6 ms·
People keep talking about having "your lawyer" do something as if everyone just walks around with a personal pet lawyer and I never understood it. Are you sugge
by mort96 5y ago
People keep talking about having "your lawyer" do something as if everyone just walks around with a personal pet lawyer and I never understood it. Are you suggesting that you should hire a law firm at $1000/hour to mildly annoy some website..?
- tsol 5y agoUsually "your lawyer" just refers to any lawyer you have a working relationship with, in my experience. I'm guessing this advice is for someone who finds the privacy issue especially heinous
- stinos 5y agoUsually "your lawyer" just refers to any lawyer you have a working relationship with So, none. I've never even met one I think. And I don't think that's quite rare?
- tokai 5y agoIf you need one to write a snarky letter you'll end up meeting one. After that you'll have a lawyer. What are you hoping to add with your line of argument?
- stinos 5y agoI understand the definition, that's not the problem, I'm merely expressing some bafflement over the 'your lawyer' term seemingly being used here as something common. And apparently I'm not alone, looking at the other comments.
- slingnow 5y agoWould you have been equally confused by someone saying "talk to your dentist"? I don't understand this widespread bafflement. Would it be less confusing to say "talk to _a_ lawyer"? This just seems like a bunch of people arguing for the sake of arguing. It has nothing to do with the original point.
- stinos 5y agoWould you have been equally confused by someone saying "talk to your dentist"? No, because in my culture it happens to be rather common for people to have one fixed dentist. Moreover, tranlated we also effectively it 'your dentist'. Would it be less confusing to say "talk to _a_ lawyer"? For me personally yes, because it does not have the same connotation i.e. doesn't imply something common. Which leads me to think this might be a combination of cultural/language thing. As in: when I read 'your lawyer' I translate this mentally then think about occurrences where I heard that phrase in my language. Doesn't ring a bell, so I start thinking about what I did hear or think I would hear another person say when talking about something like this. And 'a lawyer' would be that. This just seems like a bunch of people arguing for the sake of arguing. It's not, at least not from my part. See previous paragraph: this is HN, I come here because stuff like that gets discussed here freely and going off-topic is also not exactly a problem.
- oauea 5y agoI've never understood it either, and always wondered if it was some American thing? Do they have a favourite lawyer like I have a favourite barber?
- chasd00 5y agoSome people do but usually the "have your lawyer" phrase means "find a lawyer who specializes in this area and contact them". Still, the point still stands, it's expensive and time consuming to even begin the process of engaging an attorney if you haven't done so before.
- ineedasername 5y agoSay "have a lawyer" instead of your lawyer would convey that point without that baggage of someone sounding like they don't understand that most people don't already have a lawyer in the same way they have a dentist.
- denton-scratch 5y agoNot an american thing, but rather old-fashioned. A long time ago, well-to-do Britons had a "family lawyer". Not on retainer; but he knew the family business (so didn't need briefing), and he dealt with wills, property, that kind of thing. Like a family doctor, rather than a specialist consultant. Nowadays only the very rich can claim to have a "family lawyer".
- dmurray 5y agoMy middle class family certainly has a "family lawyer" who deals with wills, property, that kind of thing. You should use a lawyer for those things, why not use one you know and trust? If we were very wealthy, perhaps we'd have a legal matter for him every month instead of every year or two, but that's plenty of time to build up a relationship. Similar to having a family doctor.
- chaircher 5y agoIn the EU you're probably looking at the equivalent of $300 on average for a letter like this, and you're more likely to have the disposable income available to do it. Something like this you can easily do yourself and imo wouldn't be worth the money, however getting a law firm involved in small tasks is a good way to test them with something simple to see if they're any good, and build up a working relationship with one incase you need them for something more serious or time sensitive later on. It's generally a good life skill to get comfortable working with lawyers because at some point all of us will end up in a situation where we need one, and that's really not the point at which you want to deal with that learning curve.
- acadapter 5y agoThe privacy concern is valid, but most people (from my experience) aren't interested in interacting with the legal system in this way, and for these sums of money.
- chaircher 5y agoSame to be honest. I can't imagine baiting anyone into something like this. One of the things you learn when you get more experience with the legal system is when, why, and how to avoid engaging with the legal system.
