10 ms·
Pushing back against contract demands is scary but please try anyway
- stjohnswarts 5y agoI always push back. Usually I just mark out the parts I don't like (or add to the contract!) and initial them and send it back for them to fix. If they don't want to fix it then I wish them all the best with their project and look elsewhere.
- phsource 5y ago> If the employer is a good one, they want the contract to be fair, and if the contract is unfair it's probably by accident. This definitely sounds about right -- I'm pretty sure most places I worked and most other Y Combinator companies in my batch just took the standard forms from somewhere (e.g., the Orrick forms library) and used them, without thinking too much about the terms. [1] If there's something in the terms that actually seem objectionable, it's likely the hiring manager, recruiter, and other people in your recruiting process have never thought about it either. By pointing it out, you're often educating them too on what the offer letter says, and providing valuable feedback for the recruiting process. [1] https://www.orrick.com/en/Total-Access/Tool-Kit/Start-Up-Forms/Employment-and-Consultant https://www.orrick.com/en/Total-Access/Tool-Kit/Start-Up-For...
- djbusby 5y agoSo, it's a bug and counter-party are testers?
- phsource 5y agoYeah, that's pretty much it -- usually nobody stress-tested this before they just sent it out in a rush to employee #1, who's probably a referral anyways
- hodgesrm 5y agoAlso, good contracts are difficult to write. There are templates for most contract types but it can take a while to work out the kinks. IP clauses around open source, for example, are incredibly hard to get right. We've had multiple iterations on this topic at my company.
- Buttons840 5y agoI wish a lawyer would write up some standard verbage the industry could all agree on for this common clause in contracts. Put it on a pretty webpage with an explanation of how it's fair and protects both parties. Include some horror stories people can point to to disarm the "it doesn't matter" argument. I'd rather see the contract say that work delivered to the company belongs to the company, no exception. This protects the companies future interests, they clearly own everything their employees have delivered. A conflict-of-interest clause, a NDA, and a clause stating I can't take company data to use elsewhere can cover all other concerns without limiting my ability to be a free individual in my free time.
- satisfice 5y agoI can’t run a consulting company unless I get to own the ideas I produce. However, I offer a non-exclusive license to the client. And of course anything that is outright confidential stays with them.
- Buttons840 5y agoFair. I was thinking more about standard W2 employees who rarely think about contracts, they're the ones that need a simple website for reference and help. Consultants are familiar with contracts and can make educated contract decisions on their own.
- rhubarbcustard 5y agoI travelled a fair distance to sign a contract with a third-party that I was contracting though for a major bank. They handed me a bunch of documents to sign and left me in a room for a while, I read them all thoroughly (took hours) and flagged up several things that were just plain wrong, stuff that made no sense and, similar to the OP, some clauses that suggested they wanted my first-born. They were happy to change the details to fit what I wanted and we all went away happy. The thing that surprised me was when their intiial response was, "No-one has ever mentioned these before and we've been using these for years". I mean, the wording of the contracts could have gone very badly for me if things had gone south and we ended up in court. Kind of makes me wonder if anyone actually bothers to read what they are signing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mooreds 5y ago> Kind of makes me wonder if anyone actually bothers to read what they are signing. Nope, not typically, in my experience. I'm one of the folks who does, and it usually catches the other folks by surprise. I signed a contract for a blog post I was writing and in the contract it said I couldn't mention that I was working with said company. But they were going to put my name on the blog post? I asked the person who sent me the contract, "should I not share this blog post?". They changed the contract with no issues, but it showed me that they were just using a standard contract that no one ever bothered to read.
