18 ms·
We should have a $25 minimum wage
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tencentshill 5y ago
- dqpb 5y agoEveryone should get some equity.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoIt's genuinely great Sam supports the idea of raising the minimum wage to a living wage. I fully support it, but he's going to need to run for office, or bank roll a PAC to get candidates into office who can actually pass the legislation. Platitudes are cheap, political activism is expensive AF. Wrt equity, unless mandated, you're either at a company that gives it out because they have no choice (traditionally, startups or tech firms) if they want to be competitive, or employee owned companies where owners/management see the value in being employee owned [1]. Start funding candidates who will commit to raising minimum wages, it's that (not easy, but) straightforward. [1] https://www.nceo.org/articles/employee-ownership-100 https://www.nceo.org/articles/employee-ownership-100 (Fun fact: Publix, the southeastern supermarket chain is one of the largest employee owned firms in the US, with ~200k employees).
- nh23423fefe 5y ago
- otagekki 5y agoI live in Paris. My take-home salary before taxes as a software engineer is slightly less than that, it's considered "high" salary as I pay 10% income tax on it. I'm seriously looking to moving to the U.S. by the end of the year to found a company, and while $15/h is becoming a trend, I don't really think I'll accept to come back to France after 2 years even at double the rate I am being paid now. Not being picky, but software engineer salaries here are just ridiculous (even more so outside Paris) even compared to neighboring countries like the U.K. or Germany
- dunefox 5y ago10% income tax only? Where so I sign?
- exdsq 5y agoFun thing - I work in the Bay Area but because of my visa I don’t have to pay federal taxes and only pay state which is like 18%
- Alupis 5y agoThis is probably wrong, btw. You are obligated to pay federal income taxes if you are here on a visa for over a certain number of days during the year... which sounds like might apply to you.[1] Uncle Sam always gets paid. [1] https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/how-resident-alien-taxed.html#:~:text=Nonimmigrant%20Visa%20Holders,satisfy%20the%20substantial%20presence%20test https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/how-resident-alien-t....
- exdsq 5y agoI did speak to an immigration lawyer to check! It's something like if I stay beyond a certain date I'll have to pay but because it's short term it's only state taxes.
- Alupis 5y agoFair enough. Last I saw it was around 128 days total in a calendar year, which perhaps doesn't apply to you (the way you initially stated "you work in the bay area" seemed to imply you were here mostly full time). These things are worth staying current with an attorney every once in a while. I don't imagine it would be very fun to find out the wrong way.
- junar 5y ago> I don’t have to pay federal taxes and only pay state which is like 18% This sounds a bit off. California state income tax tops out at 13.3%, and the vast majority of folks owe less. Even if you include SDI/VPDI, that's only an additional 1.1% in 2022. The most common tax exemption for foreigners is an exemption from FICA taxes (Social Security + Medicare) [1], which commonly applies to certain folks with F/J/M/Q visas. But generally, they still owe both federal and state income taxes. In fact, as nonresident aliens, their effective federal income tax rate can be a bit higher due to not having the standard deduction and certain other tax benefits. Another relatively common benefit is the various tax treaties [2]. This may provide some relief from federal income tax, depending on the country and the visa status, but not necessarily a total exemption. [1] https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/foreign-student-liability-for-social-security-and-medicare-taxes https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/fore... [2] https://www.irs.gov/publications/p901 https://www.irs.gov/publications/p901
- BayAreaEscapee 5y agoThe counter-argument is this: you're outlawing willing market participants who wish to sell their labor for less than $25 per hour. What if someone doesn't have a skill set or live in a prosperous enough market that supports that wage? Quite a bit of business will simply disappear if the labor is too expensive. That hole-in-the-wall diner in the Ozarks will simply close if they have to pay $25 an hour, and the waitress working there will simply be unemployed without another alternative.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoIf your business cannot pay a living wage, it should not exist (what a living wage in the Ozarks is is another discussion [1]). Fill the gaps with unemployment and other social safety nets. I am not unsympathetic to business owners (having been one myself many years ago), but I am also not sympathetic for having the worker class suffer for the benefit of business and consumers, and living in poverty is abject suffering. Trillions of dollars of capital class/shareholder profits shows there is productivity to distribute more evenly. [1] https://livingwage.mit.edu/counties/29153 https://livingwage.mit.edu/counties/29153
- _-david-_ 5y agoShould a 17 year old who is still in high school while living with his parents be paid $25/hour for working at McDonald's? There is no reason he needs a "living wage" since his parents are already providing what he needs.
