31 ms·
Why the past 10 years of American life have been uniquely stupid
- jdrc 5y ago> Social media has weakened all three it isn't just social media, it s also travel and immigration
- subliminalpanda 5y agohttps://archive.ph/zTzYh https://archive.ph/zTzYh
- pwdisswordfish9 5y agoFor some reason archive.ph does not load for me today.
- the_optimist 5y agoBecause we’ve massively overinvested as a society in trivial meta navel-gazing like The Atlantic, and massive underinvested in technically knowledgeable conversation, teaching, and execution.
- quantified 5y agoThat’s actually a big part of the article’s thesis. Were you intending to snark that aptly?
- scotuswroteus 5y agoThat epic headline deserves a better article beneath it.
- mathlover2 5y agoThis is the dumbest thing I have seen come from Jonathan Haidt. If social media is this powerful a destabilizer of societies, I wonder how Haidt explains first world countries like Germany, Canada, and most of the rest of the planet that have social media but haven't fallen into the same sort of divisiveness the US has.
- echlebek 5y agoCanada isn't immune from this, just look at these moronic displays. https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/22926134/canada-trucker-freedom-convoy-protest-ottawa https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/22926134/canada-truc... This idiocy was all organized on social media. The convoys are overwhelmingly unpopular among larger Canadian society, but social media allowed them to organize in an echo chamber. No comment on Germany, but I would be betting on things being similar there, not different. My personal theory is that before social media, a lot of the people involved in this would have been bullied or shamed into not doing this by their peer group. But social media lets you set your peer group without geographical restrictions.
- mathlover2 5y agoIt isn't immune, but it certainly hasn't gotten to the point it has in the US. We had a failed insurrection two years ago that killed 5 people. The truck convoy was a bunch of morons thinking they could get their way by going to Ottawa and being absolutely obnoxious --- and ultimately failing because no one wanted to put up with their shit. Social media is a factor. It's not the main factor, and Haidt's weird focus on it rather than deeply entrenched and growing economic disparities, lack of education in the US, the rise of the religious right, and other factors is in my view kinda silly.
- mardifoufs 5y agoCanada literally had to suspend the charter and due process by enacting the emergency measures act, which is unprecedented amongst western countries. Why would the government do that if no one supported them anyways? Your insurrection did not kill 5 people by the way. I get that there's a weird urge to make that event some sort of insanely important historical moment but it doesn't mean you have to make up dead people. Ironically, from a neutral outsider view, what happened on the 6th of January can also be described as "a bunch of morons thinking they could get their way and being absolutely obnoxious". It doesn't look that way when you are knees deep in american partisan culture wars, but Americans have a tendency to think that anything that happens in the US is exceptional and unique.
- rayiner 5y agoHaidt makes an excellent observation about the mid-20th century unity being an aberration due to the technology of the time: > Gurri is no fan of elites or of centralized authority, but he notes a constructive feature of the pre-digital era: a single “mass audience,” all consuming the same content, as if they were all looking into the same gigantic mirror at the reflection of their own society. Something I think we overlook is that America was more fractious prior to the mid-20th century, but the stakes were lower because our institutions were more distributed and more local. The federal government had a vastly smaller scope back then, but so did nationwide and multinational corporations. Differences in world view are less significant when the bureaucrats and executives with power over your life live nearby instead of in another city and state. Our current structure, with a homogenous federal government and nationwide corporations arose against the backdrop of that unity. What I see missing from Haidt's analysis is increased federalism and localism as a solution. Aside from maybe California, our individual states remain vastly less fractious than the nation as a whole. Here in Maryland, for example, our Republican governor has an approval rating over 70% in both rural and urban areas. That's not because the state doesn't have ideological diversity--a third of the state voted for Trump. But the extremes are compressed compared to the nation as a whole--Baltimore isn't San Francisco but neither is Carroll County rural Alabama. Not only that, it's hard to get folks in Carroll County worked up about Baltimore they way they get worked up about San Francisco, and vice versa.
- roenxi 5y agoThis might be a weird outcome of the inability of large groups to process nuance. Groups seem to struggle with the idea that things can be done one way in one place and another way in another place - and struggle in a way that individuals seem not to. Groups - even small government types, weirdly - seem to fall into a trap whenever something goes wrong. The answer to a challenge is "centralise power, then do things my way". Never mind that power is difficult to coerce, rarely does things your way and any mistakes made are standardised and amplified accross an entire country. I recall in the early days of the COVID crisis where the US banned working COVID tests (I forget if it was the CDC or some other government body) in favour of their own faulty one, which totally scuppered any chance of controlling the disease. Foreseeable outcome of the strategy. But despite that sort of thing being easy to pick, groups don't argue for parallelism in an emergency.
