12 ms·
Long-term risks of surgery: ‘It gives people’s brains a hard time’
- _bfhp 5y agoMany detransitioners are raising the concerns about the psychological effects of more and more surgery on young people to actualize their true selves. This is counter to the prevailing narrative that every surgery that a young person might have is reversible down the line through more surgery.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zarzavat 5y agoI honestly think that people in the future are going to view gender reassignment surgeries in the same way that we view FGM today. There doesn’t seem to be any possible evidential basis for gender reassignment surgery on non-intersex individuals, compared to the alternative of non-surgical intervention, and it seems that it should be considered unethical for surgeons to offer it.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoI’ve always read that it was the best treatment option. Do you have studies that say otherwise?
- sugary 5y ago> This is counter to the prevailing narrative that every surgery that a young person might have is reversible down the line through more surgery. Indeed and it's a very harmful narrative even without detransitioner concerns. Once you've had your breasts lopped off, or womb removed, or - if male - penis and scrotum fashioned into a pelvic cavity, no amount of further surgery can reverse this. Those organs are gone permanently.
- xyzzy21 5y agoAnd then you add this to the universal surgical risk of abdominal fistulas. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZKMBWOBbyws https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZKMBWOBbyws You seriously want to ponder whether you should get any surgery at all...
- snek_case 5y agoThis article suggests that inflammation in response to the surgery is the problem, but as far as I know, anesthesia itself is very dangerous. It can reduce the amount of oxygen the brain is getting for several hours, and if the brain doesn't get enough oxygen, neurons can die. Some of the cognitive changes following anesthesia could be brain tissue death due to the anesthesia itself. Careful dosage and monitoring is required, and you should probably get local anesthesia if possible. Anesthesia kills brain cells, but what does it mean? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5119529 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5119529
- etaioinshrdlu 5y agoAre all types of general anesthesia equally dangerous? I believe that some of them work in different ways. I suspect we could find a less dangerous way.
- snek_case 5y agoI agree. It's a bit tricky to study these things because you can't necessarily (ethically) assign people to different trial groups and use different dosages, but just recording data on what type of anesthesia was used and doing a subsequent followup a few months later could already be valuable.
- lazerpants 5y agoThe article you reference is specifically on very young mice, and does not attempt to prove that this happens in adult brains of mice or humans.
- uuyi 5y agoMy father definitely suffered after recent vascular surgery. They had to put him under a second time because of a bleed and do the whole procedure again. Hasn’t been the same since.
- iancmceachern 5y agoI believe the culprit is "Pump Head". Not the inflammation thing they mention, not the anesthesia. Heart lung bypass machines, ECMO systems, they all use non-pulsatile continuous flow pumps. These pumps do not have the same pressure curve and higher pressure pulses that the native circulation does. This causes blood to not make it all the way down to the capillaries, and therefore starves brain tissue that is fed by the smallest of the capillaries. To solve this problem, a company I helped called Ventriflo has been working to build a pulsatile pump that can be used for both ECMO and cardiopulmonary bypass uses. https://ventriflo.com/ https://ventriflo.com/
- nicolas_t 5y agoMy father had a significant cognitive decline after two surgeries within 6 months of each other (Cardiac Ablation). The second surgery resulted in septicimia so the inflammation is definitely a factor but both me and my mother also noted decline after the first surgery. It was very obvious in term of decline, my father had trouble with doing some tasks on his computer (when he never did before having been an early adopter and programming some educational software for schools in the 80s), he no longer could concentrate enough when reading and became more extreme in his politics (he went from voting from the parti socialiste and being mostly center left to being very left wing). He also had less control over his emotions and would sometimes explode in a rage unlike anything he had before. He himself felt diminished mentally and that greatly bothered him during the last years of his life. On my side, I've refused general anaesthesia as much as I can because it scares me deeply. When I was a kid, I had an operation under general anaesthesia and I woke up with a very strong asthma attack, completely unable to breathe. Reading this, it does give argument towards my stance to asking for local anaesthesia as much as possible.
