10 ms·
John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt
- grumblepeet 5y agoJohn Cage reads from some of his writings in this longish video on YouTube and explains some of the ideas that he was constantly exploring. This video also has Rahsaan Roland Kirk playing three saxophones at the same time. The whole thing is very 1964 but for me put a lot of John Cage’s work into context. https://youtu.be/9YbA8SXFsEE https://youtu.be/9YbA8SXFsEE
- frob 5y agoI can't help but think of things like these in a future where there was some sort of gap or loss in human learning, maybe due to a mass-extinction event. It would be seen as a mysterious artifact from the ancients that has been singing forever. Religions and priests would arise to interpret every minor change or fluctuation in the notes since they are obviously a message from a being or being so eternal that they couldn't even slow their speech enough to address in one lifetime, let alone 20.
- internetvin 5y agoIt’s eerie how true this sounds.
- hprotagonist 5y agohttps://longplayer.org/about/overview/ https://longplayer.org/about/overview/ longer duration, faster tempo
- js8 5y agoThey could also play a superpermutation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_tpNuulTeSQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_tpNuulTeSQ
- 2143 5y agoLet me add that this is scheduled to be completed on 31 December 2999, which is nearly 1000 years from now. It began on 1 January 2000.
- dahart 5y agoThis piece and the Cage piece both began in 2000, and both descriptions imply the turn of the millennium are an important marker. So probably not many > 100 year pieces have started since then, but maybe we’ll get a new set in the year 3000. Makes me curious if there are a bunch of unknown 100 year performances conceived around the turns of centuries. Anyway, I like the Long Player’s description of survival at the end; even if the music seems silly, these are interesting questions - “How does one keep a piece of music playing across generations? How does one prepare for its technological adaptability, knowing how few technologies have remained viable over the last millenium? How does one legislate for its upkeep? And how can one communicate that responsibility to those who might be looking after it some 950 years after its original custodians have perished?”
- 2143 5y agoI had read the portion you quoted and found it interesting as well. I've always been fascinated by long running processes. I'm sure you might have heard about the Clock of the Long Now [1] (Wikipedia article [2] seems more useful than the official website), which is meant to work for 10000 years. It's under construction, but their strategies to handle adversities over a 10000 year period worth looking into. Related to that, I've read about an attempt by a software engineer presumably named Brandur who, inspired by the aforementioned clock, has attempted to build a software that would send out tweets for the next 10000 years [3]. While I personally feel it probably wouldn't succeed because there's too many things that can go wrong, it was nice to read the considerations that went into the program. Perhaps more than tweeting for the next 10000 years itself, Brandur was really trying to point out that it's difficult to build long lasting software products. Writing software that endures for a long time without too much additional maintenance is something I'd like to do. Another long running — though in comparison to the above much smaller — group of equipments are the space probes Voyager 1 (launched in 1977), Voyager 2 (1977) and New Horizons (2006). Unless I'm mistaken they all continue to function in limited ways and continue to send back data to the earth. Isn't it mind-blowing that something that left Earth about 45 years ago still works?! (Or maybe it's not mind blowing because I guess space doesn't have as much distrubances as the Earth). I also like long running processes in nature. Comets are one of them. Isn't it just so cool that some of them actually (very likely) come from Oort cloud and their orbits can take hundreds or even thousands of years? Halley's Comet — which has an orbital period of 76 years, and whose appearances have been recorded by various people in various places over the past couple of thousand years — will show up again in 2061, nearly 40 years from now. I sincerely hope I can see it then. Infact I have a calendar reminder set up for it in 2061 July. Just in case I forget. (The calendar program I currently use might die first. Or I could be dead). [1] https://longnow.org/clock/ https://longnow.org/clock/ [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clock_of_the_Long_Now https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clock_of_the_Long_Now [3] https://brandur.org/10000-years https://brandur.org/10000-years
- iansowinski 5y agoReminds me this instalation in Hamburg Kunsthale, where artist constructed conditions for creation of a stalactite. It will be ready in about 500 years: https://www.hamburger-kunsthalle.de/sammlung-online/bogomir-ecker/tropfsteinmaschine https://www.hamburger-kunsthalle.de/sammlung-online/bogomir-...
