4 ms·
If I was a member of Twitter's board, Musk's history of erratic public behavior, SEC settlement, and openly hostile attitude towards the company's employees wou
by woodruffw 5y ago
If I was a member of Twitter's board, Musk's history of erratic public behavior, SEC settlement, and openly hostile attitude towards the company's employees would be more than sufficient to justify my belief that his controlling ownership would not be in the interest of the current average shareholder.
That opinion would also be consistent with how "fiduciary duty" is interpreted by US regulators: companies are not required to perform any particular action that might reasonably be in the interests of shareholders; they must merely show that the company's actions were intended to be in the best interests of the shareholders.
- aleister_777 5y agoHowever, I think it's a harder case to argue when twitter stock closed at $.18 above the price they went public at in 2013. Sounds like whatever it is they have been doing hasn't been in the interest of the average shareholder either. The stock is toast regardless after this.
- Ericson2314 5y agoThe fate of the company after it has been taken private doesn't matter as far as "fiduciary duty" is concerned.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> fate of the company after it has been taken private doesn't matter as far as "fiduciary duty" is concerned If it goes private. As always, Matt Levine says it better than I can: "...the financing seems to be made up of cobwebs and phlogiston. But also Musk has joked about taking companies private before, and he generally changes his mind a lot. (He agreed to join Twitter’s board last week! And then changed his mind four days later!) If you are a well-advised professional public company board, it is just catastrophic to imagine that you might say 'okay Elon $54.20 it is' and then he’d say 'ha no I was kidding, psych!' That would be crippling for a public company. Also that is basically what he did to Twitter’s board last weekend!" https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-04-15/sure-elon-musk-might-buy-twitter https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-04-15/sure-e...
- pbreit 5y agoLevine is being disingenuous, as usual. Obviously he would have banks and investors fighting to finance the deal. Wouldn't a breakup penalty address the breakup problem?
- jimmydorry 5y agoNot to mention he is being disingenuous by implying there was no material change between getting offered a seat at the board, and hearing what accepting that seat would entail.
- the_optimist 5y agoLevine is a former Goldmanite, Twitter advisor. GS versus MS, the latter here unusually on the hostile side.
- ellen364 5y agoIt sounds like Musk received the offer, accepted it and changed his mind afterwards. That is, after accepting the terms, not after receiving them. If that’s the sequence of events, I don’t think Levine is being disingenuous.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Wouldn't a breakup penalty address the breakup problem? No. If you’re at a table negotiating a break-up penalty, you’ve already crossed the Rubicon. You have indicated that the price was at the very least worth considering. If that buyer then walks before agreeing to the break-up penalty, the damage has been done. Board seats have been lost for less.
- Ericson2314 5y ago(To be clear, Musk is a shitshow, but a cash-out is a cash-out. How to balance those things is above my pay-grade.)
- dvhh 5y agoI agree thoroughly that's why tge pairing with Twitter would be marvelous.
- systemvoltage 5y agoOne can equally argue that opens sourcing Twitter algorithm and building trust would bring incalculable number of new users, have a profound impact on their ad business and not to mention, cut down their competitor's moat. People will flock to Twitter like bees. Ad revenue + subscription would skyrocket. So, it can go either way and can be argued either way.
- woodruffw 5y agoThat’s correct. Which is why “fiduciary duty” arguments aren’t very good.
- tayo42 5y ago> opens sourcing Twitter algorithm People need to stop saying this. It's nonsense. Or maybe keep saying it so we know your clueless about how anything works that your commenting on
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> It's nonsense Why? (Honest question.)
- burnished 5y agoAlso genuine, why would a person believe that would happen? The foremost thing that comes to mind is they'd be giving something of great value and receiving nothing in return.
