7 ms·
Energy densities of various substances and/or reactions is pretty fascinating concept. Some of the most interesting energy analysis I've come across (Vaclav Sm
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Energy densities of various substances and/or reactions is pretty fascinating concept.
Some of the most interesting energy analysis I've come across (Vaclav Smil and David MacKay especially) describe energy in terms of area: what are the comparable land areas which would have to be dedicated to specific sources or forms of energy or fuels, and how do those compare? One of Smil's descriptions of petroleum wells is "punctiform", which I love. A hole in the ground, only about 20 cm in diameter, can provide years to millennia of human energy output, per day.
1 litre of oil is equivalent to about 3 days of human energy output (at 3,000 kilocalories/day).
1 gallon of oil is eqivalent to about 11 days of human energy.
One of the oldest oil wells in production (the First Oil Well of Bahrain) produced 80,000 barrels of oil per day initially. That's over 1,000 years of human energy equivalent.
By comparison, the yeild of current biomass production is far, far less. The difference, of course, is that oil is biomass, accumulated, converted, and concentrated over hundreds of millions of years. We're consuming it at > 5 million times its rate of formation. (See Jeffrey S. Dukes, "Burning Buried Sunshine" (2003).)
In terms of radioactivity, the net metabolic rate of the Sun's core is lower than that of a human, measured in energy/mass. Solar metabolism is closer to that of reptiles, about 1/5 of mamallian metabolic rates.
Chemical energy is less productive than the most effective nuclear transitions, but its shear abundance and ease of utilisation tends to weigh in its favour.
- criticaltinker 5y ago> to produce one litre of petrol it takes 1.29 kg of oil, of which 85% (1.1 kg) is carbon. And as only 1/10,750 of the carbon remains from the plants that were buried millions of years ago, our one litre of petrol is the result of 1.1 x 10,750 = 11,825 kg of carbon from ancient plants. Finally, as plants are approximately half carbon, that means that 23.65 tonnes of plants were required to make just one litre of the petrol available at your local station Burning Buried Sunshine discussion and link: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28214230 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28214230
- dredmorbius 5y agoThanks. I strongly recommend reading that paper, it's one I return to every few years. And yes, you're quoting your comment on my previous submission ;-)
- gibolt 5y agoLand area hides the true scale though. The oil fills vast volume under the ground. Solar panels may take up more surface area, but the energy output per unit of material and volume should easily out-class oil. There is also no shortage of area on land or sea that is otherwise useless to us.
- folli 5y ago> There is also no shortage of area on land or sea that is otherwise useless to us That's a bold statement considering ecological factors.
- nine_k 5y agoI'd say that Sahara is an ecological disaster already, the result of ancient deforestation. Even if we might considering preservation of its ecosystem, we likely won't plan to preserve all of it.
- rob74 5y agoWhile some ecological disasters are definitely man-made, the Sahara has been mostly the way it is today for the last 10,000 years (source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sahara#Desertification_and_prehistoric_climate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sahara#Desertification_and_pre...). Of course the current climate change will influence whether it will expand in the future, but the "core" Sahara has been there before human influence...
- jsjohnst 5y ago> I'd say that Sahara is an ecological disaster already, the result of ancient deforestation. There is literally zero scientific evidence I’ve seen to back up that claim, unless by “deforestation” you mean natural “deforestation” by glaciars.
- kuhewa 5y agoThey could be put on top of the massive surface area of oil sands deposits that are currently being treated as ecologically unimportant. A lot of oil extraction isn't as 'punctiform' as it used to be.
