3 ms·
Tesla must pay ex-worker $15M for “disturbing” racist abuse, judge rules
- psyfi 5y agoPlease discriminate against me, I will only take $10M
- eganist 5y agoDown from a jury verdict of $136.9m, to be clear, on grounds that the initial judgment was excessive. Not sure I agree with that conclusion and would prefer to see companies permitting systemic racism absolutely thrashed in civil court not only to make an example but to make the cost of garbage treatment of workers higher than the cost of changing course. 15 million, even once per year, isn't a disincentive because it easily costs more than that to change ways of working at any company.
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoI think the PR damage is worse than the actual fine.
- seoaeu 5y agoReally? You think that the PR cost is more than a super bowl commercial, 50 New York Times full page ads, and a few hundred million Facebook ad impressions combined?
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoIt’s possible. It depends on how the thing is covered.
- andrewclunn 5y agoMake it lucrative enough to be a victim and suddenly people will start wanting to be victimized (or at least pretend to be). Your comment speaks of religious fervor, and that righteous hatred will only make heretics and nonbelievers. Incentives cut all ways.
- MBCook 5y agoIt sounded like that was about as high as the judge could go based on the laws. However as the article mentioned this is not the only lawsuit for this kind of thing against Tesla. Maybe one verdict isn’t enough but a couple of them might be.
- gnicholas 5y agoIIRC from law school, there are constitutional limits on the ratio of punitive to compensatory damages, and 10:1 is roughly the limit. Based on the compensatory damages here, much larger punitive damages could have been held to be constitutional, but that would depend on the egregiousness and other factors. This will likely be appealed, so this isn’t necessarily the end of the road. It’s just the ‘turn’ card that reveals more information and positions the parties for new settlement discussions.
- Thorentis 5y agoThe punishment must be proportionate to the crime. Companies pay less in compensation when a worker has serious workplace injuries resulting in disability than this. I see no justification in "racism" carrying a higher punishment than that.
- _8j50 5y agoThis isn't a criminal prosecution. The court can induce a cost that is more than the measurable damage caused. How do you measure racism? $1000 each time a derogatory remark is made? The cause of action in whatever civil law they are using for the suit might help but ultimately the victim didn't lose money, they were harmed and a fair compensation would be to harm the guilty party equally. As in, cause Elon and his company an equivalent level of distress over an equivalent period of time. A fair punishment would be to reward the victim a random percentage of the company's net profits with 10% increments every year ( 10,30,40% ) with 40% max for as many number of years the person worked there and a 95% tax on that award to prevent they guy taking over the company. The company will suffer distress that is arbitrary and prejudicial in nature just like the victim did.
- Thorentis 5y agoYour "fair punishment" is based on the idea that because the racism was random and arbitrary, the punishment should also be random and arbitrary. This isn't how justice works, and if this was applied to any other "crime", nobody would be okay with it.
- _8j50 5y agoCare to elaborate? I was implying it should apply to other crime as well. In my perfect world, prison sentences would be a lot less common. Fairness is a fundamental compnent of justice. If there is a victim then the aggressor needs to be harmed in a similar way. Theft? Something if equal value should be taken from you. I also agree with "lashing" and damaging a persons body for certain crimes like rape for example (chemical or otherwise castration in addition to some torment). Fines are a joke, a slap in the face of justice. The affect the poor only even when proportional to income. 25% of a poor person's wealth has much more impact than 25% of a billionaire's wealth or a corporation's profits. While I believe in mercy strongly (especially when the victim supports it), justice has to have fairness and equal application and is better left not administered than administered partially.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Hamuko 5y ago>His supervisors and Tesla's broader management structure did little or nothing to respond. And supervisors even joined in on the abuse, one going so far as to threaten Diaz and draw a racist caricature near his workstation. Do the supervisors not have any kind of personal liability in these cases?
- micromacrofoot 5y agothey can potentially be charged with a hate crime
- polski-g 5y agoYou can not be charged with a hate crime unless there is an underlying criminal offense in America. The first amendment gives you the right to say racist things.
- micromacrofoot 5y agothat’s why I said potentially, not sure if what they did went far enough to be considered harassment, which would be an underlying crime
- yhoneycomb 5y agoYeah, this is very strange to me. There was a case involving Cleveland Clinic where an Asian nurse's coworkers and supervisor were openly racist to her, and the case was straight up dismissed. https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-6th-circuit/1767833.html https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-6th-circuit/1767833.html > Plaintiff alleges that younger nurses called her an “oldbie” or “old bitch” and referred to rice she ate as “lice.” (Lee Dep. R. #33-4 at 170) She asserts that one nurse stated, “you Chinese people eat anything that crawls and walks” and also stated that Plaintiff does not have “chinky eyes” even though she is Chinese. (Id.) In December 2013, Plaintiff reported the incident to a different supervisor, Debbie Brosovich (“Brosovich”), who responded that she was “overreacting” and being “sensitive.”
- 5y ago
- nr2x 5y ago
- sn00tz00t 5y ago
- ncr100 5y agoWhat part?
- throwntoday 5y agoProbably the part about being treated like you're the problem no matter what you do.
- ncr100 5y agoIt seems like an illogical position to me. Doing the correct thing, to solve a problem, involves getting buy in from the stakeholders. E.g. https://youtu.be/lOTyUfOHgas https://youtu.be/lOTyUfOHgas
- cato_the_elder 5y agoForget FIRE. Borrow some money, move to the US, get hired at a Tesla factory in California, make a bunch of friends, convince them to write some offensive messages about you on your workstation, sue Tesla, and share the profits with the lawyers and your friends.
- hnburnsy 5y agoThe plaintiff found a loop hole where he could sue because he did not work for Tesla, he worked for a third party and never had to sign an arbitration agreement. Tesla has closed this loop hole.