14 ms·
US Navy wirelessly beams 1.6 kW of power a kilometer using microwaves
- coenhyde 5y ago1km through the atmosphere is probably all you need to verify that the approach would work for Space Based Solar. I know the military is interested in that. Imagine being able to deploy energy anywhere on Earth and not have to setup a logistics chain to facilitate it. That's priceless. The economics for SBS don't really make sense to me, for domestic energy consumption. But economics are irrelevant if it enables you to project power deeper into hostile territory.
- walrus01 5y agospace based solar probably works fine outside the atmosphere, but any space based "power beaming" system would need to contend with the entire thickness of the atmosphere for path loss. > Imagine being able to deploy energy anywhere on Earth and not have to setup a logistics chain to facilitate it. theoretical setups for receiver arrays for space based solar power beamed over microwave are very large, if you're going to go to the trouble to erect a big receiving array somewhere in an empty piece of land, you might as well just build a large ground mount photovoltaic system based on commodity 72-cell monocrystalline Si 400W rated panels.
- DennisP 5y agoThe atmosphere is fairly transparent to microwaves, so the loss shouldn't be much worse. The book The Case for Space Solar Panel cited net efficiency of 40% with the tech at the time it was written, with a theoretical maximum of 60%. It's a pretty good deal given that a panel in geostationary collects five times as much energy in 24 hours as the same panel on the ground, and the power flows 24/7 for most of the year with no need for storage.
- scythe 5y agoWe're a long way from geostationary orbit with this tech, though. They got 1 km, now you need 35,000.
- giantg2 5y agoI guess it depends on how tight the maser beam stays. Most of that 35k km has little to no atmosphere, so that part is a little less important.
- scythe 5y agoThere's an equation for that. The effective range of a Gaussian beam is roughly equal to (beam width)^2 / wavelength. I'm not sure what wavelength or beam width they used here, though.
- engineer_22 5y ago10Ghz from the article, and photo of the target appears to be 3 meters square
- scythe 5y agoThat means they're right at the Rayleigh length. You'd need a significantly wider beam or higher frequency to send power from orbit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rayleigh_length https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rayleigh_length
- DennisP 5y agoIn fact, SPS designs involve receivers measured in square kilometers. But they'd be mostly wire and would only contribute about 0.7 cents/kWh to the cost.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pfdietz 5y ago
- walrus01 5y agoI'd question whether anyone writing "the atmosphere is fairly transparent to microwaves" has calculated the link budget, then implemented in the real world an FCC part 101 licensed microwave radio system (example: 1024QAM modulation, 11 GHz standard FDD band plan, +16 Tx power, 80 MHz channels H&V dual linear, 35 km, 180 cm high performance dishes both ends) and seen the path loss in reality. I think anyone that's done terrestrial point to point microwave telecom professionally will take a very skeptical view of things like 10 GHz band, 1 km power "beams". the reality is that the atmosphere absolutely eats microwave, and when it's not eating it, you have temperature inversions, ducting and diffraction effects to take into account at long distances as well. this is why their demo only works at 1.0 km.
- DennisP 5y agoIndeed. Such a writer may, however, have read up on studies on expected losses for the frequencies proposed for SPS. The book I mentioned covers a lot, but a paper I just googled is available on scihub at your discretion. Here's the abstract: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00222739.1970.11688771 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00222739.1970.11... The paper is published in the Journal of Microwave Power, proposes using a wavelength around 10 cm, and with a vertical beam calculates a loss of 1% in clear skies and up to 10% loss with rain.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoMy imagination is limited. Care to help me out? 1.6kW deployed to any area in the world. I’m not sure how to visualize that, or what the implications are. Could this power a drone indefinitely with no need to land?
- _s 5y agoYes, any vehicle that can be drive with a motor. Here’s an out there scenario - a few power generating aircraft or satellites in high orbit sending power down to drones at lower altitudes, and vehicles on the ground that just have inverters and motors. No costly batteries, let alone the logistical supplies required for fuel and maintenance for combustion. You are no longer limited by the slow moving fuel vehicles; a blitz is a whole other thing now. Generators and solar arrays are the backbone of most forward operating bases - no longer. You have so much more freedom and space as you are no longer restricted by your power / fuel requirements. It will shift the balance of war, vehicles, infrastructure, logistics. For less military uses - imagine doing away with power cables entirely. No more costly infrastructure built above or below the ground. Just a few towers (much like mobile phone towers) transmitting to households. Depending on where the technology goes, imagine not needing batteries in anything anymore. You’re just hooked up to the wireless grid for power too. It’s still in its infancy, but this is pretty significant.
