9 ms·
They can't do it. Most of the games in their console libraries aren't theirs, they belong to third parties. They can't even offer it for purchase. I've been wan
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
They can't do it. Most of the games in their console libraries aren't theirs, they belong to third parties. They can't even offer it for purchase. I've been wanting to buy the older Ace Combat games on PlayStation for years but they never come due to idiotic licensing issues nobody cares about.
Copyright industry will always defeat itself. Anything short of everything humanity ever created in one place fails to compete with copyright infringement.
- sb057 5y agoAce Combat doesn't have any licensing issues. They rereleased AC5 and AC6 as preorder bonuses for AC7 just a couple of years ago. The stated reason the series producer has for not rereleasing them is that they wouldn't want to sell the games as-is, and they don't have enough resources to remaster them.
- postingposts 5y agoHey you know, it’s a good thing! This helps you not be attached to the past, and let’s be honest here… people make things for money, not love or art. Otherwise they wouldn’t copyright it.
- tsol 5y agoI'd argue people make things for money AND love. It's just the money you need to survive, and the love is just nice and fulfilling-- so you can guess what people end up hyperfocusing on
- postingposts 5y agoUh, it’s not love if you’re doing it for money. It’s work. You might enjoy the feeling of getting paid but that’s not love.
- colejohnson66 5y agoIt’s possible to enjoy doing something, and realizing you can make money on it after
- postingposts 5y agoYes that’s called enjoying making money. It’s not love. Why is that confusing to so many people?
- oriki 5y agoBecause if the thing I'm doing is, for instance, making artisan screwdrivers, I don't spend my whole day making money. I spend my whole day making screwdrivers. If I love making screwdrivers, then I love making screwdrivers. Now that I have all these real nice screwdrivers lying around, I can sell them to other people who might want a really nice screwdriver. Not only did I get to do the thing I enjoyed doing: making screwdrivers, but I also made some money off of it. Some of that money can be used to cover cost of materials on the screwdriver I made, the rest of it can be used to enrich my personal life, or maybe grant me access to stronger tools to do the thing I enjoy doing. Making something and selling something are two different tasks. I can love making things and still sell those things for a profit, and my love for making things can have absolutely nothing to do with the fact that I get money out of it. Where do you get the presumption that you can't possibly do something good that you like and still make money off of it?
- anyfoo 5y agoYou never had a job that you enjoyed?
- postingposts 5y agoI would like to say yes but the reality is no. If you would like to talk about it I don’t mind. I have decided that I’m going to engage people on a more limited basis because no one seems to want actually discuss the topic at hand.
- tshaddox 5y agoAt every job I’ve had there have been days where the alarm goes off and I’d rather stay in bed than go in that day. Even if there are other days I enjoyed the job, the money is the reason I go in on the days when I’d rather not.
- munificent 5y ago> people make things for money, not love or art. People make things for all sorts of combinations of various amounts of money, love, and art. The idea that motivation must be purely extrinsic or purely intrinsic is false and toxic. It demeans paid work and discourages people from seeking meaning in their jobs.
- postingposts 5y agoIt’s my perspective. I think that money is toxic and demeaning. You won’t change my perspective on that.
- munificent 5y agoYou're certainly welcome to your perspective. You can also choose to apply it to other people. But that doesn't magically make it their perspective or motivation. Saying, "I don't like mint chocolate chip ice cream" does not spontaneously cause sales of it to plummet across the world.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> it’s a good thing! This helps you not be attached to the past What an interesting way to spin into a feature the copyright industry's inability to give people what they want. You know what else is a good thing? Emulation. Amazing thing. > people make things for money, not love or art. Otherwise they wouldn’t copyright it. Not only is this false, it's a huge factor in authenticity and quality. We want creators who have an intrinsic drive to create, who something to say, who have a vision they want to realize, who would create regardless of profits. Nobody cares about cheap cash grabs. The money is meant to enable their creations.
