16 ms·
Mullvad VPN now accepts Monero payments
- usednet 5y agoI’m curious as to what HN’s VPNs of choice are. I personally use IVPN and Mullvad.
- bennyp101 5y agoI just connect back to my router. I don’t have a “hide from websites” need, but a “don’t trust public internet” need.
- notRobot 5y agoMullvad for me. I'm very happy with their offering.
- ravenstine 5y agoProtonVPN because I already have a Protonmail account and they don't sponsor podcasts (as far as I know).
- capableweb 5y agoMaybe I'm missing something, but why is "not sponsoring podcasts" a plus for a VPN service? Personally Mullvad is my favorite and AFAIK, they also don't sponsor any podcasts, but I don't think that would influence how I feel about Mullvad.
- flaviut 5y agoThe VPN industry is generally pretty shady & tries to sell users services that do them no or even negative good by making silly claims. When a service isn't being honest in their advertising, it makes you think about what else they're being dishonest about.
- capableweb 5y agoThat's more about what's in their marketing material ("when a service isn't being honest in their advertising") rather than where they actually put that marketing material. And yeah, then I'd agree, if Mullvad started lying or pushing useless services down my throat, I'd definitely dump it quickly.
- brewdad 5y agoI used Mullvad for a few years and was largely happy with it. I got a multi-year deal on ProtonVPN that was too good to pass up, so now I'm on that. Overall, I think I liked Mullvad better so may go back to it when my time is up. I used NordVPN back quite a few years ago. Once they started advertising on cable tv shows, I knew it was time to jump ship. A VPN service spending that kind of money is either burning through cash too quickly to survive, selling user data, or a government honeypot.
- ipaddr 5y agoIt shows scale and also makes them a bigger target for lawsuit which get's settled through access. Check out what vpn have been sued over the last year (they all have been no log companies) and you will quickly realize that logs are being shared by anyone of size. The smaller the service the better.
- Liquid_Fire 5y agoI'm also not sure why sponsoring podcasts is relevant, but FWIW I have heard ads for ProtonVPN on the Darknet Diaries podcast (https://darknetdiaries.com/sponsors/ https://darknetdiaries.com/sponsors/).
- ravenstine 5y agoIt affects my decision making because the stuff that gets plastered across podcasts and YouTube videos is often crap the hosts themselves clearly haven't even used. Just my opinion based on the times I've actually researched the products I've seen sponsoring content. YMMV
- hda2 5y ago> and they don't sponsor podcasts I do this as well! Annoy me with to much ads and I'll avoid you and your product out of spite.
- jermaustin1 5y agoMy own digital ocean droplet. Its easy to set up and get going, costs only $5/mo, and with all of my other droplets bandwidths combined I effectively have unlimited bandwidth. Only ever use it on public wifi, and it isn't meant to be "private", just good enough to prevent accidental data leakage at Starbucks/doctors' offices/wherever else my 5g doesn't reach and I'm forced onto public WiFi.
- tomxor 5y agoI used to do this, and it's nice having your own IP, however keep in mind that while you preserve privacy from your ISP/gov you lose privacy from the websites and services you access as you become very uniquely identifiable.
- jermaustin1 5y agoYeah I'm less worried about trackers (block those with uOrigin and AdGuard), and just more worried about data leaks on public wifi which are less and less likely with everything being on SSL now, but until everything is FORCED onto SSL then I will still run my own VPN when I'm on public.
- tomxor 5y agoNote that those are client side. Nothing can stop a server from seeing your IP.
- 0des 5y agoNice try officer, just AOL for me thanks ;)
- jmuguy 5y agoHello fellow youth, I sure do like loitering. Let's talk about our favorite spots around town to loiter with our friends.
- McDyver 5y agoAirVPN You can use openvpn or wireguard as clients (or their own), and while i was writing this I just saw they accept payments with different crypto (bitcoin, ethereum, litecoin, bitcoin cash, dash, doge, monero)
- capableweb 5y agoSame as Mullvad. Personally, the greatest feature of Mullvad is that they accept cash sent in envelopes, it doesn't get more (proven) private than that. Does AirVPN offer something similar?
