22 ms·
Are film critics losing sync with audiences?
- okasaki 5y agoI've done this analysis for games. My theory was that the correlation was falling because the ratings of old games were dominated by players playing old games now and then rating them, and they were more likely to play games for which there is already a consensus that they are good (old bad games are mostly just forgotten). Whereas for current games the games being played are more random.
- mzvkxlcvd 5y agoalso consider the fact that you might have a 40 year old reviewing videogames when the target audience is like 4 years old. my kid and the typical video game reviewer probably have different opinions about the latest paw patrol game.
- cbozeman 5y agoI sometimes hear this, but I disagree. If you're 40 years old, you need to be able to consume any kind of media and then place yourself into the mindset of a younger person and judge it from that mindset - because you used to be that younger person. Truly exceptional media is good enough to transcend the age barrier and is enjoyable for everyone, e.g., The Incredibles is enjoyable for young kids because it's a cartoon and it's flashy and exciting, it's enjoyable for young boys who want to be the "best" at a sport, it's enjoyable for girls transitioning to puberty because of Violet's storyline, it's enjoyable for men who have lost some of their steam and can relate to Mr. Incredible, and it's enjoyable for women because of the struggles Elastigirl has as a mother and a homemaker. Even Syndrome is shown as a sympathetic villain who is evil not because he is a bad person, but because he was dismissed and ignored by his idol. There are plenty of people who can relate to that. Ghostbusters (1984) is another expertly crafted movie that is fun for kids, but well-written enough to be incredibly enjoyable for adults. When my young cousins or my nephew corral me into playing a game with them, I'm not playing it from my 41-year old perspective, I'm playing it through their eyes. If you can't do that, then don't review content. Content always has a specific audience. Really great content can weave together enough bits to at least satisfy every audience. Exceptional content manages to speak deeply to every audience. I still feel that's why The Incredibles is one of the best movies ever made. The struggles shown in that movie are relatable for every single person on the planet.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoThe funny thing is that games used to be FAR more punishing than they are today. Give an 8 year old (or hell, a 16 year old for that matter) Super Mario Bros. Watch their reaction when they get to World 1-3 or something and then lose all of their lives and realize that the game doesn't care, they have to start ALL the way from the beginning. Compare that to Elden Ring, which has difficult boss fights but otherwise isn't any harder than any level of one of those old games.
- treeman79 5y agoI recall as a small child ordering Castlevania from the Sears catalog and having to wait many weeks for it to arrive. It would certainly be many more weeks before I would get any other game to play and there were a few other distractions.
- BlargMcLarg 5y ago>Compare that to Elden Ring, which has difficult boss fights but otherwise isn't any harder than any level of one of those old games. I haven't played Elden, but for comparison's sake, I haven't had any trouble picking up SMB3 blind nor did I find any of the levels individually more difficult than most high rank monsters in Monster Hunter Rise. SMB1 definitely isn't a difficult game either bar a few specific levels, 8-3 being the most notorious. The biggest thing I see people struggle with is patient, reactive and/or predictive gameplay. Any game with counter mechanics relying on tight windows showcases this: most people either fail to utilize them or simply don't bother. Let alone emergent counterplay. The other part, you can't just statstick your game through most older non-RPGs, where newer games provide you with many more methods to allow more failure.
- Aunche 5y agoI don't think Super Mario Bros was ever considered particularly difficult or punishing at the time. It was just designed for an audience that had less access to videogames. They'd rather repeat the same levels with the prospect of seeing a new one than breeze through the game they paid $25 for ($60 in today's money) in 2 hours.
- dfinninger 5y agoAnother part of that is that it seems like critics play a lot more games than the average consumer (or, at least, me) does and may get burnt out easier. Most reviewers I watched heading into Horizon: Forbidden West said that it was just "more of the same". But I didn't play the most recent Far Cry or Assassin's Creed or whatever else they were comparing to. It was fresher for me playing though it than it was for them, constantly comparing.
- cookie_monsta 5y agoI had a run of games a while back that were next to unplayable for the first 6 months while the bugs got ironed out and the patches got patched. Now I just wait 6 months or so (bonus - they're generally heavily discounted by then, haha) - if games critics are reviewing new releases but gamers reviews come in over the lifetime of the game, they're kind of reviewing two different products and it would make sense if critics' reviews were harsher.
- thenightcrawler 5y agoI don't think critics should necessarily follow general audiences , anymore than you would want a food critic to rate mcdonalds.
- bio_end_io_t 5y agoOn the other side of the coin, you can have situations like in 1989 when Jethro Tull beat Metallica for Best Hard Rock/Metal Performance at the Grammy's.
- kevinventullo 5y agoOr when Macklemore beat… basically anyone else that was nominated. But I’m not sure the Grammy’s represent critical consensus?
- ratww 5y agoThat’s not critics, though. Grammy voters are people who work in the music industry. To qualify you even need creative or technical credits. I bet that critics in 1989 overwhelmingly preferred Metallica’s album to Jethro Tull’s, which at this point was kind of a has-been.
- ascagnel_ 5y agoThe Grammys have notoriously been considered out-of-touch for some time, even when you compare them to the other big awards shows (Tonys, Emmys, Oscars).
- dvh 5y agoBut then again, there's a reviewbrah...
- _v7gu 5y agoA reviewbrah mention on hn? My joy is immeasurable and my day is made. Honestly, gaining trust of audiences is also part of a critic. Else you're just a loud contrarian/populist.
- deleted 5y ago
- nomdep 5y agoA fascinating example of a blog with comments that work. The commenters are polite, informed, and return to reply when the author engage them
- wolverine876 5y agoIndeed! How do they accomplish that?
- sydthrowaway 5y agobrendangregg.com is like this
- Kranar 5y agoOne of the interview questions I ask all UX Researchers is to open up rottentomatoes, sort recent films by rating and then look at the movies that have the lowest critic scores. Almost always you can see the audience score for those movies is much higher than the critic scores. I then ask why this is the case. The overwhelming majority of answers involve critics being out of touch with the audience, critics being perhaps snobby, or watching movies in an elitist fashion whereas the audience just wants to sit back and relax, not think too much, just be entertained. A very small minority of UX Researchers come to the correct conclusion, which is that most professional critics have to review every single movie, whereas the audience typically only goes to see movies that they are likely to enjoy, so that one should not be surprised that the audience score will often be significantly higher than the critic score. Those researchers are typically the ones I hire.
- raincom 5y agoActually, both statements boil down to the same with little modifications: (a) being out of touch with the audience is same as (b) the audience typically only going to see movies that they are likely to enjoy. (a) is broader than (b), can subsume (b).
- parkingrift 5y agoWritten another way... You interview people, ask them their opinions, and hire those that agree with your opinion. The most excellent way I've seen to hire a group of people biased toward a singular way of thinking.
- yhoneycomb 5y ago“I hire people who think exactly like I do”
- tomrod 5y agoWhen you have the right mental model, this is an appropriate approach. Not every mental model is correct, either locally to a domain or globally in all cases. 1 < 2, in almost all cases except for small Z_{0,1} or similar type cases where mod functions modify the space to something exotic or comparator functions are defined far out of the typical. If you think there is a case for 2 < 1, and you aren't appealing to something exotic, you have the wrong approach.
- asiachick 5y agoInteresting article that shows via data that yes, critics are losing sync with audiences. Not that they were ever in sync? Although the data suggests that actually they are not that far off. For me, I've always attributed a big difference of critics vs the general population is that critics have seen 10x the movies and so movies an audience finds interesting are often "been there, done that, and better" to a critic. Other things I see which I'm not sure the cause and effect are movies that seem (to me) to be highly rated by critics for their message, direct or indirect, and not for whether they are actually good movies. An example to me (I know it's mistake to list one but I'm going to do it anyway), is Moonlight (2016). I'm not saying it's a bad movie but movie of the year? I saw it and other than remembering that it's about gay black men I remember absolutely nothing about the movie. It had zero impact for me. My feeling is it was chosen for its messages. That black men can be gay too. That black actors should be given more diversity in roles. That there should be more diverse movies with black leads. All of which I agree with. But the movie itself, while definitely a well made movie, had zero impact on me as a movie. I don't remember it. Conversely say, Women in the Dunes (1964), that movie will stick with me for the rest of my life. Another random personal observation is it seems like "they" (the creators), have, at least for documentaries, figured out the formula for always making them crowd pleasers. They're the highest rated category both by my own experience looking up movies, and by the article. For me though, I've pretty much decided not to watch documentaries anymore because I see the formula and because I see they are super manipulative. Following the formula they can make you believe almost any conclusion about their topic.