- postingposts 5y ago“ The money is meant to fuel their creations.” I’ve never seen this in practice. It’s usually to fuel buying some big house that no one normal could ever afford and then acting like you were granted a lordship. I am more than happy to change my perspective but not to have a headache by deluding myself that “everyone just has to take profits!” Maybe that’s the world you live in. I don’t want to live in it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bduerst 5y agoThis is survivor bias. Investment into information property (IP) goes unseen because you only ever publicly see what happens after the success. Without a legally guaranteed return on investment on IP, investment into developing it would be stunted. Now is usually when someone counters with open-sourced initiatives, but they themselves still have copyrights legally protecting how they are used after being developed.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- postingposts 5y agoOk but that’s assuming I have empathy for investors; I do not.
- konfusinomicon 5y agothe past is soooo addictive though. its money that they could still be making.. they should syndicate it, like Seinfeld
- postingposts 5y agoSee that’s actually a brilliant idea. Have a series of products, actors, musicians, and sign them all together onto similar platforms. I bet Amazon could do it. You would only see these actors using these certain types of products and appearing in movies where the action or entertainment incorporates product. Presenting The 90s, brought to you by Amazon. Beige computers, everyone has the same hairstyle, small town Americana! I think most people are tasteless enough to really like this.
- deadbeeves 5y ago"Taste" is just a way to divide personal preferences into arbitrary acceptability categories so that some people can have an excuse to look down on people who don't share their preferences, while giving it a facade of legitimacy.
- oriki 5y ago> people make things for money, not love or art. ...you're on Hacker News. A significant portion of this website is just people talking about Open Source Software, something that consistently produces case studies about people making things for love or for art or for passion instead of just for money. Plenty of people make things for value that isn't purely financial. > Otherwise they wouldn't copyright it. This isn't how copyright works, at least in the US. Generalizing broadly, you own the copyright of whatever you create unless you've otherwise signed that away. It's automatic. You don't fill out a form to have copyright over a work.
- postingposts 5y ago“ ...you're on Hacker News.” Am I? I know that’s the name but it’s not really for hackers. It’s mainly for businesspeople who are very sensitive, don’t really know much of anything beyond their desk job or coding and don’t care much for the hacker ethos. If I post like myself, really like myself, that is, extremely weird and sarcastic, I’ll get the Socrates/Voltaire/Diogenes treatment and be shown the door. I think people like to call themselves hackers, or pirates, or “code ninjas” —- it is escapism from the truth that they no longer do it for the love, it’s for the money, or they are doing it for the job, the prestige, the “do you know who I am?!” Effect. Which I don’t care about cuz I’m a hacker. I didn’t get your fancy 4 year degree. I’ll write your code dude but I’m not going to fawn over wealth like it’s valuable because to me it isn’t. I’ve seen many people get sensitive or bristly attitudes here, report the post, downvote, because they don’t have much to say or engage with. They disagree, and that’s it. I am “man you disagree with” and “bad man” because you disagree.
- oriki 5y agoI'm not even going to bother with the first two paragraphs here - you're mostly just going on about how you don't like the people on HN and don't think they're real hackers and then you're deploying a massive and wide ad hominem against HN's readers. Luckily, I don't really identify with them all that much either -- in fact, I actually have a lot of recurring issues with HN's readership, but I'm saving that for another time. The simple truth here is this: I don't have a four year degree. I don't even write code for a living. I work in IT, in a role that you would probably best describe as just 'IT guy.' I don't make more than $60,000 a year in the role I'm currently in. I care about money to the extent that I need money to live, to feed my car gas, to feed myself food, and to feed my computer at home electricity. You're getting the cold shoulder here because you don't seem to have the nuance to understand how people actually interact with and care about their work. I feel like we live in a nightmarish hellscape where a significant portion of work is driven by nothing but desire for profit, but this doesn't suddenly make me think that everyone involved in making things is only there because they get paid. On the other hand, you appear to think any person who sells anything is going through this whole process purely for money. The replies to you have been perfectly amicable, and encourage discussion. YOU have been shutting that discussion down because people don't agree with you.
- boondaburrah 5y agoeyyy good troll
- postingposts 5y agoI’m going to respond to you directly and clearly. I dislike posts like this: they’re low effort and accusing someone of ill behavior because they have an opinion you don’t share is a cheap shot at best. I’m trying to be charitable here and I’m finding it unenjoyable because no one is apparently willing to have a serious discussion if we aren’t all constantly agreeing. You really can’t imagine how disappointing it is and how little it makes me want to engage in the future.