- Retric 5y agoIt might have value in a military setting, but it’s got to be really really stupidly cheap to compete in the civilian space. Which seems extremely unlikely.
- reaperducer 5y agoNo costly batteries, let alone the logistical supplies required for fuel and maintenance for combustion And if the enemy captures your vehicles, you can simply deauthorize them and they won't work anymore.
- thinkmassive 5y agoSounds cool, but also like that satellite is a massive single point of failure
- ghostly_s 5y ago> 1km through the atmosphere is probably all you need to verify that the approach would work for Space Based Solar. How so? Wouldn't a space-based-solar facility need to transmit through the full height of the atmosphere which is much more than 1km?
- coenhyde 5y agoIt is. I guess I was extrapolating without explaining. Whatever results they get from this test at sea level, they should be able to predict the efficiency for a Space Based Solar System. I wasn't necessarily saying their test verifies that Space Based Solar would work, but just that they have the information to determine if it would.
- lazide 5y agoWe already know the efficiency - terrible. Actual end to end efficiency even of this system was more like 2%
- paranoidrobot 5y agoSo what you're proposing is: - Gather a whole shitload of power on-orbit - Build a massive fleet of power-shunting satellites - Deliver all of that down to the ground I think you may have watched too many James Bond movies. What seems to be missing is consideration of what happens to all that 'lost' power. In their test, they sent 91kW, and received 1.6kW, over a distance of 1km. That missing power doesn't just up and disappear, it's heating the air and water between it. You'd have to scale this up, massively -- I'm not good enough at the math or physics, but I can't imagine it gets any easier at longer distances. So what you're really describing is a death-beam that even if you don't cook the people on the ground, is going to be dumping huge amounts of heat into the atmosphere.
- pmoriarty 5y agoIf Space-Based Solar becomes a thing and starts being used in war zones, then it seems almost inevitable that warfare will move in to space... and that could lead to a catastrophic chain reaction of exploding satellites (aka the Kessler syndrome[1]) leading to an impenetrable field of space junk around Earth, which will prevent or at least greatly delay further use/exploration of space. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome
- TechBro8615 5y agoHow would space-based solar increase the risk of warfare in space more than space-based communications and geolocation infrastructure already risks it? Knocking out GPS satellites seems like it’d be nearly as effective as knocking out power-supplying satellites. I guess maybe the difference is there is redundancy in the GPS network – taking out one satellite wouldn’t do much damage, but with power supplying satellites I presume it would.
- Jeff_Brown 5y agoThere's also a symmetry concern. All parties to any conflict would be using something like GPS. But if only one has access to SBS, the others have less to lose by taking the fight into space.
- neltnerb 5y agoOf course, a country that can shoot down a satellite can probably already launch a nuke, if they have one. And they likely have a bunch of stuff in space as well. There are a few counterexamples, but they wouldn't be, for instance, Russia or China or the US. They'd be mad to do that over a power delivery system that they can utilize or hack.
- JaimeThompson 5y agoThe US Military can degrade GPS performance of a selected area while keeping the military encrypted accuracy at standard levels which they did during the Kargil War IIRC.
- gerdesj 5y ago"Imagine being able to deploy energy anywhere on Earth and not have to setup a logistics chain to facilitate it." Logistics is quite a complex beast and you mention "the military". Out of POL (Petrol, Oil, Lubricants) you now have one item nearly sorted - "petrol" ie power source. Your machines also need a few other things to work. Then there is food and water - your army's people need a power source too. Oh and they need a few things to throw at the opposition - munitions. There's a major war being fought in Ukraine right now. Ukraine is bloody huge and it's all about logistics. Russia cannot possibly "win", where win is take and hold all of Ukraine. There was a huge armoured convoy headed for Kyiv and it stalled because it could not possibly have had enough of anything to run for more than a few days. As my dad always used to say (Col. (Retd) RAOC): "An army marches on its stomach". That means that Russia may continue to commit acts of barbarism but it cannot possibly achieve its original aims. They have not got the legs. That's not much comfort for the peoples of Ukraine suffering massive indignity and savage brutality, day after day.
