20 ms·
It’s always good to remind people that: GDP ~= Population * Productivity If your population growth flat-lines (which it did last year), productivity has to co
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
It’s always good to remind people that:
GDP ~= Population * Productivity
If your population growth flat-lines (which it did last year), productivity has to compensate.
Can productivity compensate if the average age is getting older (people tend to be less productive after a certain median age)?
One reason investing in index funds makes sense is the underlying assumption that global population growth keeps increasing (GDP for ‘free’).
I’m super interested in what investing looks like in 50-100 years as the population starts collapsing, because it might collapse faster than productivity can possibly compensate for, which means unstoppable GDP decline.
GDP has to be at certain levels to support different types of economic activity. E.g. at some point, GDP might be low enough that new semiconductor research isn’t affordable (because all the workers are used up caring for the elderly for example).
- ultra_nick 5y agoGDP per capita seems like a more useful metric for domestic use.
- HFguy 5y agoIt is a common mistake, but stocks don't have a positive return because GDP increases over time. They have a positive expected return over time because they have a risk premium. That is, to invest and take on risk, an investor will demand a return above and beyond the expected value of the cash flows the business generates. Whatever path of GDP and/or population is expected to be is already factored into the discounted valuation of the cashflows. That is, you aren't getting a positive expected return because population growth is increasing over time (i.e., everyone knows that, it is already baked into the price). Now, if the expected population growth changes...then the price would change. You have an expected return because you are taking on risk.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> stocks don't have a positive return because GDP increases over time. They have a positive expected return over time because they have a risk premium You’re both right. The equity risk premium [1] is real. But it’s a premium over something. That something is, approximately, production. (It’s precisely the risk-free rate of return. Which, in the long run, is base-rate production.) [1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/equityriskpremium.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/equityriskpremium.asp
- HFguy 5y agoYes, all assets are priced relative to the risk free rate. As the assets all compete with each other and they all compete with cash rates. So that rate can be thought of as being baked into other assets already (including equities). Having said that, if you wanted a return strictly on base-rate production, then you'd invest then in risk free assets (vs equities).
- RC_ITR 5y ago> Yes, all assets are priced relative to the risk free rate. Based on your name I bet you work in research at a hedge fund. I hate to break it to you but ask most people who are price setters what their discount is and they’ll say 10% regardless of 10Y treasury yields (since you know, TINA) As a result securities are increasingly priced on liquidity more than cash flows and that’s a function of the credit cycle way more than it’s a function of productivity. It’s a weird post modern approach to the economy, but hey that’s showbiz baby.
- paulpauper 5y agoagree. GDP does not mean stock market gains. In fact, you can have strong shareholder returns even if the economy is not growing at all. If $1 billion company generates $100 million in net profit annually, this is $ that must go to shareholders regardless of GDP. This is the situation right now with the US...major companies are generating huge profits annually even if real GDP, productivity, and population growth is sluggish, which is why the stock market has done so well in spite of so many things seeming to be wrong..
- slv77 5y agoLong term corporate profit growth overall can’t exceed demographic growth + productivity growth unless you assume that corporate profits will eventually consume all of GDP with labor and taxes going to zero. A large amount of corporate profit growth since the 80s has been due to a declining share of labor compensation vs capital and declining effective tax rates. Productivity gains are the only real “free lunch” which is what capital investment is supposed to provide to justify the gains. Productivity growth has been stagnating for a couple of decades.
- MuffinFlavored 5y ago> They have a positive expected return over time because they have a risk premium It feels very weird that the same: 1. US government (which bailed out some big banks when they did all of that corrupt greedy stuffy during the '07 housing collapse) 2. the predatory banks themselves 3. institutions like Vanguard, Blackrock, UBS really let "the small guy" win in the "retail investor" by allowing us to just click "buy" on things like index funds. it all seems too good to be true. when does the little guy ever actually win?
- MuffinFlavored 5y ago> You have an expected return because you are taking on risk. I have a dumb question. Most publicly traded companies rarely issue new shares. Why does a company care about its share price? If we are being rewarded for buying and holding their shares based on the growth a company makes quarterly, how does the company benefit from their share price going up? They don't commonly take loans against their shares or issue new shares. I know they have a duty to shareholders but... take Facebook for example. Who cares if their stock is down 60%? How does it affect the companies financials?