- zasdffaa 5y agoIt's too early in the morning but something doesn't seem right here, not even close. > 1 litre of oil is equivalent to about 3 days of human energy output (at 3,000 kilocalories/day). Working 8 or 24 hrs/day? . <https://peakoil.com/generalideas/how-much-energy-is-there-in-a-barrel-of-oil https://peakoil.com/generalideas/how-much-energy-is-there-in...> " So, is oil really worth $100 a barrel? Another way of looking at it is to compare oil to a horse. A horse laboring a standard 40-hour work week (eight hours a day, five days a week, 50 weeks a year) would have to labor for more than one year to produce the energy in a barrel of oil. Do you think a horse could be fed and maintained for a year for $100? Not likely. Human labor is even worse. A fit human adult can sustain about one-tenth of a horsepower, so a human would have to labor more than 10 years to equal a barrel of oil. " . and an extract from a loong! thread <https://peakoil.com/generalideas/how-much-energy-is-there-in-a-barrel-of-oil https://peakoil.com/generalideas/how-much-energy-is-there-in...> " This has been argued and debated often on TOD, mainly in response to some of my own quotes in media about 1 barrel equating to 25,000 hours of human labour (12.5 years at 40 hours per week). Ultimately the answer to this question depends highly on assumptions - but we can arrive at a good approximation. 1 barrel equates to 6.1 Gigajoules (5.8 million BTUs). Depending on the 'job', humans use roughly 100-700 Kilocalories per hour (Computer work requires an estimated 119.3 Kcals/hr). 1 kilocalorie (Kcal) = 4,184 joules. So 1 barrel of oil has 6.1 billion/4,184 = 1,454,459 kcals. Using a range of 100-700 kcals per human hour of work then results in a range 2078 and 14544 hours per barrel of oil. At 2000 hours per year (40*50), this is would then be 1.0-7.25 years per barrel. " . One more <https://www.texasmonthly.com/articles/sneak-peak/ https://www.texasmonthly.com/articles/sneak-peak/> " One barrel of oil has the same amount of energy of up to 25,000 hours of hard human labor, which is 12.5 years of work. At $20 per hour, this is $500,000 of labor per barrel " . 1 barrel ~158 litres <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barrel_of_oil_equivalent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barrel_of_oil_equivalent>. Also hard labour is about 5,000 calories/hour. (edit: horizontally spaced a bit for readability)
- wcoenen 5y agoJust to clarify where the original numbers came from... The claim you are responding to: 1 liter of oil ~ 3 days of human energy output. Energy in a liter of oil: about 30 megajoules. Human base metabolic rate: below 100 watt. Let's say 100 watt. 1 watt = 1 joule/second. 30 MJ / 100 joules/second = 300000 seconds = about 3.5 days. So the original claim is correct in that sense edit: Now, this doesn't mean you can get the same benefit from a human laboring for 3 days non-stop as you could get from 1 liter of oil. This is just the energy required by the human body to stay alive. Any additional useful energy output would be on top of that, and humans can only sustain a small amount of additional power for long. That's why your references seem to disagree. Though you will really get that 100 watt from a human in the form of heat, which is why that number needs to be used when designing airco systems.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoBiomass production on the other hand, can be carbon negative and generate power from waste that would otherwise get dumped. So isn't it negative surface area by this metric? Similar to rooftop solar. Despite this being a ridiculous metric, I feel oil probably loses on it still, if you did a proper well to wheels analysis. Particularly the step when you turn it into electricity, oil/biomass is going to take a major hit in both energy and and surface area.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'm not quite sure what you mean by "can be carbon negative". Are you referring to sequestring some of the biomass in soil or other formations? That's possible, yes. The principle limitation though is net primary productivity, and the human use of that, HANPP (human appropriation of net primary productivity), a/k/a the photosynthetic ceiling. Humans already account for about 20% of all NPP, with considerable economic impacts. Our fossil fuel consumption equates to another large share (from memory, I believe another 40 percent). The likelihood of substituting for even a small share of that is small. Humans initially switched from biomass (wood and biowaste) to fossil fuels because rates of consumption of current biomass productivity exceeded replacement, as well as for degredation of ecosystems in which they were produced: "forests proceed us, deserts follow us". I've yet to see a biofuel proposal which even remotely pencils out in theory, let alone when considering the likely practical obstacles. This includes woodfuel, plant-oil plantations, peat harvesting, various grasses, pickleweed (a brackish-estuary fast-growing plant), or algae farming. There's some marginal contribution possible, but even that comes at extreme cost. Human populations, per-capita energy consumption, or both, would have to fall dramatically.