5 ms·
AFAIK these EULAs are legal. In reality, RED isn't exfiltrating their customers' video (the files are enormous so people would notice) and they would go out of
by wmf 5y ago
AFAIK these EULAs are legal. In reality, RED isn't exfiltrating their customers' video (the files are enormous so people would notice) and they would go out of business if they did. Probably every product has some objectionable clause in their EULA which no one reads, so you're better off not reading it and moving on with your life. If you want to be a freedom fighter, go work for the EFF; if you want to make video, make video.
- red_throwaway 5y ago> Probably every product has some objectionable clause in their EULA which no one reads, so you're better off not reading it and moving on with your life. If you want to be a freedom fighter, go work for the EFF; if you want to make video, make video. Maybe a bit naive but definitely practical advice. I hear you.
- _tom_ 5y agoThe purchase is completed before he gets it home and finds new conditions being imposed. That the part that I question about being legal.
- red_throwaway 5y agoYes, this! The sales person made absolutely no mention of any licensing terms or agreements that I would need to sign off on before my camera became usable as a camera.
- jrockway 5y agoI think you're entitled to return it for a full refund. The same would be true if you took some video and didn't like how the camera worked, or just got cold feet on your $30k purchase. I get the feeling that you want more than that (like a custom license agreement, or some punishment for the sales person for not mentioning the EULA), and I don't think you're going to get that. Return it for a refund, RED has to sell it as an "open box", and the EULA costs them a few hundred bucks this time. Or make a fabulous video and forget all about their updates that move things around in the UI, and just live with it because the video quality is so good. Those are the best possible outcomes here.
- technothrasher 5y ago> or just got cold feet on your $30k purchase. You are typically not entitled to a refund in this situation. Many companies will allow it under a goodwill return policy, but they are not legally obligated in most situations.
- jdsully 5y agoThere is an implied warranty of merchantability. If a EULA wasn’t disclosed until post purchase and is required for operation then the product isn’t operable and they would have to return it or find a way to make it operable. Your average store clerk will roll their eyes if you discuss this with them - you’d have to sue. For $30k it might be worth it, but most purchases it is not.
- JohnHaugeland 5y agoIt's almost certain that the EULA is on the website
- jhugo 5y agoIf I walk into a store and buy something and they never mention the surprise extra contractual terms I need to go looking for on the website, then those surprise extra contractual terms aren't part of the sales contract. He's entitled to a refund if the EULA terms were not disclosed to him before purchase, because he purchased a camera and it can't be used as a camera until he agrees to an additional contract.
- red_throwaway 5y agoI'm pretty sure I would be granted a refund if I asked for one. That being said, I'm not left with a lot of options after returning it because there aren't many comparable alternatives for this class of camera. In fact, I don't know of even one camera that's as high quality without also being almost double the price. RED has a lot of leverage here.
- kube-system 5y agoIt is legal. But under warranty law, they also have to deliver you a product that works or refund your money.
- Tuna-Fish 5y agoDepends on jurisdiction. Inside the EU, the EULA is not a valid contract and gives RED no rights to anything. This is true of any and all "license agreements" that are presented to the user after money has changed hands. You can safely click agree on any such things without actually agreeing to anything. I don't actually know, but I believe that in the US things are more complex.
- usr1106 5y agoDo you have a reference for your claims, inside EU...? It sounds reasonable to me personally, but not convincing in reality. There are 27 legislations in the EU. Edit: Based on a quick web search it seems correct for Germany and Austria.
- usr1106 5y agoAt least under German consumer law clauses that are suprising and harmful to the rights of the consumers have been repeatedly declared void and unenforceable by the courts. However, in this price class I could have my doubts whether consumer laws are applicable. Businesses are less protected, they are supposed to know what they do. The question was about European laws. There mostly is no such thing (very few exceptions exist, like e.g. GDPR). Laws are national, so you have 30 of them. EU directives set some borderlines for those who are members or associated. But they are not always implemented in a timely manner, and even if they are the details are up to national legislation by design.
- wmf 5y agoEvery product works this way.
- bzxcvbn 5y agoNonsense. I bought a hammer the other day and could start using it without signing away any of my rights. It's pretty much only digital products that somehow force you to do that.
- kube-system 5y agoIf you brought the hammer home and it didn't work as you expected it to, you can take it back. Just like you can with this camera, you can decline the EULA and send the product back.
- pessimizer 5y agoYou're not entitled by law to take a hammer back if it doesn't work as you expect it to.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> You're not entitled by law to take a hammer back if it doesn't work as you expect it to. Yes you are. If it’s not fit for the purpose you’re entitled to return it.
- jhugo 5y ago"Works as you expect it to" is not the same thing as "fit for purpose". The purpose of a hammer is (mostly) an objective fact. Your expectations of what the hammer can do, on the other hand, may or may not be reasonable. (Though in this case I think it's perfectly reasonable to claim that the camera is not fit for purpose if the EULA terms were not clearly disclosed before the purchase was made.)