- Shared404 5y agoWell said. On mobile at the moment, but will edit on my pc later to fix formatting if I remember. I'll be up front - I do disagree with your take, at least partially. I quite like the screwdriver analogy used elsewhere in the comments. I love working with computers. I have for years. Recently, I turned that into a job. I enjoy my job, though I wouldn't say I love it. However, it does allow me 5o practice and learn, so that I can improve my skills when I do perform a labor-of-love project. If I were to make a labor of love project, and then someone were to pay me to support it, why would that project atop being a labor of love? There would be extra workload that would not (billing, other business cruft, etc), but I think the core of it would be. Similarly for art/music - if I producea song because I like writing music, and people are willing to pay for a high quality download, would it stop being a labor of love at that point? Curious to hear your thoughts on these edge cases.
- postingposts 5y agoFeel free to disagree again: I think you’re either being unclear with your definition of enjoyment and love, or you are perhaps confused between the two. Which isn’t to say you aren’t having positive feelings at your job, I think that’s possible and in general ideal. Enjoyment out of spending more time the way you want to as opposed to the way others have dictated it be spent is very natural, I believe. But I have to draw the distinction between love and enjoyment. Love (to me) is the expression of an idea from the soul, and the willingness to nurture this idea from the perspective of nature and harmony. There is a harmony in creating order (code, poetry, music), and there is a harmony in creating a roughness around which order and harmony form. (Clouds, fractals, abstract ideas, natural patterns) to experience this as the self with the world and with others in the world is how I believe love exists and comes to be. When you’re paid for this process it diminishes love with the element of time, and space. You have to do it by so and so time, or there will be a material consequence. (Even if the time is very far away) I don’t think that your labor of love becomes undone, but it’s something else. It’s enjoying the fruits of your labor, and that is not the same as laboring for love. Not to me at least. I even would say you can enjoy making things others love. But for you yourself, it’s not possible. And for me, in practical experience, I don’t get many who love what I do, and I don’t really enjoy the climate around me full of people doing nothing but stacking up money for no purpose. I suppose my real gripe here is that I wish things were good or meaningful.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoSeems to me those 3rd parties would want access to that cash flow, even if Nintendo took a percentage for making them available on the latest system. The app store model.
- larkost 5y agoIt may well be that either the third parties who created the game are no longer around (making their intellectual property difficult/impossible to license), or that they in turn had licenses for various assets (images/sounds. etc...) or other technologies to parties that are not longer around, and under licensing restrictions that never envisioned this sort of use. Sometimes tracking all of this down to even know what the pieces legal provence is would be more trouble than it would be worth.
- chimeracoder 5y agoThis is a great argument in favor of shorter copyright terms. Instead of a situation in which everyone loses (the status quo), after some point, the games would become public domain because the maximum possible copyright period has run out, enabling people to play them again.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoOr at least require active registration and renewal, which fixes the "orphan works" problem to a certain extent.
- PeterisP 5y agoThis seems like an argument for copyright terms which are short by default but can be extended if the holder cares about them and pays some fee; so any abandoned content would actually become available to the public instead of being locked away for whole generations.
- autoexec 5y agoI don't see any benefit to the public in allowing a company to pay a fee to extend their copyright. Once the copyright has lapsed the company will still be free to do whatever they want with the property, it's just that so will everyone else.
- colpabar 5y agoace combat rules!
- telchior 5y agoThe game industry is so unstable, it can be nearly impossible to even tell who you should pay for something. An anecdote: Master of Magic is one of my favorite games of all time. The company that made it was acquired; the acquirer, I think, shut down. Anyway, the upshot of all that was that the source code was literally lost. Nobody has ever found it, and people who wanted to mod the game had to do it in bytecode. Even the license was sort of lost for a couple decades; a known company owned it but they were too large to care about deaing with this old, niche license. A few years ago, someone (Slitherine) finally persuaded them to sell. A remake of the game was then able to be released commercially, and a sequel is in the works. But it took over 20 years for that to happen.
