9 ms·
One of the reasons I left google is that their "content moderation team" (the folks who make you take down wrongthink memes) is so far out of touch, that somebo
by dekhn 5y ago
One of the reasons I left google is that their "content moderation team" (the folks who make you take down wrongthink memes) is so far out of touch, that somebody had to explain to them there are people in the world who are discriminated against, but aren't black. They simply didn't know that was the case! And if that's the people who are moderating content...
I said motherboard all the time in meetings and chats, never had any pushback. TBH if I did get pushback on that one, I'd bring it to HR and say the pushback was affecting my ability to get work down.
- nebulous_two 5y agoPut yourself in the shoes of your average content moderator. Aren't they there for the paycheck like most people at their jobs? Why does everyone assume these people are first and foremost bastions of acceptable behaviour? They are instructed by executives as to how to do their jobs. Now executives are learning nuance and say "oh there's more to this than you thought, so here's the updated guidelines to follow now", to shift blame for this broken system to the moderators when all along they were following orders from above.
- dekhn 5y agoNo, those folks are not there just to get a paycheck. They are evangelists for a viewpoint who use their moderation powers to eliminate thoughts they don't like. And yes, those teams really did come up with their determinations of what was OK and what wasn't, based on their own beliefs. That made that quite clear in their repeated, stupid posts on memegen.
- macksd 5y agoAre other cases of online abuse, workplace harassment, discrimination, etc. so rare that people are actually chasing problems like this for a paycheck? It would be wonderful if that was the case, but I doubt that it is.
- dotnet00 5y agoI think the point you're missing is that often moderators are in that position because they specifically want the power that comes with it. We see this all the time with volunteer moderators getting high on their power, pushing through whatever agenda they have regardless of user opinion. I think those types of people are even more likely to end up as paid content moderators, since the work tends to be too tedious for most average people to deal with.
- newjersey 5y ago» I think the point you're missing is that often moderators are in that position because they specifically want the power that comes with it. I love that you were courageous enough to say this because this is completely true and also why we say #ACAB. Most people who want to be police officers are absolutely unfit to be police officers!
- dotnet00 5y agoI hadn't actually thought about applying that reasoning to the police and while there is a higher bar to becoming a police officer, I do have to agree with the overall idea. There probably isn't any job which is an exception to this, politicians are similarly mainly people who want the associated influence and even engineers become engineers so they have control over engineering. It's just that the incentives are more perverse with politicians, police and moderators than with engineers.
- bombcar 5y agoOnce the pool for some jobs gets large enough, the self selection of those who apply for it can become a problem. From what I understand from rumors in the area, is those who couldn't become police (for whatever reason) would then go apply at the prison, and those who couldn't get a job there (and it appears they take anyone with a pulse) would go work for TSA. Perhaps the "public servant" idea should be taken to a larger extreme, and some positions picked by lottery instead.
- skrbjc 5y agoMany people willingly do things like this voluntarily at their jobs to the point that the job they were hired for seems like a second priority for them.
- reaperducer 5y agoso far out of touch, that somebody had to explain to them there are people in the world who are discriminated against, but aren't black. Sounds preposterous, but is not. I had a boss around 2000 who believed wholeheartedly that people brought from Africa to the United States were the only slaves that ever existed in history anywhere on Earth. This came up because someone noted in passing conversation that an anniversary was coming up related to the Atlantic slave trade in the 1600's, and my boss insisted that there couldn't have been slavery before 1776, because slavery was started by the United States. I walked out of the break room early in the conversation and decided to let the others handle it. She was my boss, and I would have gotten fired for contradicting her.
- knorker 5y agoNot only that, but there are more than three times as many slaves TODAY as ever were in the transatlantic slave trade that is the only one the US knows exists.
- hedora 5y agoThere are more slaves added each year in the US today than at the peak of transatlantic trade: https://www.britannica.com/summary/Transatlantic-Slave-Trade-Timeline https://www.britannica.com/summary/Transatlantic-Slave-Trade... Peak transatlantic: 78,000 new slaves per year. https://thecurrentmsu.com/2021/01/24/prison-labor-americas-secret-workforce/ https://thecurrentmsu.com/2021/01/24/prison-labor-americas-s... Current US forced prison labor population: 1-2.1 million.
- hedora 5y agoWow, lots of replies are trying to downplay the existence ongoing human suffering. A few things to consider: - A disproportionate number of prisoners are African American, and that subset are mostly in prison for crimes that whites simply don't go to prison for (e.g., pot, or coke vs. crack). - US prisoners aren't given nutritionally adequate food for free. They have to buy that at inflated prices from the prison. Once they blow through any savings, their only option (other than malnutrition) is to work for wages that would be illegally low outside of prison. - As during the transatlantic trade, it is straightforward to buy your way out of forced prison labor. - A growing fraction of prisoners consider the current system to be eugenics as well as slavery. The prisons take the majority of men while they are at prime child rearing age. It's well known that any that do manage to have kids will probably be forced into a situation where they can't adequately care for those children (dad goes to prison for driving while black or whatever), making the next generation easy targets for the same scheme. (This is coming from current prisoners, not me.) The other pushback against my comment boils down to "it's legal, so we don't use that word". Similar arguments were made in defense of the transatlantic trade. For instance, black Africans were generally the ones selling slaves, and often used real or imagined criminal records as an excuse. Any objective comparison of the two systems would find that the transatlantic slave trade was roughly as immoral California's three strike law is in practice. You could argue the slave trade was worse because the kids were automatically slaves. In the current system, they're only probably going to prison, but the prisons also aren't paying to raise them. I suggest reading Things Fall Apart if you're unfamiliar with the African side of the slave trade.
