11 ms·
Origin of life theory involving RNA–protein hybrid gets new support
- oneoff786 5y agoIt seems difficult to imagine DNA forming without first single strand RNA no?
- ralusek 5y agoJust because a hypothesis seems likely doesn't mean it doesn't require evidence.
- oneoff786 5y agoThe article suggests the dna hypothesis was the front runner for a while though
- creatonez 5y agoNo? The article is talking about RNA World hypothesis vs. RNA-Protein World hypothesis. The RNA world hypothesis has been accepted widely for a long time. Before membraneless RNA viroids were discovered, some abiogenesis researchers may have thought that DNA is fundamentally required for self-replication, so whatever first occurred must have had it. But this is simply a lack of imagination on what RNA can do.
- divbzero 5y agoCould there be an unknown class X of biomolecules that was involved in the origin of life but was later outcompeted by the DNA + RNA + protein combo that dominates today? This class X could have been less efficient at replication but kinetically easier to form from the primordial broth.
- stainablesteel 5y agoit would likely be something of a hybrid nature or an extremely similar precursor, nothing drastically different
- ncmncm 5y agoThe environment at the time life evolved was very, very different from today. In particular, free oxygen was practically non-existent. Metals, particularly iron, and metal complexes were dissolved in the water at high concentration. Processes that spawned the first life had to be compatible with all of that, and may well have depended on many details of it, most of which we can barely imagine. The ancestors of everything alive today survived the arrival of free oxygen a billion or two years later, with the loss of most dissolved metals, leaving no trace of the overwhelming majority that failed to adapt to that. Conditions today, even without competition from existing life, might be wholly unsuitable for biogenesis.
- exyi 5y agoFor sure it's possible, but evolution rarely gets completely rid of something (as far as we know). My favorite support for RNA-world (and similar) hypothesis is that RNA molecules are used as enzymes in some processes (ribosome - translation), even though RNA is a pretty bad catalyst. If the evolution could choose, it would most likely use a protein, but the cost of switching to "new tech" is too high.
- zmgsabst 5y agoThey’re mentioned elsewhere, but viroids[0] are another example of RNA acting as enzymes[1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viroid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viroid [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ribozyme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ribozyme
- axytol 5y agoHow about prions[0] or something similar? They replicate, and are much simpler and smaller than RNA or DNA based replicators. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prion
- COGlory 5y agoThey don't replicate, they take other proteins and refold them. They need existing protein to do that.
- gus_massa 5y agoI agree, but I want to add two bad metaphors. (I'd like to have a good one, but I only have bad ones.) * Prions are like falling domino pieces. If you have a lot of standing domino pieces, and one of them falls, it may cause other domino pieces to fall. But they don't create more domino pieces, or standing pieces. They just pull down the pieces that are around. Also, they store no information, they just flip a bit from 0 to 1. * RNA is like a small pile of glued magnets glued on their side. If you put some glued magnets in a box full of magnets and shake them, they will pick other magnets and create a inverse copy. If the side of the magnets is (magically) sticky, the copy may get glued permanently. After some more shaking, you have two piles of glued magnets moving around and collecting more magnets and making copies. They store information, because the initial pile may be NNSNSNS and the new piles will have the same pattern until there is an error in the copy.
- COGlory 5y agoThose are interesting analogies, particularly for the RNA. Thanks for sharing them.
- gus_massa 5y agoThanks. I agree that they are interesting. (I wrote them :) .) But I can think a few reasons why they are wrong. Anyway, I think they are useful to understand the difference between prions and rna, and why prions are not a good proposal for the origin of life.
- dtgriscom 5y agoFrom [0]: > A shadow biosphere is a hypothetical microbial biosphere of Earth that would use radically different biochemical and molecular processes from that of currently known life. Although life on Earth is relatively well studied, if a shadow biosphere exists it may still remain unnoticed, because the exploration of the microbial world targets primarily the biochemistry of the macro-organisms. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadow_biosphere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadow_biosphere
- edgyquant 5y agoThat isn’t what they’re asking at all. They’re asking about a pre-cellular life like virus that evolved into ours that was then outcompeted.