- nkrisc 5y ago> Kind of makes me wonder if anyone actually bothers to read what they are signing. A lot of times, no. It happens to me even. I’m not a lawyer and I’m asked to sign contracts written by lawyers for other lawyers. I’ma reasonably smart guy and I can usually put two and two together in a contract, but often it’s written in a way that simply very difficult for me to understand and I can’t really tell what the contact is saying. It’s a burden. If the stakes are small I might just sign it. Otherwise I might ask for clarification but most times you’re asked to sign something it’s assumed you’ll just take a minute to sign it so now you’ve thrown everything off. I understand why contacts need precise language but I think it’s a bit unfair to expect lay people to sign contracts without a lawyer present much of the time.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- satisfice 5y agoI always have a contract when I teach my classes or consult. I always protect my IP. They can pay me for ideas or coding, but I only grant full ownership to IP that pertains uniquely to their business. Anything “generic to software testing” is an idea I own and grant them a non-exclusive and perpetual license to. I also push back on drug tests and insurance requirements and background checks, although for the right money I will relent.
- mpettitt 5y agoThis is such a good point. I've been pushing back for quite a while, and have generally had a positive response where the company revises the contract wording to a more acceptable level. I feel that the principle of least privilege would be a good point for employment contracts to start, rather than the current approach of "try get control over everything employee might think of whilst employed, even if it's during their own time and unrelated to the business"
- throwaway81523 5y ago> "try get control over everything employee might think of whilst employed, even if it's during their own time and unrelated to the business" That is illegal in California, and California contracts I've seen have mentioned that.
- ccleve 5y agoThere are a couple of techniques that I have used in the past that have worked well. First, don't edit the proposed contract itself. Instead, add a rider that specifically overrides the provisions you don't like. Something like "Intellectual Property. Work produced by employee shall be considered work-for-hire. 'Work" is defined as..." Then add a line to the bottom of the rider that says "If any portion of this rider is in conflict with the main contract, the terms of the rider will override the terms of the contract." The benefit of this approach is that you avoid the back-and-forth niggling over particular words in the main contract, and you often overcome the other party's resistance to changing the language their lawyers said had to be there. It's stupid, but it works. The second technique is simply to say, "this contract isn't large enough to justify these provisions. If you would like to bump the contract, we can talk. Otherwise, no." This has worked for me in negotiating software licenses. I haven't tried it in an employment situation. It works because it forces the other side to acknowledge that their demands have costs, and they can have what they want only if they pay for it. They never do. I am not a lawyer. Heed this advice at your own risk.
- willhinsa 5y agoThis sounds like great advice. Thank you for the ideas!
- hodgesrm 5y ago#2 is absolutely great. It's particularly useful to justify limitations of liability.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Buttons840 5y agoI'm not a lawyer, and don't know how the first suggestion would work with contracts that say things like "this represents the entire contract, any additions or addendums are void". If the main portion of the contract says "all additions are invalid", and an addition says "this addition overrides the main contract", which one wins?
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoLet's talk about "unlimited PTO" -- I'm seeing more of this in my half-hearted job search and I'm really wary about it. I'd like to get my prospective employer to agree in writing to a certain number of days that would be considered normal/acceptable PTO, so I don't a) feel guilty for taking that amount and b) get shafted in performance assessments for taking a normal amount. Has anybody had any luck getting a prospective employer who advertises "unlimited PTO" to do this in contract negotiation phase? Basically I don't want to just rely on the goodwill of said new employer to treat me respectfully for taking a good chunk of said PTO, and I want to define what is reasonable expectations up-front.
- rebeccaskinner 5y agoA lot of places have a "mandatory minimum" and that might be the phrase to ask about.
- macksd 5y agoThis is a good idea. I've had two employers with "unlimited PTO". One of them explicitly set an expectation that I was expected to take at least 4 weeks per year. And it wasn't in writing, but everyone was told this, so there's "witnesses" which is better than nothing. This actually worked really well, and everyone seemed to take an appropriate amount of time, but no one was explicitly keeping track or expecting you to fill out paperwork just to take a break. Another employer said you needed to talk to your manager and justify time off with regards to results, and the timing of your break, relative to releases, etc. In this scenario I hardly took any time off, but folks who clearly didn't care about their manager took SO MUCH. Learn from me, though: they never gave me the promotion I was chasing anyway.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoFrankly, over my 20 year career, I've learned the best way to get promotions is to switch jobs.