- McDyver 5y agoI couldn't find that option, so I'd say no
- dotnet00 5y agoSame. The other big point in AirVPN's favor is configurable port forwarding. Makes it much easier to quickly expose something to the internet on any network.
- makeworld 5y agohttps://www.privacytools.io/#vpn https://www.privacytools.io/#vpn
- mirceal 5y agoMullvad FTW! I've tried basically all VPNs out there and Mullvad and Proton were (at the time I did the experiment) the only ones that were 1) trustworthy 2) just worked
- octatrack 5y agoI recently discovered IVPN and really like it. It's my preferred VPN. Previously, I've used NordVPN and ProtonVPN.
- searchableguy 5y agoFor Indians, mullvad and others will not be available soon. New order require mandatory logging and storage of customer details for 5 years for digital infra providers post June. https://entrackr.com/2022/04/it-ministry-orders-vpn-providers-crypto-players-to-store-user-data-for-five-years/ https://entrackr.com/2022/04/it-ministry-orders-vpn-provider...
- atypeoferror 5y agoI wonder how they plan to impose compliance on entities that have no legal presence in India, accept cryptocurrency payments, and take no PII as part of the signup process - all of which I believe apply to Mullvad.
- searchableguy 5y agoThey are gonna ban self custodial wallet which are rare in India anyway. So exchange will monitor and KYC anyone you transfer crypto coins to. Impose a penalty on the citizen side as well.
- 0des 5y agoIts either a custodial wallet, like an exchange, or a wallet for yourself like keys you generate and hold on your own. The latter is fine
- nvrspyx 5y agoIf you're able to exchange rupee for another currency, you can always mail the cash to them. I admittedly don't know how feasible or how difficult that is to do though.
- fs111 5y agoMullvad accepts cash via mail
- dotnet00 5y agoMonero users are more likely to be the type to use a cold wallet, and a ban on cold wallets is unenforceable (especially for Monero, where transactions can't be traced) as it's kind of like holding cash, except that there isn't anything to be found physically.
- throwaway4good 5y ago
- 0des 5y agoMost of us wear a trenchcoat and moustache glasses
- CommieBobDole 5y agoI'm a clipart hacker, so I wear a hoodie and sunglasses. Indoors, in the dark.
- tomxor 5y agoYou should also wallpaper your room with green binary glyphs
- nonrandomstring 5y agoI find thick black leather gloves really help with my typing too.
- hall0ween 5y agoTor at least but there’s likely more. also rumor in the internet goes (and looking to be correct if misguided) the us government identifies its citizens that dl Tor
- vmception 5y agothey cant see what you do on tor you can still take flights, get mortgages, enter and leave the country after being on the imaginary or actual list, so why do so many people care?
- irl_ 5y agoThat's nonsense. There are somewhere between 2 and 8 million users of Tor every day. The vast majority of Tor users are ordinary people that want a little more privacy. What a waste of resources it would be to try to identify and track each of them.
- 0des 5y agoIts too bad monero research lab seems to be slowing down and disbanding. Devs have to eat and all, but I wonder sometimes if a longer and slower emission curve would have helped here. Monero is mostly emitted at this point. For a project that means so much to the world and still has much work to do, its a shame how things turned out with MRL.
- vmception 5y agoWhy is that bad? it’s done people deciding if they want excess holdings of Monero shouldnt base their confidence on a standing committee
- 0des 5y agoIt is not a standing committee, it was community funded research that produced privacy technology. "It" is never done.
- vmception 5y agoTornado cash is good enough tbh Monero communities arrogance and in-grouping has segregated them just like they desired. That technology and user experience is an evolutionary dead end, it can exist and that has enough utility. But in the multichain world the user experience is better and the funding models are better, even gitcoin grants streamline development of projects.
