13 ms·
Apple must pay a man $1,000 for not including a power adapter with new iPhone
- belval 5y agoIt's an interesting take, I wonder if the argument hinges on USB-C not having market penetration everywhere. For example I (Canada not Brazil) have mostly USB-A wall chargers, with only one USB-C charger that came with my phone. If Apple had chose to give a USB-C to USB-A cable while not providing a wall charger, would the case still stand?
- gwoplock 5y agoThe thing that gets me here is the "exclusive manufacturer". I don't see how that can ever be the case. You aren't required to use Apple's brick or cable (though they have to be certified).
- wccrawford 5y agoApple even presented that stance in court, but they seem to have rejected it because of the USB C plug rather than the older style. They also didn't buy that it reduced waste since they sell it separately. Personally, it would reduce waste for me. I have a ton of those plugs and cables in many combinations. But I could see how some people might not have it yet. Perhaps Apple should have offered it for free for a couple years if you ask for it, rather than include it by default, and maybe they would have been better off here. Edit: I'm wondering if I misread it. Is it a proprietary plug on the charger end of the cord? If so, that makes a little more sense, though there are generics for it for a while now anyhow.
- jsnell 5y ago> They also didn't buy that it reduced waste since they sell it separately. But that's a bizarre take from the judge as well. Obviously the claim isn't that no charger is needed. It's that you need way fewer chargers than devices, so shipping a charger with every device is indeed just waste.
- gwoplock 5y ago> Is it a proprietary plug on the charger end of the cord? If so, that makes a little more sense, though there are generics for it for a while now anyhow Iphones come with a Lightning (proprietary) to USB-C (standard) cable but no USB-C (or any other) brick. So there shouldn't be anything proprietary needed to plug it in.
- mastercheph 5y agoI will help you reduce waste, send me all of your extra plugs and cables and I will pay the shipping.
- kingcharles 5y agoThere are definitely ways out of this for Apple. Obviously they can go back to including the brick in certain jurisdictions like this. The other good solution, as you say, is to ask the customer if they need one, and offer them something else, like a 10% off coupon, if they reject the charger. Otherwise everyone will simply say "yes" even if they don't need it.
- wccrawford 5y agoI know a lot of people would take one, even if they don't actually want it, just because it's free. But I know there are things like that in the past that I haven't opted into because I realized I really didn't need another one sitting around, or even just didn't need a first one. Oculus' free rubber insert for example. I have a third party one that I like and didn't need the one Oculus offered, so I didn't take them up on it. It'll partially reduce their cost right now and get people used to the idea that it won't be there in the future, instead of this shock where it's just not there, but expected.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 5y agoIt has to do with a law about 'tied sales' where you can't sell something that requires people to buy a second thing in order to for the first thing to work.
- vlovich123 5y agoTied sales are about requiring you to buy another of your products only, no? Like if I buy a remote control without batteries included, that's not a tied sale. Is it a tied sale because to get the full fast speed charging it has to be Apple or Apple-licensed in some way because they don't fully support PD? EDIT: > But the judge rejected the argument, saying the cable didn't work with wall adapters lacking a USB-C port, with which the Apple charger was designed. I really don't follow this reasoning. It sounds more like Apple is having some political trouble in Brazil and this is the evolution of it.
- gwoplock 5y ago> I really don't follow this reasoning. It sounds more like Apple is having some political trouble in Brazil and this is the evolution of it. Hadn't thought about that but I think that's the real take here. Since I can't make sense of any other reason they gave.
- changoplatanero 5y agoIs one allowed to sell a bicycle in brazil without also selling a pump for the tires?
- tremon 5y agoOnly if the nozzles are industry-standard. If you sell a bike with pentalobe-shaped nozzles and only you make such pumps, you must include the pump with the sale.
- gwoplock 5y ago> Only if the nozzles are industry-standard. If you sell a bike with pentalobe-shaped nozzles and only you make such pumps, you must include the pump with the sale But this is more akin to shipping with an adaptor to the standard nozzle but not the pump. And you can buy 3rd party pumps and adaptors with whatever ends you want.