- cool_dude85 5y agoAnyone else recently heard about this on the Uhh Yeah Dude podcast?
- JasonFruit 5y agoDoes anyone love this as music, rather than as an idea? Of composers, there are two schools: those who try to express something interesting musically, and those who produce interesting concepts. Some of Cage's work, especially, takes the second approach to extremes, where it cannot even be experienced as music. I don't think any of that sort of music will survive long, because the concept is no longer clever after it loses its novelty.
- jeegsy 5y agoIts an excellent point. You really cant get a sense of the whole thing since its mostly one tone stretched out most of the time. Hopefully it survives the stated 639 years
- Bud 5y agoYou could listen to one of the versions out there that only lasts an hour. That would give you a good sense of the full piece. Then you could go listen to a snippet of it, in this extremely slow version, and get a sense of that. Then combine the two.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoIt's pretty silly IMO. Extreme Concept™ isn't difficult to do, and it's even less difficult to imagine. It's trivial to make extremely long time-based pieces on the web. You load the page, it works out the time/date, and it plays whatever the algorithm says is right for the time date. With the right algo you can make pieces that last for millions of years. And so on. There is a sense in which it's an interesting idea, but it's also a cultural dead end. You can only make it bigger and more extreme, and that's more about spectacle than music.
- Honga 5y agoThe work doesn't necessarily argue against you. It may have been the intention, or it may be the effect of the work that ideas like yours come into existence. One idea of conceptual art is that the work plays out in your mind, and the physical creation is secondary, utilitarian even. The authenticity of the piece and it's validity is reinforced by our conversation and replay. On this measure the timeline is arbitrary, and trumping it is a second work all together, creating a new conversation.
- mhb 5y agoPerfect soundtrack for the pitch drop experiment: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pitch_drop_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pitch_drop_experiment
- MikeDelta 5y agoIndeed! I remember a few years ago when the drop was supposed to fall. It was so exciting watching the drop almost fall, but after a few weeks of no visible movement it got dull.
- da-bacon 5y agoMusic for the thousanders from Anathem.
- jacquesm 5y agoInteresting. Besides the fact that they would sing to themselves but yes, when you live on a different time-scale you probably would have entirely different musical art. Though I personally do not think this is interesting and I suspect a thousander wouldn't either, they seemed rather more complex creatures.
- adam0c 5y agowhy... lol
- jmclnx 5y agoEDIT: hprotagonist beat me to this :) Took a while for me to find the link. Ignore me Interesting, will need to check it out. Also there is https://longplayer.org/ https://longplayer.org/ which is on the same idea as this piece
- cm2187 5y ago“Art”
- rubyist5eva 5y agoAnd I thought 20 minute prog rock songs were awesome.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- je_suis_music 5y agoNot prog rock but I used Moroder's 15+ minutes long "Love to love you baby" and "I feel love" when doing 4+hrs vinyl sets in disco bars, plenty of time to go to the bathroom. If I had Göttsching E2-E4 I'd have spun that one too.
- amelius 5y agoIf you play long enough, will you not at some point infringe someone's copyright? Or will the lawsuit take 639 years too?
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoI'm pretty sure it would be considered fair use, even if it was quite heavily influenced (and in some parts, taken) from a work. It isn't like anyone is going to listen to the two pieces and get them confused nor is any copyright holder going to lose money because someone plays their song so slowly that most folks just hear a single tone, even if they stay for days.