- MobileVet 5y agoLogistics (fuel, food, tires etc) were definitely a contributor to the convoy’s stalled assault. As it turns out, there were also a group of Ukrainian Special forces that pestered and attacked that column relentlessly. Kudos to them and their efforts. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/mar/28/the-drone-operators-who-halted-the-russian-armoured-vehicles-heading-for-kyiv https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/mar/28/the-drone-oper...
- krisoft 5y ago> As it turns out, there were also a group of Ukrainian Special forces that pestered and attacked that column relentlessly. I mean yeah? That is the nature of millitary offensives. The opposition tends to make your life harder every way they can. When someone says that the attack stalled because the attacking force botched the logistics, that doesn’t mean that they forgot that tanks run on fuel. It means that they couldn’t deliver the supplies needed because their logistics were not resilient to enemy action. In the very micro level this might mean that a particular Ukranian soldier shot dead a particular Russian fuel truck driver. (Or they blown up the truck, or trapped it, or misrouted it, or caused them enough fear the truck driver decided to run away instead of getting the supplies to the troops.) On the macro level the details don’t matter, there you can say that the logistic failed. Similarly if during an excercise in your own country the fuel trucks show up a day late that’s not a problem. You spend the day camping next to your tank and the fuel arrives when it arrives. But if the same happens during a real invasion you are a sitting duck the enemy is trying to kill. Logistics failing and the Ukrainan forces pestering and attacking the column are not two different things. They are one and the same, but on two different levels of abstraction.
- ta8645 5y agoIsn't this more likely just the cover story for a space based death ray? Why pass energy to the ground for your troops, if you can just kill your targets from space?
- ReactiveJelly 5y agoAn electric drone with a few bombs and endless range might be able to blow up tougher things than a 1 kW microwave alone
- chris_va 5y agoNo, the ionosphere does weird things, including self-lensing at high enough power densities (frequency dependent too), so there's probably a bit more to test
- coenhyde 5y agoThanks, I wasn't aware of that.
- zo1 5y agoWhere would one learn about that?
- chris_va 5y agoA bit old, but fun read: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19810019084/downloads/19810019084.pdf https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19810019084/downloads/19... ... there are newer sources, but I'd have to dig through notes, nothing very concrete.
- DennisP 5y agoPower density for a beam from geostationary would be quite low. Receiving stations would be kilometers wide.
- Renaud 5y agoI doubt it's never going to be practical enough to be useful, at all. I might be wrong and someone can do the calculation to prove me wrong, but I don't think there is any way you're going to power an army or even a single regiment with that (or even more than a couple of toasters). First, Low Earth Orbit is at least 160km above the Earth. You could do it at 100km but now you have to fight atmospheric drag on top of everything else and constantly need to readjust your orbit to avoid burning up. Forming a beam tight enough that it stays focussed on your small target is the first challenge. Talk about fraction of a degree. You'll get much worse energy loss just there, because your target will always be smaller than the energy spot. If you have to build large targets, then there is a point where it would be more advantageous to just use solar panels on the ground. Second, since you'd be using a low orbit, you'd still be in the dark at night, so no power for you. Third, the lower the orbit, the faster the satellite is going to zoom past in the sky. You'd need a constellation of these to constantly reshape their beam to all their targets. As their distance from the target increases, the power received will also vary a lot. It also means the satellite will have to know the precise location of the target at all times. Might be workable for a static unit, but if you're talking drone/autonomous system, then they will need a way to transmit this information somewhere, very, very accurately too so the beam can find it. It's not something you could deploy anywhere in an instant unless you have thousands of satellites covering all areas of interest. The solar panel size you would need to ensure some decent minimum power received on Earth would be pretty big. Say you have a super efficient solar panel that can get you 30% efficiency, you'd get max of 300W/m2. So you would need very large arrays of panels just to get a few kW on the ground. Now if instead of solar panels you want to beam up energy to bounce from the satellite back to the target, you'd double your problem space: need lots of large emitters that would need to target a constellation of fast moving satellites. Not great unless you know you can deploy them exactly where they are needed, which probably limits the use cases in foreign territories. So, I'd say this will remain a niche application on Earth, where the size of the transmitting arrays depends on the distance to the target, and will probably never go beyond a trial in space if they manage to convince someone to get funding for it.
