6 ms·
Welcome to Hotel Elsevier: you can check-out any time you like – not
- meatsock 5y agothe headline would be clearer with punctuation re-added before the word 'not' to reflect the author's sarcasm
- WaitWaitWha 5y agoOr get of it completely? It is only used by a "narrow" sub-culture group in the USA, as far as I know.
- reaperducer 5y agoIt is only used by a "narrow" sub-culture group in the USA, as far as I know. The way we learn about the world is to be exposed to "narrow" sub-culture groups in various countries.
- happytoexplain 5y agoIn language, "familiar with" is a vast superset of "used by", and only the former is required for clear writing.
- mgkimsal 5y agoArchive.org: https://web.archive.org/web/20220510131526/https://eiko-fried.com/welcome-to-hotel-elsevier-you-can-check-out-any-time-you-like-not/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220510131526/https://eiko-frie... Main link was down for me - exhausted resources.
- nayuki 5y agoMe too. Out Of Ressources This page exeeded given ressource limits, so we cannot serve every request. Please try again later!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- williamkuszmaul 5y agoMIT recently cut all of their relationships with Elsevier journals. Researchers are still allowed to publish in Elsevier, but when they do, even they won't have access to their own articles without going through a paywall. The widespread emergence of nonprofit open access journals is promising. I am hoping that in twenty years, Elsevier will be a thing if the past.
- Ansil849 5y agoA number of European universities have also cut ties with Elsevier - https://www.enago.com/academy/german-universities-cancel-elsevier-contracts/ https://www.enago.com/academy/german-universities-cancel-els....
- bell-cot 5y agoFar better (an incentive for open-access publication) would be if Elsevier-published articles "didn't count" for funding & tenure decisions.
- malshe 5y agoThis is the critical step. I don't know who will bell the cat though!
- jonlucc 5y agoPractically, then, how do researchers access Elsevier articles? I work in big pharma, and if there's an article I don't have access to, I just request it through our information services office, and it is emailed to me almost instantly. Presumably, that is charged to my department. Is there a similar system in place at MIT? Does it come out of research budgets now?
- notimetorelax 5y agoI love it when articles about privacy and consent published on sites that don’t give me that option.
- Ansil849 5y agoReminds me of the Amazon data request process from a few weeks ago - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30820424 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30820424
- rendall 5y agoBorat: "You can NOT check out any time you like NOT" https://youtu.be/fhIdbRp6xeg https://youtu.be/fhIdbRp6xeg
- SamBam 5y agoIt's amazing to me that the big research universities haven't banded together to make a competing open-access system of journals. It would require no more work on the side of the academics -- they are already doing all the work for Elsevier -- and the administrative costs of hiring editors would almost certainly be equal to the fees they currently send to Elsevier. The fact that they haven't makes me think that, with the exception of independent universities such as MIT, Elsevier's lobbyists are able to lean on the political people at the top of most large universities.
- Nemo_bis 5y agoThey did. https://doaj.org/ https://doaj.org/
- gowld 5y agoImpact Factor metrics gaming for tenure. Elsevier journals are "prestigious". Open journals exist. Some academics still choose to publish in closed journals.
- techdragon 5y agoSimple proposal then… we the academic paper consuming community need to start considering Elsevier journals as not prestigious. If you’re involved in any academic hiring then you are absolutely ducking responsible for perpetuating their power if you don’t push back however you can on the assumption that these journals are somehow more prestigious based entirely on their past history. It won’t happen overnight but unless we change the assumption that these journals are special then we will never truly take back the power from Elsevier.
- dredmorbius 5y agoBut who should bell the cat? https://satibal.com/cat-mouse-and-bell-story/ https://satibal.com/cat-mouse-and-bell-story/ What perpetuates the prestigous-journal practice are review and hiring committees, often swayed by journals themselves through various means, which hold the true power. Changing institutions, particularly academic ones, is difficult. Far more often, splinter groups are formed. Schism at Balognia resulted in Padua. Schism at Oxford resulted in Cambridge. I believe there may have been a similar dynamic between Harvard and Yale. Arguably the same might be said of Harvard's failure to cultivate an engineering curriculum, and hence M.I.T. Though it might be interesting to look at academic disciplines and institutions and identify which are most controlled by journals. I suspect business, medicine, and law would be near the top of such a list.
- stone0338 5y ago"Academics write articles for Elsevier journals for free and hand over copyright; other academics review and edit these papers for free; and Elsevier then sells these papers back to academics." -- This is not accurate. Elsevier journals also charge huge amount of fees (around or over $1000 depends on the journals) from academics for submitting and/or publishing their manuscripts. --edit: changed submitting to submitting and/or publishing
- lou1306 5y agoUhm, no? That may be true for open access publications, but traditional publishing (with Elsevier or others) is typically free of charge.
- Ansil849 5y ago> That may be true for open access publications, but traditional publishing (with Elsevier or others) is typically free of charge. Yes, and Elsevier has open access journals with APCs (article publishing costs).
