13 ms·
US plans campaign to attract Russian scientists, engineers to America & CERN
- bezospen15 5y agoEnd H1B
- unmole 5y agoDey took er jerbs!
- Gordonjcp 5y ago> It also plans to help Russian physicists at the CERN nuclear lab continue working there, rather than return home when their normal visas expire, if they wish. Do you want Stranger Things? Because that's how you get Stranger Things.
- davidpowell2441 5y ago
- mdb31 5y agoWell, the race to attract the outflow of the current Russian 'brain drain' is definitely on. If the US is able to attract the majority of that (as it most likely will), while keeping out the Putin-aligned plants and/or otherwise mentally deficient factions (which remains to be seen), that will definitely be huge gain for them.
- HarryHirsch 5y agoIf the US is able to attract the majority of that (as it most likely will) That remains to be seen. There is a huge undercurrent of Russophobia, and potential takers will have observed the FBI-led harassment of Chinese scientists (not too long ago a Tennessee jury refused to convict a Chinese national on account of the threadbare evidence), already these factors would make anyone coming from an enemy country hesitant. Combine that with funding and employment issues in the physical and life sciences - anyone young and ambitious would be well advised to settle in China instead.
- thriftwy 5y agoOr at least some cosmopolitain eastern locality such as Dubai; the one which would naturally meet the 'unprecedented invasion of an independent nation' accusations with a lot of laughs. Having said that, I can imagine that there would be (already is a) proxy brain drain from Russia to Dubai but catering to the Western customers.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoDubai is a stationary Potemkin village. There is nothing there for technical people to do outside of ill-conceived construction projects for princelings.
- beebmam 5y agoIn the workplaces that Russian scientists and engineers will go in western countries, like software/pharma/bio/academia/etc, it's highly unlikely there will be virtually any ethnic hate. I've never once seen it in the places I've worked; we are all quite accustomed to diverse colleagues and most of us celebrate that. I personally wouldn't count on China, an ethno-nationalist country that does not offer a pathway for naturalization for people who are not Chinese-passing, to provide a safe place for me or my family to reside. Not to mention the enormous scale of abuse of power the current Chinese government is engaging in.
- rayiner 5y agoAs a brown guy I'd prefer my odds in the reddest county in Mississippi than anywhere in Asia (other than my own ethnostate).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>There is a huge undercurrent of Russophobia Where? The highly skilled Russians part of the brain drain will most likely go to big cities, full of high earning and/or well educated people, not in hick towns full of xenofobic loonies. Russians brain drain to the US is not something new, but has been going on for several decades and it seems to have worked fine for them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CircleSpokes 5y agoIt also has to do with keeping that brainpower from going to other potential problem nations. There is a reason the US basically paid former Soviet rocket and nuclear engineers after the fall of the USSR.
- adtechcomment1 5y agoMy employer is based in Warsaw, Poland with offices in Ukraine, Russia, and many other countries. A day or two after the invasion they sent a company wide email saying they will pay for and coordinate moving, transit, housing, food, etc for anyone and their family in Russia, Ukraine, or the surrounding countries. About a week later they shut down operations in Russia. Though not confirmed we were told a not insignificant portion of Russian employees fled to Poland and still work my employer. I doubt this occurred at very many places, but anecdotally Poland gained a meaningful number of highly skilled tech workers. I haven't worked with any of the Russians, but many of my Polish counterparts hold the belief that the US is largely responsible for the invasion of Ukraine. I will be very interested to see immigration numbers of where Russians end up.
- throw93232 5y agoPoland and surrounding countries no longer give or extend visas to Russians. My guess people who came were from Ukraine.
- FpUser 5y agoSo they want people to go back and work for Putin? Smart move.
- formvoltron 5y ago"gain for them".. which side does your "them" refer to? because I could see gains for both US and Putin. US obviously gains with more smart people here working for the US and paying taxes. Putin gains because he remove smart people from Russia, making it easier to keep hold on power.
- robonerd 5y ago> while keeping out the Putin-aligned plants America doesn't need political purity tests, let them all come. If the concern is espionage, that's the FBI's concern to worry about. If the concern is them sending money back to Russia, simply forbid that. If the concern is their influence on American politics.. well that's a non-issue because native born Americans sympathetic to Putin far outnumber all the PhDs in Russia. And besides, American society can and should be able to tolerate dissent. A small number of wackos are outnumbered by reasonable people and aren't a realistic threat to the system.
- mistrial9 5y ago> sending money back to Russia, simply forbid that. hmm - working people usually send money to those that need it, whatever the language spoken...
- robonerd 5y agoThere are presently sanctions forbidding it, are there not? Those sanctions are what I'm referring to. Language has nothing to do with it.
