12 ms·
Proof-of-work is so obviously, undeniably, mathematically guaranteed to be a crypto dead-end, that I'm gobsmacked we're still having discussions like this. Pro
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
Proof-of-work is so obviously, undeniably, mathematically guaranteed to be a crypto dead-end, that I'm gobsmacked we're still having discussions like this.
Proof-of-work requires, by design, that the electricity value expended on mining is proportional to the total market cap of Bitcoin. It's really just simple arbitrage: if the value of Bitcoin goes up, but the electricity cost doesn't, then you have essentially 2 different prices for 1 good, which should attract more miners to spend more money on electricity. And, indeed, this is exactly what has happened.
The problem, of course, is that if it takes an Argentina's worth of electricity to run Bitcoin now, how does the world manage if Bitcoin has a 10 or 100 times greater market cap? Obviously it can't, and world governments would rightly shut it all down before the majority of our electric output went to mining BTC.
There is simply no way around this issue if you're on a proof-of-work system, and given that, it's so easy to see that BTC is guaranteed to fail at some point. It's like we're on a train rushing towards a bridge that's out, and everyone can see the bridge is out, but somehow we've convinced a large number of people that we'll "jump the gap" when we get there.
- kobieyc 5y ago
- madacol 5y ago> the electricity value expended on mining is proportional to the total market cap of Bitcoin That's not true, it's at most, equal to the printing rate of bitcoins (coinbase transactions)
- junofan 5y agoYou’re saying that as the price of Bitcoin has risen, the price of electricity has risen? I think something’s missing from your argument.
- tiagobraw 5y agoI think he meant that if the price of 1 bitcoin rise, the energy cost of mining 1 bitcoin should also rise in proportion
- yuvadam 5y agoYou are making very bold statements ("of course", "obviously") on a topic that has been deeply analyzed over the years without any decisive conclusions. For one example, I really appreciate Lyn Alden's analysis [1] [1] - https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-security-modeling/ https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-security-modeling/
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI'm making bold statements because I've read reams and reams of treatises on the topic, and every single one ignores some basic, simple, fundamental truths that are inherent to a proof-of-work system. I certainly don't believe I'm particularly smarter than average, and there are definitely other people saying the same thing I am, and certainly much smarter people than I have realized this issue and are transitioning other cryptocurrencies to other proof systems, but I have come to believe that many people are content to keep the music going, even if they know it's going to stop at some point. When it comes to mining BTC, it really doesn't matter much how miners are paid: through block rewards, transaction fees or some other sort of "security fee". Miners spend money on electricity, and get BTC in return. Furthermore, it's, again by design, a competitive system: those who are able to mine faster (i.e. are spending more on electricity, on average) will win the "block contests" faster and get more BTC. All other arguments are just "yada yada yada" unless you are somehow arguing that electricity spend is no longer proportional to chance of mining a block, at which point I'd argue that's probably no longer proof-of-work. This is not a hard concept. If I'm an idiot (which is totally a valid proposition), somebody should be able to explain how a proof-of-work system can get around this "arbitrage problem" very simply - it shouldn't take pages and pages and pages of circular argument.
- hihihihi1234 5y ago> I've read reams and reams of treatises on the topic Care to share any of them here? I'm not that knowledgeable about BTC so I have no idea whether or not you're right, but I'd love to learn more.
- gverrilla 5y ago
- cowtools 5y ago>Proof-of-work requires, by design, that the electricity value expended on mining is proportional to the total market cap of Bitcoin. This is mostly true, but I think you're conflating a couple different things here. At market equilibrium, you would think it would look like the cost of power + hw depreciation = crypto price * (block reward + fees). >if it takes an Argentina's worth of electricity to run Bitcoin now It might be justified if bitcoin could replace the traditional financial system (think about how inefficient that is), but I do not think it can. >how does the world manage if Bitcoin has a 10 or 100 times greater market cap? I don't think bitcoin's market cap can multiply by a factor of 10 or 100
- remper 5y ago> It might be justified if bitcoin could replace the traditional financial system (think about how inefficient that is), but I do not think it can. Bitcoin is already way more inefficient than the current financial system. Just compare cost per transaction between Bitcoin and Visa, for example. People seem to think that Bitcoin will somehow replace the entirety of the financial system when it's not even designed to do that and only really handles transactions.