- CompleteWalker 5y agoI wish Cage had kept the acronym ASAP
- gunfighthacksaw 5y agoMy cool hipster roommate told me about this 10 years ago when I first moved out for school, and I’m now the age she was back then (and the piece is 10 years older)
- wintermutestwin 5y agoThis version of Pyramid Song by Radiohead is slowed down 800% and IMO it is amazing and beautiful. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XiKWfcy-Z70 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XiKWfcy-Z70 But then again, the source is an incredibly beautiful song which has an interesting time signature and chord progression: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MdZSOoOF5Ms https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MdZSOoOF5Ms https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SKMAV8pvlOA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SKMAV8pvlOA
- antiterra 5y agoNearly anything sounds beautiful when it’s spectrally smoothed and lengthened 50x by Paulstretch, including the most irritating pop song you can name off the top of your head. http://hypermammut.sourceforge.net/paulstretch/ http://hypermammut.sourceforge.net/paulstretch/
- wintermutestwin 5y agoGood point. I wonder how much of the beauty is due to the interesting SW approach vs. the speed. Here is an interesting discussion with the creator: https://web.archive.org/web/20120217161857/http://www.microscopics.co.uk/blog/2010/paulstretch-an-interview-with-paul-nasca/ https://web.archive.org/web/20120217161857/http://www.micros...
- corporealfunk 5y agoI haven't played with Paulstretch, but it looks similar to what Tom Erbe's "Soundhack" program did (windowed FFT with overlap add resynthesis). Soundhack was originally written in the late 90's and was used by the sound designers of The Matrix.. anyhow. Soundhack is now defunct, but Tom released the source and I ported the time stretching bit of the software to Go if anyone's interested: https://github.com/corporealfunk/gopvoc https://github.com/corporealfunk/gopvoc
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pwython 5y agoThis is great, I have to check out more slowed down songs. The only other one I've heard is the Jurassic Park theme (-1,000%) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LX40crWTTYs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LX40crWTTYs
- GrumpyNl 5y agoThe organ used looks pretty new, how did they do that without interrupting the continuous playing?
- Bud 5y agoIt probably looks new mostly because the pipes are so shiny. This is because, in order to change any note, a new pipe is actually installed in one of the slots.
- zb 5y agoAny thread about this is incomplete without mentioning the article about a note change in this performance by John Darnielle (of the band the Mountain Goats, who is also a novelist): https://harpers.org/archive/2016/01/there-are-other-forces-at-work/ https://harpers.org/archive/2016/01/there-are-other-forces-a...
- dang 5y agoIncredible that Cage managed to provoke riots in his audiences in 1974 and 1976. Impressionists and modernists famously did so in earlier generations but the mid-70s is astonishingly late for an art riot. Among Buddhists in Boulder, no less!
- anonymoushn 5y agoThe page on the linked official web site has already link rotted within a few months!
- homonculus1 5y ago
- je_suis_music 5y agoI think death sentence for blasphemy is antichristian too, but, when your funny idea to perform in church involved the risk of burning alive, people were indeed far more considerate.
- drunkonvinyl 5y agoSaying “Encore!” in 2640…
- jdrc 5y ago"A pretentious piece of avant garde struggles to remain relevant"
- ARandomerDude 5y agoSorry, but anyone who thinks this will see completion is delusional. It'll be amazing if our distant posterity will recognize a map of today's Europe, much less be interested in this song's performance. We live closer to Christopher Columbus than the end of this song. Think about how much the world has changed in that time.
- kobalsky 5y agowhen columbus set a foot in america there were 1000 year old pubs in europe that are still open today. sometimes it's hard to understand how mind boggingly old europe is, being from the younger continent.
- LB232323 5y agoThe Americas are just as old, it is just that people in their arrogance have chosen to overlook the works and achievements of Mesoamerican civilization. History did not begin with the arrival of the Europeans, that is just when colonization began. The long history of these continents is treated as some sort of lost and mysterious thing of times past, yet the people from those civilizations are still here today. Cage and Glass both understood this and named a number of their works aptly.
- goldphotograph1 5y ago
- Honga 5y agoMedieval Christianity revived and resumed ancient Greek culture and philosophy. That's a larger gap than we're talking about here. There's precedent if you look hard enough.