- bmelton 5y agoThere's an interesting concept with user reviews, in that they're inherently OF the people, whereas critical reviews are FOR the people. In a way, critical reviews are like celebrity chef cookbooks in that they should be considered aspirational. What we HOPE to be watching to please our senses of austerity, versus the pulp trash we might actually prefer to be watching. Similarly, sure, we might WISH we were making / eating boeuf en croute regularly, but if you go to a recipe site, the highest rated reviews is more likely to be chicken soup, or something more accessible / makeable on a weeknight. It's always fun to review Plex and routinely see <95% critic ratings, 25% user ratings> or vice versa, but the deltas are more often closer than not. I don't know if I have a point to make here other than to point out that there's utility in noting the distinctions between aspirational and practical, and that serious critics have always given off a vibe of divorcing themselves from the practical, preferring arthouse to action, and in both arenas, Julia Childs-esque figures that can bridge the gap between the aspirational and the practical are extremely rare.
- klodolph 5y agoThe highest rated reviews favor desserts & baked goods, for what it’s worth.
- mikkergp 5y agoFreakonomics just did a good podacast about this this week: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/dont-worry-be-tacky/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/dont-worry-be-tacky/. Essentially that what we talk about liking and what the general population actually like are very different. They interviewed this woman, who as an art student learned all about 'high art' and 'low art' and in a moment of loss of inspiration went back to using some low art she appreciated as inspirationn: https://news.artnet.com/art-world/flora-yukhnovich-2077868 https://news.artnet.com/art-world/flora-yukhnovich-2077868
- bmelton 5y agoOh, thanks! I've pushed that to the top of the queue (but which I'm woefully behind on now without a commute)
- deleted 5y ago
- logicalmonster 5y agoI don't know if this tells the entire story, but I think these are 2 of the bigger issues at play. 1) The corporatization of social media is a big factor. There's big money involved in controlling reviews. Critics and influencers devoted to certain fandoms inevitably get influenced, pressured, infiltrated by studios who expect favorable treatment towards their product or that entity loses access, gets attacked, etc. Try being a blogger who writes about something like Star Trek for example and consistently writing bad reviews. I'm sure you're going to lose any studio access for interviews and all kinds of good things if your criticism ever becomes a little too harsh. 2) Everything has become political, and the media class is totally out of touch from what average working people are looking for. A critic is going to want to rate some drama about a queer latinx non-binary vegan sex worker thats trying to come to grips with his atheism while interracial dating higher than the story deserves just to appear to have the "correct politics". Typical working people don't care as much about that, and just want to know if something is entertaining and worth their time and money.
- floren 5y ago> The corporatization of social media is a big factor. There's big money involved in controlling reviews. Critics and influencers devoted to certain fandoms inevitably get influenced, pressured, infiltrated by studios who expect favorable treatment towards their product or that entity loses access, gets attacked, etc. Remember the online rehabilitation of the Star Wars prequels when Disney was spinning up their crap?
- jrm4 5y agoOnly "1" is correct here. As for "2,", come on, it's ALWAYS been political. It's mostly always been this way except for changes in which particular groups you've named.
- deeg 5y agoYou bring up a good point and there's possibly an additional, simpler, effect: producers of big-budget films pay for good reviews, both by critics and by IMDb users.
- apeace 5y ago
- AMerrit 5y agoInteresting that the gap is with lower budget movies. It goes along with my gut feeling that mid budget movies are disappearing (I have no data to back that up), and it's as if the studios have optimized movie making into two types: #1 The big budget crowd pleasing blockbusters. A few flop, but generally audiences like them and they don't do anything critics can complain about too much. #2 Highly targeted low budget movies. There are small but consistent audiences with endless appetites for horror, action/thriller, etc films even at lower budgets. This seems to be where the biggest disconnect is, the genre fans highly rate their genre films even if it's direct to streaming fluff, while the critics see them as flawed, and broader audiences just don't watch them.
- ascagnel_ 5y agoWhat killed the mid-budget movie was the rise of "peak TV" -- the B-list actors that defined mid-budget movies can land a meaty TV role that pays them well on a consistent basis. We're also seeing more and more A-list talent move to anthology or event series, where you can make a deep dive over 8/10/13 episodes instead of a 120-minute film.
- gigaflop 5y agoSometimes, I'd prefer some sort of limited series more than a movie. 'Maniac' was enjoyable for me because it had time to let things go slowly, despite taking course over what was probably 1 week in-universe. I may also be different from the usual audience, in that I try to avoid binging anything. Hour-long episodes are great for my WFH lunch break, and to pad some time in the evenings if I so desire, but I prefer to commit to watching a movie if I know I have the time. Molly's Game was a nice and long movie, but at over 2 hours long, I feel like it could have had potential at being a miniseries. But also, maybe not? Who knows how much meaningful material was left on the chopping block.
- ascagnel_ 5y ago> Sometimes, I'd prefer some sort of limited series more than a movie. 'Maniac' was enjoyable for me because it had time to let things go slowly, despite taking course over what was probably 1 week in-universe. Maniac is an excellent example. If it were a film, much of it would be cut down, and the movie likely would have had a singular focus on Jonah Hill's Owen character. The show, in having more time to breathe, realized relatively early on (by episode 3 or 4) that Emma Stone's Annie character had a far more compelling story to tell, and shifted its focus accordingly.
- jrm4 5y agoI mean, the biggest thing to remember for me is that the criticism is part of the entertainment. It feels as if things are even different from the Siskel and Ebert era, where you could be pretty sure that their review was driven by how much they liked the film. There's money in hot takes and extremes. (My personal belief is that this is strongly reflected in the extremes seen in the superhero movies. I enjoy them and they are fun, but e.g. the variation between the Marvel and DC ones is just not that extreme. They're all "Dude, appropriately humbled, fights and beats other very similar dude.")
- brootstrap 5y agoSome people are just looking in the wrong places. Tim and Gregg have kept me in touch with quallity Cinema. 5 bagger for sure.
- astrange 5y agoAnd in sausage rolls.
- shantnutiwari 5y agoWere they ever in sync? I've always seen critics as a "negative recommendation" -- if a critic recommends a movie, it's usually bad and vice versa (and like all rules there notable exceptions like Thor Ragnarok, which both critics and normal people loved). And this is true not just in movies but books as well. Critics in both domains love the "ooh lala, fancy pancy hard to understand arty farty" book/movie that doesnt make sense but makes the critics feel smarter than the holloi polloi. Critics have always recommended movies that wouldn't appeal to the working Joe , in a sort of condescending manner. (and yes, like all rules, there are exceptions) Coming to this article-- as someone who isn't a data scientist, I wasn't sure what point the author is making? Correlation is 0.7-- eh?
- michaelmrose 5y agoHave you ever considered that there might actually be something to "ooh lala, fancy pancy hard to understand arty farty" movies that you are merely unable to appreciate and that your failure to appreciate any virtue doesn't constitute proof of its nonexistence? The whole point of pursuing the opinion of critics isn't averaging them to see what smart people like its in finding critics whose taste isn't wholly out of line with yours and using recommendations to cut through the crap and find things worth watching.
- jimmyjazz14 5y agoI used to love artsy stuff then I realized that often they are not any better or deeper they just appear to be or the depth and meaning is projected on them through interpretation which has its place I guess.
- munk-a 5y agoArtsy movies are great... sometimes, and unartsy movies are also great sometimes. Sometimes I want to watch the Seventh Seal and sometimes I want to watch Die Hard - both movies have their place but a lot of critics tend to lean strongly into arthouse movies and sell them well above their actual appeal. I think one of the hardest parts of being a genuinely good critic is being able to leave your own tastes at the door when walking into a new performance - and those tastes are generally ones that have been honed by an education in classic works. Some movies use extremely bold cinematography choices to add a lot to their work (I'd point out Sin City and Schindler's List both of which made extremely good use of high contrast black and white (mostly) filming to add heaps to the story) but then you've got so-so art-house pieces that play into those familiar tropes without delivering anything of real value. It takes a really good critic to watch a movie they really personally enjoyed and tell everyone that it's probably not for them - please do talk about what you liked to inform like minded people - but don't give a 5/5 just because it appealed to your specific tastes.
- chrismeller 5y agoSo the main takeaway here for me is that more low budget (“indie” or “film festival”, my terms) movies are getting to theaters and being loved by critics, but people hate them. My wife and I have a rule in our household. Anything that was awarded at a film festival (Sundance in particular) I will not watch with her. This analysis backs up the feelings I’ve had that lead to that agreement… Any movie that does well with critics or at a film festival has “a strong message” or “teaches us something”. That’s all well and good, but I don’t need these expensive (€20/ticket) modern fables. I’m paying to be entertained, not to be lectured to.