- Inityx 5y ago>Should a 17 year old who is still in high school while living with his parents be paid $25/hour for working at McDonald's? Yes. >his parents are already providing what he needs And what about people who aren't in this particular situation? What is the policy solution to filter out people who you feel don't deserve this level of compensation for their labor?
- 5y ago
- legitster 5y agoWhy not $50? Why not $75? The quality of the "standard" minimum wage studies is pretty bad, and it should worry people that there has effectively been no upper bound found on the effects of minimum wage. If someone claims they found an infinite money glitch hack of the economy, it probably deserves some scrutiny (Dube did propose an upper limit of 60% the median wage, but it was very informal). > obviously it will cause some severe disruption but one lesson of the last couple of years is we can adapt to labor changes. If the adaptation is more young workers move back in with their parents and more women leave the workforce, then yeah I guess? At this point you are being pretty tacit that the tradeoff between higher wages is lower labor force participation.
- TomGullen 5y agoWhy $10? Why not $0?
- anm89 5y agoWe already have a minimum wage of 0. Every person who has no job because of minimum wages gets the true minimum wage of zero. (note transfer payments are not a wage, I'm not saying they have zero access to money)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- notch656a 5y agoAny job between 0 and minimum wage becomes either a 1099 job or a black market job. When people say $25 minimum wage, they really mean make sure anyone paid less is on the black market and has no protections.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere are instances in which people pay to work --- "finders' fees", "placement", various assessments to supply tools, (mandatory) uniforms, station rental, etc. Involuntary servitude still exists, even in advanced countries, though it is illegal, usually as "white slavery", mostly immigrant sex workers. $0 is not the lower limit.
- NiagaraThistle 5y agoIt might be a popular opinion because I make more than this and have increased my earnings over the years from $2.90 per hour to what I earn today, BUT why does anyone think the MINIMUM wage should be this high? DO the same people expect to give me a similar wage increase to offset what will inevitably bring on higher costs and probable inflation? I mean assuming minimum wage were $10 and we raise it to $25 arbitrarily, that's a 150% increase. At the BOTTOM. Now everyone who wasn't earning minimum wage has just had their earning power slashed. What about the employees that worked hard in school or through a series of jobs to get up to $25 per hour? Now they are making "minimum" wage at a potentially high-experience-necessary job? Does this mean that my and other people immediately and automatically deserve a 150% salary increase to keep the earning-power relative? So someone who was earning $100,000 now automatically deserves $250,000? What about costs of goods and services? Do we automatically increase these by 150% too? Gas that is $4 now $10? Rents at $1000, now $2,500? How does that help the minimum wage earners? Sure they have a higher wage, but now costs (ie inflation) has just skyrocketed keeping them and their buying power exactly where it was previously. And if EVERYONE'S wages weren't increased those not on minimum wage (assuming their wages didn't get the 150% bump) just lost out bigly. I am ALL FOR fair wages for work. But resetting and arbitrarily raising the minimum wage doesn't work for a sustainable long term solution. Instead, why not pressure companies to minimize profits thereby reducing costs so lower wage earners can afford the basics and hopefully some extra comforts. Why not provide more financial education so lower income workers don't get caught in credit card/debt and paycheck loan traps that keep them poor. Let's put more tax dollars to work in low income neighborhoods and areas. I feel there are so many other ways to lift people out of poverty traps, but arbitrarily raising the minimum wage only looks good on a piece of paper/paycheck. In the long run it just keeps people in the same position and hurts those higher up the ladder. And yes I know this last part sounds elitest, but that is not my intent. I am only saying that this hurts EVERYONE'S buying power in the long run.
- fallingfrog 5y agoThe data shows that you are not correct- Seattle has a 17$ per hour minimum wage and the sky did not fall. Things improved, mostly for the people at the very bottom. Business owners made a lot of threats but ultimately they did not move out of the city. https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/7/13/20690266/seattle-minimum-wage-15-dollars https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/7/13/20690266/seattle...
- fallingfrog 5y agoI mean, the whole point of having an economy in the first place is so that people have food and shelter and other amenities. If it can’t do that for the population in the aggregate, it’s broken. Raising the minimum wage would cause some decrease in the amount of resources going to everyone else (comment if you want my mathematical reasoning, otherwise it’s an exercise for the reader). But I’m ok with that.