- metadat 5y ago
- rebeccaskinner 5y agoI've been pushing back against these IP ownership clauses for years, although the last couple of years they seem to have gotten much less common. Generally, most companies I've talked to have been very happy to make a change to the contract, but you have to explicitly ask them to do it. If you simply bring up that there's a problem with the contract, most recruiters and hiring managers default to empathy-but-inaction. I think that it doesn't really occur to people that you _can_ change the contract unless you specifically ask about it. I also think it's helpful to realize that for a lot of companies, they are pretty happy to change an employment contract, you can make the process a lot nicer for everyone if you given them a heads up early in the process that you intend to review the documents and might ask for changes. Most recruiters I've worked with have been happy to send over all of the standard documents well ahead of a final offer so that I have time to review them, and it gives them a chance to get changes made before you actually sit down to fill out the final versions of all of the paperwork (but still review the version you are actually signing). I will say that while my experiences negotiating these things have generally been good, I've also specifically avoided larger companies that have a reputation for overreaching IP ownership clauses. If a startup has an overly broad ownership clause, it's quite likely that they are just using a form contract and didn't think too much about it. If large company with thousands of developers has a similar clause, I'm much more likely to assume it's intentional and simply not interview to save myself the trouble of trying to negotiate with a behemoth.
- mooreds 5y agoSo important to do! Make sure you exclude anything you have previously written or thought about writing. Make sure you understand the employee handbook, which is often included by association. It seems fair to me that anything I do 'off the clock' on hardware I own is mine, though of course you need to respect any confidentiality agreements you sign too.
- drawkbox 5y agoNever sign a non-compete. Non-competes, the most anti-innovation, anti-skilled worker, anti-free market, anti-business and anti-American thing in working today. Non-competes are protectionism for larger businesses over small/medium businesses and try to own employees skills that they may have brought to the company or client themselves. As a freelancer, contractor and self-employed business owner/worker, please make these illegal, tired of these. The worst part about non-competes is they are blanket protectionism usually and up to 2+ years of non-compete, this sometimes happens on a job that is only 1-3 months. You have to laugh at those types of situations. Usually the client will push them aside or lower the time to the job plus some time, but both non-competes and arbitration agreements are horrible for workers in today's economy where people change jobs frequently and many are self-employed/freelancing/contracting. NDAs are plenty enough to protect companies from clients and work done specifically for the projects. After SCOTUS upheld arbitration agreements [1] I am worried if non-competes become fully legal which they are not in extreme cases except in California [2]. The FTC is looking into non-competes now and they should be illegal [3]. We need to move the way of California and make non-competes null and illegal, it hasn't stopped innovation in CA and may be a big reason why so much innovation goes on in Cali. The non-compete should not exist. At the core, removing competition from skilled workers in our economy is bad all around, unless you are one of the current big fish. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/21/business/supreme-court-upholds-workplace-arbitration-contracts.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/21/business/supreme-court-up... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/13/business/noncompete-clauses.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/13/business/noncompete-claus... [3] https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/events/2020/01/non-competes-workplace-examining-antitrust-consumer-protection-issues https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/events/2020/01/non-competes-...
- esel2k 5y agoI agree and want to emphazise that especially desperate job seeker might sign it just to get a job in the given industry to a few years down the line hit a wall when getting a great offer at the competitor... I went through this with a lawyer and she told me it is unlikely they would sue me, but they could make my life miserable. That was enough for many to be too scared to go to the competitors. - My experience is from Europe; but I will never ever sign a non compete anymore and so fo I recommend go anyone.
