12 ms·
Got food cravings? What’s living in your gut may be responsible
- smallerfish 5y agoDoes anybody know of good research which shows how long it takes the microbiome to adjust if you significantly change diet? New diets can be hard to stick with initially, and it seems like the gut's "needs" may be a real cause of this.
- hirundo 5y agoI'm a long-time serial dieter who has radically changed my diet on several occasions now, from SAD to vegitarian to SAD to vegan to SAD to raw vegan to SAD to FODMAP to SAD to McDougall high carb to paleo low carb to meat-centered to (currently) carnivore. (Among others.) Each time (moving to non-SAD) it takes around six months before I stop naturally losing weight and either stabilize (on carnivore) or start heading back up (on everything else). I attribute this mostly to the microbiome, so by my own N=1 experiments, I'd say about six months.
- kshacker 5y agoAs a fellow failed dieter, just trying to find something that will work for me ... So you switch diets because you stabilize and want more weight loss, OR because they stop working? Curious to hear about the switch. My personal preference is sugar-free. Successful for 2 years from 2016-2018, and now trying low-sugar (not no sugar) since January 2022, and reasonably successful although not much (just 6 lbs about 3%) to show for it.
- hirundo 5y agoI was a failed dieter from age 7 to 57. It took me that long to figure out that this body works best on animal products. I was never a particular meat eater and had to be forced to try it by an inability to move my bowels on anything else. But it has reduced and stabilized my weight like nothing else has, while all but eliminating my cravings for SAD food. I really like eating this way now, and get as much or more pleasure from food than ever. When I switched it was in despair over failure. They all (but the last) stopped working, though I continued to follow them religiously. For years I was an obsessive food diarist, and have books full of logs on what I ate, with charts showing how my weight gradually stabilized well before goal, and started going up again. This followed the trend of my appetite. When I switch diets my appetite goes down, and it recovers gradually over that half-year. I think going sugar-free is a great move, but from sources like https://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.com/ https://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.com/ have come to think that avoiding seed-oils is even more important, over a span of decades.
- mirceal 5y agoimagine all the microbiome meetings and all the unhappy little fellas having to go through a reorg every 6 months. :)
- octokatt 5y agoThis was a good enough question I started researching. TL;DR: Your microbiome adapts quickly, but you don't get to see the full effects for weeks to months. Turns out, your microbiome will shift significantly within a few days of changing your diet [0]. A more recent study showed that increasing raw vegetables in your diet significantly changed microbiome at about the same speed [1]. However, because the _effects_ of a healthy microbiome are things like better vitamin reception and disease prevention [2] [3], it can take months to see the effects of something like better B12 can take weeks to see [4]. Disease prevention of metabolic diseases takes years to see fully. [0] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-guts-microbiome-changes-diet/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-guts-microbio... [1] https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2019/10/study-finds-gut-microbes-adapt-quickly-to-changes-in-food-preparation/ https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2019/10/study-finds-g... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_microbiome#Disease_and_death https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_microbiome#Disease_and_d... [3] https://depts.washington.edu/ceeh/downloads/FF_Microbiome.pdf https://depts.washington.edu/ceeh/downloads/FF_Microbiome.pd... [4] https://www.nhs.uk/medicines/cyanocobalamin/ https://www.nhs.uk/medicines/cyanocobalamin/
- dbcurtis 5y agoAnother link for you https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25198208/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25198208/
- virtuallynathan 5y agoIt’s very quick: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3957428/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3957428/