- malshe 5y agoIt depends on the field. Accounting and finance journals have significant submission fees. For example, the Journal of Financial Economics, an Elsevier journal, charges $750 for the initial submission and then lower fees for each resubmissions ($500 for the first resubmission, $250 for the second) https://www.elsevier.com/journals/journal-of-financial-economics/0304-405X/guide-for-authors https://www.elsevier.com/journals/journal-of-financial-econo...
- sampo 5y agoLooks like you can first volunteer to work as a reviewer of manuscripts for the journal, to earn rights for reduced submission fees, or completely free submissions. Maybe the Economics community has problems to find reviewers, the journal is resorting to that trick to find some balance between submitted manuscripts and available reviewers.
- 5y ago
- gHA5 5y agoIn Germany at some universities linen bags with the Elsevier logo are handed out to freshmen, and you occasionally see students using them. Admittedly, I think their logo does look nice. Because of this I'd argue that the public opinion of Elsevier is actually rather positive.
- blfr 5y agoWhile it's silly that academics rely on a commercial company to maintain their commons, the fact that this company knows which articles you open strikes me as completely normal. Any library does that. That they know which IPs you used? Any server you contact knows that. That they have your account number on file after they paid you? What were your expectations here.
- gbear605 5y agoIf I go into a library, I can open and look at any number of books without the library recording it. Of course if I check it out they’ll know, but that’s primarily to ensure you return it (and secondarily so they can see what books to buy in the future).
- ObservingFuture 5y agoAs research slowly migrates to independent open-access journals and conferences, I wonder if there is an opportunity to coordinate (and incentivize) the peer review process in a decentralized manner. Maybe a digital currency that's created by reproducing (or disproving) existing papers (weighted by lack of reproduction) and with which the author of a submitted manuscript "pays" reviewers and editors, which they in turn use to submit their own papers?
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe coin of science is truth, and history has shown repeatedly that it responds quite poorly when any other goal is incentivised. That includes "publish or perish" (promotes low-value journal-milling), impact factor (dittos), various forms of degree conferring and/or tenure-gating (journals become gatekeepers to disciplines and careers, and can feed back influence to senior faculty and/or administrators to enshrine that status), and more. Schopenhauer's essay on authorship is strongly recommended. Peer review, for all the awe it inspires presently, is quite modern as a significant factor, dating to the 1980s. https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=peer-reviewed+article%2Cpeer-reviewed+journal&year_start=1919&year_end=2019&corpus=26&smoothing=3 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=peer-reviewed+...
- ObservingFuture 5y agoHuh, I didn't know that peer review was that recent. For all of its issues, I still think there would be some value in encouraging people to find issues in papers and publicly note them instead of relying on an oral history of which papers are accurate (hence my suggestion to encourage people to reproduce or disprove papers, while slightly penalizing submitting new research). Many fields have reproducibility issues, and my experience has been that research groups informally build their own internal lists of (seemingly) inaccurate publications. It would be naive to believe that even the most devoted individual would opt to starve rather than pivot their work to eat. As it stands, there isn't much an incentive other than "truth" or general political reputation management to document the reproducibility of other work. Erroneous works make it difficult to find relevant, accurate ones.
- memorable 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20220510013415/https://eiko-fried.com/welcome-to-hotel-elsevier-you-can-check-out-any-time-you-like-not/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220510013415/https://eiko-frie...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dncornholio 5y agoLike the author said, a lot of smoke but not much fire. The data they have is the data you provided to them. If you don't want them to have your bank number, don't give it to them. You can say a lot of bad things about Elsevier, but I don't see much issues from this post?
- AlbertCory 5y agoAs a former patent buster (ok, that's bit of hyperbole, but I did bust patents): It's rare that I would know I want an entire article, until I skim it. I would skim literally 100s of articles just to find one that might be useful. Only then would I actually want to read it carefully. There's no amount of cost that's justified until then. Fortunately, you can almost always the author's work for free somewhere else.
- dredmorbius 5y ago"Why Information Goods and Markets are a Poor Match" https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2vm2da/why_information_goods_and_markets_are_a_poor_match/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2vm2da/why_inf... (I'm agreeing with you.)
- AlbertCory 5y agoThanks. These points especially: "Quality isn't, and often cannot, be known in advance." "The idea of "too small to matter" of a micropayment is at odds with "deciding if it's worthwhile"." "Content is frequently available elsewhere. Gate / turnstile jumping is far too easy." "Virtually all payment systems create a data trail of what content you're accessing -- it's an Orwellian wet dream of identifying who is reading, watching, or listening to what." Especially that, for legal searches
- dredmorbius 5y agoOn searches: anyone looking for information related to reproductive services through much of the central and southern US, say.
- ChildOfEru 5y agoAlways interested in the abuses of regulatory capture. Here is RELX (owner of Elsevier) lobbying spending in the US: https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/clients/summary?cycle=2021&id=D000067394 https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/clients/summary...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- IshKebab 5y ago> These €55 sure came with a privacy cost larger than anticipated. I mean, I don't think it's unanticipated that giving your bank details to Elsevier would mean that they know your bank details. Elsevier are 100% evil but this article has some crazy fear mongering.
- 8bitsrule 5y agoAfter reading about Elsevier's behavior, the word "colonialism" lept to mind. I'd like to hear from academics about why their colleges seem to do nothing to put a stop to these tactics.