- hodgesrm 5y agoAlways push back on terms in contracts that you don't like. I deal with a lot of Master Services Agreement and Statement of Work markups. 75% of the time people just put out changes without really being very tied to them. If they want to do the deal, hire you, etc., they will make changes. Here are some tips that have worked for me. I am not a lawyer but I've spent a decade plus reading all kinds of contracts. It's kind of a hobby. 1. Read the entire contract carefully. 2. Consult a lawyer if there are things you don't understand. My biggest single disaster was because of failing to do this on a partnership agreement. It almost tanked a company acquisition deal. I always go back to counsel whenever something new pops up. You can think of it as paying lawyers to teach you how to take care of yourself. 3. If you see something you don't like, you can ask a question like the following: "I see you put X in the contract. What's the problem you are trying to solve here?" It sets up a conversation about how to rewrite it in terms that are more acceptable. 4. Provide alternative language whenever you can. This is better than forcing the other side to go back to their lawyers who may be motivated to cover their butts / show they are putting in the time rather than finding a real solution. There are things that counterparties see as vital so at some point you'll hit things where they simply won't budge. At that point you can make an informed decision whether you want the overall deal. Meanwhile you get the other stuff that's important to you. Places I tend to be really careful: matters related to IP, liability, and indemnification. These are all areas that can get really painful if things go south. There are a number of tricks to do end runs around liability in contracts. Check with counsel if you have any doubt and push back hard. Places where I'm more flexible: terms for payment, length of termination period, governing law, venue for resolution of disputes (e.g., arbitration vs. courts), etc. Again I'm not a lawyer and your experience may be different.
- Buttons840 5y agoGood time to remember that saving money isn't only for making a big purchase one day. Having money saved, money that just sits there doing nothing, is power in these situations.
- eertami 5y agoIf the problematic contract clause is completely unenforceable by law then I usually don't bother arguing about it. People like to write all kinds of weird things in contracts, but you can't legally sign away your rights (in Europe, USA may be different?). I quite happily break unlawful contracts, no company with a functional legal department is ever going to be stupid enough to take it to court.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> but you can't legally sign away your rights (in Europe, USA may be different?) You can easily sign away your rights. If you couldn't, it would be impossible to sell things (which was a feature of European feudalism - land was generally not alienable). A right that you can't waive is called an inalienable right. A right that you can waive is just a right.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- srcreigh 5y agoI do this when renting apartments. Rules like no pets, no additional occupants, etc are unenforceable where I live. But if I asked the landlord to change it, they may just pick someone else. Therefore, I sign and break the contract.
- kemiller 5y agoMy two cents here: I read every contract we were offered and if there is one thing I learned it’s that everything is negotiable despite how it’s presented. If you can articulate a reasonable need, reasonable people will listen. Lawyers are paid to get the most favorable result so most companies, especially big ones will give you a very lopsided first pass and will tell you it’s required. But you can totally push back. If they 100% won’t budge walk away. They WILL be trouble. Good luck out there.
- listenallyall 5y agoAgreed. I've been in this situation and managed to have "non-negotiable" confidentiality agreements and intellectual property contracts changed. It's never a pleasant experience but clarity and communication are essential to achieving the results you want. I think the key elements are a) mention your intention to review IP contract language early, in writing, so it isn't a surprise later (because it WILL be a surprise otherwise) b) only talk to people who can actually make a change (no low-level people) c) be reasonable yourself (don't overreach) and be specific about your change requests (don't make them guess) d) don't get angry (can be difficult), it's a negotiation e) actually be willing to walk.
- ISL 5y agoI have pushed back against contract clauses. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. The most important outcome is the communication itself. Done well, the discussion builds mutual respect. Both sides want to enter into an agreement that is healthy for them as individuals and, in the best case, for the relationship itself. An example: I've always looked very skeptically at NDAs. I pushed pretty hard for a sunset clause on one once. The other side pushed back. I ultimately decided to sign, as everything else about the arrangement was very acceptable. Once privy to the information on the other side, I understood their reluctance. Also, there are some states with reasonable worker IP protections. Those change the foundations of some contracts for the better.
- ssss11 5y agoThis is a good answer. It forces the dialogue about the issues, and you either align or realise the relationship for what it is - one way. It hopefully helps build mutual trust but does also risk the relationship failing if you can’t agree on important things.
- ISL 5y agoOne should always have a BATNA, even if it is an unpleasant one. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Best_alternative_to_a_negotiated_agreement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Best_alternative_to_a_negotiat...
- akhmatova 5y agoMy hard-won experience on this matter is: If an employer/client tries to pressure you to "c'mon, just sign it, it doesn't really mean that / isn't enforceable anyway" -- especially when the contract unambiguously does really mean what they say it doesn't really mean ... From that fact the transaction is pretty much destined to not be particularly fruitful anyway, and (unless you're short on cash or otherwise in some kind of a corner), you're best cutting your losses and moving on.