- gwoplock 5y ago> The judge said Apple had "obliged the consumer to purchase a second product of its exclusive manufacture," This take is baffling to me. While I don't necessarily agree with Apple's decision to take the charger out and change to USB-C at the same time, this is an awful take. First of all there's a million and 1 USB-C chargers from many different manufactures. Second, USB-A to C adapters exist. Third, there are 3rd party manufacturers of USB-A to Lightning cables. I'm confused how anyone could believe Apple is the exclusive manufacturer of anything required for an IPhone but the phone.
- rahimnathwani 5y ago"there's a million and 1 USB-C chargers from many different manufactures" How many of these are compliant with specs? How would you know? If you fry your $1000 iPhone due to choosing incorrectly, will Apple refund you?
- egwor 5y agoSee joshvm’s reply here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31112241 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31112241
- rahimnathwani 5y agoMFi doesn't cover USB-C chargers: https://mfi.apple.com/en/faqs.html https://mfi.apple.com/en/faqs.html If MFi did cover chargers, the iPhone warranty conditions would then be forcing you to buy a charger that is made by either Apple, or a company that's paying fees to Apple.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tinus_hn 5y agoI love how in one hand HackerNews is gushing over how the EU might perhaps be planning to mandate USB-C ports in iPhones for the 50th time, and on the other hand HackerNews wants to live in a world where Apple users have to be compensated for only being able to use Apple chargers for their standard USB-C ports. This story is not about standards or chargers, it can be shortened to Hurr durr Apple bad LOL amirite!
- mangoTangoBango 5y agoI wonder if this would work in small claim court in the USA? Just make a form letter lol.
- ab_testing 5y agoThe problem with suing apple in the US is that they can lose and give you compensation but then they can also disable your iCloud account and now all you have is a paperweight .
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- elliekelly 5y agoIsn’t there someone suing Apple over this in California? Apple turned off their Apple ID for whatever reason and the person lost access to thousands and thousands of dollars of purchases?
- exabrial 5y agoffs apple just use usb-c. Just like NFC, it doesn't need to take a decade to figure this crap out.
- oniony 5y agoThey do already, just on the wrong end.
- sneak 5y agoThe cable is included, so there is USB-C on the end of the stuff that comes in the box.
- Bud 5y agoIndeed. It only takes 5 minutes to figure out that staying with Lightning serves Apple's existing customer base better than an arbitrary stupid change to USB-C, which offers basically no advantages to iPhone users and a lot of disadvantages.
- ultrarunner 5y agoIt would offer me the advantage of the phone not detecting a "non-genuine" lightning cable and refusing to charge. This used to be possible disable through jailbreaking, but the closest I've come lately (with admittedly little effort) is to get a phone at 10% to sit at 10% overnight, neither charging nor discharging. Ostensibly, a dumb pipe (yes, the CC pull-ups form a state bit) would preclude them the ability to prevent charging.
- ars 5y agoWho has so many lightning accessories that would be so disadvantaged? On the other hand switching to USB-C, like the entire rest of the planet would open up a TON of more devices that would now be compatible with Apple. It means you could actually charge your Apple phone when not at home, because most people have USB-C these days, but lighting only those who have Apple devices.
- 5y ago
- CTmystery 5y agoThis is only ever so slightly related, but I just have to write this somewhere because it happened yesterday. An iPhone X is what, 4 years old? I took one that died completely to the apple store yesterday. They said that it's out of warranty and the "logic board was dead" so there was nothing they could do. But I could pay $560 for a new one! I dissappointedly gave them the phone to recycle. Then on the walk out of the mall I saw one of the "we fix phones" kiosks and thought I'd give it a shot. I was thankfully able to get the "paperweight" phone back from the Apple Store. And, I'm not kidding here, this single employee at the kiosk had the phone split open and booting in under two minutes. The genius bar staff just resorts to "bad logic board" when they don't want to spend even a minute diagnosing the problem. Or maybe they don't have the skills, IDK. I was happy that this solo kiosk rep was a repair wizard.