- newjersey 5y ago> First, Low Earth Orbit is at least 160km above the Earth. You could do it at 100km but now you have to fight atmospheric drag on top of everything else and constantly need to readjust your orbit to avoid burning up. I am just thinking out loud but what if we went out further and added an array of satellites in the geostationary orbits, not to power anything on earth but rather to power each other. I was thinking if we had enough of these satellites and they were in line of sight between each other, could they kind of send power to each other in case one of them was in the dark? Just thinking out loud.
- egsmi0 5y ago> Imagine being able to deploy energy anywhere on Earth and not have to setup a logistics chain to facilitate it. I suppose. But on the other hand, let's say "anywhere on Earth" is a PCB inside an attacking enemy jet fighter. I haven't designed any PCBs for the military, so I don't know what their standards are, but I can say every low voltage circuit I've designed would not appreciate even 10W being dumped into any arbitrary net...
- jakedata 5y agoDetune for death-ray mode.
- awslattery 5y agoHad to do a double take for a minute, as in my days in the Army, we could max out our AN/TRC-170 on troposcatter mode at 2.0 kW, with a substantial range on a good atmosphere day. The use case here, however, is incredibly different. We'd typically be towing 2x 10 kW diesel generators with us, so this is certainly an interesting POC to follow.
- walrus01 5y agoone of the fun things about "modern" troposcatter modems is they're pretty much the same as the more advanced SCPC satellite modems you might see in use for a dedicated piece of transponder kHz in the C or Ku bands, and a geostationary-based link between two locations. I've only done a tiny bit of troposcatter but it's my understanding that the extreme loss in the path generally results in using fairly rudimentary modulation (like QPSK 1/2) with a vast amount of FEC in the total percentage.
- olliej 5y agoWow, 60% is way higher efficiency than I thought these systems were getting. I was fully expecting “using 16kw of power 1.6kw was successfully transmitted”
- SigmundA 5y agoIts was actually 91.2kw of power for 1.6kw on the other end, so actually only 1.8% efficiency. 60% is not measuring end to end efficiency and pretty misleading.
- kylehotchkiss 5y agoit’d be really cool (and understandably unlikely) if this could be harnessed for cargo ships so they don’t need to burn bunker fuel
- moffkalast 5y agoSure easily, as long as the ship stays within 1km of an active transmitter at all times and each transmitter has a power station on it to provide enough juice to push through the losses or is connected to a grid. Might be easier to build nuclear powered ships.
- l-lousy 5y agoI think the end goal here is for the power to be delivered via satellite, which would be great for a ship out on the open ocean. Though you’re right that a nuclear powered ship would be better
- nayuki 5y agoOutside of SimCity games, I never heard of microwave power transmission in the real world...
- MaxBarraclough 5y agoLet's hope we don't end up with the SimCity 2000 variant where the beam occasionally misses the dish and causes a fire. (The Internet tells me that in SimCity 3000 this never occurs.)
- formvoltron 5y agoNext stop, the Dyson sphere.
- KSPAtlas 5y agoDid they use it to power a microwave?
- mNovak 5y agoI'm highly skeptical of the 60% efficiency figure being any sort of end-to-end metric. I suspect that was poorly phrased, and the receiver/rectifier was operating at 60% efficiency (which is reasonable for RF rectifiers), of power incident. But the vast majority of power loss is happening along the path before reaching the receiver. Some ballpark numbers: 1km at 10GHz is ~110dB of path loss. Those look like feasibly 40dBi antennas at both ends. That still leaves -30dB link budget, i.e. 0.1% of energy reaching the target.
- apcragg 5y agoI'm also not convinced that they're even out of Far-field. That looks like a roughly 5m dish, which at 10GHz is still in the radiating near field at 1km. I wouldn't be surprised if the main lobe is entirely incident on receiving aperture. That's a neat demo but it does not demonstrate truly radiating power between two distant points. They've essentially built a fancy a wireless cellphone charger. 60% is also almost certainly not total system. A portable antenna like that by itself, with no path loss or other losses, would likely have an aperture efficiency of about 60%. A planar patch antenna like the one used to receive would be similar.
