10 ms·
Obviously don't know the full context of why Satrajit Chatterjee was fired, but I can say that I followed the Timnit Gebru story quite closely, and there was a
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
Obviously don't know the full context of why Satrajit Chatterjee was fired, but I can say that I followed the Timnit Gebru story quite closely, and there was a gigantic chasm, IMO, between what actually happened (and by "what actually happened" I mean that I'm conservatively just considering Gebru's own statements and tweets) and how things were reported in the wider press.
The press will always be incentivized to report on "big bad Google" and make any termination sound like a David vs. Goliath battle. And, of course, while sometimes that narrative is true, there have been many cases where I've thought "These are some of the most toxic individuals I can imagine (again, by their own statements), and working with them sounds like a nightmare." To emphasize, I'm definitely not saying that's the case in the current example, but I am saying that nobody has enough info one way or the other unless they are more personally familiar with the details. Reactions based on what's written in the article are thus just personal Rorschach tests.
- choppaface 5y agoAnd Google Legal profits the most from turning these cases into “personal Rorschach tests.” In the case of Glasson’s pregnancy discrimination case, she had to wait two years and go through Google-requested health screenings just to reach a settlement. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/apr/09/she-sued-for-pregnancy-discrimination-now-shes-battling-googles-army-of-lawyers https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/apr/09/she-sued-... Google Legal wants these cases to reach settlement or some other point of deterrence because they don’t want the real evidence and merits to enter public discussion. Google not just saves reputation value but also counter-party price discovery. Whenever Corp Legal fires an employee like this, they always ask “will this case blow the budget on severance + litigation this year?” They don’t want anybody else to know what this number is, and it could effectively leak if a case doesn’t get settled. While the linked article may not give many details on the merit of this case, what also is not reported is the realities of large well-funded corporate legal teams.
- TheMagicHorsey 5y agoAgree strongly with you on the Gebru firing. I followed it closely. The Press was pretty dishonest in the way they portrayed it.
- blairdon 5y agohttps://twitter.com/jacobsteinhardt/status/1521599337943289856 https://twitter.com/jacobsteinhardt/status/15215993379432898...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mikkergp 5y agoIn the David vs Goliath battle David is incentivized to do exactly what Google is accusing this researcher of. Put out a controversial finding that supports your beliefs, regardless of whether or not it has been fully vetted. As a David you may not have the resources to fully vet the story anyways, particularly when the vetting process is defined by Goliath. Goliath of course has as an ocean of toxic incentives to maintain the status quo, promote their own Agenda, and Gatekeep David. I understand why researchers want to work at these giant institutions. It's harder to influence the narrative if these giant institutions can operate unhindered. On top of that as you mention the press is incentivized to side with David since it's a more compelling story. It 's part of the challenge of analyzing incentives, and means most people come to conclusions based on their prior beliefs. To come to the right conclusions you have to be able to dig deeper in the story than we have information to do so.
- 21723 5y agoIt sounds like you're alleging that Timnit Gebru (whom I've never met, but who seems like a fine person from what I have read) is "toxic" and that working with her would be "a nightmare" to you. Am I correct in inferring this?
- 21723 5y agoThis'll probably be read by no one, but I want to correct the record... I was trying to set up rhetoric for the argument that TG is not "toxic", because from what I've read, she is not. The downvotes suggest that I was interpreted otherwise, and I'm sorry for this.
- gonehome 5y agoNot OP, but here's an old thread from the last time this came up which is the bit I'm remembering: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25297823 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25297823
- dekhn 5y agoI'd have a hard time working with her because she says that the techbros of silicon valley are eugenicists. timnit's repsonse to https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/04/22/1050394/artificial-intelligence-for-the-people/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/04/22/1050394/artifici... was "this was a beautiful article to read after spending all weekend reading about the modern day eugenics movement underlying much of the whole AGI stuff." She sort of godwins her arguments.
- lupire 5y ago
- Traubenfuchs 5y agoI never expected to read „eugenics“ and „html“ in the same sentence.
- 5y ago
- dehrmann 5y agoI'm surprised news outlets still report that Timnit Gebru was fired. It's at best disputed. This case looks much clearer; he was terminated with cause.
- brimble 5y agoThat's... still a firing, no? What it's not, is a lay-off.
- robonerd 5y agoThe 'he' in "he was terminated with cause" is not referring to Gebru, but rather to Chatterjee. That Chatterjee was fired is seemingly not in dispute, but there was a lot of disagreement on HN over whether Gebru was fired or quit (she offered an ultimatum, which Google accepted.)