- JaimeThompson 5y agoWhat sorts of films don't lecture?
- Izkata 5y agoMost entertainment-oriented films. There's a big difference between "has a message" (which those usually do include) and "lecture" aka "beat you over the head with".
- delusional 5y agoI think most blockbuster "entertainment" movies are MORE heavy handed in their preaching. The big differentiator for me is that they preach what is already assumed. It's not that they don't lecture you, it's that they lecture you in what you already agree with. In that sense entertainment-movies are more like sermons from your pastor. It's a reframing of a story you've already been told a million times, so your brain can just switch off and absorb the message uncritically.
- AlexandrB 5y agoYes. The typical modern blockbuster constantly hits you over the head with its messages of "family" or "finding yourself" or "overcoming obstacles" of whatever like you're still in grade school. Compare that to something like No Country for Old Men - a movie with a much more nuanced set of ideas. Or even to older blockbusters like Die Hard which are more consistently focused on the action and keep the moralizing to a minimum.
- trophycase 5y agoGeneral population has terrible taste, movie studios are now buying fake audience reviews to pump the ratings, they also buy critics but I assume they've always done that. Pretty hard to argue that critics are out of touch when the general population votes Avengers: Infinity War a top 10 movie of all time when it's released.
- shmde 5y agoInfinity war if not in top 10, but is a very entertaining, well made action flick which deserves to be rated high. Probably one of the best action movies in the 2-3 decades.
- Melatonic 5y agoHave they ever been in sync?
- oblak 5y agoYes, when you were a kid and didn't know any better.
- DharmaPolice 5y agoI don't know about in sync but I think there might have been more common ground in the past. Movies like The Godfather, Jaws, Goodfellas, Pulp Fiction or Shawshank Redemption sometimes feature highly on both critics and the public's favourite movie lists. I doubt many serious film critics are going to be putting any of the Marvel movies in their top 10 of all time yet there are large numbers of people out there who would.
- photochemsyn 5y agoAnother possibilty is that audience scores are easier to gamify via the use of bots relative to critic scores (which I assume are limited to identified critics who work for major media outlets). One way for a movie's PR/advertising group to generate buzz is to flood rt with positive movie reviews for example. I suppose you could detect this by correlating individual movie advertising budgets with rt audience scores across the board?
- nix0n 5y agoOne possibly overlooked factor is the death of Roger Ebert, who managed to be both a man of the people and respected among critics (possibly because he was also an excellent writer).
- ahelwer 5y agoI suspect film might just be dead as an artistic medium that can be enjoyed by lots of people. I maybe go to a movie theatre once every couple of years these days, the rest of the time I watch things at home. It’s a hard ask to set aside two contiguous hours (or more!) to watch a film when there are so many good series or video games that demand less contiguous attention. People will rant about attention spans I guess but it’s really a matter of what quality of entertainment you can fit in with the rest of your life. If I watch a film in the evening that is pretty much the only thing I do with that evening; not so with other entertainment formats. The two hour film is also like the equivalent of a short story: there’s the mental barrier to entry of loading new characters and settings and world rules into your head, and so I find it more difficult to read anthologies of short stories than a novel of the same length.
- stnmtn 5y agoAlmost all my friends echo your sentiment that film is much harder to commit to than a TV show; and I can't disagree more. Watching a TV series means I'm committing to 8+ hours per season, across many days of my life. A film, even a 2 hour one, I watch in an evening and can enjoy taking it in in full, with all questions that it wants to answer itself being answered. A TV show will end with cliffhangers each episode just to make sure it demands your attention again tomorrow night. That's not to say TV=bad, movies=good; just that IME respect your time way more and are easier to commit to most nights.
- fleddr 5y agoBoth of you should give this lecture to people in the third world. The act of sitting on a couch, watching something entertaining that thousands of people put work in to produce, is a "commitment". And in fact, the commitment is too much. Because for this same commitment, one could replace it with several smaller ones that entail the exact same thing, but with even less thinking. If only there were a device that would just directly inject the memory of a movie into our brains, saves us from all this "effort".
- imbnwa 5y agoAre film critics losing sync with the average person who actually goes outta their way to rate movies on IMDB?
- squarefoot 5y agoI wouldn't base any statistics on IMDB ratings, they're garbage. Just look at how many awful amateurish experiments there receive spectacular 10 star reviews within days of their release, very likely by cast and crew friends/relatives (or worse), then are buried by 1 star reviews when actual viewers eventually watch them.
- akvadrako 5y agoYou have to look also at number of reviews. Then it's mostly Indian films which get ridiculous user ratings.
- blablabla123 5y agoDo you maybe have an example? I'm always astounded how well the IMDB score matches how likeable a film is (minus personal preferences of course). 5 is basically always really bad unless I'm a fan of a specific actor/director/genre. The comments are mixed, the comments below the YouTube trailers tend to be quite on point though to see if a film is worth watching
- justinclift 5y agoIMDB seems to be widely abused these days for marketing purposes. eg fake high ratings to try and mislead people into giving them a try Examples in point (both exceptionally terrible, but with very fake high ratings): * https://www.imdb.com/title/tt13668894 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt13668894 ("The Book of Boba Fett") * https://www.imdb.com/title/tt9170108 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt9170108 ("Raised by Wolves")
- sydthrowaway 5y agoThe best critic is Critical Drinker on YouTube
- regpertom 5y agoBegs the question as to how much Mr Plinkett changed the review landscape? Long form anal sis including the meta, the craft, and how the soup was made. Throw in every frames a painting as maybe another OG. Going beyond is it good or bad x/10 to something else entirely. 6 hour review of the 2 hour phantom menace. Or in efap, what it means to pan right or left. Flexing the knowledge of a critic and thereby proving the worth of film studies, often maligned as useless, allowing us to see through their eyes. Trusting the audience and giving them tools to be a critic themselves. “You might not have noticed, but your brain did” Now there’s mauler, critical drinker, er, to name a few. Going beyond entertainment, long form analysis of politics and more. Go beyond the press release and the status quo. I’m conflating a lot of things here purely because it would be funny if mr plinkett could be shown to have revolutionised the world in ways the “pretentious snob” could only dream.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoFilm critics want triumphs. Audiences want to be entertained. Will Smith was a ridiculous, inauthentic disaster in King Richard, but won Best Actor anyway.
- monocasa 5y agoThe critics don't decide the Oscars, the academy does. It's more a political thing than a statement of quality.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoThe want the same dumb, boring, monotonous somber shit every year and the Academy largely votes the way the critics tell them to.
- monocasa 5y agoNo, all of the awards are pretty much lifetime achievement awards that happen to coincide with some movie. 'Sure it's not his best work, but he deserves an Oscar.'
- goto11 5y ago> the Academy largely votes the way the critics tell them to This is absolutely not the case. For example "Oscar campaigns" have significant influence on the Academy, and they happen after the critics have given their verdict.
- munk-a 5y agoI think there are some confounding variables that make this analysis extremely difficult. First off I'd like to establish that in the 90s film critics had no idea what audiences like, most of the famous film critics were film majors who values cinematography well above what standard audiences would rate it - a poorly shot movie with guns and explosions would be a box office darling while a black and white drama in the style of ingmar bergman would delight critics (I'm not badmouthing these movies btw - they just didn't tend to be audience favorites). Additionally, pre internet we essentially had no access to unprofessional opinions - hobby magazines and word of mouth were the only things that could counter a bad review from the globe or times. Secondly, I think, like we saw with pretty much all "old media" that critics took their damn sweet time to transition over to the internet. In the early days of rotten tomatoes you'd rarely see newspaper critics within the tomatometer - those criticisms were the property of their respective media companies and they didn't want to give the milk away for free. As such it's taken a while for the professional grade critics to actually fully move into the new space - mostly by way of replacement. Old critics die and retire and new critics fresh out of film school start their career running a blog and being tech friendly. From those two points, while I find the data in the article quite well calculated theoretically I think it's hard to really draw any conclusions - the conversion rate of critics would need to be better understood and the pre-internet critic inaccuracy would need to be evaluated. There are some great examples of films that were absolutely panned by critics but ended up being extremely beloved classics[1] and, then, we've got all the cult hits like RHPS which, when originally screened, had the vast majority of critics simply walk out on. 1. A NYT article about "classics" that got negative contemporary reviews on release https://archive.ph/kiDVH https://archive.ph/kiDVH
- ulrikrasmussen 5y agoFilm reviews are not supposed to be a predictor of general popularity I think
- shadowgovt 5y agoIt really depends on the critic. Some critics try to be an "everyman viewer" and break down the films they see based on whether they think folks will like them. Others just have the attitude of "my taste, take it or leave it."