- thriftwy 5y agoPeople will not emigrate if it means leaving relatives and family behind. That's why you saw so little emigration from the USSR - once they're out they were completely shut off.
- nickstinemates 5y agoOperation Paperclip 2.0
- raverbashing 5y agoMaybe now it will be called "Operation Clippy", who knows? However I wonder what the actual value now would be. They would get some inside info on some technology but it would be very far from the tech they got from WvB after WW2
- Apocryphon 5y agoOperation Osoaviakhim in reverse
- georgecmu 5y agoThe US work-based green card application (I-140)[1] has had the 'Soviet Scientist' category for decades. I knew it hasn't been removed after the breakup of the Soviet Union, but I didn't realize it has been in active use this whole time. From a commentary on a USCIS Interim Regulation from 2005[2]: This benefit for Soviet scientists will be available for a limited time for a limited number of qualified scientists. Therefore, anyone who may qualify under the Soviet Scientist interim rule should begin filing as soon as possible to avoid missing this window of opportunity. This category is supposed to create a win-win situation for the individuals concerned, who are of exceptional ability, and in the national interest of the United States by bringing exceptional scientists to work within the government or the private sector on important projects. [1] https://www.uscis.gov/i-140 https://www.uscis.gov/i-140 [2] https://www.murthy.com/2005/04/29/soviet-scientist-interim-regulation-released/ https://www.murthy.com/2005/04/29/soviet-scientist-interim-r...
- ourmandave 5y ago
- danielodievich 5y agoI am one of the brain drain 2 waves ago from mid 90ies. Especially these days I thank my family to have moved from there to USA. I have an uncle who is twice the programmer than I am and he had a chance to come bit stayed there because, you know, emigration is rely hard and his girlfriend didn't want to come. Now he's just super stuck in Moscow with mortgage in a modest apartment, wife whose job got killed due to sanctions and two children and unsure that he has energy to make a move. Hope programs like that can help him but he should have moved 20 years ago....
- atdrummond 5y agoWhat’s his area of speciality?
- danielodievich 5y agoHe runs an software engineering group in MTS, a big telecom. I think mostly large-scale distributed backend engineering.
- thriftwy 5y agoMoscow is too expensive: it prices even software developer leads out. Still, I don't think he have any but first world problems.
- antisthenes 5y ago> Moscow is too expensive: it prices even software developer leads out. No, it doesn't. This "woe is me, underpaid all the time" rhetoric from someone with a software dev salary is getting really tiring. Moscow is huge. And Software devs are a small minority of all occupations. Plenty of people afford living in Moscow just fine without anywhere near the level of salary typical of software. Probably the only place in the world that priced out software devs was pre-Covid SV, where you weren't able to work remotely from cheaper accommodations. But that really is a unique location and a self-inflicted CA problem. It's not even a first-world problem. It's more of a middle-upper class spoiled rich brat with a 1% salary problem. The NY alternative for this is "woe is me I can't afford private school for my 6 kids and a 5th ave apartment at the same time"
- chrisseaton 5y agoRussia should set up a reverse offer than we can see which political philosophy people prefer in practice.
- Dma54rhs 5y agoThey already have long time ago. Offering land in Russia for people living in former occupied areas to return, so at least economically they've lost the battle. Guess ideological push is not that big if a factor either.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- johnny22 5y agoI think they meant an offer for folks living in places like the US or western europe.
- ogurechny 5y agoIt has already been announced, all of a sudden, in the first week of the war. It had all the signs of being a creation of old bureaucrats who had really outdated personal values. So they promised near 0% mortgage plans and exemption from military service for “IT specialists”, fast track for foreign workers' permits, cut or reduced taxes, grants, and subsidized loans for IT companies. Oh, and “IT specialist” is someone who has a diploma to prove it (cue the sarcastic trumpet effect). Another joke is that university education usually makes you a useless reserve lieutenant in whom military is not interested anyway, and juniors with college degrees who do get drafted right after they get them are certainly not getting any offers from international companies. Well, neither are local ones going to give you any additional points for having a degree, to be honest. So they expect people to shut up and work on supporting government goals in order to keep better living standard than “regular people”, like they themselves did in the Soviet era (yeah, at the time when just having stylish foreign clothes meant you were well connected, and above “regular people”). It's hard to imagine that someone with a decent IT career can see that as an opportunity. However, there is enough swindling types to ride the “we are constantly reducing our dependence on imported technology” propaganda wave who try to make contacts with relevant officials in order to transfigure government budgets into personal wealth. There have been many companies relabeling Chinese hardware after making minimal changes, and there is going to be more. So, among other things, it was announced that we need “our own Github”, and they vaguely described it as some kind of “central source of open source”. Man, even I can make “my own Github”, and maybe even a second one if I'm not feeling lazy. That announcement only resulted in people scratching their heads and guessing whether Github would be blocked, and require additional network configuration to be accessed.
