8 ms·
>> He's already said that he'd follow all local laws Is Twitter available in on of the following countries? China, Saudi-Arabia, Russia, Turkey? Since we know
by hef19898 5y ago
>> He's already said that he'd follow all local laws
Is Twitter available in on of the following countries? China, Saudi-Arabia, Russia, Turkey? Since we know the answer I'm looking forward to see how helping those local governments go after "dissidents" will be aligned with Musk's high ideals of free speech.
- hickimsedenolan 5y agoIt is available in Turkey.
- hef19898 5y agoExactly! And in Turkey people get charged with supporting terrorism by tweeting negative stuff about Erdogan. On the surface of it, Musk should be against that, free speech and all that. Supporting local law would mean supporting authorities in finding those users. One way out would be to just retreat from, in this example, Turkey. But since this whole affaire started with "ElonsJet" refusing to shut down, and Musks reaction was a teenagers "Then I'll buy this company and fire you", I'm inclined to believe free speech is going to be ok as long Musk is criticized.
- recuter 5y ago> Exactly! And in Turkey people get charged with supporting terrorism by tweeting negative stuff about Erdogan. Sadly, not just in Turkey but increasingly in what you'd consider developed "western" countries. This is concerning. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2021/14/introduction/enacted https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2021/14/introduction/enac... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech_by_country Certainly he could retreat from places like Turkey and China. Alas, increasingly there is nowhere left to run. You can be inclined to believe what you want, we can just wait and see what happens no?
- kubb 5y ago> Sadly, not just in Turkey but increasingly in what you'd consider developed "western" countries. This is concerning. Bullsh*t alert! Name one western country that charges people for terrorism for criticizing Erdogan.
- kubb 5y agoEvery single answer to this has moved the goalpost by the way. Unbelievable.
- namecheapTA 5y agoYou can get locked up for very mild 'hate speech' in the UK. And I don't even mean hate speech, but posting "I hate these people and this is why", not "violent acts towards so and so!"
- nailer 5y agoA Scottish man in the UK was recently charged with saying the only good British soldier is a dead one.
- kubb 5y agowhat a legend, what did they charge him with?
- recuter 5y agohttps://www.theverge.com/2022/3/31/23004339/uk-twitter-user-sentenced-grossly-offensive-tweet-tom-moore-joseph-kelly https://www.theverge.com/2022/3/31/23004339/uk-twitter-user-... Twitter user sentenced to 150 hours of community service in UK for posting ‘offensive’ tweet
- OrlandoHakim 5y agoIn Canada, protestors had their bank accounts frozen for saying mean things about Trudeau. It's not exactly the same as your example but it does rhyme.
- mardifoufs 5y agoIt's better to stick to local rules than getting a clique in silicon valley to decide what they think should be acceptable to say. He said he wants more free speech, not to break the laws of foreign countries. If twitter was already doing just the minimum required by law, and Elon said he still wanted more free speech you'd have a point. But they go far beyond that! This has nothing to do with elonjets btw and if that's the worst example you can come up with... you'd be just convincing those who think that Twitter's moderation policy is horrible. Because for them, a dude censoring people who track him (which won't happen anyways imo) is still insanely better than the current policy that they deem is used to supress entire ideas/events.
- lostlogin 5y ago> It's better to stick to local rules than getting a clique in silicon valley to decide what they think should be acceptable to say. In SV you don’t get locked up or suicided if you say the wrong thing. Following the law in some of the places listed above would have Musk help identify those breaking local laws.
- mardifoufs 5y agoAgreed. I'm not saying they should, just that they have to follow the laws. But they don't have to police their platform according to what an extremely sheltered SV-adjacent elite thinks should be okay. It's not an either/or question, they can not bend down to police states and also not let that minority have the last say over what is okay or not across the entire globe.
- tekknik 5y agoWhat is your solution then? If twitter weren’t available, do you think you’d see more or less people speaking against their gov? You’ll also see some people in this thread asking for identity verification. Which shows the value of anonymous posting. Perhaps we should make twitter much like HN and not require identifiable information that links to a real person?
- 5y ago
- ceeplusplus 5y agoThe entire point is that the _platform_ should not be doing the censoring. The local government can legally, according to their bogus laws, jail and censor their own population, but the platform should allow those posts to appear in the first place. So stuff like "hate speech" (what exactly does Twitter define as hate speech?) should not be censored.
- Nathanba 5y agoit really doesn't require such extreme examples. The EU will also ask for all kinds of censorship. Germany just made wearing the 'Z' illegal, meaning that any kind of pro-russian viewpoint will have to be censored. There is only one country on earth that has decent free speech and it's the US
- raxxorraxor 5y agoI hope nobody listens to the German government on speech rules and nobody should. There should be a rule that you have to make it through 1 century without creating 2 dictatorships before you can even say anything about allowed or forbidden speech. And no, none of these dictatorships had anything close to free expression like some people hilariously and tragically suggested.
- mmmmmbop 5y agoWhich are the two dictatorships you are thinking about? Your proposed rule might be unpractical, since it would disallow the U.S. government from from saying anything about free speech for at least 30 more years (see [1] and [2]). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9ta... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1954_Guatemalan_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1954_Guatemalan_coup_d%27%C3%A...
- School-Cotton 5y agoThey presumably meant the Nazi period (1933-1945) and the period of SED rule in East Germany (1949-1990).
- robonerd 5y agoIt's a sliver over a hundred years ago now, but Germany was also under a military dictatorship lead by Hindenburg and Ludendorff from 1916 through 1918.
- afro88 5y agoHe'll do both. Free speech in countries that have laws that allow/support it. But the thing everyone forgets is that he has very strong ties to the US government. From a free speech perspective, this is as good as the government taking over twitter, but much better PR