- shadowgovt 5y ago> As making and releasing movies has become easier, we have seen an increase in the number of low budget films hitting the big screen. At the same time, these films have become increasingly more divisive, although I’m not sure why. I believe we can expect one from the other. Hollywood and Rockefeller Plaza are huge gatekeeping infrastructures; the sheer number of specialists you need to get buy-in from to make a film in the traditional system means there are multiple layers of people with veto power (or creative control) over an idea. Decreasing price-to-entry means more people can bypass larger pieces of those edifices, which means fewer gatekeepers between the creative and their idea hitting a screen. Couple that with increasingly bypassed distribution channels (not every film needs to hit a theater), and you're likely to see a more diverse set of minds creating content for people to consume. Diversity can breed divisiveness if people are of a critical bent, and since we're talking about critics and film audiences, I think we'd expect that link in this context.
- shadowgovt 5y agoMy favorite thing about film critique is the phenomenon of anti-signal. There was a local-paper film critic who was just the most delightful curmudgeon. If there was a film done in any style that wasn't aping 1960 or earlier, he despised it. But it made him a very useful barometer for me: I'd look at the movies he panned and go see those.
- elil17 5y agoThe people who leave IMDB reviews are probably also pretty far away from the average audience - only a small set of people post reviews their and there’s probably a lot of sampling bias towards film nerds.
- monkeybutton 5y agoReally? I would say user reviews on Rotten Tomatoes skews more towards film nerds and IMDb is the more everyday sort of person. Between the two platforms there's a disconnect in users' preferences.
- elil17 5y agoI’d agree, but I think both are very far away from the typical person, who does not post online reviews at all. Maybe the difference isn’t film nerd vs. not, but I’d wager there’s a big difference between an IMDB reviewer and a randomly sampled person.
- HighChaparral 5y agoThis was my reaction to the article also - the base assumption that the relatively tiny group of audience members who rate films on imdb are statistically representative of the audience at large needs to be proven first.
- duxup 5y agoJust from a review reader perspective: I don't want critic scores to necessarily go hand in hand with audience scores. I have no idea what a given audience member wants. Random user reviews might rave that "Fast and Furious" speaks to the truth of the human condition, but I'm kinda skeptical and don't really know what that means coming from their perspective ... maybe question that person's life / film viewing experience. Now if the Fast and Furious is a fun summer flick that isn't dumb enough to make me roll my eyes too often, I want to know that. I might be in the mood for that. But few if any user reviews will tell me that reliably. I look for different things from critics and users. The ratings matter less to me than where they are coming from / what they tell me. I also miss Roger Ebert.
- bombcar 5y agoThis is the whole point of reviews I feel - you get to know a reviewer and you can use their review to decide if you want to see it. They may absolutely hate the movie, but the way they hate it makes you know you'll enjoy it. "Review aggregators" have killed much of that I feel.
- ghaff 5y agoI assume there's also been a fairly dramatic falloff in professional reviewers given the state of newspapers. Not that people writing reviews as a hobby or as a twenty-something working for pennies for the "exposure" can't do a good job. But you're probably going to get a lot less consistency if nothing else.
- bombcar 5y agoTrue, back when newspapers were a "every city has one or two" there'd often be a local reviewer writing for that paper. Then it went to syndicated reviews and now I'm not sure I can even name a single reviewer. Also, you have access to much more information about a movie if you want it, instead of having to figure out if you want to see a movie based on three inches of column.
- brimble 5y ago
- bumblebritches5 5y ago
- lamontcg 5y agoI feel like the mass of people are ossifying around the familiar. People like re-watching the same stuff that they've already watched, they're comfortable these days watching reboots of the same superhero movies. They like big budgets and flashy special effects. They don't like being challenged by anything. Even when it comes to something like online forums, something like reddit is mostly a wasteland of the same 50 or so jokes endlessly recycled, with people desperately trying to be clever, but not too clever, to hit that sweet spot of mediocrity that gains piles of "updoots". I don't know if its always been this way and I'm just more annoyed with it lately.
- gotaquestion 5y agoI thought the reboots were in order to retain property rights, and that with 2-3 years between reboots aimed at teens, there are a new batch of teens. So it seems like a win-win: renew property rights and lure in the new batch of teens.
- aidenn0 5y agoThat's specifically true only for Spiderman I think. Reportedly[1] Sony loses the rights if they go too long without producing a Spiderman film. 1: This is treated as fact in many places, but was very hard for me to source. The most definitive statement I could find was contemporary with the MGM/Sony dispute being resolved: > The Marvel-Sony contract requires the studio to begin production of a Spider-Man feature quickly; the actual deadline could not be obtained. It also places Columbia on a short leash in scheduling sequels, requiring in some cases that financing for a sequel be arranged within months of the release of the previous feature[2]. 2: https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1999-mar-02-fi-13115-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1999-mar-02-fi-13115...
- yoz-y 5y agoMy theory is that: You make a massively appealing thing by removing what people don’t like, not by adding something they do. The truly mass market media is devoid of substance because of that. Hence why I feel that the most interesting things are those which are polarizing.
- pessimizer 5y agoI think the numbers are just a distraction. What the critics like is informed by the desire to maintain access to the studios and the quality of the goodies they've been given (access journalism/junket whores), and what the public likes is informed by the size of the marketing spend and what the critics have already written before they saw the film. A better proxy for public sentiment would be viewer scores from test screenings. For me, it would be easy enough to blame any increasing divergence on the fact that now, due to the internet and consumer culture/conventions, critics scores matter less and direct marketing spend matters more. That would also account for why genre films diverge most, because each spends the budget of a small country on promotion. edit: sorry for not being an amateur psychologist about this or moaning about ivory tower elites, but these are products.
- oehpr 5y agomy... I see you have adopted an appropriate name. By this logic I could just spend all my budget on telling the public a movie is great, then show them a grey rectangle for 2 hours and get rave reviews. If this is not the case, then to what degree is it one or the other? Where would you put your ratios?
- frumper 5y agoYou know, I think there would be people in this thread that would call that a good movie. It challenges you to think about cinema differently and provides a unique theater experience.
- he0001 5y agoI feel like it’s the opposite. You are losing touch with the critics. As today there are so many and you are not as “faithful” towards one source anymore. You are getting reviews from all sorts of sources, good and bad.
- andrewclunn 5y agoWhen reviews became numerical and used to recommend content via algorithms, was it any wonder they became as broken as any other form of rating online? Incentives and emergence shape everything. Want a good critic? Find someone (an individual) with tastes similar to yours. The aggregate is always a distorted mess of corrupt business practices, incompetent hot takes, and people you disagree with mucking up the waters. That there is or was ever "critical consensus" should be the least reassuring thing.
- paxys 5y agoThe TL;DR is that more people these days are watching and rating low-budget artsy movies that critics generally love but they don't, hence the rising discrepancy.
- nonameiguess 5y agoYou probably need to do some data cleaning and validation before drawing any conclusions. A fair number of critical darlings are somewhat topical movies about current relevant social issues and they can be subject to review bombing by audiences, often audiences that don't even see the film. I'm not sure if IMDB really does much about that. Rotten Tomatoes at least stopped letting you review a movie before it was possible to see it after Captain Marvel had thousands of bad reviews before it even came out, but they still don't verify you saw the movie. They surface verified reviews closer to the top, but the ratings from unverified raters still count. This was, of course, much less of a thing in 2000 than in 2019.
- gubatron 5y ago
- wwilim 5y agoLow budget is a breeding ground for divisive genres on both ends of the spectrum - crappy horror movies and arthouse experimental drama alike
- cwkoss 5y agoCritic reviews are prescriptive: what they think the masses should watch. User reviews are retrospective: how much did they actually enjoy watching the movie. I think there has always been a fundamental disconnect, in that critics think the masses should be watching 'smarter', 'more artistic' or, less flatteringly, more pretentious movies. The world has become a lot more political over the past couple decades. I wouldn't be surprised if critics are trying to be increasingly prescriptive, using their review to try to change the modern zeitgeist. I think a very interesting graph would be so see to what extent critics prescriptions are accurately forward-looking to viewer attitudes. More interesting further research could be: For movies that came out before 2010 where the user rating diverged from critic rating by more than 10%, are user ratings which were rated after 2015 in the same direction as the critic's divergence? There are certainly movies that I enjoyed as a teenager, but cringe watching today: were critics at the time cringing in the same way, ahead of the masses? Or are critics just in a pretentious bubble that is not predictive of societal evolution?