- throw93232 5y agoFrom my social circle, most developers are leaving for SWIFT ban. It really affected badly prowestern Russians who make living remotely. In Georgia or Kazakhstan, you can still speak Russian, but it is much easier to do business. Once sanctions are lifted, they plan to go back.
- user432678 5y ago> once sanctions are lifted How many sanctions were lifted since 2014? How many sanctions were lifted from Cuba since 1960s?
- redisman 5y agoI also really fail to see a situation where the west would think it acceptable. If Russia completely leaves Crimea and pays reparations to rebuild Ukraine - maybe. But that is never going to happen
- HKH2 5y agoThe West, particularly Europe, has an energy dependence problem. I think they might have to accept some things they don't want. Was nuclear power such a terrible option?
- dunkelheit 5y ago> From my social circle, most developers are leaving for SWIFT ban. This of course can change any day, but for now SWIFT transfers still work with non-sanctioned banks (e.g. Tinkoff). So this may be a pretext.
- btrettel 5y agoThe US already produces too many scientists measured by people with PhDs. As someone who finished their PhD during the pandemic and faced a bad job market for research jobs, I feel that without increasing the federal science budget, the current generation of US PhD graduates will have to compete with more experienced Russian scientists entering the US job market. From what I understand exactly that happened during the early 90s and many new PhD graduates found themselves without a job related to their degree. I don't recommend to anyone to get a PhD these days.
- azinman2 5y agoAnd yet everyone says they can’t find enough talent. It can’t be both. PhDs can do more things this just become a professor, which does have a fixed number of spots.
- mistrial9 5y ago> everyone says a vigorous and unending renegotiation between management, the agents of management, and people who "do it", in action.. advanced negotiating tactic - broadly give public opinion in mainstream media about "shortages" of whatever it is that you want more control over.. next, read carefully for market change and new entrants.. rewards, feast on newbs and do-gooders with special offers and limited term deals.. repeat..
- bluGill 5y agoI need specifc talent. I don't care how great you are a physics, pharmacy, mechanical engineering, or any of dozens of other PhDs that you might have, I'm hiring people who program and your degree isn't the right one.
- btrettel 5y agoDon't be too quick to write someone off for their degree. The best Python programmer I know has a PhD in civil engineering. And I've certainly got the impression that people write me off as a programmer far too soon because my PhD is in mechanical engineering.
- formvoltron 5y agoI'm not sure if we want Russia without smart people. Then it's a criminal on top, a bunch of gullible people at the bottom, controlling 3500 nuclear weapons.
- okaram 5y agoAnd how is that different from today?
- adventured 5y agoI'm certain that's precisely the joke meant by the parent.
- yeputons 5y agoI suspect the US is way down in the list of possible emigration routes. It's just a very annoying process if you consider the default route. Getting an offer from a US-based company is the easy part. The hard part is winning the H1-B lottery. The very annoying technical part is getting an appointment in an embassy as a non-resident (there are no visa interviews conducted in Russia, so you have to apply elsewhere, appointments are rare) and then some people (esp. cybersecurity and ML, if rumors are right) get sent to SAO (Security Advisory Opinion, "administrative processing") for a random period of time. No updates or feedback at all during that time, obviously, so you cannot plan anything. Some of my friends were sent for about 1.5 months and had to postpone their three-month internship (sic!) at Google because of that. That was about five years ago. Some other had to wait months before being able to renew (sic!) their work visa. There are rumors of people waiting years without hearing back. To compare, one can obtain a national German visa in a week or two after receiving an offer, if you have your university degree translated to German (not even apostille is required for lots of cases). This visa gets converted into a EU Blue Card once you arrive and apply for it, IIRC.
- ajross 5y ago> The hard part is winning the H1-B lottery. The article is literally about a proposed relaxation of the visa policy for Russians with postgraduate science/tech degrees.
