8 ms·
Top US corporations raising prices on Americans even as profits surge
- silexia 5y agoThe solution to high prices is simply increasing competition. Eliminate the patent system, remove government regulations and licensing (usually set up by entrenched businesses with regulatory capture), eliminate tariffs.
- throwawaymanbot 5y ago
- ericmay 5y agoI agree that this is a basket of things we could do to increase competition which may reduce prices, but it may also create a whole entirely new host of problems depending on what we change. Eliminating tariffs for example will almost certainly put a lot of Americans out of work who, can't really do much about it. When they don't have jobs and don't have money to pay bills or eat, they'll re enact tariffs, or... start a revolution. The main issue is that all countries in the world don't live on the same playing field. If we got rid of nation states altogether then we wouldn't need a lot of these things.
- jleyank 5y agoOverly naive. Without some form of hardware/drug matter patent a whole lot of things aren't going to get made without direct government funding. Why, for example, should a drug company try to be the first manufacturer of a new drug class given the risk of failure? Why try to invent a new product class - better to clone. Without regulations, there's no consumer protection or guarantee that what's purchased was what was described. Very bad when it comes to biologically active materials and "well, it worked for me" isn't the kind of defence I want to hear in the marketplace. And I'm not sure how that would eliminate costs due to transport or raw materials unless you allow stealing them.
- Proven 5y ago
- cannaceo 5y agoRegulations provide increased safety but at an extremely high cost. In the absence of regulation companies need to build trust with consumers through their reputation and third party auditing. Consumer protection is vastly overrated IMHO. Better to have more affordable healthcare for all than high liability healthcare that only the rich can afford.
- jleyank 5y agoWithout rather strict drug regulation, healthcare of any kind will waste a lot of time dealing with drug overdoses and side-effects-gone-wild. How many unregulated business "build trust" with customers. Walmart sells on cost not trust. And there's simple solutions to healthcare that all nations except the US have found.
- fzeroracer 5y agoI don't understand how people can say this when the pre-existing condition insurance nightmares occurred before regulation stepped in to stop it. For reference: My parents went bankrupt back in 2003 because my mother had a stroke and insurance denied her claims because they called it a pre-existing condition. I think people that claim consumer protection is vastly overrated have never found themselves in a situation where they get fucked over by under-regulated corporations.
- jleyank 5y agoBeing pregnant was a pre-existing condition before ACA, forcing people to carry COBRA for the length of the pregnancy and some more time to allow for complications. Or, you could not switch work until the child was 3-6months old.
- anamax 5y agoI'm having trouble seeing why encouraging women to maintain health insurance throughout pregnancy is a bad thing. Same with chronic problems.
- noTooMooch 5y agoThe solution to high prices is stop using monopolized nation state currency being “loaned out” to us by banks. Remove useless middle men whose role is to “generate value” by charging fees to move money. Money is moved via electrons in machines now. Moving real money is environmentally expensive and let’s grifters nickel and dime for merely acting as custodian for a moment. There are a lot of options and we didn’t save horse and buggy when cars came along; screw the bankers.
- jimnotgym 5y agoPetrol is really expensive compared to any time in the past in the UK, but that is not a primarily patent, licensing or regulatory problem. Isnt the lack of competition there due to the huge capital cost of starting an oil refinery and distribution business in a shrinking market?
- throwaway787544 5y agoRemove regulations and we all suffer. EPA is just one example; regulations stop companies from dumping toxic waste in the ground and sewers where it leads to streams and rivers and ground water, and goes back into our food and water (to say nothing of killing animals and insects which further impacts ecology). Why do you think regulation exists? For fun?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- foolzcrow 5y ago
- danielfoster 5y agoThis analysis glances over the simple reality that corporations not only need to make a profit, but need to make the highest profit possible relative to their peers. Stocks have reached such insane valuations that companies need double-digit growth just to maintain their existing prices Many Americans are still flush with cash from loose monetary policy, pay raises, and COVID savings. So long as they have this cash, companies will keep increasing prices. Companies are also understandably trying to get in as many price increases as they can now because this may not be possible later. And what about when these companies lose money? Should I have paid more for my flight tickets during the pandemic just because I had a higher net worth than United?