- anm89 5y agoThis is such a bizarre viewpoint. Can you show where its clearly defined that > the whole point of having an economy in the first place is so that people have food and shelter and other amenities Having a purpose is a trait of things which are created intentionally. Economies dont "have a purpose". They are emergent systems. It's like saying the purpose of an ant colony is to dig dirt. An ant colony doesn't have a purpose. No entity with an intentional will created it and it doesn't exist "for a reason", it's an emergent system that forms naturally. The economy doesn't "have a point". It would exist even if no one wanted it to.
- dredmorbius 5y agoPOLITICAL œconomy, considered as a branch of the science of a statesman or legislator, proposes two distinct objects: first, to provide a plentiful revenue or subsistence for the people, or more properly to enable them to provide such a revenue or subsistence for themselves; and secondly, to supply the state or commonwealth with a revenue sufficient for the public services. It proposes to enrich both the people and the sovereign. The first object of political economy is to provide subsistence for the people. -- Adam Smith, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations http://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/smith-an-inquiry-into-the-nature-and-causes-of-the-wealth-of-nations-cannan-ed-vol-1#lf0206-01_head_052 http://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/smith-an-inquiry-into-the-...
- anm89 5y agoPolitical Economy as Smith defines it is the STUDY of economics. Political economy has a point. It is an intentional action taken by a person who want to understand economies. The economies themselves don't "have a point". They are composed of individuals who do things which "have points" but the emergent system by definition does not "have a point"
- anm89 5y ago
- exabrial 5y ago
- temp8964 5y agoWhy left’s proposal is always universal? Just make your own city $25 min wage, unlimited abortion, free health care, free education. If you are doing good , everyone else will follow. No need to keep persuading others.
- tannhauser23 5y ago
- exabrial 5y ago
- Inityx 5y agoYou do realize that minimum wage has not kept up with inflation, and much less the cost of living? > Increasing their pay of made up units (dollars) doesn't actually make them any richer, it just moves the scale and prices go with it. This take is completely divorced from the reality of the current world economy. We currently have a situation in which value is being squeezed out of the working class, and into the pockets of ogliarchs. Increasing the minimum wage would compensate for the massive deficit between produced value and wages, to the benefit of the people actually doing the work.
- Alupis 5y ago> You do realize that minimum wage has not kept up with inflation, and much less the cost of living? Inflation? It's far exceeded inflation actually. Minimum wage was introduced in 1938 at $0.25 per hour[1], which would be about $5.06 per hour when adjusted for inflation[2]. Which means, a federal minimum wage of $7.25 far exceeds inflation... by about 43%. Many (most?) states have a higher minimum wage than that even. Cost of living had certainly increased since 1938, but it's not the same everywhere. The COL in San Francisco is no where near the same as Omaha. We cannot apply a universal federal minimum wage of the likes Sam A. is discussing in this post... it quite literally would drive up costs of goods and perpetuate a negative feedback loop. We're seeing it right now in real time. We handed everyone thousands of dollars for "free", and inflation is now rising at levels not seen since the 80's... which mostly squeezes the very people you are trying to help by increasing minimum wage in the first place! [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_wage#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_wage#United_States [2] https://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm https://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm [3] https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/minimum-wage https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/minimum-wage
- tamaharbor 5y agoInflation much?
- exabrial 5y agoAll minimum wage increases are regressive against the poor. Let's say minimum wage is $1 and the family saved up $100 in a bank account. They have 100 units of labor saved up, which is a lot of purchasing power. Now some brilliant economists move minimum wage to $100/hr. The family's saved labor is wiped; as the bank didn't automatically increase their savings to $100,000.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ceeplusplus 5y agoNot only that, high minimum wage doesn't actually make a minimum wage job any more livable than low minimum wage. Bay Area low skill wages are over $20-25/h already, but rent prices have risen to match (or in the case of rent control, the quality of housing declined exponentially to 1930s unmaintained shitboxes). Same goes for NYC, Seattle, LA, etc. No reason to expect rent to not increase accordingly if minimum wage goes up to $25/h.
- dredmorbius 5y agoA land-value tax, or an equivalent which captures surplus rent values and returns them to the general common weal would also be required. The law of rent and iron law of wages are two ends of the lever. Both must be addressed.