- snake_doc 5y ago> Most publicly traded companies rarely issue new shares. False, most public companies have stock based compensation plans, which are ways of issuing new shares. Without them, they would need to substitute stock compensation with cash to acquire talent. Facebook issues shares every time they approve a new stock based compensation plan.
- MuffinFlavored 5y agohttps://finance.yahoo.com/quote/FB/key-statistics?p=FB https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/FB/key-statistics?p=FB FB has 2.3b shares outstanding. How much has that number grown past 12 months, 24 months, 36 months so I can put what you are discussing into perspective?
- snake_doc 5y agoIt's not as simple as looking at the stock of outstanding shares to determine issuance, as it's a net figure. In terms of new issuance, FB spends billions in stock based compensation each year since 2012, all of these are new issuance under the equity incentive plan. It was ~$9.164B for FY2021 alone. In terms of buybacks, FB started buying back stocks in 2017 and has continued since. In FY2021, they spent ~$55.47B to buy back stocks. Therefore, outstanding shares have been decreasing since around 2020. But this doesn't mean the company stops issuing shares. The more stock prices fall, the more equity they would need to issue to compete for talent, or alternatively supplement with cash. Long term, stock prices is one of many measures of how the company would be able to raise capital (stock based compensation is an indirect way of raising capital). Data from Bloomberg: https://postimg.cc/Lq0sNCJV https://postimg.cc/Lq0sNCJV
- ChrisLomont 5y agoRisk doesn't add value. Production does. Stocks rise as the company is perceived as more valuable, generally due to productive gain. People don't want to risk investing without expected gain. But the risk is not causing growth.
- coldtea 5y ago>I’m super interested in what investing looks like in 50-100 years as the population starts collapsing In most countries the population has already started collapsing
- jbergens 5y agoI think the rate of change is pretty slow right now but number of births per woman has gone down. If these lower levels stay or goes down further then the population will start to shrink faster in many countries. Some countries may be able to delay this by taking in more immigrants.
- ac29 5y agoA solid majority of countries are still experiencing population growth, and among those shrinking, the magnitude is small - the largest population decrease (in a non tiny island nation) is in Latvia, which is shrinking around 1% a year. Hardly a collapse. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_population_growth_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_populatio...
- ben_w 5y ago> I’m super interested in what investing looks like in 50-100 years as the population starts collapsing I don’t think it’s possible to forecast economics on those scales. If I was cryonically preserved and woken up in 2122, I would be equally willing to believe we were declining or stagnant for the reasons you give… or that we had solved AI and von Neumann replicators and that the planet Mercury had been fully dismantled and used to construct a Dyson swarm whose descendants had already done the same to a similar planet around each of the nearest dozen or so stars.
- snikeris 5y agoBefore being frozen, what would you do w/ your current wealth to ensure you have something of value in the future?
- ben_w 5y agoThere’s no way for me to ensure that outcome given I believe the nature of the world economy is not forecastable that far ahead. In the Dyson swarm scenario, assuming constant population, the productive capacity per person is 2500 times higher than the current global output, and a random act of rounding-error charity would give you more than Musk, Bezos, Zuckerberg combined, and it won’t matter if you have nothing (unless your sense of self worth exists only by the size of your bank account). In the stagnant scenario, you might be OK with property, if you can be sure it will be maintained in the meanwhile. In a decay scenario, I wouldn’t even want to guess what’s resilient, but houses will be fairly redundant due to oversupply. But those scenarios were deliberately chosen as illustrative outliers; there are options between them, and I would do no better with making the right choices there — a limited AI that makes one sector redundant would destroy any investment I made in that sector while also making the output of that sector too cheap to bill separately, much as digital computers have done to the human profession of “computer”.
- alexanderdmitri 5y agoInvest in the entities that are managing your storage and unfreezing.
- 5y ago
- lisper 5y agoIt is also good to keep in mind that GDP is not a good measure of societal well-being. If GDP double but the population quadruples, most people living at the end of that process would not consider it to be a good outcome.
