12 ms·
Behold GoldenEye 007 with four screens – dream come true or travesty?
- code_runner 5y agoScreen cheating was allowed in my friend group but we might call someone out… no big deal. When LAN parties became a thing it was really the first time I had played a game and not even had the option. Both are fun.
- legalcorrection 5y ago$10,000 to split a video signal into quarters? They got fleeced. And how is this even a story? They took a video signal and split it into quarters. What am I supposed to be surprised or impressed by?
- ericlewis 5y agoI was sitting here thinking the same thing. You could probably achieve this with an rpi or two. The article is light on technical details unless I totally missed it..
- dylan604 5y agoThe video from the tweet clearly shows the rack of gear doing it. It flashes them quickly and I didn't bother to try to pause the video to look. They look like boxes from BMD, but there are other manufactures that do this screen splitting for large room displays as well. It's pretty common gear in the AV world. The point isn't how they did it, but that they did do it. Only on HN is the actual point lost.
- knolan 5y agoI would imagine you could do it easily with a HDMI mod and some edid dongles for a few bucks.
- dylan604 5y agoShow me a BOM for this, please.
- ungamedplayer 5y agoProbably with huge latency too. Everything is simple if speed/latency is not a consideration. Ie, you could use a webcam on a screen, and then cut it up using FFMPEG cropping, send each of them via an RTMP stream to a device... but then you have encoding + cropping + network latency. Sucks for gaming.
- dylan604 5y agothat's the most bizarre way of thinking about it, that I'd almost think I had the idea myself. luckily, I grew up in this world, and am familiar with equipment that does this properly. phew. you failed to mention the major hit in quality of videoing a CRT screen with a webcam. also, hope that webcam supports genlock as well as the CRT, otherwise, your h/v sync will never match. and i thought i could come up with some zanny ideas. this one though, boy, i don't know.
- ungamedplayer 5y agoWe're going budget yo.
- knolan 5y agoThere are low latency dongles you can use for old consoles to output to HDMI, see my reply to the parent.
- knolan 5y agoThere are several N64 HDMI mods. Here is one on Amazon for $20. https://www.amazon.com/Nintendo-HDMI-Converter-Cable-Compatible/dp/B07TGJZXWR https://www.amazon.com/Nintendo-HDMI-Converter-Cable-Compati... Or this one for $150: https://www.amazon.com/Super-64-Nintendo/dp/B07TKF5XBS https://www.amazon.com/Super-64-Nintendo/dp/B07TKF5XBS You could also use an upscaler like the MClassic for $100: https://www.marseilleinc.com/mclassic/ https://www.marseilleinc.com/mclassic/ Then you need a 1x4 HDMI splitter like this: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Controller-Splitter-Supportt1920x1080P-Splicing-4-Channel/dp/B09TD4HJMF/ref=sr_1_4?crid=2IMYK9GQB5PEE&keywords=hdmi+1x4+splitter+video+wall&qid=1652130507&sprefix=hdmi+1x4+splitter+video+wall%2Caps%2C41&sr=8-4 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Controller-Splitter-Supportt1920x10...
- paulryanrogers 5y agoIt's a museum so reusing CRTs and their low latency is probably part of the appeal.
- djur 5y agoYeah, the Ars Technica article makes it clear that this is a temporary use of hardware they already had on hand, and the $10k is just an estimate of what it would cost to buy this vintage hardware online today.
- lelandfe 5y agohttps://arstechnica.com/gaming/2022/05/how-to-play-multiplayer-goldeneye-on-four-tv-screens-with-only-one-n64/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2022/05/how-to-play-multiplay... ArsTechnica’s article includes more detail in how exactly they got this to work - it’s pretty great/disgusting.
- Nextgrid 5y agoI wish they'd change the link to this as it contains more technical details. Edit: nevermind, shame that you can't flag your own comments for moderator attention. I know I can email but I feel like it's not important enough to warrant one.
- colejohnson66 5y agoIt’s too late now, but for future reference, if you can still edit your comment, and no one has replied, you can delete them
- dehrmann 5y agoYou'd have to do some buffering, but I guess you could "just" (this is way easier with digital tech) buffer scanlines, send the first half of it to one screen, the second have to another at half speed, and replay the line for the next scanline? What's nice is you don't have to buffer a full frame to do this, so there wouldn't be a frame of lag.