- kitkat_new 5y ago> Not only that, high minimum wage doesn't actually make a minimum wage job any more livable than low minimum wage. This is wrong, because not all costs will rise proportionally to the minimum wage in general There is more to the costs of living than a rent
- TomGullen 5y agoIncrease in minimum wage should improve the quality of life for those on minimum wage - I wouldn't expect many minimum wage earning families to have substantial savings but it's irrelevant, we shouldn't let the imperfect be the enemy of the good
- ctdonath 5y agoMinimum wage: if you can't produce enough, you're not allowed to produce at all.
- notch656a 5y agoNo no no, you see it's merely a winner take all where there are far fewer buyers willing to buy from the lower earning producers. Those who can't produce enough can engage in hunger games for a coveted minimum wage paying position, and the rest can work as 1099s and be 'liberated self-employed business owners' minus a hefty 15% cut from uberslave.com
- mhh__ 5y agoSo these threads usually have a kind of friedman-esque approach to this question: Minimum wage laws stop people earning at all if they're worth less than the minimum wage. Maybe this is true for many small businesses, but what proportion of low wage employees in America are working for companies with whom their employees at such pay have basically no negotiating power? It's all well and good making these often glib approaches to policy, but if we know anything about economics it's that prose does not beat evidence when it comes to seeing what actually works.
- Ekaros 5y agoMaybe we should make it work other direction. You can't pay less than 90% of value worker produces.
- onesafari 5y agoPlease, someone introduce Sam to the economist Thomas Sowell.
- BMc2020 5y agoWe don't need Thomas to tell us the minimum wage has gone down, but if you want.
- timcavel 5y ago
- TomGullen 5y agoDepressing to see so much vitriol in here for an idea to improve living standards for people who earn less. The argument that cost of living will somehow increase in linear proportional lockstep with minimum wage increases is nonsense. Abolishing minimum wage opens the door for horrendous exploitation of people, the labour in the market are not perfect rational actors and businesses will exploit this where possible. A liveable baseline is really important. We are mostly all commenting from the privilege of skilled labour and all the freedoms and benefits that come with that.
- ceeplusplus 5y agoRent prices in the Bay Area, Seattle, LA, NYC, and other high minimum wage cities beg to differ. As a percentage of monthly minimum wage earnings I'd bet rent comes out as higher in high minimum wage cities than low wage cities.
- stormbrew 5y agoNow control for median wage (which is pretty much completely unaffected by a $5-10 spread of minimum wage but is drastically affected by high wage earners) and land use policies, see if the correlation holds.
- lesuorac 5y agoAn x% increase in minimum wage is correlated with an <x% inflation [1]. This is also trivial to show as the cost of a good is rarely majority labor (even trucking is majority diesel) so if a $9 shipment is $1 profit, $4 gas, $2 labor, $2 depreciation a 10% increase in labor (to $2.2) only moves the overall cost to $9.2 is a 2% increase. But even if a good was majority labor, a total cost of $9 with $8 labor becomes $9.8 which is still less than 10%. Obviously also goods produced by labor above the minimum wage (ex. plumbers) isn't affected by a change in the minimum wage. [1]: https://ftp.iza.org/dp1072.pdf https://ftp.iza.org/dp1072.pdf
- somethoughts 5y agoIts been my tangential and perhaps unpopular observation that in high COL areas where there's a high minimum wage/high salaries - there's an increasing benefit to RV/apartment arbitrage. Basically take benefits of the high minimum wage that was meant to address housing costs/RV camping but live in an RV/couch surf/double up a single family during the week anyways. There are stories/Youtube videos of of techies living the RV life or multiple roommates to benefit from this arbitrage. To be honest if you are single maybe the tradeoffs aren't that bad. Also there's also these challenges apply to "self-employed contractors" as well. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/may/07/the-uber-drivers-forced-to-sleep-in-parking-lots-to-make-a-decent-living https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/may/07/the-uber-...