- xhkkffbf 5y agoHave you had much luck convincing doctors to go with locals? A doctor who did colonoscopies said that they needed to use a general for their own convenience. Everyone just went along and so that became the standard.
- PawBer 5y agoHaving the patient awake is a liability. It's understandable that doctors don't want to take the risk.
- pge 5y agoNot OP, but I have convinced a surgeon not to use a general for shoulder surgery. I was fortunate to have had a previous surgery with a doctor that avoided general when he could, so I knew it could be done and that it worked well for me. To bolster my case, I found research papers showing that recovery from the surgery I was having was faster and better with a local nerve block + sedative instead of a general. The nurses tried to convince me I was wrong and making a bad choice, and the doctor would not do the surgery unless I agreed that he could use general if he felt he had to in the middle of the surgery. But then he did the surgery, did not have to use the general, and thanked me, because he said he was going to start doing more surgeries without general.
- blamestross 5y agoHonestly, Modern Medicine doesn't provide good evidence or reasoning for people around risks like surgery. From the systemic point of view, frequentist statistics permit doctors and policy-writers to consider risks, but an individual doesn't get to re-play the experiment 1000s of times to get results that represent the statistics. You don't get to try again if you get a complication or die on the table but your doctor and the system do. The very human desire to regain "health" and comfort combined with a not unreasonable pitch from a doctor tend to override that rationale hesitance. Risking death or further disability to be freed of pain and discomfort is an oddly acceptable risk.
- whatshisface 5y agoI agree with you overall but going after statistics as the problem is a flawed way to make that point. If you commute to work on the road you're taking accumulated risks equal to many surgeries, and if you aren't making those decisions based on statistics you're making them based on what people around you consider normal. 1% risk that everybody takes is just as dangerous as one only taken by yourself.
- blamestross 5y agoThe statistics don't actually tell you YOUR risk. They tell if the risk a population has on average collectively. Your personal risks could be much higher or lower, and quantifying them is basically impossible. It only makes sense to use the "average" risk level for reasoning if the sampled population is particularly representative of you, which is vanishingly unlikely due to the "curse of dimensionality". It makes a lot of sense to decide public policy of how driving should be managed based on those statistics, but is hilariously inappropriate to base your decision to get in a car and drive based on them.
- whatshisface 5y ago>It makes a lot of sense to decide public policy of how driving should be managed based on those statistics, but is hilariously inappropriate to base your decision to get in a car and drive based on them. Driving and surgery both involve a lot of risks you can do nothing about, making statistics (selected for your demographic, of course) the most you can know. Statistics are not a good way to predict whether one's self will buy a red shirt or a green shirt (when you can know exactly what you will do because you are deciding), but you have no say in whether or not your anesthesiologist will guess the right dose or whether your surgeon will put the sutures in exactly the right positions to stop a post-op bleed. The same goes for most accidents, which are called "accidents" because culpable negligence is actually pretty rare.
- jagger27 5y agoI’ve been under general anaesthesia four times and I felt absolutely awful all but one of those times. The dosage in the most recent one was so perfect that I actually remember every moment after waking up from surgery, and I was awake enough to thank the anaesthetist for having a light touch. It really is a crapshoot and/or an art. It’s not surprising that people are having long term cognitive complications from having our brains forcefully shut down.
- dannyw 5y agoAnecdota: I am in my 20s and got turbinate reduction surgery under general anaesthia about two years ago. While difficult to isolate from the effects of the pandemic, I observed a significant reduction in my ability to recall memories and the level of detail. Still, it's worth being able to breathe through my nose at night — and the benefits that brings (including to my dental health, as I was getting cavities multiple times a year despite me trying keeping my dental health impeccable; which now have stopped after a year post surgery).
- selectodude 5y agoAn opposite data point, I had significant back surgery and the only cognitive decline I dealt with was a mild opiate addiction that I had to kick a month post-op. But that was on me.