- dbcurtis 5y agoThere is general research that shows that after about two weeks of limited inputs, bacteria colonies will go dormant, retreating into the structural matrix ("slime") that bacteria produce for themselves. If fed, they will come roaring back relatively quickly. To mostly kill off a species of bacteria, it can take months (6-ish?) of starving them during their dormant state. Sorry, no links, just reporting recollections from general reading that I have been doing. Stop reading now unless you are interested in cardio-vascular disease. I started researching this a little over a year ago when I got a cardiac stent to prop open a 99% blockage in the left anterior descending artery. Yeah, I was probably within weeks of having the classic widow-maker heart attack. (I didn't, and I'm now fit and healthy, so I consider myself lucky.) I eventually found a line of research out of the Cleveland Clinic, work done by Dr. Caldwell Esselstyn. His work is based on this: 1. CVD is the result of an injury to the endothelium that first attracts white blood cells to the damage, then cholesterol joins the party and they form "foam" cells that can get under the endothelium and eventually calcify. 2. The endothelium produces Nitric Oxide gas that is both a vaso-dialator and also helps the endothelium repair itself and cleanse itself of non-calcified foam cells. 3. The primary driver of CVD that is associated with the standard American diet is that the diet destroys the Nitric Oxide blood gas. How does that destruction of Nitric Oxide happen? 1. Carnitine, lecithin, and other proteins found in meat, fish, diary, and oils are metabolized by a colony of gut bacteria to produce tri-methyl amine (TMA). 2. TMA travels to the liver and is metabolized into tri-methyl amine oxdide (TMAO). 3. TMAO enters the blood stream and annihilates nitric oxide, robbing the endothelium of its self-defense mechanism. Eating a meal that feeds that bacteria colony will suppress nitric oxide blood gas for 6 to 8 hours. So, if you eat the SAD at every meal, the level of nitric oxide will never recover. I am on a mission to starve those little bacteria bastards out. Kill'em all with gleeful murder in my heart. So for about a year I have been on a diet that is most easily described as vegan, with the additional restriction of no oils and high-oil foods. I wish I had some good way of measuring my blood TMAO levels. I don't, so I'm just going by the general rule of being as strict as possible for several months to try to knock the bacteria out as best as I can.
- tayo42 5y agoIf i remember correctly nitric oxide is/was a pretty popular weight lifting supplement. Did you ever try supplementing it?
- obblekk 5y agoI didn't realize this until recently, but we don't actually know every chemical compound that's in our blood. As in, I don't believe there has been a study that takes 1 liter of blood and just documents every chemical structure found (at any concentration). Realizing that + learning about the seemingly vast gut microbiome has definitely led me to feel more humbled about what we know and can predict about human biology. I now think it's possible (but certainly not proven) that some hard to anticipate cascade of compounds (produced by gut, or foods, or environmental, or whatever) could be responsible for significantly increasing subjective feelings of hunger across the population at large, and this could lead to more calories being eaten than needed. I'm actually optimistic that this has happened, because then there might be an effective way to reverse the health problems we see... much like removing leaded gasoline seems to have helped reduce crime rates.
- tamaharbor 5y agoWhy is it scientists would have us believe that they know everything definitively regarding covid, covid vaccines, climate change, etc?
- pc86 5y agoLiterally no scientist has ever said that they know everything definitively about any topic, let alone those.
- coding123 5y agoBut we ascribe policy as if they do know 100%.
- pc86 5y agoThe fact that politicians are idiots, in addition to surprising approximately zero people, shouldn't be used to impugn science.
- Spivak 5y agoI think there's a difference between "we make and adjust policy based on the strongest theory we have with an extra dose of caution" and "we think science is infallible."
- nvusuvu 5y agoI eliminated food cravings in perhaps an unorthodox method. It wasn't my intention, but I am better off for it I believe. I started with a 72 hour fast (water only). After that, I had a bite of a steamed carrot and the experience immediately after tasting the carrot was the biggest natural high of my life. It was like my brain dumped every pleasure producing chemical into my bloodstream. I started to focus on healthy veggies and fish/chicken with small servings of nuts and avocados. I lost 20 pounds (so far) and don't craze processed sugars like I have in the past. When you stop eating a lot of sugar, the gut biome bacteria chlamydia starves I think, and you are much healthy for it.
- standardUser 5y agoSimilarly, I have found that every time I severely limit carbs for a solid 3-4 days my appetite flatlines instead of rapidly rising and falling throughout the day. And everything starts to taste better. And I have way less gas.