- knorker 5y ago> I said motherboard all the time in meetings and chats, never had any pushback. TBH if I did get pushback on that one, I'd bring it to HR and say the pushback was affecting my ability to get work down. And get Damore'd?
- dekhn 5y agoI'm not worried about being Damore'd, as I have a lot more experience fighting progressives than he does.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThe easiest way to not be Damore'd is to apologize and repent. Damore doubled down and at that point (because the gap between "manager" and "employee" at Google is so narrow) became a walking Title VII violation. Once his coworkers came out in public saying they wouldn't be able to work with him, Google was backed (legally and PR-wise) completely into a corner. It turns out American companies are not the Athenian Lyceum, and some topics are not up for debate.
- nullc 5y ago> The easiest way to not be Damore'd is to apologize and repent. What? Absolutely not. That is terrible advice when it comes to something that couldn't have been a literal accident. If he'd used the word "mother", then sure-- that could be apologized for. But a protracted essay on population level statistical differences between genders and its impact on the employment pool? Not a chance. There is so much noise and outright disinformation about any issue that often the only reliable source for wrong doing is when the target of an accusation admits it themselves. And even when that fails to protect you, at least you can be a hero to someone. Do you think a damore that apologized and said he was mistaken would be more employable? That people would eventually see it as a youthful transgression? I doubt it greatly-- it's not like the screens that show up when you google his name will yellow with age. Instead he'd just be the enemy to both factions of the war he wandered into, rather than enemy of one and hero to the other.
- duxup 5y agoOne of the challenges with moderation teams like that or similar is that the folks who REALLY want to do that job .. are the folks who absolutely should NOT be doing it.
- tempnow987 5y agoThis is I think a major issue. The passionate people on these committees have views that are perhaps in the 10% edge of spectrum. No mothers, birthing persons etc etc.
- xwdv 5y ago
- CoastalCoder 5y agoI very much relate to that sentiment. One thing that keeps me in check is that, I assume, the feeling is mutual. I'm guessing that in both camps there are people who have trouble believing that the other side is arguing/acting in good faith, because their position is so obviously ludicrous.
- Auracle 5y agoFor anyone reading this, I volunteer. My moderation level would be based on words that were considered bad in the year 2005. I won’t have to do much work and you still get to say that you have someone that’s doing the job. Win-win.
- humanistbot 5y agoAh, the culture war version of the famous Douglas Adams quote about technology: "1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. 2. Anything that's invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. 3. Anything invented after you're thirty-five is against the natural order of things."
- blueflow 5y ago> that somebody had to explain to them there are people in the world who are discriminated against, but aren't black I wouldn't have believed you that there are people like this, but a few minutes after i read your comment, i saw replies (requires showdead) to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31123102 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31123102 that said men cannot be discrimated against...
- grishka 5y ago> somebody had to explain to them there are people in the world who are discriminated against, but aren't black. As a Russian, this is amusing to read. For me and most people I know, when you meet a black person, it's totally normal to ask them "where are you from" because they can't possibly be local. Our society just doesn't have the concept of racism it seems because of the exceeding rarity of people who aren't European or Asian. People in Russia are often discriminated against based on their sexual orientation, political views, and nationality though.
- duskwuff 5y ago> Our society just doesn't have the concept of racism it seems because of the exceeding rarity of people who aren't European or Asian. "Slave is an Ephebian word. In Om we have no word for slave," said Vorbis. "So I understand," said the Tyrant. "I imagine that fish have no word for water." -- Terry Pratchett, Small Gods
- grishka 5y agoEither way, people here aren't discriminated based on their race. Never were. This particular problem seems to be uniquely American because of their history. We do have a word for racism by the way. It's, unsurprisingly, "расизм".
- GordonS 5y agoAmerica certainly takes racism to extremes, but it's not a problem unique to the US - racism is a thing all over Europe and Asia too, to varying degrees. I've never been to Russia, but I'm finding it hard to believe racism doesn't exist there.
- kofejnik 5y agohaving lived in Russia, I assure you there's a lot of pretty open racism there, racist slurs are openly and widely used for anyone who's not a slav, and even some slavs now as well (e.g. Ukrainians)
- yupper32 5y agoSorry but did you just say one of the reasons you left google was the memegen moderation team? I can't imagine that being a legitimate worry that would impact my employment decisions. It seems there's a group of people who are too far in the other direction too. When I heard that it's preferred to say "allowlist" instead of "whitelist", do you know what my reaction was? "Sure, whatever." And I moved on with my life. It has zero impact on my day to day. The pushback reminds me of people who deadname others on purpose. Like, who cares? Bob wants to be called Sally now? Sure, whatever.
- karmakurtisaani 5y agoI find this a very reasonable approach. I also find it natural that language evolves and sometimes it can even be marginally beneficial to artificially guide the evolution. All in all, in practice it just doesn't matter in my life.
- djitz 5y ago
- nicbou 5y agoYou're right. I use the new terms and move on. It's really not that bad. However it tends to become a password game. There's a new password every few months. If you know the new password, you get to feel above those who don't. It's as we invent new crimes to charge people with. If no one calls it out (because sure, whatever), it keeps ratcheting up. Then banal conversations turn into minefields. What you say gets invalidated because you used the wrong password.
- yupper32 5y ago> What you say gets invalidated because you used the wrong password. Is this a common occurrence for you? It has never happened to me. I'm skeptical about whether it's actually and issue or mostly a hypothetical issue.
- AJ007 5y agoIt's also terrible for real long term projects to be continually renaming things and modifying naming conventions. Engineering isn't fashion.
- Mezzie 5y ago> somebody had to explain to them there are people in the world who are discriminated against, but aren't black. blinks in disabled lesbian
- uoaei 5y agoHoly straw man, Batman!
- dang 5y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31123615 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31123615.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]