- dredmorbius 5y agohttps://nitter.kavin.rocks/sama/status/1521939982662836225 https://nitter.kavin.rocks/sama/status/1521939982662836225
- simonsarris 5y agoWe should have a $0 minimum wage, but the arguments for it are not nearly as straightforward or compact. But they are, I think, much more humanitarian than people trying to fiddle with where to cut-off work. I will try to put them as compactly as possible with a few counter-example questions. What if a 16 year old wants to partly make money, partly learn the ropes of some job, and some place could use "some" help but not get meaningfully enough work to pay a kid [$X min wage]? Right now, these kids and businesses are out of luck. This would make them even more worse off. What if a 60 year old is feeling lonely and wants to be a greeter or lecter or something helpful, and they need this meaning and sociability more than they need money, but it is not worth [$X min wage] for 99% of places to have such a job? Right now, these old folk and businesses are out of luck. The sheer amount of work you exclude when you require all jobs to be [minmimum | livable | comfortable] is huge. Just enormous. Not everyone is trying to strike it out on their own. Some people want to help in small ways and are fine with commensurate pay. Why force these jobs out of existence? Are you sure doing so is solving the problem you want to solve, while creating no others? Why do people think money is the only operative thing here, or the only one ever possible, for all possible jobs for all possible people? It suggests a lack of imagination that I find a little frightening. I have written about this in a very circumspect way in a few places before, because I think people have trouble with the straightforward argument. One of them got popular here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27695181 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27695181
- Pelerin 5y agoI don't understand how those situations you mentioned should be given high priority given the number of people who are being paid poverty-level wages currently. I'll grant there is a high count of counter-examples, but the number of potential employees that match those counter-examples feels quite low.
- csomar 5y agoYou are trying to build your arguments with particular cases. It's more fundamental than that in my opinion: Freedom, necessitates, that people are free to chose how much they sell their labor for. Now if you care for fairness, you should look that people are paid fairly in proportion to how much wealth they have generated for the business. That's obviously something people like Sam Altman wouldn't want you to think: That means tech businesses would have to share their bounty with software developers (and other employees) relatively to how much they contributed. The bounty share should remain for the lifetime of the company. Obviously, no one in the leadership of the tech industry will want to entertain that. They would rather focus on hospitality businesses and businesses they have no business in.
- phkahler 5y agoLet's just raise interest rates a bunch, cut out the QE, promise not to overuse borrowing, and see where things settle.
- orbit7 5y agoI think tax cuts exempting those on minimum wage would be a better approach since it would otherwise cause job losses, some businesses would not survive.
- betwixthewires 5y agoRight now in the US, the bottom limit on federal withholdings and filing a return is around 12k per year. If you make less than that, you don't pay income tax. That needs to be doubled at least. A big chunk of lower tier earners get all or most of their withholdings back and pay 0 tax, of course after an interest free loan to the treasury. Some of them even get money back for having kids and things, effectively a negative income tax. Those thresholds should probably rise as well. All in all I don't think most people should be paying an income tax at all.
- rs999gti 5y agoDoes that means all other pay gets to inflate as well? For example nurses, depending on education, license, and experience, can make 20-60 USD/hour. If the min wage is 25/hour for no education and no experience jobs, surely an even wage increase across the board is fair? So that now nurses make 30/hour USD starting wage and all other jobs and careers receive similar increases?
- commandlinefan 5y agoNope, pretty sure it means everybody else will suddenly make the same… which will be worth a lot less when the price increases that are necessary to sustain this astronomical minimum wage kick in.
- csomar 5y agoI remember, something...something, before this Quantitative Easing round that "Printing money" or "easing liquidity" wouldn't affect inflation. That was the basis of much of these Pandemic packages where the government pushed money to businesses and people. Well, that turned out really wrong didn't it. Of course, the politicians blamed the pandemic logistics, the war, the ..., but anything but their strategy. I wonder who Altman is looking for to blame when an $25/hour minimum wage turns out disastrous for everyone involved. Of course, that would be anything but his genius idea. There is one thing true (at least in the long-term) about economy: You can't bullshit your way around the economy by manipulating numbers. A $25/hour minimum wage doesn't build more homes, doesn't create a new metro line, doesn't improve shipping logistics, doesn't increase the literacy rate, doesn't build a hospital and doesn't teach a doctor.
- paxys 5y agoMinimum wage increases aren't going to be funded by printing more money but rather through corporate profits. How would that cause inflation?
- Ekaros 5y agoIncreased demand of things the current minimum wage workers can't afford? Thus increasing price of them and thus affecting inflation. On other hand most of that if not more due to chain effects would go to increasing GDP...
- culopatin 5y agoMinimum wage increases are going to be washed away by the immediate inflation generated by the massive jump in buying power on the demand side and by the inflation generated by the increase in supply costs caused by the increase in wages. Not to mention many companies would probably move more of their operations to other countries and just sell their stuff online and not have to hire anyone here.