- toephu2 5y agoFrom the YouTube comments: Video carefully avoids to state that the overall efficiency of the system is 1.8%. Input power was 91.2kW at the TX antenna, out of which 1.65kW was produced at the receiving side. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/mediastore_new/IEEE/content/media/9171629/9673801/9662403/roden.t2-3130765-large.gif https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/mediastore_new/IEEE/content/medi...
- uuyi 5y agoI’m not sure why people get excited about this. Putting 92kW in for a 47dBm over 1km is comedic levels of loss. It’d be more efficient to move a 2kW generator over and send several people on laps with pogo sticks carrying thimbles full of diesel to keep it running. I all really tired of all the unicorn shit being shoveled in the wireless energy transfer research area.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hilbert42 5y agoFrankly, I'm a bit tired of these proposals transmit power by microwaves back to earth, especially so when frequencies such as 10GHz are either proposed or are used as test frequencies. Do these people actually realize the likelihood of interference to RF and Microwave bands from potential intermodulation products that they'd cause? It would be an environmental disaster much worse than Musk's light-radiating satellites. I'd reckon that huge swathes of radio spectrum users includibg radio astronomers would be up in arms at such an outrageous proposal. I've nothing in principle against such a proposal but it needs to be done in a part of the spectrum that will not cause interference to communications - and that will take considerable research and planning. For instance in the infrared or THz spectrum but even then we'd need to take great care for many reasons. (Recently, I've heard of experiments to detect neutrinos in the THz spectrum so that may also be ruled out). I've strong thoughts about the inappropriate funding of this research in the 10GHz spectrum but I'll refrain from further comment for the moment. Just let's say I've insufficient adjectives in my magazine to ensure a knockout.
- NoblePublius 5y agothis beam would charge my Tesla in 2 days
- zw123456 5y agoI have one url to say https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-space_path_loss https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-space_path_loss just look at the equation, physics don't lie. mic drop
- nreilly 5y agoTransferFi [1] has commercial wireless power transfer products. Comparing the two, this commercial option gives 42% efficiency [2] at up to 25m. [1] https://www.transferfi.com https://www.transferfi.com [2] https://www.transferfi.com/s/TFI_Sense_WPN_Spec.pdf https://www.transferfi.com/s/TFI_Sense_WPN_Spec.pdf
- SigmundA 5y ago42% is RF to DC conversion efficiency, absolutely no way those omni antennas are end to end dc-rf-dc 42% wireless transmission efficiency at any distance, its going to be many orders of magnitude worse.
- kibwen 5y ago> The frequency was chosen because it was not only able to beam even in heavy rain with a loss of power of under five percent, it's also safe to use under international standards in the presence of birds, animals, and people. What frequency is this specifically? I'm curious to know how people-safe it is in practice.
- ncmncm 5y agoI wonder about whether a big enough orbiting phased array, with all the elements carefully quantum-entangled, could achieve much better power delivery to a small receiver. In this scenario, the phased array transmitters would be placed randomly in a swarm. The receiver would broadcast a pilot signal, and they would all adjust their phase by the received pilot-signal phase and, implicitly, their position in the swarm. (Maybe the pilot signal is at exactly half or twice the transmit frequency, and a maser, so all its photons are entangled.) I don't know how you arrange to quantum-entangle the transmitting elements and their emitted photons to the pilot signal and (this) to one another. The goal is for all their quantum amplitudes to interfere constructively only at the rectenna, and so deliver all of their energy there. Is there any necessary or enforcible relationship between the photon wave phase and its quantum amplitude? For a decoupled swarm to stay together, each would need to be in a slightly different almost-circular orbit, continually milling about a common center. Alternatively, they could have hair-thin fibers tying them to near neighbors, and all orbit as a unit.