- gruez 5y agoThat's why you use GDP per capita for that.
- dragonwriter 5y agoGDP per Capita is not a good measure of societal well-being either, since it doesn't reflect distribution of anything, just aggregate production.
- lisper 5y agoThat's true. But if GDP per capita goes up, even if GDP goes down, your odds of having society being better off as a result are much better than if GDP goes up while GDP per capita goes down.
- adventured 5y agoIt's an excellent measure of the typical societal well-being in fact. On average there is a strong correlation between the two globally and there has been during the entire post WW2 era at the least. It is the rare outlier that doesn't see a correlation between societal well-being and GDP per capita. Shall we stroll down the list of high GDP nations? Surely it's unnecessary, as we all know the names. Oh ok let's do it anyway. Ireland $101k | Norway $99k | Switzerland $96k | Qatar $84k | Brunei $80k | Singapore $79k | US $76k | Iceland $74k | Denmark $68k | Australia $67k | Sweden $58k | Netherlands $57k | Canada $57k | Israel $54k | Finland $53k | Austria $53k | Belgium $52k | Germany $51k | New Zealand $50k | UAE $50k | UK $50k | France $44k | Japan $39k | Kuwait $39k | Taiwan $36k | South Korea $35k | and so on And everyone also knows what the bottom 1/4 or 1/3 of GDP per capita nations look like and how horrible their societal well-being is. The correlation is blatant. It's not perfect of course, it is however very high. There are no great societal paradises where the GDP per capita is ~$500-$5,000. And there are no countries that are like Zimbabwe, Somalia or North Korea but have $30k+ GDP per capita figures. The only serious weak spots in the correlation, primarily, are the US being ranked so highly on GDP per capita (but being below eg Finland on societal well-being), and the couple of smaller resource rich nations like Qatar where human rights are weak. For the vast majority of nations the correlation is quite sound and consistently so.
- russdill 5y agoI feel like you're using that equation in a bit backwards way. If suddenly, everyone between the ages of 0 and 5 vanished, it would have a huge effect on the population, but at first take, zero effect on the GDP since presumably that age group is not involved in production. With a second approximation, you might say that GDP would increase since parental childcare is not part of the GDP and those parents could instead be adding to the GDP. Similarly, the current flatlining (ignoring the decrease due to excess deaths) of the population won't effect actual production until a couple of decades on, unless you count possibly increased production described above.
- mywittyname 5y agoParents of 0 to 5 year olds spend an assload of money on them.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> If suddenly, everyone between the ages of 0 and 5 vanished, it would have a huge effect on the population, but at first take, zero effect on the GDP since presumably that age group is not involved in production. That age group is involved in production (e.g., in media.) But not lot, so, yes, the narrow first-order GDP effect would be very small. > With a second approximation, you might say that GDP would increase since parental childcare is not part of the GDP and those parents could instead be adding to the GDP. I suspect second order demand side effects would probably be more strongly negative that second order supply side effects would be positive. You can't predict GDP effects from labor supply side effects alone.
- slv77 5y agoLower birth rates initially boost economies because it increases the percentage of the working age population which can drive a virtuous cycle in terms of savings and investment. In economics this is called the demographic dividend which if well managed can lift countries out of economic poverty. Eventually though the benefit disappears as the demographic pyramid becomes a pipe and the share of working population shrinks again. The US demographic dividend was the era of the baby boomers who were a large cohort but had relatively few children.
- pradn 5y agoA country with a declining population can keep a growing economy or low immigration, but not both. Some countries (the Anglophone countries, France, and Germany) are magnets for labor given their relatively high wages, standard of living, and multi-culturalism (racism and anti-immigrant politics are problems, but still). But others, like Japan (with low immigration) or Bulgaria (with low immigrant interest) can't reap the population dividend. Perhaps you can pick two of three: a stagnant economy, low immigration, non-right-wing politics. Japan picks a stagnant economy and low immigration (Shinzo Abe though a nationalist was no Marine Le Pen). France picks a somewhat growing economy and somewhat high immigration, and suffers from the growth of right-wing anti-immigrant parties (Marine Le Pen won 40% of the vote recently).