- listenallyall 5y agoI find that contractual language covering "ownership" of IP is likely ineffective and doesn't match reality. If I'm paid by a company to write some code while employed, sure the employer owns it. But it also exists in my brain. Do they own that too? Can I write it again for myself or for another employer? If not, how much needs to change? If I wrote it in Python originally, would a functional equivalent in JavaScript remain "owned" by the original employer? I'm surprised contract disputes surrounding this concept aren't quite common.
- pydry 5y ago>One employer asked me to yield ownership of my entire work product during the term of my employment, including things I wrote on my own time on my own equipment, such as these blog articles. I think the employer should own only the things they pay me to create, during my working hours. >When I pointed this out to them I got a very typical reply: “Oh, we don't actually mean that, we only want to own things you produced in the scope of your employment.” What they said they wanted was what I also wanted. I still view this as a huge red flag. The companies I've come across that had fuck-you clauses like this inserted by overzealous lawyers usually had a toxic culture to match. A company that will default to "we get first dibs on everything coming out of your brain" will probably not treat you with respect even if certain individuals who work there are reasonable human beings. The worst company I ever worked for not coincidentally had the worst contract (e.g. they had 8-7 working hours followed by a verbal "dont worry nobody actually works that"). Contractual clauses are an underrated window into company culture. It's the one place where honesty prevails. These days I dont push back on unreasonable clauses or give the opportunity for the hiring manager to say "whoops so sorry our lawyers tried to fuck you". When a company tries to tell me who it is I believe them - first time.
- steelframe 5y agoI walked away from a company I really wanted to work for because the terms of their interview NDA were "everything and forever." IANAL, but I did take an IP law class when I was in graduate school, and I recall the professor saying that one of the key takeaways from the Listerine case is that any lawyer who allows their client to enter into contract with no term limit is basically incompetent. I lived outside California, and tech workers in my state had been successfully enjoined by a former employer on multiple occasions. I wasn't about to put my ability to earn a living in jeopardy. I made it a few interviews into the loop while steadfastly refusing to sign the NDA, and I even told the recruiter that I objected to the scope of the contract. The recruiter indicated that they had absolutely no leeway on the NDA, and it was "take it or leave it." So after passing several interviews in the loop with flying colors, I called off the remainder of the interviews. They freaked out because I had been doing so well and wanted to know why on earth I wouldn't at least let them draw up an offer. "Your NDA is inequitable" was my responses, which really seemed to confuse them, because they were so used to tech workers dreaming of stock options in states with more worker-friendly legal environments like California just signing whatever they shoved at them. Their recruiting department still had the nerve to pester me a couple of times to sign the NDA after I terminated the interviews because I objected to the NDA. *Edit: I previously called California a "right-to-work" state, which is something I've heard a lot of people say, but I guess it's not technically correct.
- charcircuit 5y agoWhat are you afraid of by signing it? Even if indefinite NDAs were legal (contracts can't be indefinite) the amount of damage the information you learn during the interview process is most likely not that high. As time goes on that damage will very likely just go to $0.
- steelframe 5y ago> contracts can't be indefinite Of course they can. That was the whole premise of the Listerine case.
- 5y ago
- dboreham 5y agoMy experience has been that almost all contracts end up being edited. Whoever gives the impression that "they never change the contract" is lying.
- joshjdr 5y ago> If the employer is a good one, they want the contract to be fair, and if the contract is unfair it's probably by accident. This is an optimistic, and perhaps productive perspective, but often the legal advice suggests writing the template language in the employer’s favor, knowing it may be negotiable. The advice is good… read agreements before signing, and negotiate reasonable points.