- cowtools 5y agoYes. The fees are mostly due to bitcoin's unreasonable 1MB blocksize constraint. Most other cryptocurrencies do not have this problem because they make a more reasonable throughput to bandwidth/storage tradeoff
- tromp 5y ago> the electricity value expended on mining is proportional to the total market cap of Bitcoin That would be the case if price doesn't vary much over time. But marketcap is current supply * current price, while the large majority of current supply was mined when bitcoin was WAY cheaper and thus much less electricity was spent on it.
- buzzin_ 5y agoHere you are confusing "total amount of electricity Bitcoin used trough history" and "amount of electricity Bitcoin miners are currently using". The second is proportional to the current Bitcoin price, the first one, who cares.
- Geee 5y agoYou're wrong. Block rewards halve every 4 years. Next halving is in 2 years. This means that electricity use funded by block rewards trends to zero. Miners earn also transaction fees, which will gradually replace block rewards in the long term. Transaction fees are revenue from utility. It's a well designed incentive system; it will keep Bitcoin running as long as people find it useful, and it won't eat the world.
- Retric 5y agoThe issue is total transaction fees must be kept high enough to avoid miners defecting into double spend attacks. That would be easy if people where using it as a high turnover currency, but if people want to use it as a long term store of value transaction fees can quickly become many orders of magnitude smaller than the value stored in Bitcoins. It need not be illegal. Short Bitcoin, preform double spend attack between addresses you own, profit.
- louloulou 5y agoThere's a simple solution to this... just wait longer
- Retric 5y ago51% attacks work on arbitrarily long timescales. Though obviously you can still do short double spend attacks at some probability with less hashing power.
- ssl232 5y agoAn attempt to rewrite the ledger with a 51% attack would be detected almost immediately. The Bitcoin in the rewritten ledger would quickly become worthless, including that belonging to the keys owned by the attacker. All that mining gear used to perform the attack would then be worthless too. This doesn't seem to me like a profitable attack vector once you consider the complete picture.
- louloulou 5y ago> Proof-of-work is so obviously, undeniably, mathematically guaranteed to be a crypto dead-end Bold claim. > Proof-of-work requires, by design, that the electricity value expended on mining is proportional to the total market cap of Bitcoin False statement (as it ignores the bitcoin emission schedule and transaction fees). > The problem, of course, is that if it takes an Argentina's worth of electricity to run Bitcoin now, how does the world manage if Bitcoin has a 10 or 100 times greater market cap? Obviously it can't, and world governments would rightly shut it all down before the majority of our electric output went to mining BTC. Constructing an irrelevant hypothetical based on the initial false statement. > simply no way around this issue if you're on a proof-of-work system, and given that, it's so easy to see that BTC is guaranteed to fail at some point More bold declarative statements with nothing to back them up. Learn more here: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Controlled_supply https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Controlled_supply
- datadata 5y ago> mathematically guaranteed to be a crypto dead-end Your argument is not mathematical at all. It assumes first that bitcoin needs to appreciate 10-100 times current value. And second, that political willpower exists to then shut it down purely because of energy usage. Neither of those conditions are mathematically guaranteed, nor are they even in the realm of mathematics. I won't even address the underlying assumption that energy usage is unilaterally bad. One possible outcome, for example, is that bitcoin just hovers around its current price for a long time. If feels like every discussion on bitcoin is made of people who either think that it must either take over the world or must go to zero.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoOK, of all the comments I've seen trying to refute what I've written, yours is the only one I've seen that at least makes sense. Yes, I totally agree, the crux of my argument is really just "in a proof-of-work system, it is undeniable that electricity spend is proportional to total network market cap", so if the market cap doesn't change, then things can certainly putter along. That said, if the idea is that more and more of the world's economy will be represented by BTC transactions, which these days is pretty much what every person who owns BTC believes, then the market cap can't stay static. I also have a very difficult time believing that if the market cap did stay static for 10 years or so that people wouldn't start to realize "the jig is up". But yes, I totally concede, if the market cap doesn't rise, current electricity spend doesn't need to rise either.