- theandrewbailey 5y ago> Congress should update the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act, which unwisely set the age of so-called internet adulthood (the age at which companies can collect personal information from children without parental consent) at 13 back in 1998, while making little provision for effective enforcement. The age should be raised to at least 16, and companies should be held responsible for enforcing it. That won't change anything if parents keep buying smartphones for their 10 year olds.
- ngngngng 5y agoSo prosecute a few of them
- bobobob420 5y agoThis journalist really wrote an entire article about facebook. Why is an essay needed to descibe obvious behaviour that everyone sees and can intuitely understand with their eyes. "In the 20th century, America built the most capable knowledge-producing institutions in human history. In the past decade, they got stupider en masse." ???? People didn't get stupider in the last decade. There is access to more information and education then ever has been. We are slowing coming towards ultimate prosperity. Just look at the response to the Russia-Ukraine war. With technology education has slowly reached every human and everyone is aware of corruption and how war is merely a tool used by the powerful that only results in the rest of society harmed. Look at the reactions to things like abortion or taking rights away from people. There is so much progression yet the author lets his jaded view of Mr.Zuck's actions and his own obsession with social media to recreate this misguided world view. A view where access to political information that doesn't fit his point a view is a world where humans have become stupider.
- bobobob420 5y ago"The stupidity on the right is most visible in the many conspiracy theories spreading across right-wing media and now into Congress. “Pizzagate,” QAnon, the belief that vaccines contain microchips, the conviction that Donald Trump won reelection—it’s hard to imagine any of these ideas or belief systems reaching the levels that they have without Facebook and Twitter." I feel sad for this author. Still clinging on to right vs left. Refusing to understand that half of the country voted for the candidate he opposes. Yet he can not make the simple intellectual jump to understand the other side? You really cannot sit in the shoes of Americans who vote differently to you and understand why they feel this way, what their reality is, what their experiences are, what they have been taught? This intolerableness stems from the author's high horse he sits on. This article is merely a reflection of his own lack of intellegence.
- redmen 5y agoYou sound so angry here. What are your thoughts on Ray Dalio, polarization? My thought is that this is a force of nature the USA is up against. Even in nature before humans, things polarize. There is a balance between the strong and the weak force. Between cooperation and competition. It's when these balances get thrown off we move towards another.
- russellbeattie 5y agoThis article is 100% wrong. Russia's misinformation campaign against the U.S. is 100% the cause of our current national discord. Our entire culture has been maliciously and actively poisoned by a proven state sponsored attack on the U.S. and Western Europe. Everything in the past decade needs to be re-evaluated and filtered through the lens of Russian disinformation. Day in and day out, for over 10 years, the Russian government has been posting millions and millions of divisive and destabilizing messages online, amplifying the most controversial topics and creating true distrust and hatred among fellow Americans. Their efforts happened to occur along with the unprecedented rise of smart phones, which enabled this campaign conceived during the Obama administration, to have success beyond Russia's wildest dreams. Additionally, there have been thousands of spies sent to the U.S. in order to infiltrate Congressional and Presidential offices, military personnel and business leaders. How many Russian spies have you heard of? Last night I watched PBS Frontline where I learned of yet another one: the former CEO of Overstock's girlfriend was revealed to be a spy by the FBI (Maria Butina). He was the guy funding and pushing for recount efforts like in Arizona. I remember reading about her, but didn't realize the connection with "stop the steal". We need to respond. Aggressively and radically. We need to pardon the Jan 6th insurrectionists (I'm a liberal Democrat, mind you) and start a national campaign of de-russification. (As someone named Russ, I don't state that lightly. Haha. Sorry dumb joke.) The reactions to what I'm saying will be predictable: 1) I'm oversimplifying or exaggerating. I'm not. This is all fact. 2) I'm a liberal Democrat and I'm somehow trying to target Republicans because I hate freedom. I'm not spreading a narrative. I'm trying desperately to understand why articles like this from the Atlantic keep trying to explain the state of the country, when we already know the answer. When is the majority of the country going to realize we've been played and react appropriately??