- jonplackett 5y agoMost of the time it just happens because a company is trying to save money and use a template that works fine for most people. Most people don’t have a second job / blog / business / side hustle / whatever and don’t care if the company owns everything they make. I’ve renegotiated the same clause as in the blog multiple times with no issues. Also had to do the same for a book I wrote taking out of copyright fairy tales and gender swapping them with an algorithm I made. The publishers contract (quite understandably) said the manuscript couldn’t contain any work in the public domain, but the whole concept of the book was to gender swap a text exactly as is, to shine a light on the inequalities in the original. It was a bit of a battle to change it but I think more based on requiring more lawyer time than anyone trying to do anything untoward. Always ask to change it but always be nice about it. They probably aren’t trying to screw you over! (But also don’t let anyone screw your over just because they didn’t mean to!)
- abalaji 5y agoThese techniques work great, I've had success with pushing back against language in contracts like these even as an intern. Often times, after doing all the hard work of interviewing you, companies are willing to compromise, so they don't have to go back to square one. Places this might not work are larger companies with armies of lawyers--you don't have leverage in these places, since if not you, they can find someone else to sign the contract.
- josh2600 5y agoI cannot state how real this is as a startup. There are instances where I have said “yeah I totally agree with you but our lawyers worded it this way.” Most of the time it’s fine and not material. Some of the time it’s the defining detail of the contract. I wish I had the wisdom to know the difference.
- bitwize 5y agoAn employer tried to hand me a contract that would have me sign over the rights to my name, voice, and likeness "for marketing purposes". I was like hell to the no, and told the HR person I wouldn't sign the contract as written, being sure to clarify that I had no problem with my name and likeness being used for practical, internal company purposes (like printing company IDs). They printed up a new contract with the offending clause deleted. I didn't last long there, and I think part of the reason why is because they were pissy about the contract. Should have seen the writing on the wall.
- 7402 5y agoOne additional thing to watch out for is additional documents that are presented for your signature after you start work. One place gave me an employee handbook on day one and asked me to sign something saying I agreed to follow the terms in it. I could have said no, but obviously I had much less bargaining power at that point. Since then, before accepting an offer I always said, "I'd also like to see any documents that I will be expected to sign on the first day of work, or any employee handbook whose policies I will be expected to follow."
- neoCrimeLabs 5y agoIn 2000/2001 I was offered a position at a startup who was looking to make it big in the intrusion detection and prevention space. They handed me a contract with an IP clause that summed up to their owned any idea I came up with. This wasn't uncommon at the time, but it was more aggressive than I was used to. I made it clear to the HR person that I was actively contributing to open source tools at the time, such as snort, nessus, and also had ideas of my own that I was already working on. The HR person made it clear that if I were to continue working on these ideas it would become property of the company -- Even if performed during my free time. I don't remember the specifics any more, but after some discussion and escalations we came to the agreement that since my hobbies were so close to my work function that any new ideas I came up with were property of the company, so I was asked to provide a list of what I was working on and it would be amended to the contract. I provided a 4 page outline of the 4 projects I was working on and their what intellectual property they involved. The the next day they rescinded the offer. At the time I had assumed it was because their ideas were not that novel and they wanted fresh ideas to take and profit off of. Will never know for sure, but they went out of business between 2001/2002. Regardless how right I was, since then I was always a lot more aware of IP clauses in contracts and how they were phrased. I also try not to work for companies who sell security software.
- billyt555 5y agoI once had a business owner put forth a similar contract after they had purchased the company where I was employed for a few years. I refused to sign (I was only one out of 60 or so employees that did so). The "accountant" told me I would never work in California again as all companies were moving in this direction. I'm still employed in CA, however, that company no longer exists. :).
- tomohawk 5y agoAnother thing to note is just because someone puts a piece of paper in front of you doesn't mean you need to sign it. It also doesn't mean you need to object. You can just ignore it. For example, if you are already employed, your employer may want you to sign another document. I've successfully pocketed such documents and not returned them. I was never called on it. If they don't force the issue, there's no point in making it an issue.