- uncletammy 5y agoWhat ended up being the actual problem with it?
- kurupt213 5y agoServicing outdated hardware is completely against the Apple idea of providing an excellent customer experience, which requires helping you select from the current product offering that meets today’s performance experience goals
- brianwawok 5y agoI don't think genius employees are trained or permitted by Apple rules to open up a phone and start tinkering around. They are very much there to provide basic t1 tech support, and if anything is broken in hardware to send it back to the mothership for repair/replace.
- Bud 5y agoCorrect. Genius Bar folks are not hardware-repair folks.
- bduerst 5y agoIsn't that the problem though? That someone in a mall kiosk is more skilled and authorized to fix a phone than an entire Apple store full of Apple geniuses? Edit: Apple Authorized Service Providers (AASP) have mall kiosks, for those doubting authorization.
- vl 5y agoAnd for MacBooks: you can't buy extra power adapter and MagSafe cable as a combo. You need to buy power brick and then cable separately. And of course they sell cable itself for $50! While generally I'm against unnecessary regulations, I think we need laws for providing repair manuals and parts for cars and devices, and then for controlling prices for parts and proprietary accessories. While MagSafe cable is a benign example, this gets ridiculous for medical devices. People use them for life, but necessary parts, batteries, etc are completely overprices.
- robertlagrant 5y agoThis sounds like a terrible idea. If things are that overpriced, start a company that makes 50% less profit per unit and take the market.
- vl 5y agoI'll bet that in US you can't really start a company which will make replacement parts for proprietary medical devices without license from the original company. Pay $400 every time you need to replace proprietary sound processor rechargeable battery, and I'll listen to your arguments then.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- robertlagrant 5y agoI'm talking about making medical devices, not replacement parts for other people's medical devices.
- twobitshifter 5y agoI had an issue with my iPhone X not charging completely after running it completely empty last week. First the bedside wireless charger seemed to be messing up. Next I tried just charging with a cable and that seemed to work one night but then the phone wouldn’t keep trying. I decided to go buy a new cable and charger because I needed to have my phone, so I went to Walmart. They had some very cheap chargers and the apple options. I splurged on the 20W USB C charger. That charger doesn’t come with the cable in the box because the cable still comes with the phone. Since all my other cables aren’t usb C to lightning, I had to buy a new one. The only one at Walmart was from Belkin. All in all it was $40 for everything. This makes the Brazilian case in yet another way. They’re selling the charger without the cable you need to use it. On the bright side my phone did charge to 100% overnight and everything seems to be back to normal.
- asciimov 5y agoI just recently replaced my 2016 iPhone SE with a 13 Mini. While I'm ok not getting another charger, I am not ok with getting a usb-c to lightning cable as I don't have any chargers in my house that have a usb-c port. Fortunately I have plenty of usb-a chargers and lightning cables in the house to fit the bill. I'm also very tired of apple dragging their feet on putting a usb-c port on the iPhone.
- blackoil 5y agoI for one is happy with this ruling and hope it comes h to more countries. I am tired of company making anti consumer decisions hiding behind some shitty logic and lies. Removing 3.5mm jack, crappy cables and removing free power adapter are all anti consumer and have nothing to do with the lies told about them.
- ilrwbwrkhv 5y agoThis is a great outcome. Apple should be penalized for trying to squeeze every buck. If they want to save the environment they should have kept the price the same and knocked off 30 dollars if you didn't want the charger. The fact that they even try to make this about the environment is absurd and what is more idiotic is the general populace believe it.
- vineyardmike 5y agoI mostly agree… but isn’t it possible that they kept the overall cost fixed and spent the extra $30 from the charger making slightly better phones? I think it’s good they stopped including the charger since i already have at least 10 apple branded ones myself but I have no faith they didn’t also get better margins for this “generosity”.