- shadowofneptune 5y agoDepartment of Energy studied the use of phased arrays to beam power (http://spaceflighthistory.blogspot.com/2016/12/energy-from-space-department-of.html http://spaceflighthistory.blogspot.com/2016/12/energy-from-s...). The use of a pilot signal was useful because it prevented any 'death ray' scenarios. The transmitter would only be able to beam power to a receiver, even if it was knocked off target. I am not sure what the benefit of a small receiver would be for power transmission. The DoE system used the same 2.45 GHz frequency as a microwave oven, so the receiver was more like chicken wire than the receivers we are familiar with. They would have been very large to prevent overflying aircraft or birds from being fried by the transmission, and could maybe be placed on pylons over otherwise useful land.
- ncmncm 5y agoIf you could use a small receiver, it could be mounted on an aircraft. The transmitters would have to know the velocity vector of the aircraft so as to adjust their focus to where its receiver will be when the waves get back to it, not where it was when its pilot wave was sent. Without some (quantum) way to ensure that the energy is delivered exclusively to the rectenna, such a system would be hard to justify deploying.
- stuckkeys 5y agoI always thought they used some kind of infrared tech for the endpoint to receive the power boost. Good piece. I love good information. Thank you!
- coding123 5y ago1.6 kW, they might as well have 4 410 watt solar panels. Or just have 20 of them and a battery.
- Decabytes 5y agoThis is how we will power our evangelion style mechs
- andkenneth 5y agowhat would happen if a plane flew through one of these?
- dougbrochill 5y agoOr if someone accidentally walked through it? I can't imagine it would end well...
- verytrivial 5y agoThe only way this is in any way interesting is as a 1950s style death ray, and even then, it's only enough to warm porridge at that distance. A close-quarters vehicle mounted version at 100m might be a different proposition.
- catmanjan 5y ago1.6kw is a nice space heater, I look forward to warmth as a service
- t_mann 5y agoThe headline makes me wonder - what ever became of Tesla's dream of an building a global atmospheric electric power network? Is it for commercial, physical or technical reasons that the idea seems to have been given up?
- belter 5y agoThere are also attempts to use 5G... "5G as a wireless power grid": https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-79500-x https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-79500-x
- silexia 5y agoThe most impressive note in the article is that they only had a power loss of five percent.
- ncmncm 5y agoYet, not really at all.
- BenjiWiebe 5y agoIt says they operated at an efficiency of 60%. 5% is the additional loss when it's raining. Some microwave frequencies are easily rained out.
- jleyank 5y agoA maser? Obviously tuned to avoid hitting the rotational frequencies of things like water vapour (think microwaves). Neat bit of engineering.
- pfdietz 5y agoWhy would you think it's a maser?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- R0b0t1 5y agoThe microwave frequencies we use don't perfectly match water. If they did it would only heat the skin on top. They have some penetration. To do this they probably beamed far more than 1.6kW. You need to heat the vapor in the middle and either go through it or move it out of the way. Fun consequence of this, you can disperse clouds by pointing microwaves up. It doesn't take a massive amount of power either, but scales with power.
- geoduck14 5y agoFor context, 1.6 kW is about enough to power 1 home appliance: a dishwasher, refrigerator, or toaster. I think your A/C would be more - but I'm not certain If you had Solar panels deliver this power, you could get similar power if you spent ~$1.5k on a panel 6.5 ft X 16 ft
- Neil44 5y agoMy toaster is about 1kw, fridge and freezer a few hundred watts. 1.6 is touch and go for a dishwasher though.
- willis936 5y agoThose appliances nearly never have 100% duty cycle. It's important to note that this power can be transmitted when it is cloudy or nighttime and could potentially require less weight and setup. I'm not saying line-of-sight transmission is a great solution, but this is an impressive engineering demonstration with some limited battlefield application.
- closeparen 5y agoHow much does a battery powered drone need to recharge?
- nannal 5y agoPerfect application for this tech. Drones can fly back to the ship to recharge without landing, local aerial defence fleets can be lighter as they'd need a smaller capacity battery. Moderately long distance wireless power transmission has a whole host of applications.
- tapland 5y agoIn the US this is almost exactly the maximum you'll find to not risk blowing fuses. Electric heaters are probably the most obvious continuous draw ones.