- tayo42 5y agowhich part do you want open sourced? timelines are generated after going through machine learning and then multiple services. even then, some of the infrastructure limits what you see in the end. https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/topics/infrastructure/2017/building-and-serving-conversations-on-twitter https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/topics/infrastruc... > Unfortunately, Haplo has its limits. Since we try to pull every single Tweet ID in a conversation every time a conversation is loaded in real-time, this is potentially an unbounded amount of data. We’ve found that if our platform tries to load more than a certain number of entries from our cache at once, our cache request latency will spike, and we begin to time-out on a significant fraction of read requests. Because of this, there is a limit of thousands of Tweets per conversation tree in this cache. even just showing an ad is a ton work has a bunch of services involved https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/topics/infrastructure/2021/sharding-simplification-and-twitters-ads-serving-platform https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/topics/infrastruc... Other stuff that I think explains the complexity https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/topics/insights/2017/using-deep-learning-at-scale-in-twitters-timelines https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/topics/insights/2... https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/topics/insights/2020/using-machine-learning-to-predict-the-value-of-ad-requests https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/topics/insights/2... https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/topics/insights/2018/twittertensorflow https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/topics/insights/2... there's no single algorithm, its a bunch of parts coming together from hundreds of engineers and multiple services.
- SilasX 5y agoThe problem is, this plan applies much broader than Musk, and penalizes even the “good” activist/takeover artists.
- TigeriusKirk 5y agoAfter they've been bought out, the performance of of the company is of no concern to the former shareholders.
- bko 5y agoIt doesn't have to be complicated. The shareholders should have a right to decide through a proxy vote on whether to accept the offer
- rufusroflpunch 5y agoTo me, this seems obvious. No reason something this fateful shouldn’t be put to shareholder vote. No good reason, at least.
- tenpies 5y ago
- chx 5y agoYishan Wong , the CEO of Reddit until 2012 have tweeted a long thread about how Musk doesn't understand the current state of moderation necessary because he was much more involved with an earlier Internet. But I am of opinion that Yishan is also behind as one half of the debaters simply left facts and reality behind. This post here is an example.
- ben_w 5y agoShareholding is not democratic. It is one-dollar-one-vote and therefore plutocratic rather than democratic. (I was going to say it also involves too much money to be lefty, but then I realise that just might be my Overton window and isn’t necessarily related to what you think “lefty” means).
- rpmisms 5y agoThe massive and immediate shift from "It's a private company and they can do what they want" to chanting in unison "This is a danger to our democracy" has been horrifying to watch. I don't own a TV, and yet I can tell you what the chiron said this morning, nearly verbatim. Ask anyone who watched it.
- bpodgursky 5y agoYeah, I think Elon is going to demand this (and as a 9% shareholder himself, is likely to get it)
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> If I was a member of Twitter's board, Musk's history of erratic public behavior, SEC settlement, and openly hostile attitude towards the company's employees would be more than sufficient to justify my belief that his controlling ownership would not be in the interest of the current average shareholder. That... makes absolutely no sense. The interest of the current average shareholder ends when they sell their stock. There is no point in time at which both (1) the current average shareholder owns more than zero shares, and (2) Musk has a controlling interest. So it's impossible for those two things to conflict. If you were a member of Twitters board, would it be in the interest of the current average shareholder to sell their shares at well above the market price?
- fach 5y agoIt depends on how you define fiduciary responsibility. If it’s a point in time, transactional view, yes. If it’s a long term view of maximizing share holder value over time, not necessarily.
- chipotle_coyote 5y ago> If you were a member of Twitters board, would it be in the interest of the current average shareholder to sell their shares at well above the market price? That definitionally depends on whether you, as that hypothetical board member, believe that Twitter has the potential to reach a share price higher than $54.20 if it stays public. Also, remember there is nothing that binds the board of a company to solely consider potential shareholder value in the actions they take. There's a widespread belief that "fiduciary duty" overrides all other concerns, but from a regulatory/legal standpoint, that's simply not so. The board obviously needs to take it into account, but if they believe a merger or takeover is not in the best interest of the company, they don't have to take it.
- chernevik 5y agoRight, but they hurt other shareholders by preventing them from taking it. Don't like the bid, fine, say no -- but don't prevent your peers from selling out.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nonethewiser 5y ago> If I was a member of Twitter's board, Musk's history of erratic public behavior, SEC settlement, and openly hostile attitude towards the company's employees would be more than sufficient to justify my belief that his controlling ownership would not be in the interest of the current average shareholder. But all that is irrelevant because he wants to take the company private- no shareholders. The impact to shareholders is the massive bailout he would give them on their shares. If they cared about shareholders best interests they would bring it to vote.