8 ms·
What's interesting is that oil pretty much prevented the entire world from being deforested in our crazy search for fuel. It also saved the (remaining) whales
by m463 5y ago
What's interesting is that oil pretty much prevented the entire world from being deforested in our crazy search for fuel. It also saved the (remaining) whales when it replaced whale oil for lamps.
(I think I learned this reading "the rational optimist")
- rob74 5y ago...but, being so cheap, it also enabled crazier ways of using fuel, like cars and airplanes, which wouldn't have been possible (or would have been possible, but not feasible at the scale we have nowadays) with wood or coal. So now our civilization is addicted to cheap oil and other fossil fuels, and the question is how we can keep up our level of civilization (or let's call it "standard of living") while beating this addiction.
- automatic6131 5y ago> it also enabled crazier ways of using fuel Which massively raised the quality of life most humans can live in, in various direct (we can transport a wide variety of foods quickly) and indirectly. The question is how we can feed this "addiction" (stupid word: you're also "addicted" to breathing and eating) yet ever more whilst reducing or eliminating the negative externalities. A low energy use society is also poor society which is also, in most of the ways you presumably care about, a bad society. And I don't mean poor as in dollars.
- developer93 5y ago"A low energy society is a poorer society" while you're right in general, in the west we can live far more efficiently than we do without really impacting our quality of life via things like longer product life cycles, more public transport, living closer to places we need so we don't have to travel so far every day, better distribution of resources. These things could be improved if society took enough interest. Still might not be enough and we have to beware of efficiency increases getting swallowed by increased use, but my point was it's not 100% true.
- philistine 5y agoThere are signs that we are transitioning to all of these. For example, demographic growth is at best neutral in everything but cities; that means people are using less land and are closer to their needs. The problem is the pace at which this transition is happening. It’s not fast enough to stop a really bad future.
- jtbayly 5y agoAnd we're all going to starve in the 1800's, too.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThose grim predictions were only pushed back by the exploitation of nonrenewable resoruces. Coal-fired furnaces produced iron ploughs. Strip-mining guano from South American deserts and Pacific islands fertilised fields until Haber and Bosch discovered how to turn nonrenewable natural gas into ammonia fertiliser, and munitions. Steam-powered, and later electrified, pumps, irrigated fields regularly. Chemical pesticides eliminate insect pests (and disrupted ecosystems). Vast new farmlands in the Americas fed Europe (pity the natives who'd been there before). Powered farm equipment displaced human and animal power on the fields. Rail and refrigeration moved food across continents and oceans to hungry mouths, without spoilage. Virtually all of that entailed utilising resources at rates faster than they could be replaced: coal, oil, gas, guano, topsoil, fertilisers, groundwater. There were also advances in cultivar selection, in hybridisation, in weather forecasting, in general farming techniques, and the like. Many of those relied heavily on reducing defencive and other metabolic loads on crops (e.g., staving off insect pests, or sending deep roots for uncertain water) and directing more energy into producing grain yields. This is a gain in efficiency, but a loss in resilience. (See Howard Odum for more on this.)
- jtbayly 5y agoIt sounds like you’ve got a prediction to add to the list. Go ahead. I’ll write it down with a calendar reminder to see if you’re right.
- pfdietz 5y agoIf I replace incandescent bulbs with LEDs, I use less energy (yes, even with elasticity of demand) yet I'm better off, not poorer. The notion that any reduction in energy use is bad is wrong.
- zaroth 5y agoLED lighting is a perfect example of how technology can eliminate any trade-offs for becoming more efficient. I would say EVs are another. This is definitely not always the case, but any time that it is, I think market adoption will be swift and eventually universal. For me, the take away is that ultimately to be successful the efficient and sustainable choice needs to be the better choice on the individual level.
