thinkpads in SKUs that never existed and I would still say the Framework is more "repairable" if you define repairable as ease of removing and replace components as well as gaining access to replacement components. Framework's marketplace lists individual components that I can buy today presumably at OEM quality to fix things like hinges or keyboards and that is something Lenovo never really had (or I was not aware of it or was not able to engage with it a la some special preferred repair program).
- ekianjo 5y agogood luck finding cheap parts for your framework laptop. Lenovo however can be repaired for years with off the shelf components and at very low cost.
- commoner 5y agoSome business laptops from Lenovo, Dell, and HP rank among the most repairable laptops. But Framework goes even further by making their parts store and repair guides accessible to everyone: - https://frame.work/marketplace https://frame.work/marketplace - https://guides.frame.work/c/Framework_Laptop https://guides.frame.work/c/Framework_Laptop The prices of the parts are very reasonable, and each part is labeled with a QR code that can be scanned to access repair instructions.
- greyhair 5y agoDell Vostro laptops are not as sleek as their consumer models, but they are tanks, and they are a breeze to repair. I do like what Framework is doing, and my next laptop will likely be from them.
- ekianjo 5y agoI would not trust a company with no history with providing parts forever. If anything, I'd like them to license the manufacturing of replacement parts so that other companies can make their own if they ever go bankrupt.
- vladvasiliu 5y ago> Some business laptops from Lenovo, Dell, and HP rank among the most repairable laptops I can confirm HP isn't too shabby. Very easy to take apart, and they even put out maintenance and service manuals, at least for their Pro/Elite Desk/Book lines. They show how to disassemble them, the possible part-numbers (for example the different available keyboards with or without backlight). I've never had to actually source any parts so don't know how easy it is, especially once they get old. But, in general, I would personally not recommend the laptops. They're cheap junk with ridiculously bad screens. The desktops are quite OK, though.
- 5y ago
- lynndotpy 5y agoI use Linux, but Lenovo's reputation is still burned in my eyes ever since the Superfish incident. I'm very happy we have other names in the Linux laptop game. (Context: Lenovo installed universal root CAs on their laptops during the 2010s, so they could serve ads. They were tied to firmware IIRC, so, reinstalling Windows would not remove the malware.)
- GuB-42 5y agoI understand why you have a problem with Lenovo following the incident, but ThinkPads are something else, and they weren't impacted by Superfish. Non-ThinkPad Lenovos are not great by any mean. They are unremarkable consumer-grade laptops. ThinkPads are a legacy from IBM that Lenovo is smart enough to keep separate from the rest.
- javert 5y agoStill not acceptable. It would be hard for me to buy a ThinkPad (I have bought many in the past). Obviously Lenovo has zero integrity and will spy on us or cheat us in some other way if they think they can do it without getting caught. Sad that nobody else makes laptops with the little nub for pointing the mouse.
- smaudet 5y agoI used a TP from the 2013, 2014 era, and I have my current main laptop as a TP from 2017... The old TP was fantastic. Really out of date hardware, but it did the job. New one is great, in theory (spec-wise), but its a much cheaper build, breaks more, and just generally has far more issues than I remember with the old one. I think I had one in the middle too which was just straight up an awful peice of junk... When Lenovo got bought out by China, they weren't really that smart - they tried to consumerize their TP and thereby cut costs - the features they brought back to modern TPs are still nice but you just don't get the same attention to detail anymore...IMHO.
- imwillofficial 5y agoThat was over 10 years ago, a mistake which the company has shown no signs of repeating.
- Brian_K_White 5y agoOwning both Lenovo and Framework myself, Lenovo doesn't hold a candle to Framework.
- ekianjo 5y agoCall me when you buy a used Framework for 200-300 bucks...
- Brian_K_White 5y agoWhats that got to do with anything? My old lenovo is still too good to throw away for $200, though I'd give it to a relative or friend for free. It will be years before any Frameworks get that old, and by the time they do 5 or 8 years from now, well their whole sales pitch is that you can just keep repairing it or repurpose it's parts indefinitely. And this thread is talking about repairability not any other value propositions like market availability of old ones. It may never become a junker you sold for 200 because you used it's parts for something else or you replaced the mainboard and just kept using it. If there never appear any $200 Frameworks, that would only support the assertion that they are more user repairable. This question makes no sense to me in this context.
- arnaudsm 5y agoSome of the recent ThinkPads have soldered RAM.
- ekianjo 5y agoUnfortunately. The more expensensive ones outside of the x1 carbon line are still upgradable.
- imwillofficial 5y agoDo you understand what “not at all” means? If they did part of the work, then clearly it is “some” work, and not “none at all”
- Octoth0rpe 5y agoWorth pointing out that while linux has usually worked quite well on thinkpads, official support for linux was very infrequent until recently. Also, support for linux on non-thinkpad lenovos was much more of a crapshoot. For corporate linux support, Dell (edit: and HP!) has always been a better option. Edit: And apparently even today is very limited. Just checked Lenovo's website, and apparently only two models can be ordered in the US with linux preinstalled: X1 Carbon, and the Yoga. That's it.
- rozab 5y agoEven for framework, the official Linux support isn't much better. They don't ship with Linux and it's only recently all the kinks have been mostly ironed out with the distro they recommend, Ubuntu 21.04. They have been making proactive steps with Linux support, like providing prerelease hardware to maintainers of lots of distros, but they don't officially support any distro.