- zaptheimpaler 5y agoNo they fundamentally don't. We have chosen to organize society in this particular way, and we could choose differently. Stock ownership is highly concentrated among the rich. When we prioritize the interests of those owners over the customers, the majority lose. Maybe those stocks should crash. Growth by just raising prices isn't really substantive growth for society anyways, it's just moving money from consumers to investors.
- refurb 5y ago56% of Americans own stock and if you roll in pension plans (heavily invested in stocks), your claim that "ownership is highly concentrated among the rich" and "maybe those stocks should collapse" is clearly not based on facts or taking into account the impact. https://news.gallup.com/poll/266807/percentage-americans-owns-stock.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/266807/percentage-americans-own...
- samhw 5y agoThank you. I'm broadly left-wing but I'm tired of how much economic illiteracy is common coin nowadays among the left. That argument reminds me of the exasperating "climate change is caused by the rich because most carbon emissions come from big companies" argument.
- 5y ago
- weezin 5y agoRemember when there was debate over $15 dollar minimum wage and people arguing against it said that would just increase inflation? Well entry level low skill jobs pay over $15 dollars an hour and now we have inflation.
- bin_bash 5y agoAffirming the consequent fallacy: > If Brian had been thrown off the top of the Eiffel Tower, then he would be dead. > Brian is dead. > Therefore, Brian was thrown off the top of the Eiffel Tower.
- pessimizer 5y agoYou're using it as a generalized argument that could be used to cast doubt on anything that is true. If someone makes a prediction if A then B, then we decide to do A and B happens, the duty of people who still believe that A doesn't imply B is to at least speculate about alternate causes of B, not to argue against the concept of cause and effect. I say this as someone who thinks $15 is too low.
- weezin 5y agoOnly one problem, mapping my statement to your example, Brian was thrown off the Eiffel Tower and Brian is dead. Now did Brian land in a net and die of other causes? I guess you have to argue without using random fallacies that don't apply.
- dmamills 5y agoThe suggestion of this comment being that the people making the least are the people causing the problem?
- weezin 5y agoNo, that its not an issue of shear dollars its an issue of prices being targeted toward the people that make the least.
- newbamboo 5y ago“We should just get rid or corporations. And we should get rid of prices too. And profit of any sort should not be tolerated by the Government. We should all have exactly the same possessions and live in identical houses that the Government provides. And these shouldn’t be better for people in the west. We should all have free healthcare too, and unlimited credit that can be used for loans that never have to be repaid.” —The Guardian
- 93po 5y agoThis but unironically
- zaroth 5y ago“Guardian analysis of 100 top US companies percent change from the most recent reported quarterly profits to two years prior.” Gosh, what could possibly be confounding this analysis, I cannot imagine?!
- pfisherman 5y agoDisclaimer: this is all personal opinion and I have no expertise in this area. The fed has been pumping cheap money into the system since 2008 to prop up the values of the housing market and the stock market, which is where the majority of Americans have parked their wealth. Now the chickens have come home to roost. The massive spike in the value of bitcoin should have set off alarm bells as it was a clear sign of excess money sloshing around in the system chasing returns. The sad part is that while things like stimulus and other programs that pumped money into the system were well intentioned, they mostly ended up exacerbating income and wealth inequality as those closest to the banks - who were able to tell a credible investment thesis - got all the money. The perverse part is that this (re)capitalization with cheap ended up creating a multiple of bad debt and asset valuations that we are going to have to pay the price for.
- titzer 5y agoI agree with everything you wrote, except I don't think the programs to pump money into the system were well-intentioned. The Fed knew exactly who they were giving money to and actively chose to prop up their friends. IMHO they should have let the biggest banks crash and relied on the FDIC to protect Joe Schmoe's bank accounts. Financial regulations were designed to keep a wall between investment banks and regular banking activities to wall smaller fish from risk. But there is precious little money based on deposits in the system anymore, it's all debt now, and it's all spiraling out of control.
- bombcar 5y agoThe Fed has been riding a tiger for 70+ years and each year it gets harder to dismount.