- replygirl 5y agoi also have a nervous breakdown when i see evidence of the HRE
- gotaquestion 5y agoOnce again, for those looking down on artists with their keen Vulcan engineer logic brains: modern art = i could do that + yeah but you didn't
- tomc1985 5y agomodern art = i could do that + yeah but you didn't + you didn't have the artist's cachet + you didn't have the connections to exhibit your work + you don't have the body of experience that lead you to this particular output + nobody is going to care about your low-effort piece but somehow this artist got them too
- zamadatix 5y agoI think this still completely misses what's interesting about this: the number of interesting performance attempts, not the piece itself which is neither first/last of the concept or the focus of the post.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- swayvil 5y agoI assume that this project has funding. I'd like to see the details of that.
- saalweachter 5y agoDamn, I missed the start of this performance. Does anyone know when the next is scheduled to start?
- genghisjahn 5y agoDude. Turn it up! This is my favorite part.
- coastflow 5y agoThis video presents a version where the piece is sped up to 36 seconds in length: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h5-Yo328Rp4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h5-Yo328Rp4
- zamadatix 5y agoUnfortunately the choice of using a sawtooth wave for playback of an organ piece makes it nearly just as unintelligible as the 639 year performance.
- kderbyma 5y agoit would be nice to live through a crescendo
- je_suis_music 5y agoI did it was called the eighties. But truth to be said, people were not 100% happy, yes there was the nuclear MADness, but also deep down they knew this modern society was making them more and more irrelevant. But they clinged on the perks and tried not to mind.
- saalweachter 5y agoHmm, so imagine setting up dozens of organs, hundreds, maybe a few thousand in a large circle. You set them to playing ASLSP in, well, a round, each set to take some long period of time to finish. If you stand still, you'll hear it at it's ponderous pace, but if you walk, run ahead of the music, it will go faster and faster; if you reverse directions, it will slow down, stop, or even reverse.
- atoav 5y agoOrgans are kinda expensive instruments, but if they just have to play a few notes...
- Bud 5y agoIt's also a lot cheaper if you don't have to install a keyboard and all kinds of stops.
- cptcobalt 5y agoI mean, you could definitely build a bespoke organ for the proposal above: You wouldn't need a manual (keyboard), or any sort of other bits and bobs required for performance (stops, pistons, couplers, pedals). Mini wind chambers per pipe, probably with an interconnected tubing so you could set up this big ring of pipes for people to walk around and observe. As for pipes, it'd just be one rank of pipes—not scores of them like with typical organs—and probably just one blower and bellows. And, given the nature of the performance, some sort of self-powering renewable energy source and battery backup.
- atoav 5y agoOrgans work with air pressure right? Maybe something with a chimey which uses some sort of temperature differencial to produce airflow?
- musingsole 5y agoDo you have a Kickstarter?
- labrador 5y agoI've don't know why people are so fascinated with John Cage's conceptual music like 4′33″ which is 4 minutes and 33 seconds of silence. It doesn't do anything for me and seems like b.s.
- Bud 5y agoYou might start to understand more about it if you read Cage's writings. He's at least as significant as a writer as he has been as a composer.
- labrador 5y agoThanks for the suggestion Bud. I didn't realize he was a writer too. I'd like to know what his real intentions are with his work.
- b3morales 5y agoIt's not what you think. The concept isn't "oh ha ha, here's 'music' that has no sound, smoke that!". It's that while you're sitting there with the performer doing nothing, there's still sound going on around you. Creaking chairs, water in pipes, bus going by outside the venue... If someone makes a recording that is literally a string of 0 bits, they're doing something different than Cage's piece. (EDIT: Although while listening to that recording you the listener can experience the sound of the space you are in. So perhaps it would be the same thing, in a way.) Cage was interested in how -- or whether -- accidental and incidental noise could be incorporated or experienced as music. 4'33" is just the most notorious (and probably starkest) expression of that idea.