- mathlover2 5y agoWait, why pardon the Jan 6th people? Just because one's been mislead by misinformation to believe something false doesn't mean that they are blameless for flagrantly breaking the law in response.
- smackeyacky 5y ago
- RGamma 5y agoFair summary of America's disheartening descent into structural idiocy. "Glad" I can see it with the clarity of an outsider, but then again... these things tend to cross the big pond sooner or later at least somewhat, as evidenced by right-wing flareups here in Europe. Hope we will be able to look back on this with the relief of having overcome a bad dream. Then again, there won't be long until that other crisis hits... and that one's not just happening in the head.
- egberts1 5y agoMeanwhile, red/blue partisanship has declined and more independent (non-partisan) voters emerge. The article is blowing smokes up where the sun doesn’t shine. Meanwhile, http://www.stevenwwebster.com/negative-partisanship-rabid.pdf http://www.stevenwwebster.com/negative-partisanship-rabid.pd...
- oh_sigh 5y agoI don't think it is safe to say that more independents means less partisanship. If people are going independent because they see themselves as somewhere between Rs and Ds, then sure. But if they go independent because they think the Rs are not right enough, or the Ds are not left enough, then that is only an example of magnifying partisanship.
- IIAOPSW 5y agoI view the "independent" label to actually just mean "my party isn't part of my identity." Most "independents" consistently vote for one party, they just aren't married to it in principle.
- egberts1 5y agoor it could be that political parties needs to reform themselves to accommodate the general public (and not the paying corporate bigwigs?)
- mymythisisthis 5y ago40 years of austerity in the west. Life span actually decreasing. Desperate people act out.
- inter_netuser 5y agoThe west hasn’t seen proper austerity yet, just barely warming up. Maybe soon.
- DoingIsLearning 5y ago> The west hasn’t seen proper austerity yet, just barely warming up. European Troika (EC+ECB+IMF) debt induced Austerity literally _caused_ deaths in the heart of Europe. [0] This pretty much seems like 'proper' austerity unless you feel that we need perestroika living conditions for austerity to be real. [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/francescoppola/2018/08/31/the-terrible-human-cost-of-greeces-bailouts/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/francescoppola/2018/08/31/the-t...
- mise_en_place 5y agoThe austerity will come when yields spike to 10%.
- inter_netuser 5y agoAll sorts of government policies induce deaths: leaded gasoline, lax pharmaceutical safety, etc. Maybe we should be more frank? Debt is an abomination and is evil.
- VictorPath 5y agoAlso with productivity gains, the average inflation-adjusted hourly wage of half a century ago is the same as it was in 2018, and it has popped slightly up and down since the . All gains have been sucked up by the heirs, the aristocracy.
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y ago
- 1121redblackgo 5y agoThis thread is the prototypical example of what Haidt is talking about. I have no interest in taking part in this comments section other than to make this observation.
- tharne 5y ago> This thread is the prototypical example of what Haidt is talking about. I have no interest in taking part in this comments section other than to make this observation. One could make the exact same claim about your snarky comment right here. If you actually had no interest in taking part in the discussion, you wouldn't have taken part, but here you are. One of us.
- dominotw 5y agoyou mean comments like yours that break the site guidelines?
- xkbarkar 5y agoWell HN is part of the problem isnt it? This platform may be one of few that allows difference of opinions in the threads but it it still very much just a subset of reddit users. With the same tendency to agree with anything progressive and attack all other points of view. Post covid era societal destruction, aka actually starting to face the devastating consequences of the extreme C19 responses, has softened a whole lot of progressives around me at least. And its easy to tell from the dominishing support of extremeist progressive commentary in HN for the past 6 months or so. That being said I adore HN. Fun random articles. Comments sections seem to leak into reddit territory but maybe that will resolve itself. HN is not ad much fun for those seeking outrage as reddit. I liked the article. He is progressive but at least he had the guts to timidly criticize his own tribe for the current state of the political divise. Good step in the right direction.
