10 ms·
The inability of the USB standards body to stick to a versioning scheme beggars belief: what in the world could "USB 3.1 Gen 2" possibly mean? Versions are free
by woodruffw 5y ago
The inability of the USB standards body to stick to a versioning scheme beggars belief: what in the world could "USB 3.1 Gen 2" possibly mean? Versions are free, why not simply name it "USB 3.2" and make the next one 3.3?
"Gen 2" strikes me as the "Essay FINAL (final version 2).docx" of standards revisions.
- smarx007 5y agoI don't think it's an accident. I think manufacturers pressured the body to ensure they can always claim compatibility with the latest standard. For that purpose, version number became irrelevant and the profile name ("Gen 2") became important.
- WithinReason 5y agoSame thing happened with HDMI 2.1, all new features were defined as optional so everyone who only supports the 2.0 feature set can claim HDMI 2.1 compliance
- xattt 5y agoThere’s gotta be some lobbying or consulting firm hired by manufacturers that’s using the same strategy between the two standards. The consortiums don’t seem to realize that short-term profits are coming at their expense of their brand.
- als0 5y agoWhen you're the only game in town, brand doesn't matter so much.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agodisplay port?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zauguin 5y agoThere's no need for lobbying by manufacturers since the consortiums are directly controlled by the manufacturers. If the brand looses value, they switch to the next one.
- paulmd 5y agoWhy would it come at the expense of long-term profits? The EU has given a legal mandate to USB-IF, you literally are not legally allowed to use anyone else's connection standards. What "profit loss" could possibly occur under a literal government-mandated monopoly requirement? Display standards aren't quite there yet but HDMI is effectively a monopoly in the living-room space and most people use them for mass-market (low-end) monitors that are the most common. Effectively it might as well be a mandate, especially when DisplayPort comes with much shorter cable lengths/etc that require equipment reconfiguration.
- xattt 5y agoMy belief is that more individuals would be seeking out Thunderbolt accessories over USB.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 5y agoNot just can, they're only certifying "2.1" now or something like that.
- WithinReason 5y agoYes, they said that 2.0 doesn't exist anymore: 1. HDMI 2.0 no longer exists, and devices should not claim compliance to v2.0 as it is not referenced any more 2. The features of HDMI 2.0 are now a sub-set of 2.1 3. All the new capabilities and features associated with HDMI 2.1 are optional (this includes FRL, the higher bandwidths, VRR, ALLM and everything else) 4. If a device claims compliance to 2.1 then they need to also state which features the device supports so there is “no confusion” (hmmmm) https://tftcentral.co.uk/articles/when-hdmi-2-1-isnt-hdmi-2-1 https://tftcentral.co.uk/articles/when-hdmi-2-1-isnt-hdmi-2-...
- muro 5y agoIt does make sense that all new features are optional. E.g. 8k resolution does not need to be supported by your TV/monitor or VRR does as well not need to be supported by a Bluray player. As long as the devices can communicate and agree on signal, resolution etc. it's all fine. If anything is a mess, it's the cables, where you have to be careful to read whether high resolutions or ethernet or what passes through that cable is supported. If anything, it showed Verge (I think it was them who published that article) don't understand the purpose of the standard and intentionally tried to create controversy, where really isn't one.
- bmitc 5y agoMaybe that makes technical sense on paper, but in my experience, all these things quickly add up to it being impossible for a consumer or system integrator to know, beforehand, if something is going to work. I just setup a monitor with a built-in KVM, and it's practically impossible going by the specs supported (if you can find it) and whatever is in or not in the manuals to know a setup will work without just trying it. You have the monitor, webcam, two computers, keyboard, mouse, and other peripherals, and then you need to juggle HDMI, USB 2.x and 3.x, Display Port, and Thunderbolt. That doesn't even take into the fact that USB 2.x and 3.x are essentially physically incompatible due to interference at the connector site if they're nearby each other. There's also the myriad of ways on how something doesn't work as expected (4K video only over USB3.x or or a USB 3.x hub not having USB 2.x backwards compatibility or whatever else). So, thousands of dollars of equipment working together cannot possibly be verified before purchase. It's insane.
- 0xy 5y agoIt's absolutely not an accident. Given they've actually changed naming repeatedly, this move can only be interpreted as being a deliberate scheme to swindle consumers.