- watwut 5y ago> Critic reviews are prescriptive: what they think the masses should watch. This does not seem to be accurate description of movie reviews I have read. Like, not at all.
- nmat 5y agoPart of a critic's job is to educate people. A good critic can explain why a certain film is groundbreaking and why another film is recycling ideas that have been done thousands of times. The critic's end-goal is to push the industry to make better films not because of critics, but because the public demands it.
- Touche 5y agoThis doesn't seem right at all, a critic's job is to drive page views and nothing more. What you are describing is how critic's like to perceive themselves.
- 5y ago
- shrimpx 5y agoCritics seem to rate movies on a global scale. How can I give this movie 9/10 when Citizen Kane is a 9/10? On that scale, this movie is at most a 6. Unsurprisingly, popular genres get trashed on that scale. Normal folks rate movies subjectively. Was it really awesome and did I love it? Then it’s a 10.
- BizarroLand 5y agoThere should be a comparison system based on genre, by the best ever, this year, and this decade. Format would be something like: Compared to the best 10/10 all-time movie of the Genre, Movie A, Movie X is a 7/10. Compared to the other movies of the genre in the last year, Movie X gets a 8.5/10. Compared to the other movies of the genre this decade, Movie X gets a 7.75/10. Final verdict, 7.75/10, if you like movies in this genre you will probably enjoy Movie X.
- dagw 5y agoIf you read the review and don't just look at the score, they generally make all those 'scores' implicitly clear.
- eldenwrong 5y ago
- humanrebar 5y ago> Unsurprisingly, popular genres get trashed on that scale. Except kids movies. I think they get graded on a huge curve. I think "I took my kid to it and I don't hate myself" gets an automatic three stars or something.
- innocentoldguy 5y ago20 to 30 years ago, movie critics seemed to review movies by giving information on the content of the film and what the film did well/poorly. Today, it seems that movie critiques are little more than smug attempts at clever prose. It seems to me that film critics used to focus on films. Nowadays, film critics seem focused on themselves.
- nacho2sweet 5y agoMovie company marketing for blockbusters 100% revolves around controlling a fandom that will review bomb things while a lot of the general public won't even participate in a RT audience score or IMDB rating.
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoNo, I don't think so. I think they get it largely right. How many reviews of movies have you seen from a senior, experienced reviewer got a film really totally wrong? I don't mean "hated a movie that genre fans will like", or "dunked on a trashy movie", because in almost all cases those reviews acknowledge their biases and even the people who like that sort of thing will get the picture. I mean: really wrong. In recent years I can think of only one major movie that was seriously misunderstood by a major critic: Cloud Atlas was totally misperceived by Mark Kermode. And even he changed his opinion on a second viewing. In general I wish other things were reviewed as fairly as films are; too many reviews of things/services are poisoned by motivated reasoning.
- humanrebar 5y agoMovie critics tend to give mediocre movies a bump when they like the message or think it otherwise is politically desirable. Similarly, critics tend to downplay movies that have a more... blue collar?... appeal, no matter the artistry or purpose of the film. For instance, Taken gets 59% with critics on Rotten Tomatoes. It was a hugely important and impactful film. It basically spawned/revived a whole subgenre of action film.
- unfocussed_mike 5y ago> For instance, Taken gets 59% with critics on Rotten Tomatoes. It was a hugely important and impactful film. It basically spawned/revived a whole subgenre of action film. A fair number of critics looked down on that film because it is casually chauvinistic, nasty and bigoted. (I absolutely loathe it. Want to see how that film could have been? Watch Man On Fire.) I don't know whether you can support your "politically desirable" assertion with meaningful data -- not to say that you might not be right, but more to say that I don't know what shape that data would have. But I'd be interested to hear a couple of examples anyway.
- humanrebar 5y agoMaybe, but skimming reviews they mostly seem to think it's boring or lowbrow or something.
- skinnymuch 5y agoOn Cinema at the Cinema has been going strong reviewing 2-3 movies each episode for nearly a decade across a dozen seasons. The host and one of his guests appear to buck the trend and know what audiences want.
- quantumfan1738 5y agoThe hosts are very sane with their movie reviews as well, nearly every film receives 5 bags of popcorn, even if it was painful to watch!
- zasdffaa 5y agoI look to good critics and they do help, but in the end what a critic wants to watch will differ from the average pleb like me because they do a lot of watching. I suppose it might be put thus: If you're eating out every day because that is your job you'll want good quality food with a bit of subtlety and care. If you're me and you've had a few days of keyboard work and naff all else, you want the junk-food-level moderately brainless entertaining tripe to distract your mind.
- Sophistifunk 5y agoIt will always be this way. Movie / music reviewers are in love with the artform itself, and view each movie / album as an artefact through that lens. Joe sixpack wants to see some exciting or funny stuff, or some heartwarming stuff, and to see some baddies get their comeuppence for once, or to briefly live vicariously through some sort of heroic or inspirational archetype. Viewers don't even have to disagree with reviewers in order to ignore their advice. They're just not looking to bask in the wonder of the artform, but to be taken on an emotional journey.
- thereare5lights 5y agoYep You have critics saying things like > "I recognized the humour in the film, but connected with none of it," O'Connell wrote in his review. > "By rooting Turning Red very specifically in the Asian community of Toronto, the film legitimately feels like it was made for Domee Shi's friends and immediate family members. Which is fine — but also, a tad limiting in its scope." https://www.cbc.ca/news/entertainment/turning-red-review-pulled-1.6377614 https://www.cbc.ca/news/entertainment/turning-red-review-pul... https://www.npr.org/2022/03/12/1086040083/turning-red-controversy https://www.npr.org/2022/03/12/1086040083/turning-red-contro...
- jokethrowaway 5y agoThe problem is that people that end up being film critics, celebrities and journalists are not representative of the population at large and they're mostly (with plenty of exceptions) susceptible to the politicised division that curse our time (which is a result of the technology we have available nowadays). The end result is that politics doesn't simply bleed into art (as it always been) but forces the people in art to create propaganda tools. When you say that half of the population is batshit crazy and this message is propagated through popular media everywhere, you end up with a scism. In the same way as people are growing disillusioned with celebrities and newspapers, they're also putting miles between themselves and film critics - and Hollywood for that matter. I'm looking forward to The Daily Wire (an American conservative publication) building an Hollywood alternative and making movies without the wokeness. Their first movie, Run Hide Fight has critics at 43% vs the audience at 93%. The data presented in the article is interesting but I feel it's lacking a dimension. It's not about quantity, it's about the extremes. The feminist reboot of Ghostbusters has critics at 73% vs the audience at 49% which is telling me more about this issue than knowing that critics like documentaries more than the average person.
- KaiserPro 5y agofilm critics tend to be "connoisseurs" which means that they prise the unusual, technical or some other subtle feature that's only really obvious after lots of repeat viewing. Not only that, they are intensely competitive to heap praise on cool stuff and dump shit on stuff that's not "cool" For example Crash one the best picture oscar in 2006. Its a shit film. Yes it talks about racism, and that perhaps the racist isn't that bad because he's got a sick dad. But still he can feel up a black woman though, thats allowed. Its just such an unsatisfying movie. near that time https://www.the-numbers.com/box-office-records/worldwide/all-movies/cumulative/released-in-2006 https://www.the-numbers.com/box-office-records/worldwide/all... all these came out, and there are some genuinley entertaining movies in there. V for vendetta, The queen, casino royal All sorts. But the critics loved crash because it was "brave" was it fuck. It was a mashed about script that barely survived the gazillion re-writes and "tweaks" from producers that have more money than sense. In short, most critics should be ignored, and placed in the same bin that contains "film theorists" As someone who was both forced to take a film theory module in uni, and then went to work in the movies for ten years, I can firmly tell you that film thoery is mostly wank 1) author theory. Nope, its a massive team effort, no such thing 2) Feminism in hollywood: there is none. there are like 6 female directors of rank, of which at least two are only there because of their dad. Most screen writers are male as well. Any female script will be "tightend" by a committee of men, you known to make it sell.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zeouter 5y agoI like reading reviews from film critics, they often pick up on things I don't, and enrich my perspective on the movies, even if I don't feel the same as they do.
- yason 5y agoHuh, have critics ever been in sync with audiences? For my whole life, I've learned and then observed that critics evaluate primarily the cinematic quality of a film, i.e. does the film as a piece of art work as a whole when considering acting, directing, screenwriting... This is generally a different axis from entertainment which is what people often care about when looking for something to see. If a critic likes a film it's because it is good cinema. If you're in the film-watching mood you would likely appreciate that film if it has high critical scores. But if you want something easy or you want to see a guaranteed uplifting film with your friends before going out to a pub round, you want entertainment and then you don't want to look at the critics scores. You might want to infer something from the review text because often critics do tell you if the film is entertaining and a good watch. The film still got 1 star out of 5 because it was not good cinema.