- 0des 5y agoRespectfully I disagree with this statement, on a conceptual, as well as factual level. >Tornado cash is good enough tbh I hold neither of these, but as someone with a significant amount of experience in the field, the facts are clear. "Good enough" is not an objective measurement of the binary quality of fungibility. Monero is fungible. Is this me saying everyone should go out and buy some Monero, no, it is me saying that when you consider the mechanics of the way these two scantly comparable technologies function, there is one clear winner because only one is fungible. I don't have a response to the social issues of those that use or perpetuate Monero adoption, just as I don't have a response to the social issues of those that use or perpetuate USD, or any other asset. It's not my business what other people do, and I don't feel associated by virtue of using the same utility. > That technology [ ... ] is an evolutionary dead end This will need a source.
- _8j50 5y agoI gotta say, I love Monero but every single time I see malware deploy a miner it is Monero for obvious reasons. More than any currency I want it to succeed because of true anonymity it provides but when you accept Monero, better beef up your anti-abuse capacity.
- Grimburger 5y agoIt feels wrong going in defending them here but basically nothing else on the planet is CPU mine-able anymore, RandomX was made specifically to exclude GPU's and ASIC's. If you had intrusions on GPU servers it would be a very different story.
- _8j50 5y agoI can't tell you why they compromise thousands of docker containers,vms and even run of the mill malware drops xmr miners with winring0.sys on windows to run at ring0
- Kiro 5y ago> for obvious reasons You might think it's because it's private and confidential but it's actually because it's suited for CPU mining.
- _8j50 5y agoEither way it is very difficult to find the owner of an XMR "wallet"
- kylebenzle 5y ago
- stavros 5y agoWhat kind of abuse could I be subjected to if I accept Monero? Seems like the most that could happen is that people can send me money.
- 5y ago
- vmception 5y agoJust as a reminder, you can bridge from EVMs to Monero via the SECRET bridges, which seems to have the Monero community's blessings on consensus models. There is ample liquidity as well. So there is bi-directional access to and from the broader crypto ecosystem without centralized exchanges and without the selectively scamming shapeshift-style sites, and for the pros: without OTC desks either.
- trompetenaccoun 5y agoWell Secret isn't exactly the broader ecosystem, it uses the EVM (as most smart contract platforms do these days) but isn't Ethereum Mainnet. So you'd have to bridge more from there. Of course you could bridge into Ethereum or other chains directly with something like WXMR as well. Everything is getting bridged these days, there's going to be 1000 bridges soon. Users should be aware of the risks! That said Secret is interesting. Another thing to note though in terms of privacy is that Secret token transactions aren't anonymous afaik, despite the name suggesting otherwise. Only the smart contracts are. It's an interesting design choice, there are probably arguments pro and contra both.
- vmception 5y agoI didn't feel the need to specify how many bridges you had to take, just that you can have XMR and get to the broader ecosystem via SECRET. That is 100% accurate and orders of magnitude better than before the SECRET bridges existed. Correct, yes, on SECRET network, smart contract variables are private, which means all token transactions are while the native currency is not. There are a variety of ways to leak data anyway. So SCRT is the native currency while sSCRT is the token version that therefore has the variables (to, from, amount) private. sXMR is the token version of XMR there.
- easrng 5y agoWXMR is not real bridge, it's effectively a pegged token. Secret Network bridges are custodial. Atomic swaps would be better.
- 5y ago
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoAs a Mullvad fan this makes me very nervous. If they begin being used by, and taking payment from criminals it's going to bring a lot of extra heat their way.
- my69thaccount 5y agoMight be a little late for that bro
- cinntaile 5y agoThey already take anonymous cash payments. They can't tell if that's legal or illegal money there either.
- tmikaeld 5y agoIt rather shows that they protect the user from mullvad itself being a privacy leak, which shows that they stand by their principles.
- _joel 5y agoYou can literally send them an envelope of cash anonymously, how is this any different?