- Hamuko 5y agoThey're in an arms race with the HDMI Forum to make the most idiotic versioning scheme.
- usrusr 5y agoBut then you wouldn't be able to label-engineer your old chips into "the latest version" (of the old feature subset). Isn't "USB 3.1 Gen 2" the usb 2 performance level as (re)specified in the USB 3.1 document set? I'm deliberately writing without involving a search engine, to make my reply an authentic sample of the resulting confusion. My memory is probably wrong - and if it isn't, the lack of confidence still serves the purpose of illustrating the confusion.
- Dylan16807 5y agoThe generations start with USB 3.0. But for bonus confusion they don't refer to connection speed. They refer to single lane speed, and a connection can have 1 or 2 lanes. Gen 1 is 5Gbps, gen 2 is 10Gbps. Gen 2x2, sigh, is 20Gbps total. If they weren't trying to obfuscate things, those would simply be 3.0, 3.1 and 3.2. There's also Gen 1x2 in theory, but I've never seen mention of anything using it. And then after USB 3.2 you have USB4[sic] which adds Gen 3 and 3x2.
- floatboth 5y agoSo it's basically like PCIe now.
- Dylan16807 5y agoLike that, but also they keep renaming things. And when it's only two lanes max and any faster device will support two lanes, there's no reason to put lanes in the name.
- infinityio 5y agoAs far as I know - 3.1 Gen 2 is what 3.1 would have been called if they named it properly, 3.1 Gen 1 is equivalent to 3.0. (the 3.0 line is 3.2g1/3.1g1/3.0, the 3.1 line is 3.2g2/3.1g2, and 3.2 is 3.2g2x2?) At this point I'm certain the confusion is intentional
- masklinn 5y ago> what in the world could "USB 3.1 Gen 2" possibly mean? Versions are free, why not simply name it "USB 3.2" and make the next one 3.3? USB 3.1 Gen 1 is the straight rebranding of USB 3.0, USB 3.1 Gen 2 is the "original" 3.1, which is 3.0 updated to a 10Gbps signalling rate (from 5), and a more efficient encoding (128/132, versus 8/10). But wait, there's worse! USB 3.2 Gen 1 is the same thing as USB 3.1 Gen 1 USB 3.2 Gen 2 is the same thing as USB 3.1 Gen 2 USB 3.2 Gen 1x2 is 2 lanes of Gen 1 (both G1 and G2 are single-lane), so 2x5Gbps at 8/10 USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 is 2 lanes of Gen 2, so 2x10Gbps at 128/132. Don't ask me why you'd want to use 1x2, I've no idea, and apparently USB-IF doesn't either (they don't even recommend a marketing name for it).
- grishka 5y ago> USB 3.1 Gen 1 is the straight rebranding of USB 3.0 Why? To solve what exactly? In a sane world, it'd be major.minor, with nothing appended at the end. Allowing marketers to take over everything was such a terrible mistake. At this point I myself just don't differentiate USB versions beyond 3.0. 2.0 is the slow one, 3.0 is the fast one, anything newer is "so fast I won't ever saturate this much bandwidth anyway". Thunderbolt also falls into the last category.
- Gigachad 5y agoPart of the reason I assume is they have both newer and more expensive editions. A port could be using the latest spec and features but not implanting the full feature set of the more expensive ports. Products like intel cpus have tiers like i5 and generations. This is kind of like what USB did but so much worse.
- mwt 5y ago> Allowing marketers to take over everything was such a terrible mistake. How else it could possibly play out? It's nice to think that NIST or a similar U.S. government agency could standardize everything, but outside of industries that are most government funded (defense, etc.) or deeply connected to government funding (medical research) the forces of marketing are going to take over eventually and at scale. It's not like the government can or will force consumer electronics marketing to be honest, at least in the U.S. and Europe. I was a little disappointed, for example, to learn during the HDMI 2.1a fiasco that HDMI (the organization/legal entity responsible for the standards), VESA, etc. are loosely organized groups from the companies in the industries. So if they want to rename HDMI 2.0 to 2.1a to make their old products look better, nothing's really stopping them.
- cycomanic 5y agoI think the should really just use sha hashes of the standard document, to avoid all this version name issues.