- phire 5y agoThat doesn't work for a four way split. The top of the screen could have almost zero delay, but the bottom of the screen would need half a frame of delay. But you can keep the delay to a maximum of about half a frame (and an average of just over a quarter frame across the whole display). It requires driving the two bottom displays out of sync to the two top displays by half a screen. You could do more with a small software modification on the n64, make it interleave the top two and bottom two images as alternating scanlines. That way while it's outputting the repeats for the top two, the n64 is scanning out the next line for the bottom two.
- basedgod 5y agostock n64 goldeneye is unplayable garbage https://youtu.be/ziUMJB3id8I https://youtu.be/ziUMJB3id8I what a waste of time
- ironSkillet 5y agoOf course it doesn't hold up to modern standards 25 years later. But at the time it was released, it was considered outstanding and revolutionary. I mean c'mon, you could shoot guards in the groin and they would slowly fall to the ground clutching their junk in agony.
- ericlewis 5y agoIndeed a large appeal was the technical marvel of have a 4 person split screen game of such magnitude. Very different from the relative simplicity of Mario kart. Edit: it also bothers me that despite our progress on all technological fronts we still get halo as the best split screen fps experience. Edit 2: also still love playing OG 007 with friends who come over because if you didn’t figure out how to prevent screen cheating you never learned how to actually play.
- dannyfraser 5y agoOh that last point! My friends and I used to just strafe along every single wall and all you could see was the wall texture until it was time to shoot. We knew all the levels so well that just the changes in lighting, or sometimes how quickly a door opened, were enough for us to tell where someone else was (avoid the coloured corridors in Complex). Screen cheating is a skill, countering it is a skill, and countering THAT is an even bigger skill.
- ericlewis 5y agoOh the sounds too. You knew when someone opened a door and there are only so many doors and if they opened two doors in rapid succession.. they were gonzo. The game is really a game of mastering all senses I guess lol.
- codingkoi 5y agoMy siblings and I would tape a monopoly board to the TV to split it vertically and then play team games to get around “screen cheating”. I think it had the best of both worlds. We were still in the same room but we could ambush and sneak up on each other. Definitely less expensive than this solution. Goldeneye 64 was the best bang for our buck of any game we ever bought. We did the same thing with Perfect Dark.
- udp 5y agoWe used to position the TV such that it was split between two bunks of a bunk bed. One player below and one player above.
- RileyJames 5y agoYep, remember doing that once or twice in halo 1. Ultimately, screen cheating is a feature. Halo worked well as the pistol (starting weapon) is all you really need. So there’s no massive disadvantage on spawn. I remember playing online 2v2 (halo on xbox, there was no online so it was actually system link, lan, run over the network. Bloody hard work from Australia) in which screen cheating is most definitely a feature. Nothing more bonding for two brothers to duke it out 1v1, and then discover you’re leagues ahead of everyone online in 2v2.
- mulmen 5y agoAs I recall the Xbox had an Ethernet port and Halo supported up to four consoles. I think there were some limitations. Not sure if two teams of 8 were possible but I think 4x4 was. At a minimum I believe dedicated screens were possible in a four player game. The PS2 had something similar (only two consoles) but it used Firewire because Sony is the Apple of Japan.
- findalex 5y agoPro tip: A+B will detonate a remote-mine (no need to switch to the watch).
- IntelMiner 5y agoTime to rent a time machine and go back 25 years Child me is gonna be king of the playground
- causality0 5y agoNo screencheating here! puts the screens in a row so you can still screen cheat Sigh. That means he "happens to have a number of bits of equipment for messing around with video," he said. This is an important line. It was done this way because they had the equipment on hand, not that they think it's a good solution for anyone else. The bit about replicating their setup is just the author being dumb. You could do this with fifty bucks in capture and output equipment.
- Khoth 5y agoThat's just for the video showing it off, they say when people are playing it for real they'll arrange the screens facing away from each other
- argsnd 5y agoSeems like a lot of the cheapest ways to do this might introduce significant latency though.