- AdamJacobMuller 5y ago> have critics ever been in sync with audiences? I think there was a smaller gap in a few respects. Firstly I think the film industry as a whole has polarized into "art" and "entertainment" films with too little crossover. Films can and should be artful and entertaining. Secondly I think critics have become too polarized to criticize films as being "low-effort" or "low-value" entertainment films. There's a reason why people go see blockbusters, they enjoy them! Finally, I think unfortunately some audiences too quickly dismiss some films as "too artsy" or "too intelligent" or "not wanting to think." There's a lot of fun movies out there which don't fit into normal boxes! Sadly I don't really see that gap closing. I agree with someone in another thread which said that there's much better and more varied content on "TV" (streaming/etc) in medium-form series. Give me a great limited-run series like the queen's gambit any day! it's the perfect intersection of artsy and fun and high brow and low brow!
- wolverine876 5y ago> I've learned and then observed that critics evaluate primarily the cinematic quality of a film, i.e. does the film as a piece of art work as a whole when considering acting, directing, screenwriting... This is generally a different axis from entertainment which is what people often care about when looking for something to see. IME and IMHO, the former has a great effect on the latter; that's why people, including critics, care about it. The qualities are what make the movie engaging, moving, exciting, etc. In UX, users may not understand how it is done but the UX design still impacts them significantly; UX designers can tell you what is making that impact and how.
- davesque 5y agoMy more general take is that "elite" culture has diverged more and more from popular culture as the middle class has shrunk. I think it's very much connected to the trend of economic stratification.
- amp108 5y agoI think at least part of it has to do with the fact that, if you're a critic, you see probably 500+ movies a year. You are likely to get bored with things that the casual viewer doesn't, and it might even be hard to tell it's happening to you. So you'll recommend something that's more "challenging" just because it's different, even if the rewards are thin for the average moviegoer.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- asciimov 5y agoThe average of film critics shouldn't be in sync with the average of audiences, and that is okay! Critics watch movies from a different perspective of an audience member. Some really get pulled in by the technical details of the film while others are drawn to the story. Meanwhile the average movie goer's sole concern is entertainment. The best way to use movie critics is like a discovery service. Find several (4 or 5) whose opinions you find agreeable (and maybe a few that you don't agree). Then go look at the movies those critics liked that you have never heard and watch them. Finally, if you have made it this far, I recommend you watch "It Happened One Night" (1934). It's a romcom with Clark Gable and Claudette Colbert, directed by Frank Capra, and it was the first movie to win the Oscar for Best Picture, Director, Actor, Actress, and Screen play. It's really good!
- switchbak 5y agoThere's times when I want to know the inside-baseball angle of a film, that can be really interesting, but those times are rare for me (and most people, I'd wager). When critics diverge so far from the role of answering the question "what's a movie I would enjoy" then no, they're not doing their job. I'm not sure exactly what job they're doing now, but I'd say by and large they aren't doing anything I'm interested in. That's like having a tourist blog that only talks about places that other tourist blogs like to blog about but not places people want to visit! Not useful for the (assumed) intended audience.
- CrispinS 5y ago> When critics diverge so far from the role of answering the question "what's a movie I would enjoy" then no, they're not doing their job. There's no critic that can predict what you'll like, since tastes in films differ so much. I have a friend I don't discuss movies with much, because we disagree on pretty much every single one we've both seen; it's literally impossible for a single critic to directly tell us both what we'd like.
- switchbak 5y agoCritics can most certainly put themselves in the position of relating to common folks, and that was a big part of what Siskel and Ebert both did. Just cause someone might not know my specific tastes isn't a reason that everyone should have to be recommended videos that most people will predictably not enjoy. That's like saying since there's no way I'd know what music you might like, then you should listen to King Crimson since it's highly respected in prog Rock circles. Yes, sure, and most people would hate it.
- bluenose69 5y agoOthers have said they miss Ebert. I'm certainly in that club. I haven't paid much attention to film reviews since Ebert died. Sure, he gave scores, but they were not the point. I read his reviews because they helped me to explore my own thoughts about the films. It's the same reason I enjoy chatting with friends about films, books, art, etc. Scoring is not the point. Agreement is not the desired outcome. Oftentimes, after I watch an old film, I'll look up Ebert's review, to see what he thought. Almost always, I'm enriched by doing that.
- julienchastang 5y agoEbert wrote beautifully. I was lucky enough to have met him once or twice at book signing events here in Boulder. He was a regular at the Conference on World Affairs dissecting movies one shot at a time. I attended all of his "Cinema Interruptus" for Mulholland Drive, La Dolce Vita, (no small commitment actually) and a few others. On top of it, Ebert was a kind, good human. I also miss Ebert. Check out his "Great Movies" book series if you can.
- WalterBright 5y agoThese days, I find I enjoy Eddie Mueller. Some movie dvds have an alternate soundtrack which is him critiquing the movies. Listening to his prattle is often far better than the movie. In related news, I recall one movie with a director's commentary track. It was full of each of the actors saying their bit about the movie. Everyone (including the dog) casually concluded with he/she had to sleep with the director to get the part. Another one where the commentary track was better than the flick.
- tomcam 5y ago> I recall one movie with a director's commentary track. It was full of each of the actors saying their bit about the movie. Everyone (including the dog) casually concluded with he/she had to sleep with the director to get the part. Another one where the commentary track was better than the flick. Wait you’re not going to tell us what movies these were? Also I assume in the first example they were kidding? Or the director was dead?
- TheRealPomax 5y agoFilm critics were never in sync with audiences. Film critics have completely different ranking criteria compared to viewing audiences. This has never not been true.
- anothernewdude 5y agoI've filtered myself out of the 'audience' because there's nothing coming out that is of interest at all. Perhaps the audience is becoming more and more biased, and of a particular kind of person.
- Koshkin 5y agoThis one never has: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Filthy_Critic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Filthy_Critic
- pc2g4d 5y agoFilm critic reviews are the Hacker News of the film world: nerds nerding out. I once went out with a woman who was highly steeped in film criticism and such. I think she volunteered as dramaturg at a theater company or something like that. We watched "I'm Thinking of Ending Things" together, and I thought it was the most dismal, dispiriting, horrible movie I'd ever seen. Afterward she opened my eyes to how a critic would interpret it, the symbolism, the cultural currents, etc. I hadn't picked up on any of that. I still hate that movie. But I guess I can see a bit better how, if you're in on it, it can be fun to pick things apart in that certain way. It's like a secret language that only you and a few others speak. There's nothing quite like speaking your native tongue when living in a foreign land. I think a lot of the professional critics are like that. We don't speak their secret language. We commoners are the foreign land they must survive in. They're having a conversation among themselves. It's not for us. At least, that's what it's become.
- freediver 5y ago> Film critic reviews are the Hacker News of the film world: nerds nerding out. Thanks for making this observation, it applies to so many things.
- sshagent 5y agoThis is giving me some flashbacks to starting a course at college on Film Studies. I left after a few weeks, the constant over analysis was too much. Let me enjoy (or hate) the movie is please. It does seem weird to me that the creatives involved would put so much effort into things that the bulk of the population won't interpret.
- boh 5y agoI don't think it's too controversial to admit how irrelevant professional film critics have become. Being contradictory may be an attempt to gain some attention. I often see "hot takes" from critics where they diminish a massively acknowledged classic (like The Godfather) and praise what was traditionally considered low brow (Weekend at Bernie's). Film critics have to operate in the same clickbait-y environment like any other columnist. I think this divergence from the audience is just their version of sensationalism.
- godisdad 5y agoNarcissistic elites losing sync with the audiences of mass culture? Unbelievable
- Isamu 5y agoFilm critics are still a thing? I honestly thought they died out along with newsprint and the shift to streaming media
- m3kw9 5y agoI feel they are like stock analysis now, rate it wrong and you’d look stupid. Rate it too low, you may piss off the studio and you won’t be invited to the special events.
- crossroadsguy 5y agoA lot of the established ones (the ones whose full time job is reviewing films; hopefully after watching them fully) are deliberately and often needlessly contrarian. And then there are the “forced” art filmmakers. The kind who wanted to make an art film since the day zero of film school. An “art” film for sure. No conviction, no original idea (if any idea at all), no coherence (that’s actually a recipe now), definitely no story. Shoddy camera work becomes experimental cinematography, bad acting is termed as realistically absurd way of channelling the character. And that’s what they actually make - not a film, but an art film. Film festivals love such films - it should just check more than few boxes of weird. These two kinds often complement each other.