- gumby 5y agoSadly this might be more user friendly then the current setup. Even just a bit vector of the capabilities, expressed as a decimal or hex number, would be more comprehensible.
- anticensor 5y agoYou would then get USB Type 61513 port and USB Type 48757 device, which could only communicate at Type 45151.
- TheRealSteel 5y agoI think they should use the Chrome/Firefox numbering system. Every time you put out an update that's big enough for users to be affected, increase the integer by one. It's the most intuitive system to humans.
- Kwpolska 5y agoThe Chrome/Firefox numbering system is “new number every month”. Most of those updates don’t bring any new notable features.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tambourine_man 5y agoAt least Wi-Fi folks seem to have taken a hint with Wi-Fi 6.
- arcticbull 5y agoDidn't last long, haha, the new one is 6E.
- tapland 5y agoHow did they fuck this up already /o\
- philjohn 5y agoThat one is at least a little more understandable, same phy, just operates in a different spectrum.
- arcticbull 5y agoI guess my point is it's meant to be a consumer marketing name - and if I have to explain to them that "6E" has an "E" because it's the "same phy, but operates in a different spectrum" then they've failed to create a rational naming scheme yeah? Don't get me wrong, I get it. But I also get USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 Like ... why "E" of all letters?
- zzen 5y agoextended?
- TheRealSteel 5y agoThey lasted less than a year before putting out Wifi 6E
- elif 5y agoI think it would be fine IF the higher numbers were universal supersets of previous versions of USB. 'i don't care what this version is it's the highest" seems fair. At least the "universal" aspect applies over time. It's the apples of the world who seem to be on divergent fork with superior and inferior types of functionality that really disrespect the "universal" moniker... While also ambiguating exactly which USB spec they are even implementing.
- FireBeyond 5y agoApple has always been 'vague' in their material about what you're getting, exactly. Often a lot of digging, and / or research needs to be done. Don't start me on the Pro / Max / Ultra... which one is the best? Which one _should_ be the best, given the moniker of 'maximum'?
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoNo, "Essay FINAL (final version 2)(1).docx"
- jeroenhd 5y agoThe USB people decided to have new sub versions replace the older standard rather than extend it. USB 3.0 was replaced by USB 3.1, and then again replaced by USB 3.2. If you think of it in a bureaucratic sense, it starts to make sense (something receiving classification A under the Widget Law of 2012, classification B under the Widgets Etc. Law of 2014, and classification Å under the Widgets Standardisation Law of 2018). The problem is that they forgot to inform the general public how their versions work, and the general public also doesn't (and shouldn't need to) care about their weird versioning system. As an end user, you shouldn't need to care about the generation and amount of lanes that USB provides. There's a logo on the box that has the USB shape, SS, and the speed. For textual representations, there's "SuperSpeed x gbps". If you see SS5 and your computer also had a sticker that says SS5 or SS10 or even SS20, you're good. That's how the USB guys foresaw the whole process going. Obscure use cases that may technically happen (like two gen 1 streams rather than a single gen 2 stream, aka USB 3.2 gen 1x2 rather than USB 3.2 gen 2x1) don't get a logo or a fancy name and you'll probably run into compatibility challenges for such a setup. USB X.Y gen ZxQ isn't meant for the general public, it's a technical specification. x specifies the generation of the version y specifies which specification, z specifies the type of connection (given X.Y = 3.2 and above) with q specifying the amount of USB lanes available. Like PCIe 4.0 1x16 vs 2x8, it's all designed as designations for domain experts. Use the SuperSpeed naming system like the USB people want you to and you'll probably be a lot less confused. They tried to simplify things (again) by dropping the SuperSpeed in USB 4, calling it simply USB 4 xx Gbps, which is probably for the best.
- gtirloni 5y agoThanks, very well explained. It's starting to make more sense now.
- SAI_Peregrinus 5y agoThe xSpeed naming was even worse. Full Speed isn't actually the maximum (full) speed (that's SuperSpeed#, for some number). High Speed snuck in there at some point. I'm surprised they never did Ludicrous Speed with plaid cables. The USB4 xx Gbps is good. The thing people care about is "which one goes faster". Numbers make that easy, vague adjectives for ever faster speeds make that hard. And it looks to improve the "not all cables work for all applications" situation that USB 3 ended up with.
