3 ms·
Why are we still using filesystems that don't have an "undo" operation, though? Is the work of programmers less valuable than, say, the work of Google Docs use
by amelius 5y ago
Why are we still using filesystems that don't have an "undo" operation, though?
Is the work of programmers less valuable than, say, the work of Google Docs users (where there is an undo operation)?
- buzzard1 5y ago
- lupire 5y agoWhich systems don't have snapshotting? Mac has Time Machine.
- amelius 5y agoDoes it take a snapshot after every shell command?
- grosswait 5y agoThis is not a file system I would be interested in. If you’ve ever snooped in on fs activity it is constant and overwhelming on even an average system. IDEs can have undo, vi and emacs have undo. As others in the thread have said, just use multiple files. Personally I’d be interested in a shell having undo capability, but not a file system.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> This is not a file system I would be interested in. If you’ve ever snooped in on fs activity it is constant and overwhelming on even an average system. I'm not sure how these sentences are connected. Are you implying that allowing undo would make those problems significantly worse? I'm not sure of that. If you have a CoW filesystem, which you probably want for other reasons, then having a continuous snapshot mode for recent activity would not need much overhead. If you're saying there's too much activity to allow an undo, well, I assume the undo would be scoped to specific files or directories!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- suction 5y agoAnd of course, no reply
- catlifeonmars 5y agoSnapshotting is different. Undo/redo is not a contingency plan; instead it’s something that you make a regular part of your workflow.
- Beltalowda 5y agoThat's kind of how I use git. I would never use "sponge" or "sed -i" outside of a git repo or with files that haven't been checked in already. I agree it would be nice to have this in the filesystem; some filesystems support this (e.g. NILFS[1]), but none of the current "mainstream" ones do AFAIK. In the meanwhile, git works well enough. [1]: https://nilfs.sourceforge.io/en/ https://nilfs.sourceforge.io/en/