- austinjp 5y agoWhat jig would be up? Mining as profiteering? For sure, and the end of mining is an inevitability. Bitcoin as currency could continue though, no?
- ironSkillet 5y agoThe end of mining is the end of bitcoin. If there are no miners contributing to create the network consensus, then anyone can come in with a 51% attack and destroy the integrity of the block chain.
- wizzzzzy 5y agoWhat I don't understand though is once all bitcoins have been mined, doesn't that mean that transaction fees are then also required to be proportional to the bitcoin market cap and electricity usage value?
- Geee 5y agoNo, fee costs are based on supply and demand of block space. It's simple, miners just scoop the highest paying transactions into the next block. If there's congestion, people pay higher fees to expedite their transactions.
- wizzzzzy 5y agoYes but once there's no longer the financial insentive of bitcoin rewarded for mining, fees need to have the same insentive relative to bitcoin market cap? Otherwise double spending becomes the most profitable for miners surely.
- Geee 5y agoYes, total fees need to be high enough to secure the network.
- gus_massa 5y ago> The problem, of course, is that if it takes an Argentina's worth of electricity to run Bitcoin now, how does the world manage if Bitcoin has a 10 or 100 times greater market cap? The amount of electricity is not proportional to the market cap. It's proportional to the difficulty. You can create a copy of bitcoin where the difficulty is keep very low and add a very big amount of transactions and be very easy to make fake blocks and forks and other nasty stuff. The difficulty is adjusted to keep the time to find a block somewhat constant. One problem to handle a bigger marketcap is the block size. One solutions is to increase the block size, another is to use a secondary chain. I'd like to increase the size, but most people prefer the other. Also, when you add the energy that goes directly from sun light to soy beans, I think that we are in Argentina still using a little more more energy than bitcoin.
- lofatdairy 5y ago>The amount of electricity is not proportional to the market cap This misses the point of the argument, which is to say that if the market cap of bitcoin goes up, the marginal benefit of mining by definition goes up. This in turn drives up demand for electricity, until the marginal cost of additional mining units and associated power equilizes. That's not to say that there isn't a benefit to a more efficient proof-of-work scheme, as in theory if the scheme can support _all_ future and current transactions like the current banking system, then there's a cap on energy consumption. However, what OP points out is that the speculation and monetary utility of Bitcoin both act to increase power consumption due to basic economic forces. >Also, when you add the energy that goes directly from sun light to soy beans, I think that we are in Argentina still using a little more more energy than bitcoin. This is a non-sequitur. The point of using Argentina is to illustrate that in verifying transactions, Bitcoin uses as much energy as millions of people lighting their homes, watching television, running air-conditioning, heating water, charging their phones, etc etc etc. Nobody is claiming that Bitcoin consumes more metabolic energy or solar energy, OP's just highlighting that Bitcoin's electricity costs are potentially unsustainable.
- jallen_dot_dev 5y ago> The amount of electricity is not proportional to the market cap. It's proportional to the difficulty. But the difficulty is proportional to the amount of miners, which is proportional to the profitability of mining, which is proportional to the price, which the market cap is proportional to (i.e. price x supply). So electricity is indirectly proportional to the market cap. > One solutions is to increase the block size, another is to use a secondary chain. Those solutions don't address the energy spent on mining, they just allow more people to transact. The former means more transactions (more fees), the latter means fewer but more expensive on-chain transactions (more fees). Either way I believe the block reward (and thus the amount of energy miners will throw at getting that reward) will be roughly the same, it'll be a function of how much people value and want to use bitcoin.
- hkt 5y agoThis is beautifully put, I'm saving it in my notes to remind myself of it later. The point about market cap was especially striking.