- labrador 5y agoI get that but do people really need to pretend it is art to sit silently in a room full of people in a concert hall and notice the ambient sounds long with their thoughts and feelings. People who sit in meditation with others do this all the time. I suppose the concept is foreign to most Westerners so they need an artist to come alone and give it the stamp of approval. "Let's have a moment of silence for those we have lost" People understand the above and do it without complaint "Let's sit quietly in meditation and notice our environment, thoughts and feelings. You may find it helpful to focus on your breath" Most people grudgingly do this but find it boring and unnecessary John Cage: "Listen to my piece 4' 33" which the musicians on stage won't play" People: "Oh my God, John Cage is brilliant. What an amazing artist! I can't wait to tell my friends that I 'heard' this"
- nabla9 5y agoThis is so called conceptualism, or conceptual art. art for which the idea behind the work is more important than the finished art object.
- soneca 5y agoThe phrasing confused me. It is being performed for almost 21 years (since 2001) and it will be continuously performed for the next 618 years (hopefully). Initially I thought it was being performed since year 1383 (639 years ago).
- PoachedSausage 5y agoOnly 639 years? It would take approximately 1.3m years to ring every permutation of the 16 bells in the tower of the church of St Martin in the Bull Ring, Birmingham, UK.[0] I'm not sure the bells, tower or ringers would last that long though, get there early to avoid disappointment. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St_Martin_in_the_Bull_Ring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St_Martin_in_the_Bull_Ring
- rufus_foreman 5y agoOverhead, without any fuss, the stars were going out.
- nonrandomstring 5y agoIf nothing else this piece is optimistic.
- replygirl 5y agoseems pretty cynical to me
- nonrandomstring 5y agoBy optimistic, I meant the idea that humans would be around for 600 years.
- awiesenhofer 5y agoReminds me of the Culture series book "Look to Windward" - in which a composer creates an almost everlasting symphony whos finale coincides with the arrival of the light of an ancient supernova on his planet (IIRC)
- je_suis_music 5y agoLOL the longest music piece on earth is pioneered by Schumann. Not the composer, Earth's Schumann resonance. Good luck beating that. And whoever dares arguing it is not music, in the context of Cage brain farts, is a hypocrite. N00B Cage can name his 639yo piece "Hello I'm new here". Outside the earth there is that cosmic background radiation that is hard to beat.
- WarOnPrivacy 5y agoDepending on the criteria, it may not be the longest piece ever. * On July 10, 2014, the band [Bull of Heaven] released 305: Hostages are Human Beings. On July 12, 2014, 303: n(k), 304: 0(2^18×5^18) and 306: It is Not a Lack of Love were released. On the very next day, they released several other tracks of various lengths. By the time, 310: ΩΣPx0(2^18×5^18)p*k*k*k is their longest release, and lasts for 3.343 quindecillion years.* ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bull_of_Heaven_%28band%29#2014%E2%80%93present https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bull_of_Heaven_%28band%29#2014...
- dang 5y agoRelated: 639-year-long John Cage organ performance has a long-awaited chord change today - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24384140 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24384140 - Sept 2020 (1 comment)
- elihu 5y agoKind of a weird corner case for copyright law; a piece whose copyright expires part way through the performance. Presumably it expires (in the U.S.) 70 years after John Cage's death (1992 + 70 = 2062), but if it had instead been produced by a corporation and the score wasn't published ahead of the performance, each portion of the performance would presumably expire 95 years after that portion first played. However, there's apparently also a rule that corporate copyrights also expire 120 years after creation regardless of when they were published.
- b3morales 5y agoIt's not really relevant. There isn't a copyright in the performance itself, and if they had permission to start the performance, then the expiry of the copyright certainly doesn't prevent them from finishing.
- elihu 5y agoI was thinking more about the copyright on the score, and whether other people would be able to freely copy it, make their own recordings, create derivative works, and so on.
- jancsika 5y agoIf you can't even finish the piece before its copyright expires, then the duration for copyright protection is way too short! Is there a list of edge cases like these collected somewhere? E.g., this piece for music performance duration, avocados for a high-fat content fruit, qmail's small issue list, etc. I'd like to use it as a reference to sharpen my shitposting.