- adventured 5y agoOr you can have lots of immigration and a per capita contracting economy like France. France population 1990: 58 million | France population today: 67 million France GDP 1990: $1.2 trillion | France GDP today: $2.9 trillion ($1.2t inflation adjusted forward 32 years is $2.7 trillion) They gained 15-16% in population, and gained 6-7% in GDP. A big net drop per capita over such a duration, particularly for a major affluent economy. And if one wants to be more aggressive about how big of a failure their immigration program has been, the French economy has net contracted in real terms over the last 15 years. GDP was $2.9t at the peak in 2008, and it's still there now; except to just remain steady, it needed to climb to nearly $4 trillion to adjust for inflation. So France has gained 5% in population over ~15 years, and is missing a trillion dollars in GDP they should have just to remain flat (ie they've seen a massive per capita economic contraction over those 15 years). One might claim the decline in France would have been even worse without their hefty immigration policies. Likely a false claim given the very high unemployment rate among immigrants in France over the past two decades. The French approach to mass immigration has been a disaster (while other better controlled examples have been great successes, as in Canada). Skilled immigration is vastly better than low-skill mass immigration, especially going into the era of basic human labor coming under attack by the field of productivity robotics. It's a far better approach to focus on improving your nation per capita net via attracting highly skilled labor, in terms of productivity and incomes, than just focusing on getting as much raw immigration as you can. That's the core failure of the French approach. It's far better to be rich Canada, with a flat to very modestly increasing population, in which real per capita GDP keeps rising and they keep focused on adding high skill labor (which makes their country richer and richer over time), than to be an declining France that throws low skill labor at the problem. For one thing, the high skilled labor immediately begins contributing to the tax base in a big way, which is critical for an affluent welfare state; whereas a tilt toward low skilled labor + a welfare state is a recipe for fiscal disaster. US GDP per capita is on track to reach a doubling of the French GDP per capita, plausibly this decade ($76k vs $44k now and the gap keeps widening year after year). Meanwhile Canada is also now up to $57k (France and Canada were nearly the same on GDP per capita in 2008, now there is a $13k gap), so they're increasingly leaving France behind as well.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoIf there are fewer people to consume the fruits of productivity, does GDP decline matter?
- adam_arthur 5y agoIt only matters to the extent that many existing systems are built on the assumption that the economy grows over time... e.g. taking on a 30y mortgage. If environment becomes deflationary, then it becomes a deathtrap. I think nominal GDP targeting is pretty bad policy though. Deflation can be a great thing for people, if its focused in the right areas. e.g. imagine population is cut in half overnight... suddenly housing becomes very cheap and affordable, even in previously desirable areas. Of course, need to deal with all the ramifications and second order effects of that (lots of financial instruments would implode as their inflationary baseline assumptions unravel). Debt instruments of all kind become problematic with deflation. At least in their current form. Fortunately the US could toggle on population growth on a whim through changes in immigration policy
- imtringued 5y ago>I think nominal GDP targeting is pretty bad policy though. Deflation can be a great thing for people, if its focused in the right areas. Only if accompanied with a negative interest rate so that the real interest rate is 0%. The problem with deflation is that it raises the real interest rate, even though nobody signed a contract "hey if deflation is 5% I will willingly pay a real interest rate of 5%". When you consider that deflation primarily happens in economies that don't need further growth, paying that interest rate is not good for society.
- 30944836 5y ago>GDP has to be at certain levels to support different types of economic activity. E.g. at some point, GDP might be low enough that new semiconductor research isn’t affordable (because all the workers are used up caring for the elderly for example). The good news is, this won't happen in the US, at least not in the 21st century. So if you're an American, feel lucky.
- jagraff 5y agoCare to elaborate? What makes you so sure that won't happen in the US?
- 30944836 5y agoThe population growth of the United States will never flatline for any appreciable amount of time. In other words, we'll never run out of workers. This is for two reasons: (1) We border a rapidly developing nation to the south (Mexico), with significant economic ties at that border. (2) The United States is, hands down, the most effective society at integrating immigrants and allowing them to be productive. We can always, always import more workers, and people will always, always want to come here.