- bwestergard 5y agoHuh? There have multiple structural changes in the fundamentals of the economy over the last seventy years. The problems the Fed faced from 1945-1975 - with explosive growth, the services share of employment relatively low, wages following productivity - were entirely different from those faced subsequently.
- unmole 5y agoSo, this is a relative comparison between Q1 2020 and Q1 2022. Remind me, did anything important unfold in Q1 2020? Edit: I don't understand. Parts of it are referencing 2019 vs 2021, other are talking about 2020 vs 2022. Why? And they claim 111400% quarterly profit growth for Mattel. How much did they jack up the price of Barbies to increase profit more than a thousand fold? None of this makes sense.
- bombcar 5y agoI wonder if they’re not correctly accounting for warehoused stock - or if they’re doing something silly like comparing a very small profit (or even a loss) during Covid to being back to making a profit now. MAT DEC 2021 - REV 1.79B INCOME 225.83M MAT SEP 2021 - REV 1.76B INCOME 795.08M MAT JUN 2021 - REV 1.03B INCOME -5.54M MAT MAR 2021 - REV 0.87B INCOME -112.38M MAT DEC 2020 - REV 1.63B INCOME 129.05M
- throwaway787544 5y agoWelcome to capitalism, where greed is literally the entire point
- mechE321 5y agoThe stock market has been doing terribly lately, so I wonder what dynamic is going on right now- even with higher profits something is fishy (high interest rates mean a higher yield on bond investments as an alternative, so lower valuations?)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- reducesuffering 5y agoYes, the last part. Stock market profits are still growing, it's that P/E multiples are being reset due to the alternative of safer higher interest rates on bonds and cash. Plus there's recessionary fears from global issues like the ongoing invasion of Ukraine and China's lockdowns potentially major shuttering of global supply.
- camgunz 5y agoI'm not an expert at all, but my understanding of inflation is that it's due largely to a handful of things: - Housing prices are bonkers due to chickens coming home to roost on lots of policies (lack of tradespeople due to cultural stigma and wage inequality/social welfare state for contractors, bad zoning and NIMBY-ism, non-existent public transit, education policy creating 30% very bad schools, 65% mediocre schools, 5% good schools, and very expensive private schools). - Supply chain shocks due to COVID. - Oil went bananas. A couple of things that might be undersold: - A lot of people left major cities and have lower/zero housing costs. - A lot of people aren't paying their student loans (heard this costs the US $4-5 billion/mo, which is quite a stimulus package). A couple of things I think it probably isn't: Stimulus/Rescue: I heard a stat on a podcast that said the vast majority (maybe 2/3?) was unspent, so it seems unlikely this is a major driver. Wage growth is pretty interesting. Reading about it, it seems like a lot of people left the labor market or switched to lower-demand roles/careers. People take this fact and say "see, labor supply went down relative to demand and the price went up". But if you've got 10 employees costing you $1m/yr and three quit, leaving you with 7 employees costing you $1m/yr, sure wages went up, but not overall? I haven't seen this kind of analysis out there, so I wonder if there's some politicizing by the "we need low inflation at the cost of unemployment" people towards the "we need full employment at the cost of inflation" people.
- sicp-enjoyer 5y ago> Housing prices are bonkers due to chickens coming home I think low interest rates might be the largest factor here. Purchasing decisions are made based on the monthly payment.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThe interest rates certainly factor into high home prices, but really it just comes down to supply and demand. We haven't been building enough houses, especially where people want to live.
- camgunz 5y agoDefinitely, but I think that's because of the lack of tradespeople and the barriers involved in building new houses. It's hard to build multi-unit-dwellings in cities now, so if you ever get an opportunity you're building a luxury megaplex to squeeze the max profit out of it. And sure you can look further out, but then you're looking at school district problems, lack of public transit, lack of amenities like grocery stores, restaurants, theaters, shops, culture centers. I think a lot of this probably boils down to our insistence that cars be huge parts of our lives? It's really incompatible with the 15-minute city just because of the space requirements (parking at destinations, parking at homes, street width), and let's not forget maintenance costs and noise/pollution externalities. But I guess in the face of no public transit, what are we supposed to do?