- jwaterhouse 5y agoMy gut feel is that using IMDB users isn't a good stand in for the general audience. I would think they're a lot more "into" movies than most people, and this analysis is closer to comparing professional vs "non-professional" critics. There's an old video that videogamedunkey where he talks about the relationship between a critic and reader. Critics (particularly of art/media) shouldn't be looked at as some objective judge of whatever it is their critiquing (even if that's what they're trying to be). Instead you need to build a "relationship" by reading/viewing their stuff to get an idea of their own likes/dislikes/biases. For me I've gravitated to a few critics whose stuff I read pretty frequently. Even when I've already seen a movie I'll go and read their review afterwards to hear their thoughts on it. Whether I agree with it or not I think it enriches the movie going experience.
- WalterBright 5y agoI'm old and have watched an awful lot of movies. They rarely impress me anymore. I tire of the same old stuff, like that same old hawk scream whenever there's a long shot of wilderness. There's the "guess the order in which the lesser characters die" trope. The final fight in the darkened warehouse. The bad guy is vanquished, but is restored for another battle. The hero's boss turns out to be the bad guy. The computer guy is always a pathetic nerd. The guy stalks his dream girl and wins her. But enough of that. What I really dislike is the heavy-handed moral lessons that Hollywood elites insist that they need to teach us. Chris Rock's rude joke and Will Smith's bitch slap shows that Hollywood is no better than the rest of us and has no particular business lecturing us on what we should believe and how we should behave. (To top it off, the Academy didn't even see fit to eject Smith from the premises, and still gave him an Oscar.) There are some exceptions to the unending stream of tripe. "House of Cards" was good.
- eyphka 5y agoGraphs strongly suggest that horror genre is cause of disconnect. Would be curious if desync exists if you remove indie horror from data set.
- wly_cdgr 5y agoThe good ones have never had it. The point of good criticism has never been to convince mass market audiences to like things they lack the cognitive / emotional / aesthetic skills to appreciate. The point is to provide good directors with the appreciation they deserve and need to stare down poverty and despair and keep making good work, from the few people whose opinion they care about
- wj 5y agoI'm going to drop a link to my favorite film critic and one of my favorite sites on the Internet: https://seeingthingssecondhand.com/ https://seeingthingssecondhand.com/ His reviews always rekindle my love for film when it is waning (mostly due to lack of time). Love the rankings (Marvel movies, Disney movies, etc.) as well as the reviews of the other top movies list (Better than the AFI Top 100). Feels like required reading for a cinephile.
- muh_gradle 5y agoThis is my first time seeing this critic. I'm just curious how you were introduced to this and any posts you enjoy in particular?
- wj 5y agoI've been reading it since at least 2017 which was the first time I can find that I emailed someone about it. Don't remember how I was introduced. I really enjoyed the recent 100 Greatest Stars series as it is always fun to read a ranking list and see where your own picks slot in but few ranking lists go as in depth with their reasoning as this one. Plus, it highlighted a lot of films by the big stars that I haven't got around to seeing yet. https://seeingthingssecondhand.com/category/better-than-afis-100-stars-2021/ https://seeingthingssecondhand.com/category/better-than-afis... For people with kids, or who still enjoy kids movies, this one is good: https://seeingthingssecondhand.com/category/disney-pixar-rankings-2019/ https://seeingthingssecondhand.com/category/disney-pixar-ran... I'm hoping he does a Studio Ghibli ranking at some point.
- crooked-v 5y agoFilm critics have been losing sync with audience since film was invented. Funny that they never seem to quite manage doing so, though.
- aasasd 5y agoWell, if you just open Rotten Tomatoes once in a while, you'll find that the critics are all ecstatic over comic superhero movies.
- cgrealy 5y agoA couple of things: People today confuse reviews with criticism. The two are not the same. A review is a consumer recommendation, i.e. should you pay to see this movie? Criticism is discussion of a piece of art. Both are inherently subjective. Second, how many new movies did you watch this year? I'm guessing for most people, it's >10 (data seems to suggest it's even lower). If you are a film critic and you watch 50 movies a year, you're more likely to gravitate towards the less bombastic, crowd-pleasing movies. Same with games. If you've played 50 FPS's, then that indie-platformer is more likely to grab your attention. Personally, I like guys like Mark Kermode, who can say "this movie was complete and utter nonsense and I had a great time" or "this was a really smart movie, but it just didn't work".
- CharlesW 5y ago> People today confuse reviews with criticism. The two are not the same. They are if you're talking about journalistic film criticism (vs. academic film criticism): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Film_criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Film_criticism > Personally, I like guys like Mark Kermode, who can say "this movie was complete and utter nonsense and I had a great time" or "this was a really smart movie, but it just didn't work". I think you're implying that Mark isn't a film critic, but that's what he calls himself (his bio: https://www.markkermode.co.uk/ https://www.markkermode.co.uk/). Also, movie critics recommend "bad" movies (https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/speed-2-cruise-control-1997 https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/speed-2-cruise-control-19...) and dump on "beloved" movies (https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/the-usual-suspects-1995 https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/the-usual-suspects-1995) all the time.
- magicroot75 5y agoI find it infuriating that the article states that low budget films are the most disagreed-upon genre between critics and audiences. But then doesn't show any of the data on the budget aspects.
- at_a_remove 5y agoIn the dim reaches of the past, I did film reviews (even compensated) for a 'zine. I quickly learned that, while it is certainly fun to savage a bad film, or to plunge off into some obscurity, my (hopefully) number one priority was to equip the readers of my review with what they need to decide whether or not they want to watch a movie. Just as a crude example, Joe Bob Briggs frequently reviews drive-in cinema, and at the start of a film review he will tally up breasts, decapitations, "fuzzy wangdoodles," and the odd types of martial arts you might see in a grindhouse flick (should someone be killed with a toaster, this is toaster-fu), and so these can serve as kind of metrics for drive-in movies. If your audience is a horror crowd, you might talk about practical f/x versus CGI, jump scares, black cats hurled into the screen, cheap tricks like loud scores, and "Did the movie scare me?" Later, though, you can get into the "critical" business, as sort of a past the fold realm where spoilers rule. You might even -- and here those with fond memories of Dead Poet's Society might flinch -- what the director wanted to accomplish and just how close he or she came to doing that. You can nerd out as much as you like, but ... not until you have done the job of equipping your audience with a way to make decisions. This naturally is the point where subjectivity rears its head. You have two defenses against this. The first is your basic film summary, the TV guide version. One or two sentences describing the setup, drop the names of one or two relevant actors, year of production, a genre (likely split down the middle), and the dangerous assignment of stars. The second defense is more subtle, and requires that your readers understand you as a reviewer, which is to say "wear your biases on your sleeve." As an example, read Ebert's review of Leon: The Professional, and then pause for a bit and ask yourself how Ebert might react to Chloe Moretz's character in Kiss-Ass before actually reading said review. If you knew ahead of time that he would find that concept pretty objectionable, well, then Ebert has done his job, he let you know what he cannot be objective about. Here, it is about developing that relationship of trust between the reviewer and the reader. After this, you can talk about the progression of the careers of the director, how this screenplay probably lifted elements of something else, how a given actor is up and coming, and the suitability of the selected aspect ratios. You can get pretty deep in the weeds with that. The job itself is as easy or as hard as you wish to make it. If your concern is only the "messaging" of the movie for whatever your political interests are, it is a breeze. Similarly, if you just want to trash a film -- and the joys of MST3King something which has wasted your time are not to be underestimated -- your effort comes largely in crafting whatever jokes you might make at the film's expense. If, however, you want your readers to feel like they can read at least the spoiler-free portion of your review and trust that you have given them enough information to decide whether or not they want to spend their time and money on that movie, well ... it is a bit harder.
- LeicaLatte 5y agoIf the critic isn't helping the film goer discover the next movie they are going to watch, why not.
- MiddleEndian 5y agoMy favorite movie review system was Netflix's 5 star system for DVDs. It quickly found out what people who were similar to me liked, and gave me pretty accurate guesses for how I'd rate movies.
- langsoul-com 5y ago
- fold3 5y agoCritics from art house kind of skew the data because the audience of art house movies may be little in numbers but they are more engaged and would probably buy more press, read more stuff about cinema, etc so there is more paper made for them. Meanwhile, the audience that watch more mainstream movies will be less engaged with the cinema's literature. They would probably be happy with just an ad or a trailer. Because they have different expectations about what is a movie. That is why there is less incentive to write critics for that audience. Hence the disparity in the data.