- yeputons 5y agoTrue, but I'm not buying it. Visa interview and SAO problems are universal for all applicants, I believe. SAO is even more relevant for "semiconductors, space technology, cybersecurity, advanced manufacturing and computing, nuclear engineering, artificial intelligence and missile propulsion" (quoting the article), if rumors are true. The only specific relaxation the article mentions is: > The legislation includes language that would permit technically qualified Russians with masters or doctoral degrees in a range of fields to immigrate to the US without the usual visa requirement that they have a job lined up in advance. They would have to pass a US security background check. As I said, getting the offer is the easy part. Lifting that requirements does little. They even say explicitly that some kind of "security background check" is still necessary. A random story: a friend of mine (Software Engineer, LGBTQ+, smart and sociable folk) has tried to relocate to the US for years. They even got multiple offers in the same year with multiple entries to the H1-B lottery to increase their chances. No luck. In the end they simply relocated to London instead. Another one: Massachusetts (yes, a state, not the federal government) have established a Global Entrepreneur in Residence Program several years ago using a loophole in H1-B visas. Quoting https://vdc.umb.edu/2019/04/20/how-does-the-massachusetts-global-entrepreneur-in-residence-program-work/ https://vdc.umb.edu/2019/04/20/how-does-the-massachusetts-gl... > To smooth the path, Massachusetts established the Global Entrepreneur in Residence (GEIR) program. By working part-time at the University of Massachusetts, entrepreneurs can obtain a cap-exempt H-1B visa anytime during the year, since universities are exempt from the annual H-1B quota. The program gives an entrepreneur time to master the company building process, and document their talent and ability, so that they can eventually obtain a visa independent of the University of Massachusetts. Another one, but I haven't heard it first-hand: Google typically does not even bother with H1-B last years, so unreliable it is. So the default route for a person who is needed in the US is to work in a London/Zurich office for a year and then apply via L1-B. Maybe the campaign is aimed at people like "Wernher von Braun and Kurt Debus, later the first director of the Kennedy Space Center". Again, I don't think getting an offer for such kind of people is hard in any way. - Maybe the campaign is aimed at people working in universities, which are H1-B cap-exempt. In that case, the lottery is lifted, which does make the process easier. Still not as easy as with Germany or the UK.
- ogurechny 5y agoDo they wait until June to give Christmas presents, too? Those who could flee did it when planes were still flying, and dollars were still in the ATMs. Senior, highly paid, having an experience in working for an international company, currently hired by an international company — those have been moving abroad for years, had an option to quickly relocate with their families, and tried to keep their current jobs. The campaign would probably help to decrease pressure in Armenia, Georgia, and Turkey, which are now really full of Russian emigrants who don't have any specific plans. As for the scientists, it has been common for the top students to go abroad for decades. Even if they intended to return, it could help with career opportunities and having better perspective. Also, some fields have been badly funded or badly managed, so some scientists basically had to move to work where they could do actual work.
- cato_the_elder 5y agoBased. Maybe the Russian scientists will save us from the great stagnation after all.
- trhway 5y agoA bit of context - Russia has been experiencing IT people shortage to the extent that they have granted military draft exception to IT workers, be it government or private. That US move is a part of the surfacing new "neuter the Russian Nazi beast" strategy that seems to be adopted by the civilized world. I mean it would be great if Ukrainian and NATO forces quickly reached the Moscow and denazified and demilitarized Russia like it was done to Germany in 1945. Unfortunately, that may not happen soon, and there may be years ahead with the Russian Nazist regime (as it is a totalitarian fascist regime with "master nation" ideology thus by definition it is a nazist one) menacing its neighbors and threatening the world with nukes. So, the beast has to be starved and neutered in those years ahead. The brain drain of 90-ties has resulted in severe impact to Russia - as you see there is no capable Generation X aged leadership in Russia with most of the areas of technology and military having made no noticeable progress - like for example those blood thirsty old generals having no idea about drones, cell networks, etc. and only capable of WWII style ruining of the cities using unguided bombs. Brain draining the next generation from Russia would tremendously deepen Russian impotence in tech/military/space/etc. over the next decade.
- twelve40 5y agoI could never get the point of these crazy-ass restrictions in the first place. If the US was serious about attracting such people, they would have visa-on-arrival (or online) and some kind of automatic green card, like many other countries do. It's not like there will be an overwhelming flow of people from Russia, just to get a plane ticket nowadays is like $2k - and you can always enforce the criteria you'd like (income, education) before entry. The current "campaign to attract" will probably require travel to some random country first to get a visa, and presenting tons of random documentation, and waiting for arbitrary amounts of time in random places (US, Russia, third-party countries for a visa). It will only attract people who are truly hell-bent on moving specifically to the US.
- throwawayruSS 5y ago
- SemanticStrengh 5y agoA first step would be for american scientists to start studying the excellent and revolutionnary russian research, e.g. Khavinson and his peptides
- egberts1 5y agoJust like during the late 1930s, it is always a good immigration deal.
- tdiff 5y agoI am afraid this will provide justification for the Russian govmt to close borders and may actually achieve opposite effect to what is stated. I wonder if this is intended or not.