- LiquidPolymer 5y agoI’m not certain my experience is relevant in this context, but I’ve been fighting contract language for over 30 years. I’m a pro photographer and producer in the biz for many years. I produce unique content that is quite challenging to recreate. So many contracts contain what I call “rights grabs”. They are attempting to transfer my IP to them for maximum profit. I’ve fought this trend with success for decades. I simply cross out the offending language in the contract and make the license contingent on the agreement proceeding as I describe. I’m happy to abandon a contract if it does not go my way (a luxury not everyone has). My largest checks in the past two years have been from lawsuits brought against copyright infringement. In every case my contract revisions have withstood legal challenge and the defenders/offenders have folded when they proceeded as if the original contract language (before I altered, after they signed) stood. There are lawyers who have pursued this niche to great success and I have lawyer team ready to pursue infringement on a contingency basis. It is quite amazing. More than once now, my lawyers have fought for years when the infringers had deep pockets and a terror of precedent. They paid so many thousands to their legal team but lost. I have prevailed in every case. I recognize this is bragging. But so many of my colleagues have just signed for a short term check while losing in the long run. I might be an obstinate fool, but so far it’s paid off. We in the photo biz have had to survive a huge paradigm shift in the biz model in the last 18 years. But so many people fold for Pennie’s. “I need this $250 right now to make rent”. But my settlement checks are in the $25,000 range typically (25% after my lawyers and agent get their cut). Last I looked, the average income for a photographer in the U.S, was around $7500 a year. Yes, $7500 (no missing zeros). I make six figures consistently and I’m damn proud of this fact. Most of the conversations on this forum are above my skill set, but you folks are generally paid for deep knowledge and rare skills. Don’t let anyone steal this from you.
- daniel-cussen 5y agoOh yeah. You know what? I am not big into copyright so much as patents (turned my back on a model/actor career, also big into copyright with one specific algorithm though, where it made perfect sense) and Intellectual Property. Hey can you leave your email in your profile and I'll write you? Super interested in the hard-lawyering-up angle for Intellectual Property. I guess what you're saying about a big cut for lawyers and agents. I think my agent cost 25% too.
- Trias11 5y agoMy typical approach to ANY contract is elimination of ANY one-sided clauses. They're not responsible for X but i am. I'm obligated to do Y but they're not. I can be sued but they're not. I always make them to trim the BS and equalize the wording.
- eyelidlessness 5y agoIANAL. Just my sharing relevant observations/experience. I’ve had a reputation among most of the people with whom I’ve signed contracts for being the rare person who reads the whole thing. The author is right that it’s a good idea to push back on parts of the contract that don’t sit well, and that it’s a privilege to be able to do so. When I’m in a strong negotiating position, I’ve found also that the author is also right that the other party is usually truthful and also that they’re usually open to making changes to remove conflicts and resolve ambiguities. If you’re in that position, you’re usually much better off pushing back than accepting the contract as is. Even if you know your contract has unenforceable provisions, and you know they’re unenforceable, they’re a litigation landmine. Maybe they’re highly unlikely to become actual litigation, but if there’s even a possibility everyone benefits from eliminating it. If that becomes a point of contention, bonus points: you’ve found a red flag with this other party to your contract. Even if you move forward you have better understanding of where you can anticipate conflict. But most of the time, unless your contract is incredibly unfair or the parties are incredibly unprepared to negotiate its terms, you’ll just get the edits you want because everyone already agrees in principle that it’s okay to move forward.
- simonw 5y agoI've had to push back on this provision in the past - the one where your employer now own all of your side projects. As a blogger and open source maintainer this is a deal breaker for me. I always manage to get it altered, but it is such an annoying point of friction. I'd love something like the YC safe financing documents but for employment contracts - a free resource with well vetted, well explained contract language so I can say "let's use this language from here" and everyone can get on with their lives.
- bombcar 5y agoI wonder what would happen if someone said “if you own everything you also accept all liability for it”.
- pabs3 5y agoSoftware Freedom Conservancy's ContractPatch initiative has a great saying: "Everything Is Negotiable" https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2016/aug/04/everything-is-negotiable/ https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2016/aug/04/everything-is-neg... https://sfconservancy.org/contractpatch/ https://sfconservancy.org/contractpatch/ https://sfconservancy.org/blog/?tag=ContractPatch https://sfconservancy.org/blog/?tag=ContractPatch
- ada1981 5y agoHad a potential coach, who I was ready to pay $25k for a single day, ask me to sign a contract that included a clause that gave them power of attorney in the event of a contract dispute. I said, this seems intense, I’m ready to hire you, just drop this clause… and she wouldn’t do it.