- adventured 5y ago> Can productivity compensate if the average age is getting older (people tend to be less productive after a certain median age)? Most certainly. We'll very clearly do it with robots and artificial intelligence. Although people are expecting way too much way too soon. The classic line about how people overestimate change in the short-term and underestimate change in the long-term. Elon Musk may occasionally be a clown in his behavior, but he has persistently been out on the cutting edge where newer technology meets real-world usefulness (the point where technology is ready for mass adoption; an awareness Steve Jobs also had). That's why Musk & Tesla are so interested in robotics (and they have the cashflow now to easily afford to pursue it in a big way). It will be a very large market, 30 years out, and it'll do a lot for boosting per capita productivity while population declines or stagnates. For example we might see a scenario where population declines in the affluent nations, with persistent aging, and productivity remains stable or even gains, thanks to all manner of human labor enhancements that we'll come up with in this looming era.
- JaimeThompson 5y ago>and they have the cashflow now to easily afford to pursue it in a big way Musk is in the process of tying most of his free cash up in a web app instead of investing it in his businesses which might cause those larger companies to have issues.
- adventured 5y agoMusk is mostly not tying up free cash to buy Twitter, it's going to end up largely being a debt move (as is typical of what he does, as he hates to sell his stock). And I'm not sure where your premise matters re what I said. Tesla is the entity in question with the booming free cash to spend from operations, as their business has become soundly profitable. If Musk leverages his enormous net worth on acquiring profitable Twitter - what does that have to do with Tesla's ability to direct its operational cash to robotics R&D? Maybe his focus being split further will increase the risk to Tesla's profitability over time, however you didn't suggest that (and maybe Tesla would be better off with a Gwynne Shotwell operating it anyway; a more distracted Musk that has to hire a superior operator might bolster Tesla). With $3.6b in operating income last quarter, and $9.6b over the last four quarters, Tesla increasingly has huge resources to throw at big R&D programs. Which has little to nothing to do with Musk's personal finances.
- paulpauper 5y agoI’m super interested in what investing looks like in 50-100 years as the population starts collapsing, because it might collapse faster than productivity can possibly compensate for, which means unstoppable GDP decline. Probably the same as today. Big tech will do well: google, tesla, amazon, etc. The wealthy and B2B will continue to provide a growing share of economic value, outpacing retail consumers and compensating for population stagnation. I don't see any reason for productivity to fall. Productivity surged during pandemic.
- MuffinFlavored 5y agoI have a friend who is obsessed with the notion that, despite tons of evidence otherwise, corporations have gone soft, employees have too much leverage (he's a successful business owner, shocker), and work from home is terrible for nationwide productivity.
- snake_doc 5y agoGDP ~= Capital * Productivity * Labor Population You’re missing an critical component from the Solow model. https://economics.mit.edu/files/7181 https://economics.mit.edu/files/7181
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI wrapped capital up in productivity since machines/software/tools are a facet of how the labor population manifests productive use of time (and to simplify the discussion:) )
- snake_doc 5y agoThe interaction between capital and savings from an aging population is critical, as it delays the impact of population decline on output growth. Japan is an excellent case of when labor population has declined/stagnated since 1990s.
- mrslave 5y agoIf the only thing driving your GDP is new people (and mostly immigration) you don't have a very productive economy. I think this has been the case in a lot of places for a long time, but that statistic just has to go up by the tiniest of amounts and we technically don't have recession and our leaders are doing great, right? It's a huge and disastrous example of Goodhart's Law in action.
- boh 5y agoWe should remember that GDP doesn't reflect the totality of the economic reality on its own. It was popularized at a time of high population growth and the acceleration of mass production, presenting a perfect measure for encapsulating that time's idea of progress. As environmental threats are forcing us to reconsider our consumption habits with future products possibly created with less parts/materials/inputs, people may buy more used items, durability can become more of a priority where things are purchased and kept for a long time, GDP will go down. This however, doesn't reflect the diminishing of economic activity which takes on many forms, but is just one of the indicators which requires further contextualization.
- as_as_Quasqaeme 5y agoWhat are some examples of economic activity that would not be indicated by GDP?
- jansen555 5y ago