- goldenkey 5y agohttps://arstechnica.com/gaming/2022/05/how-to-play-multiplayer-goldeneye-on-four-tv-screens-with-only-one-n64/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2022/05/how-to-play-multiplay... They are using analog signal processing equipment, the latency is probably less than a ms.
- drewtato 5y agoThis isn't the cheap way. Cheap way is converting it to digital and re-outputting it in 4 separate hdmi/vga displays.
- ShamelessC 5y agoIf you watch the video referenced in the article, he says at the end they will move the monitors for actual play. And besides, ease up. It's someone nerding out with AV equipment not an attack on your ideals as a technologist.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fernandotakai 5y agoplaying goldeneye with 4 players is such an amazing memory from my childhood. the screen cheating screams were constant -- to the point where we (as in, my group of friends) decided that screen peaking was worth an arm punch (without retaliation). and the group would judge if the offender was screen peaking or not! oh and only the "noobs" (as in, the younger of our group) could pick oddjob, because it was almost cheating.
- dahdum 5y agoScreen watching was so integral we were cool with it, not uncommon for all of us to only strafe move while facing walls (especially in Stack) to make it harder to know where we were. The real controversy was over spawn rushing. Once you figured out exactly where and how close you could be to the next spawn dying just once put you at a large disadvantage. Ultimately that’s why we stopped playing, it would commonly end up like 10-3-0-0 and that was lousy for the 0’s.
- jonplackett 5y agoTotally invented this in 1997 with a cross shaped piece of cardboard stuck to the TV screen. Radars off too for extra jumpiness.
- dannyfraser 5y agoNo radar, auto-aim off, license to kill, pistols, go!
- jonplackett 5y agoI was hoping this was going to be the announcement that it’s coming to the Switch N64 emulator
- voidfunc 5y agoDoubt that would ever happen. Probably a licensing nightmare since Microsoft owns Rare now plus whatever licensing issues they would have with the Bond franchise holders.
- arielweisberg 5y agoDidn’t even know screen cheating was a thing. That is just how the game was played. No player is at a disadvantage.
- crtasm 5y agoThere's even a game named after the term where everyone is invisible so you have to look at the other player's screens: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Screencheat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Screencheat
- dehrmann 5y agoIt's cheating in the same way looking at the community cards is in hold 'em; it's part of the game.
- ddingus 5y agoAwesome! I wanted to do that forever. Never had the hardware, but being around media people meant I knew it was possible. Dream come true, in my view! All that killer analog gear being tossed and this happens. Now I just want to play, maybe perfect dark too. To avoid screen cheating, I liked to drop the proximity mines in PD and keep moving. Effective enough they were banned from family play, lol.
- dylan604 5y agoExcept, it's not just analog gear anymore. Once that analog SD signal reaches the box, it is digitized and manipulated before being spit out one of the D->A converters.
- ddingus 5y agoActually, what I should have said was analog era gear. The screen splitters are almost certainly digital at the level you describe. Some analog gear capable of this sort of thing did exist though.
- dylan604 5y agoThe thing I found funny was the use of professional CRT monitors as opposed to common TVs. Makes sense as the splitter equipment will just be spitting out standard video signal. I never had an N64, but the NES and Atari 2600s had to have an RF modulated signal and impedance matcher to connect to an antenna port. If they did that kind of connection with this setup, then I'd really be impressed at their collection of memorabilia. Wondering when the consoles started coming out with the discrete RCA style video/audio connectors? Not enough to look it up though ;-)
- JonathonW 5y agoPVMs (pro CRT monitors) are fairly common in the retro gaming space. I suspect it’s a combination of higher image quality plus higher build quality meaning more are likely to still be functioning (as opposed to, say, N64-era consumer TVs). As for output options: The NES had composite video out, in addition to the RF out (which you most likely needed in that era, unless you had a fancy TV). The SNES kept the RF out, but added a proprietary AV multi out connector. This exposes composite video (and stereo audio) at a minimum, and older models did S-VIDEO and RGB component as well (cut in later-production models to cut costs). The N64 used the same multi-out connector, but RGB’s always unconnected on the N64 and S-VIDEO only works on NTSC models. And RF’s gone on the N64, so you needed a separate RF modulator if all your TV had was an antenna input.