- betwixthewires 5y agoI guess $15 an hour is old hat now that they're paying that at the burger joint down the street to high school kids as a result of market forces. I wonder how many comments supporting the idea in this thread would still call it reasonable if the tweet said $50. Probably about the same number as people calling the "how high is too high" arguments fallacious.
- deadbolt 5y ago$15/hour goes less far than is did when the $15/hour movement started. I'm sure you understand that.
- betwixthewires 5y agoI do, that's why market wages went up like they did, no government intervention required.
- chung8123 5y agoDon't we need to define what livable is first? Sharing a studio apartment in NY is livable but in a smaller town is inhumane. It seems weird that we don't have a minimum bar for what we define as livable.
- dgeiser13 5y agoWhy is sharing a studio apartment regardless of where you live inhumane?
- jnwatson 5y agoInstead of an invisible tax on low-skilled-labor intensive industries, we should advocate for UBI. It directly provides for folks, regardless of whether they can hold a job.
- ta8645 5y agoThese are the types of ideas that the new DHS department of misinformation will be able to suppress. Stopping the spread of ill-conceived economic ideas by non-experts will help to keep society safe and stable.
- binarynate 5y agoMinimum wages should be set at the state level, not the federal level. $25 in California is much different than $25 in Puerto Rico.
- paxys 5y agoIt already is. The federal one is a floor which applies to the whole country. A state can increase it for themselves, and a city can increase it even further.
- binarynate 5y agoWhat I'm saying is that that there shouldn't be a federal floor of $25 because the relative value of $25 differs depending on location. For example, a federally mandated minimum wage of $25 might preclude Puerto Rico from becoming a state because that doesn't make economic sense for them. I live in Indiana, and I would argue that a floor of $25 is too high here, too.
- paxys 5y agoIs there a number below which you cannot survive anywhere in the county? That should be the federal floor. It could be $25 or something else, but that number does exist.
- binarynate 5y agoFor reference, $25 * 40 * 52 = $52,000 per year. The minimum wage you're describing is much lower.
- paxys 5y agoPeople don't get that they are subsidizing low wages through food stamps, affordable housing initiatives and a plethora of other social safety programs. Every dollar you put into these programs is a dollar saved by large corporations who pay poverty wages to full time workers. Increasing the minimum wage is the easiest way to end these corporate handouts.
- solenoidalslide 5y agoDo you really think welfare and other social services would go away (in the near future)? Seems like political suicide.
- paxys 5y agoWhy do they need to go away? If you earn below $X, you get food stamps and subsidized rent. Increasing the minimum wage means more people earn above $X, so the dependence on these programs decreases. Social services still need to exist, but when you have Walmart holding sessions teaching their employees on how to make use of them, it is clear that the system isn't working as intended.
- chii 5y agoif the low wage earner currently uses subsidies like food stamps, and raising the minimum wage causes those subsidies to become out of reach, then the low wage earner would make a calculation and see if the lost subsidies are higher than the gained minimum wage. If more subsidies are lost, they are worse off, and thus, would rather stop working and get the maximum subsidies instead. If minimum wage raise is higher than the subsidies lost, the cost of subsidies is "saved" by the taxpayer. but the businesses paying those wages might not want to pay more, so they might decrease number of jobs as a response. Therefore, you'd end up with more unemployed as a side effect. Neither is a good outcome imho.
- dns_snek 5y ago> Neither is a good outcome imho. Subsidizing people who are out of work while all employees earn a livable wage is a categorically better outcome than having to subsidize everyone, employed or not, just because companies don't feel like paying a livable wage. > If more subsidies are lost, they are worse off, and thus, would rather stop working and get the maximum subsidies instead. This is an easily preventable issue that can be avoided by phasing out the subsidies instead of setting a hard cut-off.
- macinjosh 5y ago
- moth-fuzz 5y agoMy argument for minimum wage has always been a philosophical one - human life and human labor has intrinsic value and any company's bill of materials ought to include labor. The 'market price' of a human life is, say, rent and food and medical bills (grossly oversimplified but the philosophical point is the same). Anything less than that is an undersell, equivalent to selling a food for less than the cost of farming it, or selling a device for less than the manufacturing cost. I.e. nonsense in the general case. Companies have been allowed to undercut worker's value for centuries under the threat of homelessness and starvation. That's not a free market. That's robbery. Companies are the only entities we allow to just take, setting their own prices, without quarrel, because laborers don't have bargaining power when selling their labor. Hell, the interview process should be proof enough of that. Oppositionally, I believe in human dignity - I think a worker should be able to bargain. Frankly, since us regular people can't just go up to the store and say "well, I don't wanna pay full price for this item, so I'll just pay less for it - what're you gonna do about it anyway?" (we'd get arrested) I don't think a company should be able to either. When you frame it in terms of an open market, the current labor situation sounds obviously and patently absurd.