- Jyaif 5y ago> knocked off 30 dollars if you didn't want the charger A charger cost them less than $1. Checkout AliExpress to get an idea of the real price of things. Of course because they sell so many iPhones, that still represents in the order of 100 million dollars saved per year for Apple.
- thenickdude 5y agoHave you seen a comparative teardown of an Apple charger vs a $1 Aliexpress charger? They're completely different internally because the cheap ones skip all the required isolation and noise filtering, and usually deliver only half of their rated current.
- ahallock 5y agoYou are free to buy a different phone. No lack of competition in this industry.
- rochansinha 5y ago
- 5y ago
- endisneigh 5y agoIf we can’t even take away chargers from luxury phones we have no chance of making meaningful sacrifices to stop climate change lol.
- scelerat 5y agoI like that apple is trying to reduce waste by not including copper and plastic that is superfluous for a high percentage of phone buyers. Can Apple not simply offer a two iphone SKUs, "with charger"; "without charger"?
- itg 5y agoOr simply hand the buyer of a new iphone a free charger if they ask for one, but we all know it's not about the environment.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> we all know it's not about the environment. Kinda like all the complaints are not really about the charger ;-)
- extrememacaroni 5y agoI think the vast majority of buyers would ask for a free charger because: 1) one more can't hurt, what if you lose one of the others? 2) it's free, so why not? 3) it's free and then I can SELL it! 4) ... maybe more?
- victorbstan 5y agoBatteries not included.
- tananaev 5y agoI think the right thing would be to include an adapter by default, but have an option to get a small discount if you don't want an adapter. I'm pretty sure environmental concern wasn't the main driving force behind Apple's decision to not include an adapter :)
- KarlKemp 5y agoDoes it matter if environmental concern was the true reason? I’m fairly certain it does make a significant difference. And, FWIW, Apple has always been interested in making money. The environmental concern is rather new, and coincides with this decision. It may not have been the only reason, but may well have been the change that flipped the decision.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> have an option to get a small discount Then people would complain that the discount was only $1.
- Keyframe 5y agoNintendo 3DS XL didn't come with a power adapter either.. so what? As long as it's advertised as such and customers warned during purchase.
- snikch 5y agoMy Apple TV didn’t come with an HDMI cable. It’s required to work. The difference I guess is Apple don’t make the cable?
- philjohn 5y agoThe big issue I have over the whole "chargergate" is that Apple announced it as "being green", which, sure, it is. But the real reason they did this was to maintain their huge margins - cutting the cost of the charger AND they could therefore make the packaging smaller, leading to lower shipping charges from their overseas sweatshops.
- 0xfffafaCrash 5y agoThe judge seems irrational. Both arguments mentioned here are flatly wrong. It is demonstrably false that Apple not including the adapter ”obliged the consumer to purchase a second product of its exclusive manufacture”. The number of people using the product without an Apple manufactured power adapter could populate entire cities. Alternatives are easily accessible and come in many forms you might have preferences about. Furthermore many have existing power adapters from Apple and others so buying a duplicate contributes next to nothing for many despite having an environmental and financial cost. The argument that Apple also manufactures adapters so this is not environmentally beneficial to exclude is staggering in how little sense it makes. Decoupling the two allows you to purchase only what you need when you need it avoiding duplicates and waste. Can people possibly be so dense as to seriously argue otherwise? If the packaging is not clear about what is and isn’t included and suggests something needed to use the device is included when it isn’t, that’s a different story and something I can understand taking issue with (from a false marketing standpoint), but the arguments as stated here are pure garbage. I don’t need a new power adapter with every device any more than I need to also have to buy a screw driver as a part of the package every time I buy screws. Forcing the coupling of purchases effectively increases the minimal cost for consumers, decreases consumer choice, and produces waste. I suspect this has nothing to do with the arguments and everything to do with ”sticking it” to a big corporation that is disliked for entirely unrelated reasons.