- dredmorbius 5y ago30 years ago my neighbours didn't have garden lighting running until midnight every night. Today they do. That's only one example of a lighting application which LEDs have enabled. It's just not that we crank up the lumen output in every lighting fixture (though that happened in many cases). It's not just that we've started illuminating parts of our houses, offices, and exteriors which were never previously illuminated (though that's also happened). It's that activities and populations which never previously could afford to run a 60W bulb now have multiple 10W LEDs. Those might be mains or battery powered (or a combination). There's also the reliability factor. Mains power which shuts off for hours per day is useful, but has limits. Mains power which shuts off for only a few minutes or seconds per year is far more useful. Access to electricity has increased from 78% to 90% of the global population since 2000. That's nearly a billion more people with access to lighting. Kenya is a reasonably modernised country in Africa, with 47 million citizens. Its total electric generation capacity is about 2.6 GW (roughly the equivalent of a single major US or EU power station). That works out to 55 watts of power per person. Less than a single 60W light bulb. (Actual peak demand was 1.9 GW, November, 2019, or 40 watts/person.) With such a limited supply, availability of LED lighting could very well lead to far more lighting, and a shift from other energy uses. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Kenya https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Kenya https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenya https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenya
- Tade0 5y ago> So now our civilization is addicted to cheap oil and other fossil fuels, and the question is how we can keep up our level of civilization (or let's call it "standard of living") while beating this addiction. Lots of low-hanging fruit here. Most drivers of SUVs and trucks don't need such large and thirsty vehicles. I guess we'll find out soon enough, considering what Russia's invasion has done to fuel prices.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoFuel prices have gone up way before russa attacked ukraine, and cars are not just a transporting-device, but also shelter, storage and a safety device. Electric cars would solve many things, but general unavailability of cars (wait list), general no-repair fuckery of factories (either unable to replace the battery or making it too expensive), and lack of general infrastructure (charge points) make them unusable in many cases now. But due to fearmongering of both pro-oil people and 'green' parties we practically stopped building nuclear powerplants, which would bring power prices way down and make stuff like electric cars more viable.
- mlindner 5y agoThe future is a further increased energy usage powered by the Sun (and energy indirectly derived from the Sun like wind and hydro), the Earth (geothermal), and the Moon (tidal).
- throw0101a 5y ago> ..but, being so cheap, it also enabled crazier ways of using fuel […] See: > In economics, the Jevons paradox (/ˈdʒɛvənz/; sometimes Jevons' effect) occurs when technological progress or government policy increases the efficiency with which a resource is used (reducing the amount necessary for any one use), but the rate of consumption of that resource rises as falling cost of use increases demand.[1] The Jevons paradox is perhaps the most widely known paradox in environmental economics.[2] However, governments and environmentalists generally assume that efficiency gains will lower resource consumption, ignoring the possibility of the paradox arising.[3] […] > The Jevons paradox was first described by the English economist William Stanley Jevons in his 1865 book The Coal Question. Jevons observed that England's consumption of coal soared after James Watt introduced the Watt steam engine, which greatly improved the efficiency of the coal-fired steam engine from Thomas Newcomen's earlier design. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- zaroth 5y agoIsn’t increasing consumption through increased efficiency (decreased cost) a crucial factor for how standards of living are raised? I don’t see how this is a paradox.
- Majromax 5y agoThe paradox arises because cost per unit fuel does not decrease because of use-efficiency. Whether your car gets 20 miles to the gallon or 50, you pay the same price per gallon at the pump. Therefore, in an "all other things being equal" sense, you'd expect more efficient use of the fuel to lower total consumption, since the same desired effect is achievable with less input. Switching from incandescent lights to LED lighting should lower your electricity bill. The paradox arises because of an income effect or "standard of living" effect, as you note, and it arises as "all other things being equal" gives way to a new equilibrium. It's not guaranteed to happen -- I imagine few people's electricity bills have gone up because they use so much more LED lighting than incandescent lighting -- but it can happen.
- dredmorbius 5y agoForests, and even whales, are potentially renewable resources. (The Inuit had hunted whales, sustainable, for many thousands of years, with oil amongst the benefits obtained.) Fossil mineral resources are literally unsustainable by definition. Any activity described as mining, unless there is some geological process that creates new deposits faster than they are exploited, is entirely uneconomic. Extant value is being destroyed. Fossil fuels might have served as a bridge resource to a sustainable track. To date, this has not been seriously persued or attained. Matt Ridley is an exceptionally uninspired apologist for nonsustainable extractive practices, and is not a relaible or credible guide.
