8 ms·
Except it pollutes more than entire countries. And most tech stocks produce something of value. Even if that’s just funneling VC money into underpriced cab or f
by MBCook 5y ago
Except it pollutes more than entire countries. And most tech stocks produce something of value. Even if that’s just funneling VC money into underpriced cab or food delivery service.
- vmception 5y agoIt uses more energies than entire countries, just like every industry that uses orders of magnitude more than bitcoin. Energy =/= pollute Focus on the bad actors that are polluting, occasionally you’ll find a miner
- endisneigh 5y agoSome industries use more energy but do more useful things. The question is what’s the minimum to do something. Bitcoin uses more energy than the alternatives. A wood burning stove is wasteful, a heat pump, not so much. Why? Because what’s important is the difference in energy between the action taken and the most efficient action to complete a task.
- vmception 5y agoEnergy != pollute Typically this desire for any other use of energy to occur relies on not understanding why that wasnt occurring beforehand
- MBCook 5y agoEnergy does not come from nothing. A large amount of it comes from polluting sources. In those cases there is a very direct relationship between the creation of energy and pollution. Clean energy is obviously better, but suffers from a fundamental problem: energy is fungible. If mining takes up 10 MWh of juice, anyone else who would have used that energy can’t. So they have to use other energy. Often fossil fuel based energy has to make up the difference. For all intents and purposes the mining used that fossil fuel energy. If mining only used excess electricity produced by clean power plants, there would be no problem. But it’s not incentivized to use extra energy, it’s incentivized to use cheap energy. If energy can be generated by fossil fuels cheaper than what you can earn from mining, miners will use that energy. Producing pollution that wouldn’t have otherwise existed. Even if mining only used spare energy generated from clean sources, using that energy means it can’t be stored to be used later, like at night. Possibly necessitating polluting generation later. (I know storage isn’t common today.) If you can explain how mining either does or feasibly could given real incentives use only spare non-polluting energy I would love to know.
- vmception 5y agoSure, the flare gas sites that are (or arent) connected to the grid are exactly a case where bitcoin mining is taking from no other use, and actually reducing very quantifiable pollution There are likely several gigawatts of this kind of energy in north america and the amount of energy used this way and for mining in total will continue to increase without causing more pollution This is due completely to market forces as well, which is worth saying because more mining will migrate to this without it being some altruistic response to environmental outcry
- datadata 5y agoEnergy is most definitely not fungible. The availability of energy and demand for energy can vary by greatly location. For it to be fungible, energy would need to be free to transport, or demand for energy would need to be location insensitive. Bitcoin actually does a lot of good things here because it is location insensitive. For stranded energy, say methane flare gas, there is not an economical way to use the energy of this gas because transport is too expensive and demand is too far away. In this way, the bitcoin mining is consuming energy that wouldn't actually otherwise be marketable. It is also greatly reducing greenhouse emissions without demand for the energy, the methane would be burned, which has much worse emissions than when consumed in a generator.
- cuteboy19 5y agoBefore Bitcoin no one was wasting energy doing redundant calculations on an astronomical scale. Energy==pollute, actually. Energy is fungible and most of it comes from fossil fuels.
- solveit 5y agoThis discussion will go nowhere. Clearly the pro-Bitcoin crowd thinks proof of work is the most efficient way to get a permissionless, trustless, decentralised currency. And the anti-Bitcoin crowd either thinks 1. It's not the most efficient way and there's an alternative (e.g. Proof of Stake) or 2. It may or may not be the most efficient way, but Bitcoin doesn't provide the value to justify the carbon emissions ('just tax carbon commensurate to its negative externalities and let people decide for themselves', he says helplessly)
- vmception 5y agoI’m mostly avoiding the utility argument because the stranded energy reality is so much better As its not taking away from another use of energy and it’s reducing pollution, and is more likely to be the majority kind of bitcoin mining
- upsidesinclude 5y agoThis deserves to be the top posted comment, but will certainly never be. Controversial Take: There is effectively no ceiling on the value potential of Bitcoin. If you live in a hyperinflationary environment, of which there are tons of examples in the last 100 years, the value is known. To people living with the $dollar and expecting endless monetary superiority, it is hard to recognize. It's important to note, there is incentive for miners to use renewable energy. Vast amounts of capital have propped up renewables that languish for lack of a proper demand. Wind isn't on demand, nor is solar. But there's never any discussion of the waste and pollution that subsidized unproductive green energy solutions produce. Mining can utilize 100% of that supply. It acts as a reinforcing mechanism for investment in clean energy. How is this lost on people?