- paulmd 5y agoNot only is there no way around it, but it's actually impossible to start new networks from scratch based on proof-of-stake due to the "nothing at stake" problem. If attackers don't care if their stake gets burned (because the value is low) then there's no longer an incentive for attackers not to validate on multiple chains at once (which is what staking is supposed to prevent). All new networks must go through a proof-of-work stage of evolution. Further, the existence of proof-of-stake coins at all means that decentralized exchanges exist, which makes it impossible to ever kill proof-of-work in a legislative sense. Even if you killed fiat exchange for $SHITCOIN entirely, once there is a coin that has sufficient value, people will be happy to have bitcoin instead of USD, or trade to Bitcoin and then over to USD. You can either ban them all entirely, or you have to live with both PoW and PoS together. Unfortunately, crypto is a memeplex, it's like a corporation, it's a self-reinforcing living entity that supports itself (maintains homeostasis) through a series of rules and incentives, and now that it's been created it can't be easily killed. Every individual is financially incentivized to keep playing their part, so everyone would have to collectively agree to not make money by taking part, and as people fall out the incentives become steeper and steeper to participate. Would you mine on your card for $100 a day? $1000 a day? We will just have to live with destroying our planet, because now that it's been created it's virtually impossible to kill. That was the whole point. With apologies to Alien: it’s biologically engineered to be a survivor... the perfect predator (of certain other memeplexes - meaning, states and state-backed currencies, which are also self-sustaining memeplexes with their own rules and incentives). That was the stated goal of the design, and it works! There's no "off button", otherwise it would be trivial for "statists" to push it. There is no "oops we forgot to add a limit to the paperclip maximizer" or "don't kill the people who try to stop paperclip maximization" button either. People whose livelihoods depend on crypto are highly incentivized to come up with ways (like PoS) to keep it going even if the outcomes of the overall system becomes undesirable. The day it became legitimized by the SEC, it certainly became impossible to stop it. Now you will have Wall Street money fighting you too. You wanted an unstoppable decentralized cryptopunk future with assassination markets, that's exactly what it does. It wouldn't be unstoppable if individual or collective action (like that of a state or other group of individuals) could stop it, and it was designed knowing that people would try to stop it. All according to keikaku. (cue the gif from dr strangelove of general turgidson's horrified realization of what he's just said)
- HWR_14 5y ago> by design, that the electricity value expended on mining is proportional to the total market cap of Bitcoin. You have to factor in the amortized cost of specialized hardware over it's lifetime, and a few other factors. But it's a good approximation. BTC tried to solve this with diminishing rewards for mining. The problem is BTC's market cap doubled far faster than the rewards halved. But I think you are wrong at the high end. If BTC was worth 100x tomorrow, the current miners cannot just push a button and draw 100x the power. I think governments would be far more likely to ban new rigs, but may let grandfathered rigs continue to operate. If that's the case, I can see miners becoming quite profitable.
- freemint 5y ago> I think governments would be far more likely to ban new rigs, but may let grandfathered rigs continue to operate. This seems irrational given the ever increasing efficiency of hashes per energy.
- HWR_14 5y agoIt's only irrational if you think the government cares about maximizing hashing efficiency. It's perfectly rational if you recognize that in most (western) legal systems there is a difference in the ease and acceptability of stopping someone from taking a new action and the allowing them to continue taking that same action. This is due to various legal underpinnings, but also makes perfect sense in that allowing someone to invest millions and then pulling the rug out from under them is very different from telling them they were never allowed to invest those millions in the first place. Building codes are an excellent example of this. It's perfectly legal to maintain, sell, lease, etc. a building that would be illegal to build today.
- webinvest 5y agoAfter the each “halving” you should expect the energy expenditure would also halve by that same logic. The halving would could continue until the energy requirement is minor! Haha, get it, minor?
- HeadsUpHigh 5y agoThe value of bitcoin needs to increase more than x2 indefinitely for the power consumption to increase.
- redox99 5y agoFully agree with your analysis. Other's have nitpicked your exact words but your point is totally correct: There is a cap of how much Bitcoin price can increase, at least before multiple halvenings. If it increases above this cap, the mining power usage will become so absurd that external forces will come into play (regulations, and very negative perception once people realize that it's absurd). That's why I don't believe in any crypto that doesn't at least have a path to switching to PoS (or some non PoW system).