- markdown 5y ago> And I have way less gas. Sounds like you have a gluten intolerance.
- colechristensen 5y ago> the gut biome bacteria chlamydia starves I think, and you are much healthy for it. I believe you are thinking of candida which is a kind of yeast which is fungi not bacteria.
- mark_l_watson 5y agoI think that you are correct. I have been on Dr. Fuhrman's Eat to Live diet a few times: start by eating no processed food and drastically reduce sugar intake unless it is berries or a little fruit. After about a week, the level of candida in your system is reduced to levels closer to what humans had > 50 years ago. At this point, all sorts of food cravings (especially deserts) go away, and homemade meals from natural ingredients taste very good. The first time I went on this diet, I felt 10 or 15 years younger with lots of energy.
- matthewdgreen 5y agoThere's a ton of very new research on this. The big exciting candidate right now is Akkermansia muciniphila, which seems to emit a glucagon-like peptide that moderates appetite [1] (similar to drugs like Wegovy, only maybe without the side effects.) The western high-fat/carb diet also seems to cause Akkermansia populations to drop precipitously, which may be either cause or a separate side-effect of the obesity epidemic. Apparently supplementing Akkermansia in obese mice has extremely beneficial effects on weight and all sorts of health measures. I tried some from the only supplier in the US and (unfortunately) noticed absolutely no difference, N=1. Still, I am eagerly awaiting the day when someone conclusively nails the obesity epidemic down to something as simple as gut dysbiosis. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41564-021-00880-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41564-021-00880-5
- echelon 5y agoWhile I'm fairly convinced that a lot of dysfunction gets a helping hand from microbiota imbalance, including such faraway targets as pulmonary, cardiac, and even neurodegenerative disorders [1], I think there's a simpler culprit: sugar. Metabolism of simple sugars changes biochemical gears, and we as a culture and society are heavy on its use. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29882347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29882347
- matthewdgreen 5y agoSugar definitely seems bad, but doesn't explain why simple fecal transplants are able to replicate many of the health effects of a low-carb diet without the actual diet, at least in some obese mice [1]. (PS I am definitely not an expert in this area, just someone who is tired of eating low-carb to maintain weight, and wondering why other people can just eat normal food.) [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6199268/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6199268/
- nebulous_two 5y agoThe whole thing about fecal transplants is that the resulting changes in your microbiome make it so your pull to sugar is weakened. Your diet changes because your cravings change. Imagine how easy it would be if you craved food that was "good for you", or that your cravings for bad food were severely weakened. That's kinda what having a healthy microbiome is like
- narrator 5y agoI'm on day 10 of a 14 day water fast. The hunger was very bad for about the first 7 days and now its been nothing. The idea of eating is interesting to me, but the visceral hunger constantly reminding me to eat isn't there anymore. Long term fasting is great like that.
- herpderperator 5y agoAre you really not eating for 2 weeks?
- narrator 5y agoYes, really. Some people do it for 30 days or more if they have a very large amount of weight to lose. You have to take electrolytes (potassium, sodium, magnesium), and it should never be done if underweight. I started getting seriously into fasting when I asked all the people I met at longevity conferences who looked extremely good for their age what practices they used. The ones who looked the best for their age were longer-term fasters. Fun fact, the longest fast was 382 days[1]. The guy started at 456 lbs and ended up at 180 lbs. [1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angus_Barbieri%27s_fast https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angus_Barbieri%27s_fast
- filoleg 5y agoI am very curious about a couple of things regarding that experience, so I hope you dont mind if I ask a question. I want to preface it by saying that I am not trying to dismiss this pracice as inherently dangerous or bad (because I frankly have no idea). While with 14 days of it probably not being a concern in that aspect, but do people who do it for much longer periods (100+ days, or maybe even less would qualify) not have any atrophy-related issues in relevant systems? Anything related to their intestines and all the way to the exit, wouldn't they lose a significant amount of their ability to do their jobs properly? I am not saying they should be able to start processing 5000kcal of carb heavy food immediately in a single meal after the fasting stops with no issues (as that 5000kcal meal can would give quite a lot of healthy people who dont fast issues as well), but would their intestines actually be able to function fine again? I mean, for something even as banal as sphincter muscles, I am simply lost. Is human body actually that adaptable to handle it like a no big deal?