- codeguro 5y agoI fundamentally disagree with your premise. Your rhetoric mimics that of a socialist. I'll tear apart your philosophical rhetoric one part at a time. > human life and human labor has intrinsic value and any company's bill of materials ought to include labor. Human life has intrinsic value, it could be argued from a moral standpoint, but human labor does not. What matters is what that labor is used for. I could have you spend all day making mud pies. That does not mean your labor is worth anything. The only thing that can determine the true value of your labor is what someone else is willing to pay for i.e. the market. > Companies have been allowed to undercut worker's value for centuries under the threat of homelessness and starvation. More people than ever before have been lifted out of homelessness and serfdom because of the free market. Companies working under a free market is a pretty new and novel idea. > Companies are the only entities we allow to just take, setting their own prices, without quarrel This is wrong on several takes. First and foremost, you're implying that workers in general should have the ability to unilaterally determine the value of their own labor a market. This is in direct conflict with the realities of the free market i.e. spending all day making mud pies. You can moan and groan all you want, but yes, if all your work requires is the basic use of your prefrontal cortex, your labor is less valuable than if you were a doctor. That's not the fault of the employer. > Oppositionally, I believe in human dignity - I think a worker should be able to bargain. They DO have the ability to bargain. Their ability to walk away is one of their most powerful things they can do. If you truly believe you're getting a raw deal and that your labor is worth more than whatever compensation company X is offering, then you should simply walk away and apply for company Y. In a free market, the role of the buyers and sellers are inverted because it is the companies that are the buyers; specifically they buy the commodities that are your labor. And this is not even touching on the basic principles of supply and demand in context to minimum wage. The fact of the matter is, a minimum wage does not lift people out of poverty - it removes rungs from the bottom half of the ladder. Precious rungs to low skilled employees that use them to climb up out of poverty. Companies will not just eat the cost - they do not want to go out of business. They make a cost-benefit analysis and compensate for this minimum wage by firing their low-performing staff to make the remaining higher-performer workers work overtime. Now it's harder for new people with little job experience to find employment. Congratulations - you've just hurt the very people you've intended to protect. And this isn't even touching on the impact of dead weight loss caused by minimum wage. You need to study the basic concepts of microeconomics before formulating your philosophical principles, because as of right now, I can tell you that they are a little insane.
- morninglight 5y agoYou are looking in the wrong direction. The "working poor" will not benefit from your bread crumbs. Start by reducing the wealth of the top 40% and THEN it will trickle down naturally. Nobody will help the poor when they think the funds come from their pocket. Help the "working poor" by destroying the obscenely wealthy. And good luck with that, pilgrim. .
- chii 5y agowhy do you need to destroy the wealthy to help the poor? the world isn't a zero sum game. Why not enable the poor to produce more wealth, by up-skilling and by making entrepreneurship easier and less risky? A poor person today is trapped in a job they cannot afford to leave for education/up-skilling. A poor person today cannot start a new business because they cannot afford the capital nor the risk. If instead of a higher minimum wage, you could have a program where a poor person could apply for funds to either up-skill via some sort of education program at an institution, or a loan for a new business, they would probably do much better than raising the minimum wage.
- bradlys 5y agoWhy does everyone need to be an entrepreneur? Why can’t people be a janitor or working the front desk and have a reasonable standard of living?
- deadbolt 5y agoFurther, we'll still need janitors. No matter how many new companies these new entrepreneurs create, we still need people to keep the workplace tidy. Sure, we could all take part in cleaning, but I don't think that's what chii has in mind.
- chii 5y agobut in this case, the value of janitorial services will increase, as there will be fewer and fewer people doing it. Thus, at some point, the balance would be reached where someone would choose janitorial work again. The point of the grandparent post was saying that there should be a blanket raise in minimum wages. I'm saying that there shouldn't be, but that more lucrative opportunities are created instead such as up-skilling into higher paying work, or entrepreneurship (which entails taking a risk, so the state assumes a small amount of that risk for the low income earner to do it). This naturally increases the competition, and then the true value of low-paid work will become apparent.