- seanw444 5y agoBecause Monero is the scary bad-guy coin, of course.
- throwaway4good 5y agoReally? I guess running a VPN is a profitable business ...
- seanw444 5y agoThey've been requiring zero identification from the beginning. That's been their business model. They don't know if you're a criminal, or a law-abiding citizen. And they intended it that way. That's how it should be.
- seanw444 5y agoThank you, Mullvad team! This is quite literally the only feature I've been wanting. Everything else works well. Bandwidth? Excellent. Apps? Excellent. WireGuard? Excellent. No form of KYC required, period? Excellent. Payment options? Excellent. I hope I don't live to see you turn into every other shady VPN service.
- tomxor 5y agoI really like mullvad's service too (wiregaurd)... My only issue is that is seems to have become increasingly difficult to access many websites through their servers. I suppose this is inevitable to some degree with any VPN service, it's part of the deal for more privacy, you have to share an IP with potential sources of abuse. But it seems to have gotten really bad recently to the point that I end up server hoping throughout the day because different websites will have blocked different mullvad servers - to complicate matters some of their newer server IPs hosted by another company are misidentified as russian and blocked by many sites and services. I'm not blaming Mullvad, but it's changed my use of their service from a set and forget to a constant reminder that i'm on a VPN... I don't know what the solution is beyond some crude cycling of IPs.
- nonrandomstring 5y ago> My only issue is that is seems to have become increasingly difficult to access many websites through their servers. Welcome to the world of Tor users. People who value online dignity need to work together against privacy hostile web technologies. My present bugbear is Cloudflare, who seem to do a lot to disrupt privacy respecting technologies. Ultimately though, the power lies with web service designers. One can no longer pretend "I didn't know" when turning over delivery to some cheap (free) but shady CDN who then blocks millions of legitimate users because they don't want to be tracked and spied on.
- shiftpgdn 5y agoThe flip side to this is to have your site hammered by bots, scrapers and worms looking for exploits (look at your weblogs sometime and see how often Wordpress php pages are requested, lol). I don’t know what the middle ground is but in spirit I agree with you, especially in keeping the internet decentralized. In practice I’m not so sure.
- andreisbc 5y agoMullvad always seemed too good to be true. So that's why i'd won't use it if i'd had critical stuff to do. I do love Mullvad, but so aircrack-ng
- kfreds 5y agoThank you for the compliment! We are indeed for real, but I don't expect this comment will convince you. I'd love to know what we could do that would change your mind. The same goes for anyone else reading this. Are you worried that we are too good to be true? What could we do to become more trustworthy in your eyes? Cheers, Fredrik Stromberg (cofounder of Mullvad)
- Fritsdehacker 5y agoI don't know. Disclaimer: just a happy customer. What I do know is that all you know about me is the account number you gave me and the IP address I'm connecting from. I always pay cash, so that would be hard to trace back. So I know you do the absolute maximum you can do to know as little about me as possible. As far as not keeping logs and not spying on me, I suppose I'll have to trust the audit reports. Not much more you can do in my opinion. It's definitely good enough for me! Thanks for this great service!
- kfreds 5y ago> Not much more you can do in my opinion. It's definitely good enough for me! Thanks for this great service! Thank you. I happen to think there's a lot more we can do. Look forward to future blog posts. :)
- __turbobrew__ 5y agoMy only feedback is that Mullvad is based out of Sweden which is a member of Fourteen Eyes. I don’t expect you to move your location but it is the only detractor I can think of.
- kfreds 5y ago
- nuclx 5y agoWhat are people using VPNs for mostly, if they're living in a country without internet censorship? It's either your ISP or the VPN provider, which can log the websites you have visited, so there isn't a clear advantage of using a VPN. Sure the VPN provider may claim to log nothing, but that's hard to confirm and not proven to be true in some cases (related thread regarding Protonmail: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28443449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28443449). For researching confidential topics, TOR appears to be fine. VPN may have better network bandwidth, or may be blocked from less websites than TOR exit nodes I guess.