- dtx1 5y agoWe can pretty much pinpoint the movie where critics lost it: Black Panther. They loved it because it was catering to the woke crowd and it was hyped as the best movie ever when in reality it was a mediocre meandering mess with CGI below the first sony spiderman movies and a storyline so filled with borderline racist cliches that i was genuinely suprised to find it was written by a black director and not the KKK. I mean for gods sake they decide their government by a ritual fight? And one of the tribes is literally introduced by making ape noises? [1] And the villain? Suspiciously looks and talks A LOT like Malcolm X [2][3]. Somehow that racist caricature of a movie became the woke version of Iron Man and Critics ate it up. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=frHiTbjW4AE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=frHiTbjW4AE [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PyY_tjhFNBg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PyY_tjhFNBg [3] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malcolm_X#/media/Datei:Malcolm-x.jpg https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malcolm_X#/media/Datei:Malcolm...
- ComradePhil 5y agoThe problem is worse than that. Platforms like Netflix have removed user reviews. Even Imdb removes ratings when it doesn't please their friends. There is less and less ways to find out what other people like you think about the produced content anymore. This is of course easily solved by removing movie is watching as a thing, which has already been happening for a long time.
- unraveller 5y agoHard to trust chunks of self-reported data like this. Many audience reviewers on the whole tend to give out a perfect spread from 8/10s to 5/10 over the year like they have a quota to maintain along with their positive persona.
- dschuetz 5y agoTL;DR - The article says at the end, sort of, we don't know why, but probably yes.
- goto11 5y agoThe people rating movies on IMDB are not average audience members though. They are movie geeks and enthusiasts. But compared to professional critics, there is a significant difference because they still pre-select moves to watch based what they think they will enjoy. A movie enthusiast might have seen all science-fiction movies in existence but never a french new-wave movie. The professional critic on the other hand will watch a broader range of different movies, and probably a lot more older movies. Younger people goes a lot more to the movies, so the average critic will probably be notably older than then average movie audience member. Critics tend to be negative towards remakes because "this is unnecessary, the original was better". But most in the audience haven't seen the original so it doesn't matter to them. Critics tend to hate formulaic and derivative movies, but for the audience it is not that bad, they haven't seen the formula enough time to get bored by it. Fans loved The Force Awakens because it was exactly the same formula as the original Star Wars. Critics were less enthusiastic. Critics tend to value originality more than the average audience. Hollywood have always been formulaic and rehashed old ideas, but they have still been able to make great movies. But the current movies relies on franchises to a larger extent, and the franchises put hard constraints on the amount of originality and character development which can be allowed.
- bin_bash 5y ago> Fans loved The Force Awakens because it was exactly the same formula as the original Star Wars. Critics were less enthusiastic. The Force Awakens has IMDB of 7.9 but RT is 93%. Audience scores are lower than critic scores.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dagw 5y agoIMDB and RT scores cannot really be compared since they're measuring two fundamentally different things. Movie that everybody gave a 7/10 would have an RT score of 100% and an IMDB score of 7.0. Also RT scores are mostly based on reviews written shortly after the release of a movie, while IMDB scores keeps getting updated over time. For movies that come out with a burst of enthusiasm and then lose their luster on repeat viewings and closer analysis, IMDB score tend to drift downwards with time.
- shmde 5y agoPeople who usually go to imdb for ratings should check out letterboxd too. The crowd is usually obnoxious, woke, hipsters, who write memes as reviews. But the lists they make are usually of high quality and the number ratings quite appropriate. I watched a lot of not so popular movies which was recommended and it was actually good. The interface is 100x better than imdb's crappy ad pested site. Movies on Imdb gets review bombed frequently. So i have completely switched to letterboxd for seeing reviews and deciding what to watch. Tldr: Ditched imdb in favour of letterboxd. Great user interface, obnoxious users, great user made movie lists.
- Gareth321 5y agoYes, absolutely. From Rotten: Mulan - Critics: 73 - Audience: 47 The Last Jedi - Critics: 91 - Audience: 42 Captain Marvel - Critics: 79 - Audience: 45 It's clear that audiences - and you can read this as "people who like movies and are willing to leave a review" - and critics are miles apart. This prompts the common retort: "so what?" I continue to argue that the purpose of movie critics, for many decades, has been to tell the broad audience if they will like the movie. That's it. It has not been to, for example, critically deconstruct the abstract themes of power dynamics in inequitable social system. This kind of analysis appeals to a small minority of viewers. It has its place, but it should not be the majority of critics using this kind of lens, which it is. This leads us to today, where critic reviews are functionally useless for the broad audience. Said movie minority are of course very happy with the entire critic industry catering to their needs, and they argue vociferously to keep it this way, using all kinds of condescending arguments about our lack of culture and refinement. Sometimes I just want to see cool explosions and fight scenes, and there's nothing wrong with that.
- yakubin 5y agoThe movies you listed fail in a different way. There are plenty of explosions and fight scenes in The Last Jedi and Captain Marvel. What they do share is that the main character is an underdeveloped Mary Sue, without character flaws, without weaknesses they must overcome. They're just made awesome from the start. It probably stems from the inability of current Hollywood to portray female characters as having any weaknesses at all, that would be heresy. The result is that it's hard to empathize with and care about the main character. They don't have any dimensionality. Of the ones you listed I watched The Last Jedi and Captain Marvel. I know what I wrote is also true for Mulan thanks to friends who watched it and the Critical Drinker. He has a couple good films on YouTube actually demonstrating this aspect of modern films: - Mulan: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kIH-eFqBLP4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kIH-eFqBLP4> - Star Wars: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GSj6wEm4zZY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GSj6wEm4zZY> - Captain Marvel: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WKHEjpFF6J0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WKHEjpFF6J0>
- noisy_boy 5y ago
- thenoblesunfish 5y agoAre food critics losing touch with people who eat in restaurants? The fundamental problem is that someone who would become a critic usually has some bias for "interesting", relative to the consumer.
- kleiba 5y agoAre critics even in sync with each other?
- Markoff 5y agoI follow simple rule - don't watch anything under 7/10 on IMDb (with less than 500-1K votes) - to save my time and then I still choose mostly movies I like. This obviously doesn't work for Indian movies where users patriotically rate even crap movies way higher and have tons of votes because of size of Indian population, never seen such problem with movies from any other country (consistently I have to say, if I choose Iranian movie with good rating it's almost guaranteed it's not overrated, same can't be said about other countries, maybe Scandinavian movies to some extent are usually not very overrated unlike IN/US/KO production, Japanese have very few votes so it's hit or miss if you rely on lower number of votes). After watching thousands of movies in recent decades I came to conclusion 7/10 it's sweetspot dividing mediocrity from decent movies on IMDb, though it doesn't mean you won't find bad movies rated higher than 7, but it's extremely unlikely to find good movie underrated under 7 from few exemptions I ocassionally try, if the movie looks really interesting.
- glomph 5y agoI am not sure it is very insightful trying to read long term trends here as neither data sets is 'raw'. metacritic adjust the way they interpret reviews and imdb do a number of things to normalise scores over time.
- WelcomeShorty 5y agoI know from first had experience why that difference is, at least in the realm of classical music reviews. The critics are professionals, the audience is not. The observations of critics are based on years of experience and written for a large audience with their real name associated with the piece. The audience can (nowadays) vent their options too. Mainly anonymous and for the better part describing their personal feelings about the experience. Not saying the one is more useful than the other, just that the origins and intentions are completely different. I like the fact I can easily access both, and sometimes even compare the two (Rotten Tomatoes for example). But I do think the two scorings addressing two different issues.
- Traster 5y agoI think it's pretty pointless to have a discussion about this unless you first have a discussion about what Film critics are doing. What they're doing, most often, is not giving a rating out of 10. They're generally looking at a film and evaluating a huge number of things - do the individual parts of the film work, the cinematography, the script, the pacing, the acting, the set design etc. There are lots of mechanical things they're judging. They're also judging the film in the context of other films. What is the message of this film - what is it adding to the genre, what is it trying to say and does it succeed in getting across that message. Does it even have a message? What does it do compared to other films in the genre? The Metascore takes all those different features and goes BANG "1-10". What are IMDB scores noting? Did I like this Movie rating 1-10. Note how those two things are fundamentally different (and one of them is a highly questionable metric anyway). I think the relevant question here is what is the expected correlation between those two metrics. I'd guess it should be positive - well made movies should generally be more enjoyable than badly made movies. But is it 1? Hell no, you can make a great movie that only a niche audience will enjoy. So when we say "The correlation of these two metrics have moved from 0.75 to 0.65" I'm not sure what that even means.