- jpgvm 5y agoWe do what we must because we can.
- hartator 5y agoThey don’t have 4 players though lol. True nerd dilemma.
- footlose_3815 5y ago[dead]
- jwithington 5y agoWait how does a shooter on a single stick controller work again? How did we move/shoot?
- andrewmackrodt 5y agoIn the default layout the analogue stick controlled forward and backward movement and turning left or right. The yellow c buttons could be used for strafing or adjusting the vertical "aim" (the game heavily relied on autoaim). It was also possible to use the R trigger to enter an aiming mode where the analogue acts like the left stick would in modern FPS.
- wand3r 5y agoyou would hold the R trigger down to aim and it would switch from walking/move to a superimposed crosshair you could aim with the joystick. I think you could also just hold trigger and shoot without aiming. That's how I recall it worked at least
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoThere was an option to use the c-buttons like WASD and the stick to aim but judging from the way people talk about goldeneye a lot of players never discovered it.
- grumbel 5y agoSame as in any other classic FPS, the N64 has four C-buttons for directional control in addition to the stick. By default however it uses a Doom1/Duke3D-style control scheme, not a modern one, meaning the stick doing forward/backward/turn-left/turn-right, while the C-buttons are doing look-up/down and strafing. Modern games just switch the turn and strafing around. That said, Goldeneye, along with Perfect Dark, both have numerous alternative control options, one of them is using two gamepads, so you can have two analog stick and control it just like any modern shooter. N64 controller is pretty unique in being usable with only one hand.
- greatgib 5y agoI highly recommend the visit of this computing museum in Cambridge. It's an awesome place. You can use and play with almost any machine that they have and they do a great work of restoration!
- jwmoz 5y agoAm I the only person that played goldeneye in southpaw? I don't know why I did it but must have been due to the extra control with the aim you got. Always thought the n64 layout was bad for fps so ended up trained to use it the other way around. When I played an n64 decades later I could not use southpaw anymore because years of playstation had got me accustomed to the regular layout.
- johnwalkr 5y agoAlthough not a great experience, you can also play it using 2 controllers to get 2 analogue sticks[1] [1]https://goldeneye.fandom.com/wiki/Control_style#Dual_Controller_Styles https://goldeneye.fandom.com/wiki/Control_style#Dual_Control...
- whateveracct 5y agoI used to play Melee doubles with 2 mirrored TVs at smashfests. It was always a huge hit.
- dusted 5y agoThat's a neat hack
- whywhywhywhy 5y ago>where you can barely turn around and can’t freely aim while moving Not true just select the 1.2 control mode and the c-buttons move and strafe and the stick will aim.
- marvin 5y agoI'm fairly confident Nintendo posted some meta thoughts on Goldeneye at one point, where they stated that "screen cheating" is fair game.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andygcook 5y agoSome of my favorite GoldenEye multiplayer glitches/tips off the top of my head, which were all fair game at my house: - Pressing A + B activated a remote mine without switching to the watch - If you put remote/proximity mines on ammo boxes, then picked up the ammo, the mine’s sprite would disappear when the ammo box respawned, but the mine would still actually be there - Placing remote/proximity mines in the spawn locations - If you already had full body armor and couldn’t pick up another, the best move was to blow it up so no one else could grab it for awhile - The Magnum could shoot through various surfaces that other guns couldn’t (like the grates in front of the hiding spots in the Complex) - Some of the guns could “shoot through” opening doors before they were actually open in the Temple (Edit: line breaks)
- mrozbarry 5y agoI think a lot of game development companies have lost sight of the charm of basically zero-hardware config multiplayer. By that I mean, one computer (or console), one screen, multiple controllers, and no user names/sign ins. GoldenEye was great for that, you could just jump in. Having multiple monitors just seems like overhead. Some of the fun was the fact that you could target a player and be a total jerk, and you quickly find out who the "honorable" players are. To me, it's part of the game. Honestly, I wish there were more modern games like this. I'd gladly sacrifice shiny graphics and 4k to have a local couch coop game with some friends.