- nwe 5y agoIn case anyone get the idea from reading the article that tryptophan and serotonin are good for you, check out Ray Peat and he has extensive writings on them.
- rednerrus 5y agoMy observation is that there are two type of brains when it comes to processing serotonin. One type processes it quickly and increased serotonin increases good feelings. The other type processes it very slowly and increased serotonin creates all kinds of problems for this type. This type also tends to struggle with slow processing of catecholamines.
- nwe 5y agoAccording to Ray Peat, serotonin has many other functions in the body and increased serotonin can cause problems. Here is a good read: https://raypeat.com/articles/articles/serotonin-depression-aggression.shtml https://raypeat.com/articles/articles/serotonin-depression-a...
- RugnirViking 5y agoSomething that's always confused me is how I get powerful cravings for sugar, but am relatively untempted by salty foods or carbohydrates, wheras my sister(very close in age to myself) isn't tempted at all by sugar but is a sucker for salty foods. We grew up in a presumably quite similar culinary environment. I've often wondered If the differences can be explained by gut bacteria. Also, surely the claim that this is the first study to show a link between gut bacteria and food choice is wrong? I'm pretty I've known about the link for years?
- ip26 5y agoI’m pretty sure sugar cravings in my family are simply garden variety hunger. For us “sweet tooth” mostly correlates with missed meals. The brain runs on glucose, so when the body is low on food and blood sugar dips, sugar is the “quick fix” for the brain.
- The_rationalist 5y ago
- codyb 5y agoI've been getting some bad acid reflux lately leading to gnawing in my stomach due to a lifestyle with lots of going out recently as the weather gets better and more events start happening and everyone comes out from covid and the winter. Looking forward to a hopefully relaxing May to take it easy for a bit! It's amazing how much yogurt helps though. It's very noticeable, and very quick.
- armchairhacker 5y agoThis 100% lines up with my experience, every time I’ve changed my diet I started to prefer the foods I was eating. Instead of palate fatigue, eating something a lot causes me to crave it more. I used to eat a diet of mostly frozen foods. Then I made an effort to eat more vegetables and suddenly started craving vegetables. I use to prefer high-carb low-fat, then I started eating more meat and gradually shifted to preferring low-carb high-fat, except when I took a break and alternated between the two.
- sitkack 5y agoMy pet theory is that we have to constantly change our diet, behaviors, etc to move faster than the bacteria and the fungus, otherwise they adapt and start controlling the host. The fasts proscribed by some cultures might be a way to reset our guests.
- diogenescynic 5y agoPeople used to have to change their diet seasonally and buy what was available at the local market. Now people can buy the same product year round and get stuck in a narrow diet.
- User23 5y agoThis made my brain go straight to pregnancy. The women I’ve spoken to all describe it as feeling like they’re experiencing someone else’s cravings.
- sydthrowaway 5y agotldr.. whats the best way to stop hunger cravings.. green tea?
- donatj 5y agoI spent most of my life hating pickles. Suddenly a couple a couple months ago I started craving them like crazy out of nowhere. I bought a jar to the dismay of my wife who hates them, and found that I now loved them. I've in the last couple months gone through 4 jars of pickles. I have zero explanation. I mentioned it to my doctor even, and he seemed wildly disinterested. I wonder if something in my gut changed?
- kshacker 5y agoI never liked chocolates. Then about 4-5 years back (then late 40s for me), I started eating, and then for the next 2-3 years, I could never resist having a chocolate. Then after some effort from my side, I stopped and now I do not feel as tempted, but I remember the days.