- clarkmoody 5y agoClickbait headline is clickbait. Flag and move on. > Guardian analysis of 100 top US companies percent change from the most recent reported quarterly profits to two years prior.
- mimikatz 5y agoPricing is based on what people will pay, not what a thing costs to produce. This has always been true.
- bombcar 5y agoProduction costs put a floor in pricing, but no ceiling - though if you extract too much profit someone may compete. Which is why companies love regulations once they’re in - widens the moat and keeps competitors out.
- routerl 5y agoOkay, but it turns out that people will pay whatever it takes to keep food, water, and shelter. So if price analysis were as simple as you seem to think, everyone will eventually be completely emiserated by spending the entirety of their income on simply staying alive. Which is why we have laws to keep prices close to "what a thing costs to produce", and companies can't just take advantage of inflation to raise their profit margins; since, when they've historically done this, it kills a ton of people.
- sicp-enjoyer 5y ago> whatever it takes to keep food, water, and shelter. There are still economizing responses. When certain foods are expensive, people search for alternatives. When housing is expensive people move in with family or get roomates. With gas people carpool and drive less. I don't want to suggest those are good outcomes, just that there is a response function.
- mimikatz 5y agoYes, I should have been more clear what people will pay compared to substitutions available and competition in the marketplace for that good.
- HigherPlain 5y agoI think everything you typed appears to be wrong? For instance there are no laws keeping prices close to producer price. That task is done by the competitive marketplace in capitalism. In socialism/communism the price is controlled by authoritarianism, which is why those regimes are marked by mass shortages and starvation.
- cryptica 5y agoThey're not raising prices to make more profit. It's just to try to tame inflation. They're intentionally trying to cause hardship to make people more desperate for fiat so that they work harder for less money. But IMO it's not going to work because it's well-off corporate employees who are causing most of the inflation. Those corporate employees won't be feeling the squeeze so it's misdirected. I predict that inflation will keep increasing and big corporations are going to squeeze the productive working class harder and harder... A recipe for a revolution.
- salford 5y ago"What determines the price a company sets for its product?" My intuition about this is that a consumer will only buy a product if they value it more than its price, and a company will only sell it if it cost less than its price. So the price is inherently some point in between the buyer and seller's value of each item. If the price equals the buyer's value, then the seller gets all the profits, and the buyer benefits zero. If the price equals the seller's value, then the seller gets zero profits, and the buyer gets all the benefits. What determines this tradeoff? The long answer involves me learning some basic microeconomics with the help of https://courses.lumenlearning.com/suny-microeconomics/ https://courses.lumenlearning.com/suny-microeconomics/. Maybe one day I will write a longer blog post about it, but I'm still not sure I fully understand the answer. I am still not an economic expert, but here is my attempted answer to practice my micro thinking: the goal of companies is to maximize profits. If they can raise prices while increasing profits, they will do so! The only thing stopping them from doing so is competition from other companies. Depending on whether you have "perfect competition", "monopolistic competition", or flat-out monopoly, their ability to do so will differ. For the companies examined in the article, most of the companies experience monopolistic or imperfect competition. The fact that they can increase profits by increasing prices shows that people have more money to spend than they used to (makes sense, due to pandemic saving, stimulus, and a tight labor market and inflation leading to wage growth). Prices will increase until consumers feel enough pain that they transition back to whatever previous mix of thrifty and luxury goods they were using before the pandemic. Is that right? But then this analysis leads to even more questions...
- missedthecue 5y ago"Guardian analysis of 100 top US companies percent change from the most recent reported quarterly profits to two years prior." Wow. Incredibly misleading journalism. This is terrible. They are comparing today with April 2020. Seemingly arbitrarily. I wonder if anything was going on in April 2020 that may have depressed the net profits of companies like Chevron (on their list). Wasn't oil at -39 dollars per barrel in April 2020? Chevron doesn't even set or raise prices on the cost of a barrel of crude oil which contradicts their entire point anyway. I know the Guardian has a certain bias but this is basically misinformation with data.