- pumnikol 5y agoWhere I live (EU), lawyers have standard rates for standard stuff. For a run-of-the-mill letter, you're looking at ~ 100 €, but could be 50 if they want to get you as a new customer. Source: A lawyer asked me whether they should write a legalese letter to someone I was planning to sue (work-related) with their help, and explained to me all of this, plus a lot of stuff I had to stress/ watch out for. I knew I had found a good lawyer when they then told me I could also have a go at writing it myself. Now whether or not the example at hand counts as run-of-the-mill, I don't really know.
- User23 5y agoIn California a formulaic demand letter costs around $120.
- adolph 5y agoWhat's the formula for demand letters cost? Something like: https://www.kalzumeus.com/2017/09/09/identity-theft-credit-reports/ https://www.kalzumeus.com/2017/09/09/identity-theft-credit-r...
- chmod775 5y ago>People keep talking about having "your lawyer" do something as if everyone just walks around with a personal pet lawyer and I never understood it. "My dentist" also isn't my personal pet, but it's the dentist I go to. Neither am I my dentist's pet for being "their customer". I'm sure you also know some professionals that you trust and have some sort of relationship with. >Are you suggesting that you should hire a law firm at $1000/hour to mildly annoy some website..? Not really. But there's usually people who do it for the good cause and later take it to court, often backed by nonprofits. Also that cost is insane, it should absolutely top out at 300 euro/hour. Some specialized lawyers charge a flat amount to send such standard requests.
- jermaustin1 5y agoI have an accountant, a lawyer, a dentist, an internist, and plenty of others. All of them are "mine" because they are the ones I use when I need their service. They all aren't on retainer, but instead are basically fee-for-service.
- ineedasername 5y agoMost people don't even have a lawyer in the same way they have a dentist. And the fact that I might just be a few Google searches away from finding one doesn't change the parent comment's point about the fee still stands.
- lnxg33k1 5y agoMost people don't bother, in EU you can do that with disposable income, but if you don't have disposable income there are lawyers studios that are funded publicly to be used by lower income people, so you either have disposable income or you have the will to look around, but you have possibilities to make you an example I am in the netherlands, few weeks ago I went out with some friends, a dutch guy was complaining about an issue and about having to pay a lawyer, and a polish immigrant here had to tell him that he could give a go to https://www.juridischloket.nl/contact/ https://www.juridischloket.nl/contact/ , like some people live and grow up in a system and they don't even know what they're surrounded by
- ineedasername 5y agoThat's pretty interesting. In the US the civil legal system is much less accessible to anyone without disposable income and disposal time. There's small claims court which in my area only costs $15 to file, but that is highly limited in the types of cases you can bring before it. IANAL, but it appears that the type of case I'd have to bring against a company that was inappropriately handling my personal information would require over $400 just to file the papers for the lawsuit. And the fact that I can't easily determine if that's the type of legal action I'd need to bring demonstrates the opacity if the legal system that further prevents access by an individual without spending even more money on a lawyer for the help needed to make that determination. There are ways I could get inexpensive legal advice, but that's where disposable time comes in. I have too much income to get free legal aid for the lawsuit itself, and honestly there are people with much more serious legal problems that need those limited resources. Unless you can catch the attention of a class action lawyer that sees potential for massive $$ damages it is very difficult for the average person to take advantage of the legal system to protect their rights.
- bitwize 5y agoI would probably have phrased it "hire a lawyer to..." Which also conveys that you have to open your wallet -- not something lightly done for many people, although the significant trust-fund wantrepreneur crowd on Hackernews may think nothing of it.
- Adraghast 5y agoSome of the replies you're getting are comical. "Obviously we don't mean having a lawyer on retainer. That'd be unreasonable. We're talking about the lawyer with whom you maintain a working relationship should you need one. You know, kind of like your accountant!"
- eftychis 5y agoHonestly, having a lawyer on retainer may not be a bad idea in our field. Definitely you want a contract lawyer checking your contract and evaluating them.
- tshaddox 5y agoI’ll have my butler schedule an appointment.
- chmod775 5y agoWhat's the point of making fun of a strawman? Either have the courage to directly reply to the people you are talking about or keep it to yourself.
- Adraghast 5y agoMake me. (-:
- duxup 5y agoI feel like there's a parallel "internet law" that is informed by semi accurate news stories, movies, TV, and a sort of "if I could I'd have a lawyer do X and then I imagine Y will happen" ... that has very little to do with actual law.