- dividedbyzero 5y ago> Fossil fuels might have served as a bridge resource to a sustainable track. To date, this has not been seriously persued or attained. That's why I'm pretty stoked about Germany's push to become renewable and sustainable in earnest (at least for energy), even though it's going to be brutally expensive, extremely difficult and the outcome is not at all certain (not quite the kind of move you'd expect from Germany, actually). But at last someone's giving it a shot, and if that gamble works out, wow. That might completely change our collective trajectory in a crazy good way. And Germany might just be able to pull this off, with its deep pockets and highly innovative engineering base. I have high hopes that a few decades from now, there will be renewables, storage, grid tech that'll make the current stuff look crude and primitive and crazy inefficient, like what has been achieved with CPUs/SoCs since the 80s.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe knowledge that fossil fuels are finite dates to the 18th century. No, not the 21st, not the 20th, not the 19th. The 18th. John Williams. 1789.
- Someone 5y ago> Fossil fuels might have served as a bridge resource to a sustainable track. To date, this has not been seriously persued or attained. Isn’t what we are we doing/trying to do now exactly that? I haven’t seen anybody making the suggestion to go cold turkey and go to 100% renewables overnight. Most solar cells and wind farms are built using (mostly) fossil fuels. Also, many countries close down coal power plants but keep gas plants running, knowing that they need fossil fuel to get to 100% renewables, but trying to minimize their impact (because of the difference in pollution effects, it’s better to end up with X MWh equivalent of coal than with X MWh equivalent of gas in the ground) (and yes, there’s all kinds of exceptions, such as Germany closing down nuclear plants, but keeping brown coal mines open)
- dghughes 5y agotransmission fluid for vehicles was whale oil in the not too distant past late 1960s early 1970s.
- dredmorbius 5y agoTIL! "Automatic Transmissions and Detroit's Dirty Little Secret" By the 1960s up to 30 million pounds of whale oil were used each year, chiefly as the main additive to automatic transmission and locking differential fluids. It was whale oil that made these devices so reliable and efficient and it was primarily the auto industry's requirements that maintained the demand for whaling during the mid-20th Century. https://www.secondchancegarage.com/public/725.cfm https://www.secondchancegarage.com/public/725.cfm It was apparently environmental regulations which finally ended the use of whale oil in automobile lubricants. Not the Endangered Species Act, but pollution controls resulting in higher engine (and transmission) operating temperatures, which broke down even whale oil.
- cypherpunks01 5y agoThis is an extremely positive take, thanks for sharing!
- mikepurvis 5y agoMichael Shellenberger makes a similar case [1] for many uses of plastic, too— for example, items like hair combs and eyeglass frames used to be made out of tortoise shell, and like whales, the tortoises were under major threat until plastic replaced all of that and they went back to being all but ignored by humanity. So yes, there is a ton of unacceptable plastic waste out there, but the net effect (he argues, anyway) is still overwhelmingly positive for the environment, particularly if we can focus eco efforts on ensuring that plastic ends up safely land-filled rather than being overly consumed with reducing the upfront production of it. And one of the nice things about this approach is that it's not an uphill battle the way guilting people about their lifestyle choices is— you can work with NGOs to lift people around the world out of poverty, and a natural part of them becoming richer will be having the mental bandwidth to look around and demand things like a safe, well-organized waste processing pipeline. [1]: https://www.amazon.ca/Apocalypse-Never-Environmental-Alarmism-Hurts/dp/0063001691 https://www.amazon.ca/Apocalypse-Never-Environmental-Alarmis...
- mikepurvis 5y agoFor anyone interested in more on tortoiseshell in particular, the Wikipedia article is a good starting point: > Tortoiseshell was widely used from ancient times in the North and in Asia, until the trade was banned in 2014. It was used, normally in thin slices or pieces, in the manufacture of a wide variety of items such as combs, small boxes and frames, inlays in furniture (known as Boulle Work carried out by André-Charles Boulle), and other items: frames for spectacles, guitar picks and knitting needles. Despite being expensive, tortoiseshell was attractive to manufacturers and consumers because of its beautiful mottled appearance, its durability, and its organic warmth against the skin. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tortoiseshell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tortoiseshell