- brimble 5y agoAh, OK, sorry, I misunderstood the context.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dekhn 5y agoPeople argued about this a bunch. here's a simple summary that is consistent with the reality: Google (Jeff's docs) says that Timnit offered her resignation (over the paper withdrawl demand and a refusal to let Timnit confront her internal reviewers) and Megan accepted it. In reality, Megan terminated Timnit for cause, but used Timnit's offer to resign against her. At google, resignations are normally triggered by the employee explicitly resigning in a system, but experienced leaders at Google like Megan know how to get around this. I spoke to a wide range of managers at Google afterwards and the most commonly expressed opinion was "I'm amazed that Megan did that, it normally takes at least a year to fire individuals". What Jeff did led to a significant exodus of Google researchers (including some very preeminent ones) and Zoubin has to do all the cleanup.
- canaus 5y agoCan you give some example Tweets to where you concluded that these (Gebru in this example) are some of the most toxic individuals you could imagine? All of my searches are of random topics.
- andromeduck 5y agoThere was a huge divide between r/machinelearning threads and twitter. I'd start with the megathread. https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/k77sxz/d_timnit_gebru_and_google_megathread/ https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/k77sxz/d_t...
- 0des 5y agoCan you be more specific?
- chaps 5y agoHere are supposedly some posts from ex-colleagues of hers: https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/k77sxz/comment/gepq3u8/ https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/k77sxz/com...
- 0des 5y agoThanks for finding that one for me. If true, that does sound like a complicated situation.
- civilized 5y agoI have no strong opinion on Gebru, but... it's so easy for a random person to make a throwaway account on Reddit, and these comments don't have any specific info to suggest they are anything more than that.
- kettleballroll 5y agoAs those comments say, any googler can verify that the mentioned email threads exist. And someone would've spoken up if that was a lie.
- karpierz 5y agoGoogle is free to publish whatever information they'd like to vindicate themselves. The fact that they don't is information. Google is also free to sue for libel/defamation, but for some reason choose not to. This is also information. You can say "well, we don't have the full picture, so we can't draw conclusions", but this will lead to never draw conclusions about the behaviour of anything, as you'll never have a full picture.
- ZanyProgrammer 5y ago
- hintymad 5y agoAnd it's strange no one in media questioned Gebru's paper. For instance, her calculation of carbon footprint of training BERT is ridiculous, as she assumes that companies will train BERT 24x7. I think Gebru is a disgrace to the community because she always, I mean literally always, attacks her critics by motives. You think bias is a data problem? You're a bigot (See her dispute with LeCun). You disagree with my assessment on an ML model? You are white male oppressor (her attacking a Google's SVP). Gebru is not a researcher. She is a modern-age Trofim Lysenko, who politicizes everything and weaponizes political correctness.
- octonion 5y ago
- hintymad 5y agoWhat do you mean by zero-content? I mentioned the paper, her attack on LeCun, and her attack on her co-worker as documented in the reddit megathread. Please feel to verify the facts.
- registeredcorn 5y ago> weaponizes political correctness I'm sorry to be nitpick-y. I understand what you are saying, but to be clear: Political correctness is a weapon. The idea is that there is a correct answer (fact), and a separate, unrelated politically advantageous answer (group approval). Following the tactic of political correctness, to any degree, is using the concept for personal gain. There is no way to be political correct without doing so in a harmful manner. Approval of this kind can only be gained by attacking a target. "So-and-so is using explosives to destroy things." It is the design of the thing.
- robonerd 5y agoPolitical correctness means adherence to a political ideology. Whether something is politically correct or politically incorrect is relative to the political ideology in question. Subjective value statements like "X deserves more funding than Y", which don't have objective answers, may be considered politically correct or incorrect depending on the ideological context being considered.
- throwedawayed69 5y agoThe Times article has some eyebrow-raising details including a written statement from a lead author of the original paper who describes years of harassment and undercutting. > Ms. Goldie said that Dr. Chatterjee had asked to manage their project in 2019 and that they had declined. When he later criticized it, she said, he could not substantiate his complaints and ignored the evidence they presented in response. > “Sat Chatterjee has waged a campaign of misinformation against me and Azalia for over two years now,” Ms. Goldie said in a written statement. > She said the work had been peer-reviewed by Nature, one of the most prestigious scientific publications. And she added that Google had used their methods to build new chips and that these chips were currently used in Google’s computer data centers. Yet another blot on the Rorschach test, to be sure, but perhaps useful to highlight to consider the total possibility space. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/02/technology/google-fires-ai-researchers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/02/technology/google-fires-a...
- ghaff 5y agoWhoever is in the right, wrong, or somewhere in the middle, it's hard not to come away from the NYT article with any impression other than there's been serious internal squabbling and nastiness going on for a good couple of years. The reasonable supposition is someone higher up just got sick of the whole thing and/or Chatterjee stepped over some line. It's odd. 95% of the time if a company fired someone (except maybe at the very highest levels) and was asked for comment, they'd say the person is no longer employed by us (or we don't comment on personnel matters) and leave it at that.