- jimmySixDOF 5y agoThe use of mining for hashes in general seems such a completely arbitrary thing to select for Proof of Work. It may have suited the academic cryptography/CS mindset back when the whole thing was an intellectual exercise on whitepaper, but now, as a victim of its own success, it is a threatening technical debit burden. My working theory is that a system could be devised that re-defines Proof of Work to align with some demonstratable real world physical benefit like planting a tree or recycling waste or placing a renewable kwh on the grid. Yes there are tremendous process invention challenges on a Manhattan Project level scale but the stakes seem able to justify a Moonshot approach. Mining under existing Proof of Work conditions is a weird arbitrage at scale of physical compute cycle cost/performance and raw electrical overheads measured against the perceived speculative value of the minting benefits returned. Even reducing mining to a barebones fintech set of transactions would make sense at this point. A single Cash (as proof-of-work) account where each miner adjusts their relative position in real time in response to market conditions. An opensource code as law snapshot Lottery system that mimics the existing minting benefit and proportional voting rights distributions on chain. Yes it interrupts the purely distributed zero trust consensus mechanism, but, there are other compatible mitigation and trust designs, and, as an overall step change, the ability to grow without consuming nation state level power resources in this day and age is well worth the tradeoff -- if not absolutely mandatory. Also on HN the other day [1] frankenst1 reply to mondoveneziano : START QUOTE > For Bitcoin, the most popular one, on the order of 100.000.000.000.000.000.000 of hashes get calculated to mine a single block, multiple trillion per second. Within ten minutes, only a single one of those 100.000.000.000.000.000.000 hashes is actually used, depending entirely on luck. The rest are thrown away entirely. They do not form part of the final hash or anything else, the energy spent on them is lost. You need to dig through 1 million gram of ore to find 1 gram of gold, depending entirely on luck. The rest is thrown away entirely. The energy is of course not lost but was necessary to find something of value (which also creates a lower price boundary). In contrast to gold, Bitcoin mining ensures provably fair probability of winning, has a tremendously lower barrier of entry, provides incentives to be run on renewable energy and produces far less waste. END QUOTE [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31376647 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31376647
- karlzt 5y agoElectricity generation could be different and better in the future.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoTo emphasize, it does not matter. Let's say we have some great new technology that enables us to get electricity for a tenth of what it currently costs. It just means miners will be willing to use 10 times more electricity to mine for a given amount of reward (and, for the umpteenth time, block rewards, transaction fee, whatever, doesn't matter - the BTC they get in return for being the first to mine a block). Indeed, this is the whole idea behind specialized mining rigs. These rigs essentially lower the cost of electricity for a given hash rate. But assuming other miners have access to the same equipment, in the competitive system that is proof-of-work they will just bump up their usage of electricity until the point that, again, it no longer makes sense for them to do so because they'd be spending more than the rewards that they get in return.
- lumost 5y agoThis is probably part of the appeal of BTC as a value store. Gold typically sits in a vault, it’s hard and energy intensive to mine. BTC marginally improves upon gold as a value store, it’s trade able as a hard asset across national borders in real time. Time will tell if BTC is as durable as gold.
- textbookrental 5y agoI think you are the first person I have read to say this, but I totally agree. The cost to secure the Bitcoin network is a function of the market capitalization. If the market cap increases so will the cost of securing the network. If Bitcoin market cap continues to increase, the resources required to secure the network will start to crowd out other economic activity. I feel like we are seeing the first glimpse of this with the chip shortages.
- jrm4 5y agoSuch a good point. I get that it's tempting for people to hold on to the idea of Proof-of-Work because it was 100% necessary to get the idea of crypto off the ground, but this is like people holding on to the idea of burning coal to run trains forever. Bitcoin was the proof of concept, but it to me seems 100% obvious and inevitable that something else will replace it (if crypto continues to exist, which I believe it will) -- ESPECIALLY since the whole point of money is fungibility-in-practice.
- javert 5y ago> Proof-of-work requires, by design, that the electricity value expended on mining is proportional to the total market cap of Bitcoin. This premise isn't true. Funny you have this big confident argument when you're wrong about the basics. The electricity expended is proportional to the value of mined bitcoins plus transaction fees. Note that the mining rate goes down over time, approaching zero.