- leodriesch 5y agoTorrenting comes to mind. Also if you trust the VPN provider more than your ISP or VPN provider has essentially no PII of you (in case of Mullvad).
- flatiron 5y agoThis is what I use mine for. If PIA is secretly logging they aren’t going to reveal that info and ruin their business model for whatever you call a DMCA request in Canada regarding my torrent activities.
- V1ndaar 5y agoFor me one big use case: avoiding stupid geoblocks on motorsport streams. Often streams are available in countries where the licence has not been sold on Youtube or the websites of the sport itself (sometimes for free, sometimes as a subscription). For example Formula 1 has F1TV that you can only sign up for in some countries (where they didn't sell out to Sky essentially). Like, I don't even mind paying for a service if it's good and actually available!
- InCityDreams 5y agoSent a link (yt, less than a couple of minutes long) to two friends (in different, and not my, countries). Both blocked. One friend changed location via vpn and watched the video. The other, no vpn, didn't see the video AND said they wouldn't ever use a vpn as they have 'nothing to hide'.
- throwaway4good 5y agoMany years ago I worked for a telco that had a mobile product that you could buy with cash (show up in a convenience store with cash and you would get a SIM card for use straight away without any form of registration). This was 5 times as expensive compared to when you paid by debit or credit card. This offering was extremely popular amongst drug dealers and people needing a burner to call in a bomb threat. (Maybe there were legislate uses too - I never found out.) The problem for the telco was that this was generating hundred fold the number of request for wire tapping and logging by the courts and the police. And by law the telco was required to service these request free of charge. So in the end the business simply wasn’t there even though the margins were sky high. Moral of the story: selling stuff to criminals might seem like easy money but may not be worth the trouble.
- Etheryte 5y agoInteresting story, but how does this relate to Mullvad accepting Monero payments?
- throwaway82652 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monero#Illicit_use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monero#Illicit_use
- throwaway4good 5y agoMy guess is that the level of abuse is much higher by the customers paying via monero, than the ones paying by card. My guess is also that abuse is not entirely without cost for Mullvad. In other words the cost associated with the extra business that comes via Monero might be higher than the extra money that comes in.
- lordofgibbons 5y ago>Moral of the story: selling stuff to criminals might seem like easy money but may not be worth the trouble. Interesting that you think only criminals want privacy. I use Signal and TLS too, I must be Pablo Escobar's second coming?
- wesapien 5y agoPlease consider shielded Zcash Txs too
- metamuas 5y ago
- praveenhm 5y agoI am mozilla VPN, which uses Mullvad, is there any disadvantage using Mozilla over directly using Mullvad?
- csande17 5y agoIf you use Mozilla's VPN, you have to trust that they won't backdoor their VPN client in order to serve their public policy goals. (Mozilla has taken a lot of public stances against things like "disinformation" and "harassment", which could theoretically motivate them to unmask the hateful trolls who use VPN services!)
- gog 5y agoIt's always interesting to see how often stuff that Mullvad does ends up on HN, even when it's not something new. There are other VPNs out there that were accepting Monero for a long time.
- getcrunk 5y agoThey have alot of goodwill.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoWhy not mention one?
- gog 5y agohide.me for example
- password4321 5y agoWhat is the minimum viable effort required to receive Monero?
- opportune 5y agoIt depends on how security conscious you are. Technically you can route things through remote nodes and thus avoid downloading the blockchain. But the monero community is security conscious and usually recommends downloading the blockchain, which takes a while if you do it the “right” way and don’t just find a copy of it hosted somewhere and download it. If you are ok with skipping that, you can use something like CakeWallet to create a wallet on your phone and then give someone a receiving address
- tiluha 5y agoTo just receive: download the wallet software from getmonero.org and generate a new wallet. The are also multiple point of sale solutions available. To automate payments: run a node and use any of the RPC libraries available for various languages.
- kylebenzle 5y ago
- JASONNOEL 5y ago