- robertlagrant 5y agoIt would be good to make a Joel Test for employment contracts. I don't really know why most employment contracts are not from a standard source anyway: we will pay you this much, this often, for this many hours' work during that period. You don't take or destroy our equipment or represent us badly in public. When you leave you give us our equipment back, and don't solicit our employees for 6 months after. You get a bonus on these terms, and share options on these terms. Only things you make at work OR using our equipment belongs to us.
- bruce511 5y agoThe problem with this approach are the edge cases. Over a couple hundred years there have been lots of those, now taught about enthusiastically in law school. Every time there's an unfavorable edge case to (any) employer, then another clause gets added to the "standard contract". So with reusable contracts (like employee contracts) you end up with very asymmetric goals, and a very asymmetric contract. Yes, push back is important, and it's valuable to the company to hear that push-back. Speaking as an employer, I would not be prejudiced against an employee questioning or rejecting terms in the contract. Some changes might be deal-breakers, some might not. But clearly we can negotiate and assuming we don't find any mutual deal breakers we'll both be happy. I would personally also see this as a positive, not negative, interaction with an employee, not something for them to fear. But of course, being new, they don't know that, and I understand the asymmetry of power in this situation.
- saagarjha 5y ago> don't solicit our employees for 6 months after This is unenforceable in California.
- robertlagrant 5y agoSure :) But I'd rather have a standard contract that's modulated by local employment law than a bespoke contract that's modulated by local employment law. Or have optional blocks included or not (that makes a Joel Test for contracts almost self-documenting).
- NaturalPhallacy 5y ago>Any contract in which you give up your right to sue the other party if they were to cheat you. Is there any contract that doesn't do this with the "binding arbitration" bullshit?
- gorgoiler 5y agoWhen I started as a teacher I pushed back against my “contract” which I didn’t even see until two months after I started work. In reality, the way employment law works is that the legal “contract” was a statutory one, implicit from the day I started. I started work and they paid me a salary, therefore I was legally an employee. The “contract” was really just the terms and conditions which the employer is required to offer the employee within a certain time period after their start date. In the UK this are called “particulars of employment”, I think. I asked for changes to four of the clauses including IP assignment and me giving the school the right to be the final arbiter for any disputes of damage to pupils belongings. It gave them the right to withhold my pay in order to compensate parents who raise a grievance. So little Johnny could claim I stepped on his laptop and I wouldn’t be able to do anything about it if his parents got pissy and demanded I pay. The school was sympathetic and said that of course no such extreme event would ever happen, but I was also told it would cost too much to hire a lawyer to change the document. I said I couldn’t sign it but that I agreed to everything else. They let me work there for several years anyway before I got made “redundant” when they hired a better teacher to take my place. What a bunch of clowns. And that includes me — I should have walked really, but once you start working with kids it’s incredibly hard to let go of the adorable little monsters. One suspects that schools are well aware of this enormous emotional leverage they have.
- michalstanko 5y ago> You may agree today, but that can change. The company's management or ownership can change. I've lost over 7000 EUR of income from a German company over vague contract clauses which I was too lazy to sort out when signing it, because my boss and I had known each other for a long time when signing, and I fully trusted him. 3 years later, the company was sold, and the new boss started to randomly fire people on any given day he saw fit. One day I've got a call that I should stop working on my tasks immediately. I was supposed to be paid until the end of the month coming after the month in which the notice was given, but they've never paid - not even for those ~15 days I already worked in that month - and German courts could not care less, plus it was difficult/impossible for me to chase them, being based in another European country. Always be careful about what exactly do you sign - the circumstances may change considerably, however unlikely it seems at the time.
- clooless 5y agoJust want to say that here in the US, if your employer ever doesn't pay you what you think you're owed, contact the Department of Labor. There's a division dedicated to making sure the employer doesn't play games with wages. They'll show up real fast, possibly even that day, and your employer will pay (plus fines).