- cryptica 5y agoAgreed. This is obvious both empirically and analytically. As BTC price goes up, the network starts to yield larger mining profits in total (in fiat terms) and this creates an incentive for people to launch new miners to absorb the surplus profits... The increased competition then causes an increase in mining difficulty which reduces the profit margins back to what they were before the increase but now there are more miners in the network with more total hash power which are consuming more electricity in total. The equilibrium point is the point where most miners are teetering on the edge of unprofitability. One interesting thing to note, however, is that while increases in the price create an incentive for more miners to join the network, the Bitcoin network itself does not require so many miners to exist to support itself at those higher price levels. If you assume a hypothetical scenario were all governments around the world required a license to mine Bitcoin and limited the number of machines allowed in total, then price could keep going up without an increase in the total number of miners. This would be very convenient for existing miners as they would be able to earn more profits without having to buy more machines as the price increases. The fact that this obviously negative-sum game has been profitable for miners in the long run is proof that our current monetary system is broken. If our monetary system was efficient and becoming more so, it would be unprofitable to run so many miners. Bitcoin profits from the inefficiency of monetary system whilst revealing to us the fiat system's negative-sum nature. As dumb and unethical as this all seems, it is the smartest investment to make in the context of our current system. I suspect that Bitcoin saves more electricity than it wastes by turning the world economy into a giant squidgame... It attracts capital towards it instead of towards other economic activities which would end up consuming more electricity... Those other activities would certainly have made better use of the electricity (since, unlike BTC mining, they would have provided tangible value to people in return) but Bitcoin doesn't care about people's well being. It profits from the destruction of opportunities and the concentration of wealth. Poor people consume less electricity. Bitcoin saves electricity by ensuring that poor people stay poor by soaking up all the excess capital so that it doesn't get invested in real economic activities which would bring people out of poverty.
- FabHK 5y ago> Proof-of-work requires, by design, that the electricity value expended on mining is proportional to the total market cap of Bitcoin. I'd amend that to read: Proof-of-work requires, by design, that the money wasted on electricity and electro waste is proportional to the total market cap of Bitcoin times the mining reward (currently 6.25 BTC per block).
- pcthrowaway 5y agoI agree 100%, though I am interested in chains which are doing "Proof of useful work". I haven't looked into it too much, but I believe Banano participants run folding@home (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folding%40home https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folding%40home) to secure their network. This seems like it could be an alternative to classical proof of work that at the very least, isn't actively harmful to society. But I'm unsure if it offers the same security guarantees.
- hiq 5y ago> world governments would rightly shut it all down before the majority of our electric output went to mining BTC They can regulate it otherwise, e.g. demand that miners use their own source of green electricity, and make other type of mining illegal, or demand that less than 1% of the total electricity production of the country is used in mining, outlaw the rest and fine illegal operations, etc. It doesn't have to be completely banned everywhere. > BTC is guaranteed to fail at some point You'd have to define what "fail" means here, especially given that many proponents of BTC argue in its favor for different (and often contradictory) purposes. What's the failing scenario you're talking about, once mining takes all the electricity it can (be it 100% of production or whatever regulations still allow it to take)?
- mercenario 5y ago> It's really just simple arbitrage: if the value of Bitcoin goes up, but the electricity cost doesn't, then you have essentially 2 different prices for 1 good, which should attract more miners to spend more money on electricity. And, indeed, this is exactly what has happened. How is this different from any other good or service? Is it bad only for bitcoin? > The problem, of course, is that if it takes an Argentina's worth of electricity to run Bitcoin now, how does the world manage if Bitcoin has a 10 or 100 times greater market cap? Obviously it can't, and world governments would rightly shut it all down before the majority of our electric output went to mining BTC. What is the problem with it? Do you know why oil has the price it has and why we built all the enormous infra structure to extract it? Because it is useful, and we can kinda measure it by its market cap. If the market cap of bitcoin is huge, that means that...... its usefulness is huge (or you can argue it is a bubble, but then it's a different argument). So the higher the market cap the more useful it is, and its a good thing. The profit and loss is what will tell if we are "wasting" resources or not, if it is profitable, then that means that people value bitcoin more than the electricity it uses, that is not a problem.