5 ms·
This is really, really stupid. It reeks of economic illiteracy. If you think foreign investor cause harm, just estimate how much harm it is, and tax them acco
by eru 5y ago
This is really, really stupid. It reeks of economic illiteracy.
If you think foreign investor cause harm, just estimate how much harm it is, and tax them accordingly. Why would you ban them?
Taxing is almost always more economically efficient than banning.
You can even pay out (part of) the tax take to the people you think are harmed.
(In general, a land value tax for everyone would be a good idea. But if political reasons dictate that only foreigners should be taxed, so be it. Still better than a ban.)
- it_citizen 5y agoI am not super familiar with real estate markets. Has the empty house tax helped in any way? Even if it is not the best solution, is there any huge downside to that ban?
- Dylan16807 5y agoAre there any empty house taxes that charge a significant amount of money? 5% would barely get you into the same range as price growth.
- pastacacioepepe 5y agoHow do you tax foreign investors only, if they can set up subsidiaries and use dirty tricks anyway? You're gonna penalize the local market as well.
- Dylan16807 5y agoI'm just asking about empty house taxes. Which also doesn't really need to be foreigner-only. Also if a company owns a house then make it pay the maximum penalty rate when it's empty. Subsidiary problem solved.
- eru 5y agoThat's why I am suggesting not singling out foreigners in the first place. Use the tax you collect to finance local goods and services (and to reduce other local taxes). So local pay the tax and get something in return. Non-residents pay the same tax, but don't get the local goods and services; just because they aren't there. And all without any complicated rules.
- refurb 5y agoYou only have to make it less attractive than other countries.
- pbronez 5y agoI’d be very interested to read an analysis of this. Seems like the best solution to me.
- Tiktaalik 5y agoBC brought in a speculation tax that was effectively an empty house tax (you avoided the tax if you rented your house). In its first year, beyond whatever monies it made, it also added about 8000+ units to the market. Now you only get that surge one time, but hey that's not nothing, and beyond that the market seems to have reoriented slightly toward less development of apartments for sale, and more purpose built rental apartments. https://bc.ctvnews.ca/11-000-condos-added-to-metro-vancouver-s-rental-market-thanks-to-vacancy-taxes-cmhc-study-1.5205489 https://bc.ctvnews.ca/11-000-condos-added-to-metro-vancouver...
- krageon 5y agoIt's not about the "economy", it's about people being able to buy a roof over their head. Foreign investors simply don't belong in that space at all.
- hrdwdmrbl 5y ago"People being able to buy a roof over their head" is the economics of housing
- Bilal_io 5y agoExactly, and I honestly wish there were measures to fine owners that have empty homes as well. Many people would disagree with me, but to me it's not about economics. We need a way to fight the idea of hoarding homes, a basic human right, as being an "investment".
- hrdwdmrbl 5y agoIf there was enough supply there wouldn't be a problem. No one hoards cars, boats, airplanes or anything else because they think that they can corner the market and raise prices. Housing is only special because not enough is built. It's only possible to "hoard" because every 1 off the market is less for everyone else. A fixed pie. Like bitcoin. If the bitcoin supply was infinite no one would think about collecting them.
- goodpoint 5y agoHouses are non-fungible, making the whole comparison absurd. They occupy 3D space in a fixed location. Until we develop Star Trek teleportation I cannot replace my apartment with a cheaper one 1000km away. That's why hoarding real estate is exploitation of people's basic needs.
- Bilal_io 5y agoIt's easier and cheaper to produce more cars. Boats are irrelevant since they're not a necessity, a house is, a car is in certain cities.houses being already scarce, and hoarding them makes it worse, because it makes them even less affordable.
- doliveira 5y agoWould taxing do anything in this specific case? Foreign investors are already willing to pay millions in a single home just for it to lay empty, from what I read in this thread. Why would some fixed (even if progressive) tax on top of that change the demand?
- ryanbrunner 5y agoPresumably if it was high enough they would move onto other investments that are comparatively more profitable when accounting for the tax. It would have to be a heck of a tax to keep up with how Canadian house prices have been inflating recently though.
- doliveira 5y agoYeah, that seems the crux of the problem: price rising is exponential, a fixed tax can't offset it.
- hrdwdmrbl 5y agoHypothetical example: Tax it 100,000,000%. Turn a $1 house into a $1,000,000 house. Do you think they'd still want it? That's the power of taxation to change behaviour. (of course a real tax can be whatever is needed to "get the job done", it doesn't need to be ridiculous). If you don't want empty houses, tax empty houses (though as a distracting aside, the idea that empty houses is a big problem has also been fairly thoroughly debunked, but that's another discussion that it's important rn)
- GypsyKing716 5y agoOff by a few zeros. Humbly thought I might put that out there in the word problem.
- doliveira 5y agoOther than an ideological argument of preferring taxes over outright bans, I feel like the effect is the same. If foreign investors are indeed the ones pushing price up orders of magnitude above inflation, they clearly don't care about prices increasing tenfold. So it seems the tax would have to be insanely huge to actually achieve the same effect. And honest question: why do we want foreign investors buying homes anyway? I understand buying commercial locations, but not residences.
- pastacacioepepe 5y agoExplain how would you tax them effectively then, since they are foreign. Every time I talk about taxing the rich, I'm stormed by people calling me economically illitterate and telling me it's impossible as the rich will always find a loophole. So if you think they can find loopholes on the ban, why couldn't they find loopholes on new taxes? They do already and very effectively.
- hrdwdmrbl 5y agoA % tax on the cost of the property would be pretty simple. Can't buy without paying the tax up front. It's usually the more complicated taxes that have exceptions to rules that are exploitable. It's hard to find exploits in simple rules.
- pastacacioepepe 5y agoI mean yes but then you'd also hit your population, unless you restrict the tax to non-citizens, but then foreign investors can still use some sort of a front man or other loopholes.
- eru 5y agoHitting the local population with this particular tax is fine from an economic point of view. Just use the tax take to finance local goods and service and to lower other local taxes.
- eru 5y agoYes. Look at land value taxes. Btw, I would _not_ charge a transaction tax. Charge them every year for holding the property. (Eg charge whoever holds the property on New Year, the market will do the rest.) That way you don't impede transactions.
- hrdwdmrbl 5y agoAs an aside, bans are also very exploitable. Can't buy cause you're foreign? Put it in your cousin's name. Buy or start a tiny company that will technically own it. Get some kind of visa, maybe one that you can get because you have lots of $. etc.