- vmception 5y agoThe Final Season, Part 3
- renewiltord 5y agoThe naming seems strange but the idea is sound, right? Perhaps they should have picked a different marketing name for each of the Gens. Anyway, it's like how we have: C++ 17 map and C++ 17 unordered map. Different functionality is specified in the same versioning standard.
- paulmd 5y agoThe USB-IF is a group consisting of implementers (IF = Implementers Forum) and obviously it's more profitable for them if they can put "USB 3.2 support" on the box, but keep using the same hardware (newer and more capable => more expensive => lower profit). So in a perverse way - the USB-IF actually has a financial incentive to keep making more confusing standards, because consumer confusion can be exploited for higher profitability. This is why it's baffling to me that the EU wants to hand this particular forum a legal monopoly on the connector and protocol standards we all have to use in our devices, and that people actually think that's a super good idea that will work out well. At best they're an incredibly logjammed body, the only reason Lightning exists is because USB-IF couldn't settle on a replacement for USB Micro-B and after years of debate and still no progress Apple finally just went around them (which lit a fire under them to pass USB-C finally). Kinda similar to the way VESA waffled on the Adaptive Sync draft standard for years and years until NVIDIA just finally went around them and implemented their own VRR sync standard, which finally gave the other members the incentive to shit and get off the pot. Even still, the only thing they could agree on was a "kitchen sink" standard that's ridiculously cumbersome and expensive and complicated - USB-C cables require hand-termination and will simply always be more expensive than an equivalent machine-assembled lightning or micro-B cable [0], and most cables (and for that matter, most devices/connectors/etc) don't support the functional capabilities promised by the USB-C advocates. One cable doesn't do everything, and most devices and cables in fact won't do most of the things that USB-C is capable of delivering. The standard is in fact so complex that most cables get it wrong to a dangerous degree (devices can be destroyed by improperly-implemented cables) as one of Google's engineers discovered [1] when he started systematically testing cables for standards compliance. And the negotiation is more complex and expensive to implement as well, even if you're only doing a low-capability device. There are just fundamental problems with trying to have a standard that covers everything between 1.5 mbit HID devices and 40 gbit PCIe tunneling in the exact same standard and connector and cable (it sounds absurd to even say that). These standards bodies often don't work very well, and handing them the keys to the kingdom basically guarantees at least some degree of slowed progress and increase in market deadweight. If we mandated that everyone adopt VESA and that HDMI would be illegal to sell in the EU - that would produce similar deadweight loss in the display connection standards as well. Etc etc. IMO while you do want standards - you want at least two standards bodies so that you don't end up in the USB-IF situation where one of them has a legal monopoly. (not that that's a panacea - by the way - Apple also is advertising HDMI 2.1 and yet they only support 4K60 [2], they are another one of the companies who took advantage of the HDMI Consortium's new standards branding where they do the same thing as USB and HDMI 2.1 can actually be a rubberstamp reapproval of HDMI 2.0b hardware. [3]) I think a lot of people get really wrapped up in the whole "android vs apple" thing and don't really think about what exactly they're doing, they're just happy "their side" won. But in the long term it's going to be far more difficult to actually get improvements passed, because it's legally impossible to produce innovative products that exist outside USB-IF standards if you want to sell in the EU, and USB-IF just doesn't work at all. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y1Tmtd51clI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y1Tmtd51clI [1] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2016/02/google-engineer-finds-usb-type-c-cable-thats-so-bad-it-fried-his-chromebook-pixel/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2016/02/google-engineer-find... [2] https://www.apple.com/apple-tv-4k/specs/ https://www.apple.com/apple-tv-4k/specs/ (they actually seem to have rolled back the "HDMI 2.1" advertising on a lot of devices but they missed a few! There is, technically, a footnote however.) [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qo9Y7AMPn00 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qo9Y7AMPn00
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- qwertox 5y agoThen there's the additions made by the Mainboard manufacturers like Asus. For example, the manual of the Pro WS X570-ACE states that: "USB 3.2 Gen 1/Gen 2 devices can only be used as data storage only [sic]" In any case, if you connect a keyboard, mouse or USB hub to them, they'll work.