- azalemeth 5y agoI had a four hour operation on my knee late last year. I still don't feel like I've got my short term memory back. Glad to know it isn't just me.
- joeman1000 5y agoI’m the same age, has the same procedure and I’m feeling the same effects… I hope we can get better.
- marliechiller 5y agodamn, noticed the same effect here!
- MarcoZavala 5y ago
- BitwiseFool 5y agoI'm not a hypochondriac, but from time to time I will become preoccupied with health related things. It has never occurred to me that anesthesia might in some way be harmful or potentially result in cognitive decline. I'm now afraid I might get a false positive feeling that my mind isn't as sharp after my next surgery (whatever it may be).
- crate_barre 5y agoThere’s better sources on this study, but here is one: https://www.denverpost.com/2014/06/16/attitude-can-play-significant-role-in-recovery-from-paralyzing-injury/amp/ https://www.denverpost.com/2014/06/16/attitude-can-play-sign... It can be very easy to fall into a depressive spiral. Your outlook on the situation can matter.
- giantg2 5y ago"can cause degradation of the cholinergic system in the brain, which is involved in learning and memory – but it has proven hard to study this in humans." Why is it so hard? I would think a citicholine supplement could be administered to examine this hypothesis, unless the hypothesis is that utilization of choline is somehow blocked.
- ipnon 5y agoAnesthesia requires massive doses of drugs we normally consider unconscionably dangerous in public discourse: Fentanyl, propofol, Xanax, ketamine. The anesthesiologist's job is to use a slurry of these drugs to bring you to the brink of death, and then hold you over the abyss by your ankles. All of this is done to perform gross physiological trauma on your body, which your CNS responds to readily as we know from the phenomenon of people waking up during surgery. We seem to think surgery under general anesthesia is not a life changing event because we don't remember it.
- copperx 5y agoI'm sorry, but even though anesthesia seems to impair cognition, it's nothing like you describe. One can certainly die from anesthesia, but it is incredibly rare. Anesthesia is very safe when dosed correctly.
- BizarroLand 5y agoI also want to say that Anesthesiologists don't always "bring you to the brink of death, and then hold you over the abyss by your ankles". That would be silly. Maybe for open heart surgery or brain surgery or some other extremely dangerous surgery where if you were to wake up the shock could kill you, but that would be overkill for a broken arm that needs pins to heal or for an appendectomy done with endoscopic tools. Knocking you out and keeping you under would be more than enough for that.
- wnissen 5y agoThe point of anesthesia is to shut down all the conscious parts of your brain and many of the unconscious ones. It's a fundamentally difficult task, and by a lot of standards you are in real trouble during it.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> Anesthesia requires massive doses of drugs we normally consider unconscionably dangerous in public discourse: Fentanyl, propofol, Xanax, ketamine. Recreational, unsupervised self-administration of those drugs in recreational contexts is nothing like carefully measured and monitored administration in a hospital context. An Anesthesiologist carefully administering calculated doses of Fentanyl to a fasted patient who is being directly monitored and surrounded by professionals capable of emergency resuscitation has almost nothing in common with an opioid addict taking a random dose of what they've been told is Fentanyl. Don't get unnecessary surgeries, obviously, but don't confuse surgical intervention with drug abuse.
- etiam 5y agoA variation of this has had me preoccupied a few days already, on account of a study making headlines recently ( https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanres/article/PIIS2213-2600(22)00127-8/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanres/article/PIIS2213-2... ) finding that a mere ~29% of hospitalized COVID-19 patients consider themselves fully recovered a year later. No doubt some of that really is due to the virus, but it would be interesting to know for reference how many perfectly healthy people would be in that state just from going though the treatment.
- vmception 5y ago> Operations can have cognitive side-effects, particularly in the over-65s but also in the very young I’m going to need every medical professional to define “young” at the beginning of their articles, abstracts and research papers from now on. It was about 2 years ago today when I realized this isnt the same word or context as the general population and the communication skills of that entire industry is inadequate for ever saying anything to the public.