- woodruffw 5y agoBitcoin's energy use is pollution in the strictest sense: it is quite literally wasted as part of the proof scheme. Some of that energy might come from renewable sources, but plenty of it is coming from coal and dinosaur juice. This is true of lots of industries, but even our most wasteful (raw aluminum processing?) or grossly extractive (gold mining?) industries produce actual materials of value.
- nr2x 5y agoFast Fashion is pollution then as well, and that’s absolutely horrible environmentally and in regards to factory conditions. There aren’t any BTC sweat shops as far as I know.
- woodruffw 5y agoI don't understand this response. Why would you think that I would be in favor of fast fashion or sweatshops? These are bad things. That being said, I wouldn't rest on your "Bitcoin is free of slave labor" laurels so quickly[1]. [1]: https://qz.com/1978807/bitcoin-has-a-xinjiang-problem/ https://qz.com/1978807/bitcoin-has-a-xinjiang-problem/
- pessimizer 5y agoAt least "fast fashion" also pollutes the world with clothing.
- raggi 5y agoeven if all the sources were green, and they're not, the energy is being poured into the atmosphere as heat, which is still pollution.
- datadata 5y agoWhat is your definition of pollution which includes any heat? Is a hurricane pollution?
- vmception 5y agowhere can I read about that, could potentially change my view, in some circumstances I think the pollution reduction is greater and I also think dissipation is different than hydrocarbon presence
- version_five 5y agoI couldn't read the article, but I think part of the significance is that bitcoin is believed by some to be a new gold standard that investors would fly to as a store of value and medium of exchange when other markets are failing. But the reality is that it performs no differently than a volatile tech investment, and in doing do negates a big part of it's putative value proposition. I agree with everything in your comment, I just think it's worse than an energy intensive, non contributing tech stock, it also doesn't do any of the things that people talk up as reasons to buy it.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoAt least when Apple was circling the drain back in the late 1990's it had assets that more or less meant there was a floor for its stock price. I see no floor for crypto.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- charcircuit 5y ago>it had assets That doesn't mean there is a floor. If there is no demand for any of those assets they would be worth nothing. USD doesn't have a floor either. One day everyone could just decide it's worthless scraps of cloth.
- medler 5y agoUSD is fundamentally different from cryptocurrency. For one thing, there will always be demand for USD because Americans have to pay taxes in dollars. If you’re an American and you make $X in a year, you have to buy ~1/3 of that in USD to pay your taxes, no matter what.
- charcircuit 5y agoAmerica could get rid of taxes or stop existing altogether. There always exists a risk of demand drying up.
- IAmEveryone 5y agoThe article is written as a response to claims that Bitcoin is an asset (class) different enough from stocks to be useful to diversify a portfolio. It's pointing out that, at a correlation of 0.86, it really isn't. The headline doesn't quite convey this meaning.
- MBCook 5y agoWhich is a reasonable point. It really follows tech stocks pretty closely. But in my mind it’s still an unfair comparison because tech stocks generally have some kind of fundamental tangible value. It may be worth 1/500th what the market cap is, but it’s there. I don’t see that with Bitcoin. Just insane wastes of resources and pollution creation.
- chris123 5y ago
- mind-blight 5y agoYou can disagree, but this comment really isn't helpful. If you have a point, then please argue it. Ad hominem attacks are not a valid rebuttal
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jagger27 5y agoLook at the narratives you’re regurgitating yourself in this very thread.
- colinmhayes 5y ago
- kache_ 5y ago
- chris123 5y agoBitcoin and proof of work are one of the most important innovations in human history.
- perardi 5y ago…well, even if you don’t consider naturally occurring phenomena like fire to be a human innovation, I’d argue things like “the written word” or “mathematical notation” or “formal logic” are perhaps a bit more important, and one might even say foundational to Bitcoin.
- bluehorseray 5y agoProof of work existed long before bitcoin, and I haven't seen any evidence that bitcoin is an important innovation despite it being 13 years old. Send it to zerooo
- version_five 5y agoBitcoin is very smart. When I first learned about it, I thought it was so cool how it all came together, the combination of cryptographic security, distributed trust, even a Forth-like mini language built in. I made my own coin, I played with the source code, I made my own nonstandard protocol that used a bitcoin blockchain (unfortunately I never bought any bitcoin, but at any given time it's a terrible investment, even if it's paid off retrospectively). Anyway, I say all this because I really find it clever, and I really wanted it to be able to do something useful, but the reality is, it doesn't. It's never going to be useful, it's been adopted by scammers and mountebanks, it has no utility and will cause so much harms in the scams that it supports. So while it seems like a cool innovation, and from a purely technological standpoint it is, in reality it's poison. In that regard, it has (sorry for the tired analogy) a lot in common with communism. Cool idea, doesn't work at all, destroys lives. We need to let it go.
