13 ms·
Does Time Exist?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoIf time doesn't exist, then... does space exist? If space exists, does motion exist? It's pretty clear that things exist in different places, that things move, and that for certain events, there is a "before" and an "after". It's really hard to take those seriously and still say that time doesn't exist. Perhaps a more interesting question is, which time exists? There's (at least so far) a rather fundamental difference between time in general relativity and time in quantum mechanics. If time exists, which time is it that exists?
- andrewmcwatters 5y agoDidn't the great @jaden once say, "How Can Mirrors Be Real If Our Eyes Aren't Real"?
- RajT88 5y agoA great man once said, "Time is an Illusion...Lunchtime, doubly so."
- DrBoring 5y agoSounds like a deep quote I read from that page in Reader's Digest.
- SkyMarshal 5y agoIf that page was authored by Douglas Adams then yes that’s where you read it.
- DrBoring 5y agoI was making a reference the next line in the book: "Very deep," said Arthur, "you should send that in to the Reader's Digest. They've got a page for people like you."
- fortyseven 5y ago(How embarrassing.)
- DrBoring 5y agoEh, it's one thing to know a highly memorable quote. It's another to remember the following line. I've listened to the audiobooks of that series so many times. Tangent, they got Simon Jones to read for book 6. which i thought was a mistake. He played Arthur in he radio dramas. It made the audiobook hard to follow because every character sounded like Authur.
- smitty1e 5y agoObviously no time to find another reader.
- adventured 5y agoTime doesn't exist as an independent physical objective entity, it exists only as a measurement. Sometimes we represent that measurement with physical objects, such as with clocks or watches or in our heads (I can hold my breath for N seconds). It's no different than your height existing as a measurement, or the distance from here to the wall existing a measurement, or the distance of 10 meters existing. There are physical entities that exist within the measured space of course, the measurement entity as such does not exist (only in your head, or similar (eg in a computer), as a calculation). It's also the same as three apples and three oranges sitting on the table, and you multiply them to get the number nine - there is no new independent physical entity of nine objects created, other than the calculation as represented temporarily in your brain space (ie you're not able to manifest new tangible entities into physical reality this way, you can merely calculate and store the count as a computer by rearrangement). This is also why time travel backwards can't happen. There is no back there to go to, there is no saved record that some omnipotent entity is keeping track of. Backwards time travel requires either a fantasy premise of time (the mistaken notion that time is a separate, independent, physical thing and not a measurement), and or a god-like creature that has infinite energy to record the location of every unit of matter at every unit of time along with the ability to reassemble all of existence back to each save point - it gets comically silly fast for a rational person, you're better off believing in ghosts and the easter bunny.
- MattPalmer1086 5y agoThat's certainly one view of time. Relativity views all time as existing "simultaneously"; the block universe. The past exists along with the future. The passage of time is then just an illusion seen from within the greater whole. I prefer a view of time closer to yours I think, where there is a single moment of existence, the now, that evolves.
- joeberon 5y ago
- Barrin92 5y agoOne of favourite videos ever on the internet is a 'science slam' video about the thermodynamic nature of time (and entropy) from about a decade ago. It's in German but the auto-translate does a good job. https://youtu.be/z64PJwXy--8 https://youtu.be/z64PJwXy--8
- dperfect 5y agoFor more on this topic, I recommend Carlo Rovelli's The Order of Time. The book is very accessible to non-experts in the field (like me), and it opened my eyes to some super interesting and unintuitive ideas about time.
- canjobear 5y agoTime is the direction in which entropy always increases. It's the most real thing there is.
- SkyMarshal 5y agoYes, good book on that is The Order of Time, for anyone who hasn’t read it. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/36442813-the-order-of-time https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/36442813-the-order-of-ti...
- mirceal 5y agodoes entropy always increase? are there systems or forms of matter that literally cheat entropy?
- MattPalmer1086 5y agoAny system can cheat entropy as long as it's not a closed system, by decreasing locally but increasing it globally. Life is a good example.
- mirceal 5y agolife and information are good examples, yes. i sometimes wonder if our understanding of physics is somewhat limited to what we can see/observe/measure (include instruments here) and wonder if the laws of physics as we perceive them are only a set of laws that are not necessarily universal and apply anywhere where matter exists (that a long way of saying that maybe entropy comes with only one set of laws of physics that just so happens to be the ones that we are experiencing right now)
- 8bitsrule 5y agoA plant is what a seed does to the dirt around it.
- waserwill 5y agoOr at least tends to increase. Entropy can always spontaneously decrease, or can simply not increase for a moment. This was actually discussed a week ago! [1] As discussed in those comments, entropy isn't well-formulated outside of equilibrium states, and is subjective: it is a function of an observer's knowledge of the system (particularly microstates). I'd say time is very real, and an inescapable part of experience (no experience without change). As for time being the most real, we only know it through experience, so I think of it as secondary, along with space, etc. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31164725 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31164725
- arvindrajnaidu 5y agoIt cannot. For it to exist, it will have to occupy itself.
- zelphirkalt 5y agoI'll ask another one: Does it matter, whether time exists? If we go with the idea, that time merely describes a number state changes of the universe, then it might not matter, whether time actually exists.
- Slaren 5y ago[dead]
- ffhhj 5y agoYeah, time is our tracking of the evolution of processes, and it can't go backwards but sideways like in Thomson's Lamp.
- ngvrnd 5y agowhen all matter turns to EM radiation, at the end of the universe (arguendo), then time will cease to be measurable, and so will distance.