- tsol 5y agoThe probably mean infants-- the -flurane anesthetics that are often used causes brain damage in infants 6 months and below
- tristor 5y agoEvery time I've been under general anesthesia it's been a horrible experience. I usually have a severe asthma attack during recovery and have uncontrollable nausea for 3-5 days afterwards. I have certainly noticed that there are mental effects as well, but I believe they subside within 30 days. This does concern me though, because I have chronic health issues and likely will need more work as I get older.
- y-c-o-m-b 5y agoI am in dire need of back and ankle surgery, but I don't ever want to go under anesthesia again. When I had emergency surgery on my cervical spine years ago, I nearly died during the process of waking from anesthesia. As I was waking, I had a swarm of nurses yelling over me that I'm not breathing and my heart rate being dangerously high. They kept yelling for me to breathe, but I could barely understand their words due to the anesthesia grogginess, let alone force some biological function that should be involuntary to occur. After several injections of god knows what into my IV line and several minutes of frantic people gathering around me trying to figure out how to keep me from dying, I luckily started stabilizing. From that moment on though, my heart has never been the same. I developed an arrhythmia which they intially told me was due to the anesthesia and should go away within a week, but it has never gone away. Pre-surgery I had a stable idle heart rate - around 65 bpm - and now it fluctuates randomly between 50 and 115 every minute; again that's just sitting and doing nothing. My holter monitor tests showed many many episodes of both tachycardia and bradycardia as well as PVCs and PACs (palpitations). I've been looking into "awake" surgeries lately for my back, so hopefully that will be a reasonable option for most things in the near future.
- pmoriarty 5y agoShouldn't there have been an anesthesiologist there to make sure you can breathe? They can stick tubes down your throat and mechanically "breathe" for you, if you need it. Don't know why it wasn't done in your case, if you really couldn't breathe for yourself.
- y-c-o-m-b 5y agoThat's a great question, I'm not sure. Could it be because I just had neck surgery and they didn't want to risk infection or damage to the area? I don't have the medical knowledge to know if incompetence factored into the situation at all, but I suspect it did.
- kradeelav 5y agoVery interested in the papers and the discussion happening with general anesthesia being used on young kids. Relatedly: had ~15 surgeries before the age of seven back in the 90's when there was zero notion of these nuances, and there's not a small part of me that wants to slide in a mention of "Hey, a lot of this could be second-order effects of medical/ICU CPTSD". Typically the kiddos coming in for multiple surgeries already have a few major medical issues - and so bouncing back from "multiple" operations paints a lot different picture than just one clean-and-done one.
- 8bitsrule 5y agoA close relative in their early 70s had a relatively safe (3 in 1000 have complications) laparoscopic organ removal. All looked well until the massive stroke (from a blood clot) an hour later. No chance of recovery. This is major surgery. Be prepared for possible consequences. [https://www.medicalprotection.org/southafrica/casebook/casebook-may-2012/the-risks-of-laparoscopic-surgery- https://www.medicalprotection.org/southafrica/casebook/caseb...]
- thehappypm 5y agoThis is a bit of an anecdote, but my mother-in-law had some back pain, and she came home one day and said that she was going to have a spinal fusion surgery. We ended up doing a little bit of research on the surgery, and it turns out is unbelievably invasive, you were literally bolting your vertebrae together, and we recommend that she got a second opinion. The second doctor she went to was literally horrified that it was suggested and she ended up getting a cortisone shot (I think?) that dramatically reduced her symptoms to a manageable level and she’s been low-pain for half a decade.
- oversocialized 5y ago
- kurupt213 5y agoWhat’s really horrifying is that they will use a PA or NP instead of a real anesthesiologist to save money
- rajnathani 5y agoMaybe relevant recent study about anaesthesia: https://medicalxpress.com/news/2022-04-anesthetic-drastically-brain.html https://medicalxpress.com/news/2022-04-anesthetic-drasticall...