- bogomipz 5y ago>"When I first learned about it, I thought it was so cool how it all came together, the combination of cryptographic security, distributed trust, even a Forth-like mini language built in." Interesting, could you elaborate on the Forth bit? Where does this fit in? This is the first I've heard of it but admittedly I don't know that much about Bitcoin.
- treve 5y agoI have all the same concerns regarding pollution, but Bitcoins rise has made me think a lot about the 'value part' in other stocks. If Bitcoin's price can get this high without the 'intrinsic value' or producing something, then this effect probably also exists for other stocks. And this made me wonder: how big of a factor is this in other tech companies. The more I think about it, the more I feel that it must be the majority for many of them. Many companies operate at a loss and are just pumped up to push up metrics, just so someone else will pay more for it in the next round.
- yata69420 5y agoWhen you realize what dollars are, you're really going to freak out.
- pigtailgirl 5y agosame thing happened in March 2000 - browsers with no products and domains with no users were public - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=25_WjiZnvQk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=25_WjiZnvQk first dot com crash tech learned you actually need a product when the markets go south - now (second) tech is learning you need an actual good product when the markets go south --
- majormajor 5y agoYeah, people have bought stocks on future expectations - specifically, future expectations of being able to sell it for more than they bought it, and for more than if they bought something else instead - for quite a long time, compared to buying just on what has already happened. But they still use concrete financials (e.g. growth of revenue is just the derivative of revenue) to make those decisions, and are assuming that the future buyers will be looking at similar numbers that are based in the same real economic business process. The fundamental case for bitcoin-as-an-investment[0] is much less well-defined, and differs far more depending on who you ask. [0] bitcoin-as-currency is a different frequently-talked-about potential future state, but not as relevant to the "acting like a tech stock" discussion
- treve 5y ago
- nr2x 5y agoHow many resources do the employees and resources of Visa and Mastercard consume? BTC at least has very few humans, and humans consume resources and create waste. So, what does a more comprehensive measure than core time look like wrt global warming and payments? I’m not sure the answer, but I’m also sure it is not simple.
- atleta 5y agoHow many? I keep hearing this question as if asking it was a valid argument in itself. (Though, to be fair, you do underline that you don't know the answer.) Regarding your question: whatever they do, those humans will consume resources and create waste. We can't delete them if we do away with Visa :). Sure, they, in theory, would be able to work on something else, freeing up their resources, but that wouldn't decrease the resource use of humanity. Also, people keep comparing BTC's current resource use to the bank system (I think that includes the CC companies as well). However, very few transactions are done with BTC compared to the world financial system (or even just Visa). And if adoption grows, BTC price grows and if BTC price grows (or, in other words everything devalues relative to BTC) then mining rewards grow (measured in other assets) and if mining rewards grow then new miners will join and that means using more energy. I think I've seen a comparison between Visa and BTC measuring how much energy each used for doing a single transaction (or for moving a set amount). Visa was 10 or 100 fold more efficient. Even back then.
- Seam0nkey 5y agoI actually think you give the parent argument just a tad too little credit. If crypto was useful as a currency (and, as you point out, if it is comparably as energy efficient as visa), that would be an effective refutation to the energy consumption argument; freeing up human resources to do something else would be a substantial net benefit of the system for society. However, crypto does not behave to act effectively as a currency; it would be an awful idea to replace the global financial infrastructure with crypto thus the energy costs are here to stay.
- atleta 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- daniel-cussen 5y agoThat pollution is what protects the integrity. It's not waste. It's like a standing army patrolling a bank. In fact those miners are the number one private security of any currency or bank in the world, by orders of magnitude. And second, every dollar blockchain companies make is a dividend of that army patrolling the bank. Not a whole lot of counterfeit bitcoins going around, unlike some currencies I could mention. Treasuries also spend a lot of money protecting their currency, the Secret Service for instance, which works for the Treasury of USG, is mandated to stop counterfeiting. Who gets better results for the money, bitcoin or the Treasury?