- foogazi 5y agoThis assumes people have no agency and are unable to choose a better option for themselves Like preventing who can take an Uber gig job in CA
- medvezhenok 5y agoI believe that Universal Job guarantee (via a Federal Program - which doesn’t enforce a minimum wage but gives an alternative and sets a defacto floor on the price of labor - akin to the one done post Depression or WWII) or UBI are better than minimum wage laws, but minimum wage seems to be more politically palatable.
- chii 5y agoA job for a job's sake is worse than just giving the money as part of social security or something. The such a job being done must create value, or it just becomes punishment for being unemployed!
- oliwarner 5y agoMaybe. Even a job that doesn't generate saleable value can give someone experience, teach them technical and social skills that have real-world application.
- chii 5y agoYes, but that's why it's called education and training, not a job. And i am for making education and training possible or subsidized somehow.
- jimmydeans 5y agoBetter yet. $50
- virgildotcodes 5y agoSo many commenters here are taking it for granted that an increased minimum wage invariably leads to increased unemployment and inflation. It looks like empirical data doesn't really bear that out. >It appears that if negative effects on employment are present, they are too small to be statistically detectable. Such effects would be too modest to have meaningful consequences in the dynamically changing labor markets of the United States. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/279170454_The_New_Minimum_Wage_Research https://www.researchgate.net/publication/279170454_The_New_M... >wage-price elasticities are notably lower than reported in previous work: we find prices grow by 0.36 percent for every 10 percent increase in the minimum wage. https://research.upjohn.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=&httpsredir=1&article=1278&context=up_workingpapers https://research.upjohn.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=&htt... (Paraphrased) >A $10 minimum—According to the CBO's projections, the $10 minimum wage would raise earnings for up to 3.5 million workers and "have virtually no effect on employment." Nor would it have an appreciable impact on the number of people in poverty. >A $12 minimum—The $12 minimum wage would benefit up to 11 million workers while reducing overall employment by an estimated 300,000 jobs. The number of people whose annual incomes fell below the poverty threshold in 2025 would be reduced by 400,000. >A $15 minimum—Finally, the $15 minimum wage would benefit up to 27 million workers but cost an estimated 1.3 million jobs. At the same time, a similar number of people (1.3 million) would see their annual incomes rise above the poverty threshold. https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-07/CBO-55410-MinimumWage2019.pdf https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-07/CBO-55410-MinimumWa...
- xtiansimon 5y agoI’m thinking if you get a $25 minimum wage, I’m asking if that’s enough to now buy a home? If not, then whatever gain you make in wage will get gobbled by your landlord.
- felipelemos 5y agoFor all of you that are complaining that people will prefer to stop working to earn less but retains walfare and social services (which I don't think they will): why aren't you are doing the same?
- kbelder 5y agoAs the old saying goes: Republicans can't do science. Democrats can't do math. The second point is relevant in this thread.
- splistud 5y ago
- EndWarOnDrugs 5y agoYou shouldn't have to work 3jobs just to get by. I don't care what you do, working 1 full time job should be enough. If that makes me a socialist, then yeah OK.... I used to think John Lennon's 'Imagine' was such a scary thing, funny how now at 40 I think it is anything but scary.. Oh and it doesn't matter what minimum wage is, they need to start a maximum cost, minimum wage just raises the cost of everything else.... It's all an illusion, we are owned, and they got us right where they want us... Lol but hey, let's keep fighting and arguing with each other. As if there is a difference between republicans and democrats..... "Gold jacket, Green jacket, who gives a shit?"
- EndWarOnDrugs 5y agoWe spend 700 trillion on war every year.... Nobody says nothing.... Yet we argue over minimum wage? God bless america.. We should be ending hunger, we should be ending homelessness... But that's not the American way. "Land of the free.. Whoever told you that, is your enemy."
- churchill 5y ago
- culopatin 5y agoInstead let’s try to generate enough worker demand that this happens naturally.
- black_13 5y ago
- Proven 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DeadMouseFive 5y agoIf minimum wage is a problem for you, stop tracking time and move to fixed prices for labor based on piece work or milestones. The idea we all need to be working a factory 9-5 style job is Taylorism nonsense that is at least a century out of date. Hours don't matter. Output matters.