- nicolas_t 5y agoI have a lawyer that I have a relationship with and regularly ask questions to. He costs me 375 usd an hour and is great at his job (which I know by having worked with him for a while). When I was younger, I didn't use to have one and tried to cheapen out by reading contracts carefully without checking with a lawyer. One of those contracts was a rev share in exchange for free work I did (plus some work I paid other contractors to do), I didn't notice that there was an easy way to get out of the contract by the company. Once the company was successful thanks to the work I initially did, they used that to cut me out. If I had used a lawyer back then, I'd still be earning 150k a year from that contract... So, yeah having a relationship with a lawyer in the same way you have a favorite dentist is worth it. Having the reflex of using a lawyer when possible potentially can save a lot of money down the road. And using a lawyer at first for less impactful work is sometimes a good way to find out if the lawyer is any good. I'd actually suggest any consultant/contractor to have a lawyer, work with him to review every contract and budget a small percentage of your income on this every year.
- bscphil 5y ago> So, yeah having a relationship with a lawyer in the same way you have a favorite dentist is worth it. > costs me 375 usd an hour > budget a small percentage of your income on this every year What you are saying is that for those with enough disposable income to throw 375 per hour at minor annoyances, going straight to that nuclear option is often preferable to settling for a cheaper secondary or backup option. This is the "simply buy Twitter if the way it's run annoys you so much" of legal advice. This doesn't apply to 99.999% of people on this planet. It is "worth it" in the sense that $800 / oz gold plated caviar is better food than McDonalds. If the median American decided to "find out if [your] lawyer is any good" by hiring them for a 1 hour task, they have already spent more than 1% of their yearly income. In a single hour.
- nicolas_t 5y agoI'm saying, if you're a US software engineer/contractor earning 100k+ a year like a lot of people on HN, then reserving 2% of your income (2,000) for legal fees is worth it. Doesn't have to be for what the OP suggest, but definitely to check any contracts you get into (including employment contract). The advice I wrote applies in the context of consultants/contractors on HN which I'm pretty sure tends to earn quite a bit more than the median income.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> People keep talking about having "your lawyer" do something as if everyone just walks around with a personal pet lawyer and I never understood it. Let me explain: they don't walk around with a personal lawyer. Just as if I buy a chocolate bar it doesn't mean I walk around with a personal sweet shop. You've just radically misunderstood how everything in the world works.
- mort96 5y agoNo, you're just misunderstanding an exaggeration. It's just bafflement at how people seem to assume everyone just has a lawyer in the same way the just gave a GP.
- robertlagrant 5y agoNo one assumes everyone has a lawyer. The only assumption like that that's been mentioned is you thinking everyone has a GP.
- mort96 5y agoOkay, good. Me assuming everyone has a GP is a great example. I'm in Norway, where everyone _does_ have a GP automatically. I could nonchalantly say "You should speak to your GP about X" as if having a GP was the norm, since that's the only thing I've ever experienced. When I see "you should speak to your lawyer about X", I'm reading that as the same kind of assumption that "having" a lawyer is the norm; that speaking to a lawyer you have an established relationship with is just a normal thing to do.
- hombre_fatal 5y ago> You've just radically misunderstood how everything in the world works. Nothing here should have provoked you enough to get that combative. It's an amusing point they made. Not to mention, we're all roleplaying anyways. It's just not that serious. And none of us including the thread OP is actually ever going to do this, much less involve "their lawyer" over a networked <form>. It's like when we roleplay that we're going to call our government representative and inconvenience some intern with some stern words: it's just a fun circlejerk. None of us are actually going to do it. So it doesn't make sense to get emotionally involved to the point of asserting that someone misunderstands how everything in the world works.
- aeturnum 5y agoFreelancers often have lawyers who: write their contracts, adjust them for new clients, fight over breaches, etc. Founders will have lawyers who do something similar for them via-a-vie their companies. When you have a steady stream of work, you can often ask them to do little things like this as a favor, just like they might ask you to help them with some tech thing. I think those groups just happen to be massively over-represented on HN.
- littlestymaar 5y agoI can't say about other countries, but in France most (if not all) house insurance come with a “legal assistance ” clause which covers this kind of stuff. Depending on the company ou can either use their lawyer or find your own and have fees reimbursed by your insurance (of course the fees are subject to validation by your insurance and the maximum amount depends on your contract)
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoSince parent wrote about the EU, which .de is a part of, there is this thing called "Rechtsschutzversicherung" und "Prozesskostenübernahmeversicherung". Also aeons ago in tv-adverts: "Advocard ist Anwalts Liebling!" meaning with this card you are the lawyers favourite. So basically, yes, with appropriate insurance you can have that done for you :-)