- macrolocal 5y agoObligatory Alain Connes post: http://noncommutativegeometry.blogspot.com/2007/03/time.html http://noncommutativegeometry.blogspot.com/2007/03/time.html
- qiskit 5y agoIt exists in the way weight or distance exists.
- gigama 5y ago> Does Time Exist? Only relative to a given frame of reference.
- hexsel 5y agowhat if time is caused by movement? relative time, since we already know spacetime to be an entity
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- entropicgravity 5y agoTime exists in the similar sense that rivers exist. If you look too closely the thing fades away into individual water molecules. But when you zoom out it's not a rain drop or a cloud or fog, it's a river.
- pdrummond 5y agoI have no clue about the science but I like to think of time as an illusion, just for the fun of it. It appears to me to be our way of making sense of reality based on our limited senses of what's really going on. There is only "now" in reality - and we can't begin to imagine what that is like - so our minds layer up moment after moment to create the illusion of time. Previous moments are our memories, right now is reality and future moments are our imagination. If we didn't have the ability to "layer up" moments in our minds, we probably wouldn't be able to make sense of music or speech for example. Reminds me of my favourite film Memento. If the protagonist forgot everything every nanosecond instead of every 10-30 minutes or so, he would probably be completely in touch with reality and have no concept (or illusion) of time. If you put two Leonard Shelby's in a room and lock the door and observe what happens, they will eventually bump into each other but only from the observer's perspective (his mind observing the layering of moments). Neither Shelby will be aware of how many times they have bumped into each other or what "bumping into someone" is like (because even something as small as bumping into another person is hundreds of little moments layered together in the mind).
- encephalos 5y agoI’ve been wondering a lot lately if it’s possible that time is felt differently (I guess moves) for us on an individual level.
- LocalH 5y agoTime is felt differently at different points in our life, even within an individual’s experience. When you pay more attention to the passage of time itself, it appears to elapse more slowly. When you don’t pay attention, it appears to elapse more quickly. Yes, I would absolutely accept that we all perceive time at different rates, but where we externally synchronize with measured “seconds”, we don’t have any way to communicate that my “second” may subjectively feel longer than your “second”. Similar to how we can’t really describe what “red” looks like to someone else, without using the word “red”.
- brimble 5y agoAs I approach 40, a year feels about as long as a month did when I was elementary-school aged. I worry that if the current rate-of-increase continues, my last decade will feel weeks long.
- DrBoring 5y agoI feel the same way about my time in elementary school. My theory is that it was boredom that made school time feel so slow. Summer vacation always seemed to fly by.
- TechBro8615 5y agoI think the answer to this is to do more interesting things on a regular basis. If every weekend you do something different, then the month feels longer than when you stay home every weekend.
- nameisname 5y agoGreat advise! I wanted to add a bit more to it. As you age the number of novel experiences and "space" for those experiences in your brain decreases. So the first 20 years of your life you accumulated a lot of new experiences while your brain was growing an expanding. For this reason it feels like you lived in regular time. Your final 20 years will mostly be nothing new and what is new will largely include a base that is shared based on past experiences. This is why as you get older time moves faster.
- euroderf 5y agoAsking about time gets you into adjacent issues like free will. I find that interviews with Lee Smolin are illuminating, even tho I'm totally OTL on the technical aspects.
- oldstrangers 5y agoTo me it's pretty intuitive that time isn't real (outside of being a concept). We just use time as an elaborate way to explain our movement through distances (and how fast or slow we cover those distances), that's about it. The twin paradox[1] does a good job of explaining this. There's no discernable difference between today and lets say, arbitrarily, 1984. The only difference is our movement through that spatial distance. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin_paradox
- why-el 5y agoIn your rebuttal, you used a concept that necessarily assumes time ("how fast or slow", i.e. speed) to argue against the existence of time?
- oldstrangers 5y agoVelocity is real, distance is real, time is how we've decided to describe their relation. Physically and philosophically, the "idea of time" isn't real. It just helps us describe our reality.
- webkike 5y agovelocity is defined as distance over unit time so I’m not sure how you square that circle
- oldstrangers 5y agoSemantics but velocity being a measurement of somethings movement through a distance is exactly what I'm saying time is. I've stated that we use time to describe stuff, like velocity. But "time" as a physical property like gravity does not exist.
- ecnahc515 5y agoYou could probably replace the usage of "time" with "increase in entropy", but it just makes it harder to understand WRT velocity. As your velocity increases, the entropy in the universe has increased as a result of whatever mechanism for acceleration is being used. If it's gas, then you are going from a nice, mostly orderly/low entropy liquid in a container, to a chaotic, high entropy gas that's now in the atmosphere.
- mountainboy 5y agoafaict, "time" is simply a measure of matter in motion... ie resonant frequency or how long it takes a liquid to flow x distance. Thus, time is just a mental construct, not a "dimension", and "time travel" is not possible. There is only "now".
- zelphirkalt 5y agoUnless all "times" exist at every "moment" and we are merely switching consciousness between those. Maybe we are not even switching, because by "going backwards" we would be losing memories and would not know, that we went backwards. Same goes for forwards. It only seems forward, because our memories change that way. Maybe we are all just coping, trying to make any sense of every state, future, past, present, existing "all the time".
- LocalH 5y agoMy DMT “time loop” experience makes this whole topic extremely fascinating to me. I very clearly (to me, within my own subjective experience) witnessed some of the exact same events happen multiple times (within the timeframe of the experience, anyway). It was like there were two separate chronologies existing simultaneously - that of my subjective experience (the “observer”, if you will) and that of the perception of my reality.
- spogbiper 5y agoI dont have time to read the article. do I exist?
- mirceal 5y agothe question is: does the article exist if you don’t read it?