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eganist 5y ago> The purchase is completed before he gets it home and finds new conditions being imposed. That the part that I question about being legal. My experience (IANAL and I don't know the specific laws here): you can return the product if you don't agree to the bundled licensing terms, generally even if you've opened it and encountered the licensing terms after the fact (though not every retailer may appreciate this one). I've gotten a few "non-refundable" refunds after being given legal terms post-purchase that I didn't agree to. Most recently a talent release for an event. But in every case, I had to prove that the agreements weren't available pre-purchase.
- EMIRELADERO 5y agoOr you can just use the product normally without agreeing to it. Look up "unconscionability"
- eganist 5y agoI guess my point was moreso that legal agreements sprung upon you post-purchase could make for a useful escape hatch. If you want to use the product, shrug. But if you suddenly don't, then hey, there's a potential exit.
- JohnHaugeland 5y agosadly high end electronics are typically written to prevent this, which is pretty awful
- EMIRELADERO 5y agoI was referring to not agreeing to the comtract but still clicking the "I agree" button to use the camera.
- Brian_K_White 5y agoWhat good does this do? The machine and the company will still do things you don't want.
- Bancakes 5y agoThis! OP, stop asking questions and raising concerns. Consume product, then get excited for next product.
- daniel-cussen 5y ago> and they would go out of business if they did. That's what this is. This is a step in that process. This post on this forum, with both of us replying to it. You think what? There's a "scandal" and an "outrage" and then...what do you expect? The entire PR industry--a few others as well--is built to undermine scandals and outrage. Oh there's stuff on TV that sounds scandalous sure--every two months or so, in a merry-go-round set of industries...I only watch when there is nowhere in a restaurant I can avoid looking at it, but what are the scandals, steroids in baseball? A corporation that did something disgusting but isn't getting punished at all (as opposed to the many corporations that do get punished for real, TV hates showing those because then people learn what justice actually looks like). Or...some celebrity...some celebrity getting lynched. Or a rogue employee like on a crusade...or a lawsuit that the news wished had lost so they lie about it as much as possible to make the plaintiff look greedy (real easy if you just multiply the settlement by a lot, or report the claim instead of the awards, or lie about the award being reduced to what the plaintiff was asking for, or fucking insult the jury too while you're at it, even insult the judge, it's disgusting, they think they're strictly better than everybody). They wouldn't go out of business if they did that. They just have to do it in lockstep with the rest of their industry, then they'll be fine. > if you want to make video, make video. Now I very much don't want to make video, and frankly lost a lot of respect for digital video in general. And for contracts. And every time I hear the word "consent" I go on full alert, as I said in a previous comment, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31104705 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31104705 "...no rapey cookie "consent" contract, like those are just disgusting I hate getting asked for consent it means I'm about to get fucked. Every single time you get asked for consent it's because you're about to get fucked." You know why that is? Because in order to defend the act of fucking you, they have to say you consented. Or they get fucked just as hard as they fucked you. And they live in fear of that, fear of retribution, they know how harmful they are, this is like--justice is often eye for an eye[1], despite striking others blind (or in this case peeking through their eyes), I never want that to happen to me, so I need magic spells because otherwise I would feel the harm I do to others. So I need to get consent with a long disgusting contract, and further I need to get people to sign things as often as possible, for every little thing so they are desensitized to what it means to consent to being struck blind, and they give up on reading contracts.[2] [1] So justice basically is eye for an eye, historically, normally. These days it is both more and less. So you have on the one hand the Sacklers paying 10 billion instead of 3.4 trillion, that's less than an eye for an eye. The Sacklers are paying with the eyes they stole, and have plenty left. Plenty of eyes to go around! Then in the halfway point you have murderers getting the death penalty for one murder, exactly an eye for an eye. Then, the multiple-eyes-for-an-eye, a convicted rapist will spend...it really depends, but like 10 years is a common one. And due to that conviction, will be targeted by the other inmates, with the guard's approval, to rape that convict as much as they please basically. In movies it's just one rape, one time, in real prisons it's continual. So what you get, is virgins who ipso facto didn't rape anybody getting raped about 3 times a day, for 10 years, so about 10000 times, on the basis they were accused of one rape. So to translate 10000 eyes for an eye, but not even a real eye, like a glass eye. Oh you didn't like talking about that? Too gross? But it's germane to the subject, we had been talking about consent this whole time! [2] There's a synergy between abusing people's eyes and getting them to sign contracts, now that I think about it. Blind people can't read contracts, like everybody screams from the pain in their ass when a blind man asks for a contract in braille, like the discrimination is very real. And they lie to them when reading out loud. So in this slightly different case, you could be filming your screen with a RED camera to identify manipulation in a contract--like shitty javascript moving items when you click--with a RED camera, but then RED looks at what you filmed, oh he's filming the signature of a contract, we don't want that, he's using this camera as an eye to READ a CONTRACT, let's add in our update the terms that we get to edit what he recorded so we delete the evidence. Oh wait, that's even more literal! Literal striking an eye blind just when you needed it to preserve evidence! Good synergy.