- ianai 5y agoIt really should at least be able to protest and prove some IP has been abandoned. Granted the law would have to be carefully written or it’d just be gamed and perverted.
- qwertycrackers 5y agoI have long thought that a precondition to the continuation of any IP should be that the rightsholder make the IP available to the public on terms somewhat similar to the IPs original publication. So if a game or other work ever goes out of print, the copyright to it evaporates. I think this would be perfectly fair to ensure creators get their payday without depriving the public of access to good old works.
- sdenton4 5y agoThere should be a yearly filling for each copyrighted work, with a fee starting at a trivial amount and doubling each year...
- Agentlien 5y agoI agree in principle but I feel a doubling may be a bit too steep.
- behringer 5y agoCopyright used to make sense. It fails as an idea completely when copyrights last forever.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYeah, it sucks. These corporations have already made their fortunes several times over. It makes no sense for stuff released 10 years ago to still be protected. It's pure greed and eternal rent seeking.
- emkoemko 5y agoyup sometimes it comes down to the music in the game having a specific license so you can't now sell your game on a different system
- yakkityyak 5y agoNintendo has a legendary 1st party catalogue though, yet they can't even seem to offer that up.
- hnlmorg 5y agoCounter argument: by drip feeding emulation titles they way that they are, they’re introducing gamers to a great many lesser known titles. When someone has 100+ games to choose from, most people will be overwhelmed by choice and end up sticking to the household names. But by limiting the choices you perversely encourage people to try games they haven’t played before.
- antifa 5y agoSeems like you would do just as well to front page promoted games and let the rest be searchable. Right now I make zero purchases because I don't want to invest in a platform that has 1 out of 20 retro games I'm interested in.
- hnlmorg 5y agoThe Switch, like all consoles, makes the bulk of its money from games sales. Thus if you’re only interested in free retro games then Nintendo are doing the right thing, financially speaking, by not catering to you’re specific requirements. Like yourself, I’m a massive retro gamer but at the end of the day current generation consoles make their money from games licenses. So any support they throw in for older games is strictly a loss making fan service.
- erfgh 5y agoYou want to buy them. And maybe you will, if the price is low enough. But that does not mean that the process is commercially viable. I doubt enough people would care.
- IncandescentGas 5y ago> idiotic licensing issues nobody cares about The owner of the license cares about it. This is not copyright being self defeating. This is copyright working as intended. If the persons who own the rights to something don't want to sell it, why do you think random third parties should suddenly be entitled to sell it instead and keep the money? Sure it's frustrating as a consumer sometimes, and the copyright expiration periods are way too long now in the us. But how is the concept itself flawed, except to self-rationalize theft/piracy? My latest irritation on this front is the movie Strange Days. One of my old favorites, and my partner has never seen it. The police violence narrative is powerful. Angela Bassett's performance is fire. Juliette Lewis's musical performances are great. It's not available for purchase on bluray in the US, and it's not on any streaming services in the US. Press speculation reports James Cameron owns the rights, and wants to personally oversee the remaster instead of trusting it to others. And he's not got around to that yet. Are you arguing my desire to watch the movie should override James Cameron, the producer and copyright holder's decisions on when or how to sell their artwork?
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> But how is the concept itself flawed, except to self-rationalize theft/piracy? People want to buy content and yet they can't due to this bullshit. It's that simple. Nobody cares who gets paid or not, they want the thing and the copyright industry is failing to deliver. Guess who's not failing? Pirates. You have it backwards. "Piracy" is actually the natural order of things, it doesn't need any rationalization. It's the copyright system that's self-rationalizing. Artificial scarcity is an illusion, data is infinitely abundant. It's how computers actually work and also how they should work, there is no need to justify it. It's the copyright industry that keeps ruining it for us with their eternal campaign against computer freedom just to protect their irrelevant business model. > Are you arguing my desire to watch the movie should override James Cameron, the producer and copyright holder's decisions on when or how to sell their artwork? Absolutely it should. That work was released almost 20 years ago now. By all reasonable expectations it should already be part of the public domain. What the creator wants doesn't matter, he's already made his fortune off of it and it's time for him to move on to new creations instead of milking past successes forever.