- gus_massa 5y agoNobody is sure. Look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RNA_world#Alternative_hypotheses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RNA_world#Alternative_hypothes... It has three alternatives PNA, TNA and GNA that are somewhat variants of the RNA. (I'm not an expert, but my uninformed opinion is that GNA looks promising.) Also PHAs that is very different and the iron-sulfur idea that is even more difficult. (I'm not an expert, but my uninformed opinion both look too weird and the transition to DNA is less clear.)
- edgyquant 5y agoTNA is actually observed existing in stellar nurseries so it’s a likely pre-RNA candidate.
- gus_massa 5y agoI imagined a closed 4-crbon sugar, and I discarded the idea. Is theose open in the TNA? Is the 3D structure similar to the structure of a closed ribose? (My 3D imagination for sugars is very bad.)
- monkeycantype 5y agoI love the RNA world hypothesis, I love the idea that DNA is an iteration on RNA optimised for stable data storage, that proteins are and iteration on RNA optimised to be better enzymes and structures and that mediating between the two we still have to transcribe data to the legacy RNA data format, and use the legacy RNA enzyme ribosomes to translate this through to amino acid sequences. The idea the RNA metabolisms might have evolved in small cavities in hydrothermal vents also makes it easy to imagine communities of cooperating molecules in an enclosed area needing to defend themselves from free-loading virus molecules, setting up the ongoing conflict between cells and viruses right from the beginning, and also a dynamic in which viruses are both destructive and an important source of novelty
- ncmncm 5y agoImagine the seas a thick soup of iron complexes and RNA folded into quadrillions of nightmare shapes, a vanishing few of them busy replicating whatever they bumped into. One day, two of them bumped into one another. In the blink of a geologic eye, the seas were brimming with a descendant of whichever of them was faster. Somewhere, a membrane happened. I don't think anywhere in nature today do we find a membrane created entirely from scratch. Everywhere we find a membrane, it grew from and split off of an existing membrane. It may be that we should think of ourselves as fancy membranes, and DNA, RNA, and protein are just clever ways to make more membrane.
- convolvatron 5y agomy hazy memory is that it is/was assumed that the cell wall arose pretty naturally from an asymmetric protein that was hydrophilic on one end and hydrophobic on the other.
- monkeycantype 5y agoThe hydrothermal vent as a spongey matrix of cell membrane precursors is one theory for this. The thing I like about this idea is that the idea of a boundary exists before membranes, and fit with the idea of the boundary being ‘found’
- jononomo 5y agoThe origin of life is in fact the ONLY interesting scientific question because without life no other question arises. Also, the fact that there are individual proteins that must be found in a search space that is on the order of 10^70, while only 10^50 living organisms have ever existed on Earth puts to rest the “random mutation” theory of how life evolved. There was a time when mathematicians in the academy openly mocked the biologists who bought into the “random mutation plus natural selection” creation myth, but sadly those days are over because raising the obvious questions now puts an academic career at risk. It is commonly assumed that it is impossible to definitively prove the existence of God, but in fact the existence of life is a definitive proof of the existence of God, given what we now understand about molecular biology. Here is an interesting book: The Stairway To Life: An Origin-Of-Life Reality Check https://www.amazon.com/dp/1734183705/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_DA9KQS8AB72P8QANY3NR https://www.amazon.com/dp/1734183705/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_DA... Frankly it is game-over for atheism from a strictly empirical perspective.
- andrewflnr 5y agoI used to think this, but the work of Jeremy England (IIRC) has convinced me that the emergence of life is thermodynamically favored. FWIW I'm not down voting.
- pfdietz 5y agoI've seen a lot of handwaving in that direction, but I've never seen a convincing argument.
- vmception 5y agoCell theory origin stories don’t rely on an existing being willing something into existence, or steering improbable events The domain of the supernatural simply covers less and less things as our collective understanding expands
- jononomo 5y agoYou’re making a “god of the gaps” critique — but the origin of life is not merely a “gap” — it is the ONLY interesting scientific question in existence (because without life no other question arises) and it is better described as “an infinite chasm” than a “gap”. The more we learn about it the wider the chasm gets and the more compelling the argument for God becomes.