- tuatoru 5y agoYeah, but only for fixed sites, or intermittently mobile sites. Perovskites open the possibility of printing your solar cells on flexible films, so the panels can be unrolled like projector screens or greenhouse roofs, and rolled up again.[1] 10-15 kW of panels and suitable batteries would get you near 1.6 kW continuous. This (microwave power beaming) is for battlefield applications, where mobility is primary. 1. Several groups are developing these. For example in Australia, https://www.csiro.au/en/research/technology-space/energy/Photovoltaics/Printed-Solar-Cells https://www.csiro.au/en/research/technology-space/energy/Pho...
- mikeweiss 5y agoAnything in-between the beam would be badly burned or set on fire.... Correct?
- white_dragon88 5y ago[dead]
- vernon99 5y agoNo. “ The frequency was chosen because it was not only able to beam even in heavy rain with a loss of power of under five percent, it's also safe to use under international standards in the presence of birds, animals, and people. This means the system doesn't need the automatic cutouts developed for earlier laser-based systems.”
- GordonS 5y ago> it's also safe to use under international standards in the presence of birds, animals, and people Wow, is it really safe to beam 1.6kW of microwave energy through a person?
- speed_spread 5y agoThe beam is likely much wider than a person and at a precise frequency requiring a tuned antenna to convert it efficiently to electricity or heat. You might not want to stand in it for minutes, but passing through would be safe enough.
- skykooler 5y agoTheoretically, it should be equivalent to standing directly in front of a space heater in the worst case (if the human absorbs 100% of the microwaves).
- qgin 5y agoDepends on how focused the energy is. The sun is beaming over 1MW per square meter and it doesn’t vaporize people.
- KaiserPro 5y agoThe key point here is that it has a 60% efficient. The question is, why is it important? Well in the later part of Afghanistan war, significant time, money, and lives were spend shipping diesel around. If you can avoid that, you can save a shit tonne on logistics.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoSo like all technological achievements, things will improve so the amount of power that can be transmitted will increase and the distance will increase. At some point in the future it might become feasible to beam the energy down from a Low Earth Orbiting Satellite, which would transfer logistical costs into the preemptive side of accountancy instead of reactionary accountancy, but if they could do this from a LEO, then perhaps its also become a bit of a non ballistics weapon which may not be covered/restrained by current international agreements.
- FredPret 5y agoThere is a power plant in Sim City that operates on this principle. Would be cool to have a nuclear reactor in orbit!
- Terry_Roll 5y agoTesla built the means to transmit power in the early 1900's. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wardenclyffe_Tower https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wardenclyffe_Tower https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wireless_power_transfer#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wireless_power_transfer#Histor... I would imagine alot of Radio transmitting knowledge would be useful in this domain of knowledge.
- uuyi 5y agoEx RF engineer here. No he didn’t. He was a con man.
- 5y ago
- gpm 5y agoIs there some reason that this doesn't scale up to however high you want if you add more input power? I would have thought that 60% efficiency would be the interesting figure, not 1.6 kW. I wonder if you could use this for "aerial refueling" of an electric drone - might be a cheaper way to make small long-endurance vehicles than trying to stick ICEs in them (though it has the downside of "tethering" them to a ground station).
- walrus01 5y agogoogle "microwave atmospheric path loss calculation" or "microwave free space path loss" - standard calculations for point to point microwave telecom systems, you lose quite a lot to the molecules in the air. probably would work a whole lot better in a vacuum.
- buu700 5y agoIs there any chance that this could ever be reliable enough to act as the primary power source for a plane? (In other words, you'd keep just enough fuel/battery onboard for emergency landings, and otherwise rely almost entirely on space microwaves.) If so, is there any possibility that it could also provide sufficient throughput to handle supersonic flight? What if we spent most of the journey at a very high altitude, or even in/near LEO?
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoSome day, probably. But right now others have pointed out that this system is actually only 1.8% efficient as the 60% figure was just loss from antenna to antenna, but the initial input was almost 100kW! And I don’t know much about this but it seems shooting high energy beams of radiation everywhere creates other issues.
- s5300 5y agoHi buu700, Weird question - came across an earlier comment of yours. Do you happen to have a spare tube of Biomin F you’d be willing to sell me stateside? Thanks.
- walrus01 5y agothe cassegrain reflector design dish aimed sideways like that looks remarkably similar to a 1970s era troposcatter data link system used by the DoD.
- cwillu 5y agoThe very latest in coerced wireless heating technology.