- sweetbitter 5y ago> Banks and other industries have “know your customer” rules so that they can’t do business with anonymous clients laundering money from criminal enterprises. Large social-media platforms should be required to do the same. That does not mean users would have to post under their real names; they could still use a pseudonym. It just means that before a platform spreads your words to millions of people, it has an obligation to verify (perhaps through a third party or nonprofit) that you are a real human being, in a particular country, and are old enough to be using the platform. This one change would wipe out most of the hundreds of millions of bots and fake accounts that currently pollute the major platforms. It would also likely reduce the frequency of death threats, rape threats, racist nastiness, and trolling more generally. Research shows that antisocial behavior becomes more common online when people feel that their identity is unknown and untraceable. Yet anonymity/pseudonymity is incredibly valuable- it is easier to change your mind and be open to new ideas, you can be more honest and direct, and less fearful of bad actors. The author of this post clearly thinks the entire net to be composed of nothing but Facebook/Twitter/Instagram and the like, but the definition of "social media" can be extended to any 1 or more machines which can send and receive IP datagrams between each other. The internet was doing just fine when people owned more of their communications, running servers or at least using infrastructure run by fellow human beings, rather than consuming content from a handful of global feeds susceptible to these social Sybil attacks. Just outlaw or intensely regulate these massive, centralized/proprietary social media algorithms so that we can return to what was before, all while retaining the gift of anonymity.
- throwntoday 5y agoKnowing what these companies do with any bit of data they can extract from you is plenty reason to object to KYC for all rules. If anonymity is the sacrifice, I just won't partake in the discussion. It might reduce vitriol in discourse, but will do far more to quell debate when the cost is your career, relationships, etc.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoI’ve implemented parts of KYC systems. It’s one component of what is essentially an outsourced surveillance mechanism. It is probably going to abused some day. People want the government to have that power and to start inspecting and regulating speech so we can be more like China and we can fix the crisis of anonymous dissent and wrongthink? Oh well. I suppose it’s not really surprising.
- tharne 5y agoI'd say the first 10 years of the 21st century were a hell of a lot stupider. We blew a budget surplus on tax cuts for the wealthy. We started two wars that lasted the better part of 20 years, one of which was waged against a country that had nothing whatsoever to do with 9/11. Oh, and we didn't win either of them. We completely ignored the rise of China and any threat it posed, assuming all the while they'd become good capitalists and fall in love with Democracy. Bankers tanked our economy so we bailed out them (bipartisan no less!), but not the average Americans they screwed. We turned our intelligence agencies against our own people. Heck, compared to the first 10 years of the 21st century, the previous 10 years have been a relative period of enlightenment. In fact most of the problems over the last 10 years stem from the stupendously dumb decisions we made from 2000 to 2009.
- throwntoday 5y ago>We completely ignored the rise of China and any threat it posed Buddy we financed that shit
- Apocryphon 5y agoYou're not wrong. If anything, much of the most glaring political and cultural fiascos of the past decade were just exaggerated echoes of the previous decade.
- whatshisface 5y agoMany of the things you list were not fully and uncontroversially understood to be bad decisions until the end of the 2010s, so by analogy let's wait and see what we're saying in 2030 before we declare the 2010s to be an improvement over the 2000s.
- spupe 5y agoThat's not an appropriate comparison. You are talking about bad policies and political decisions, while Haidt is focusing on internal division and institutional erosion. The issue here is whether you will be free to see and declare the next war as a mistake, or whether the public space and political arena will be dominated by authoritarianism, fueled by the processes described in the article.
- drewcoo 5y ago> red America and blue America are becoming like two different countries claiming the same territory What about the rest of us? Most of us are not partisans fighting a distracting culture war. First, let's set social media aside and look at traditional media - TV, papers, radio, et al. Most Americans are completely unserved by traditional media. Because it's ad-funded, ads want attention, nothing gets attention like outrage, and it's easy to outrage the partisans. Given that, the only place we can find news (beyond sports and weather) that is not partisan bear-baiting is in emerging social media. Social media is a threat to traditional media. Thus we have traditional media (like this article) trying to scapegoat social media, trying to finger social media for the hyper-partisan content-free hellscape that traditional media has become.
- zozbot234 5y agoThe "rest of us" are centrist moderate neoliberals. Hating them all is perhaps the one thing Red and Blue can agree on. Also, Big Social Media is even more ad-funded than traditional media, so your comment applies all the more to it. Do the math.
- petermcneeley 5y agoWhy do these people use the word democracy to propose changes that are oligarchy?
- worik 5y agoPeople do not understand what democracy is. A lot of people confuse democracy and elections. Voting can be used as a democratic mechanism, but it can also be an instrument of oppression.
- throwaway787544 5y ago
- bihla 5y agoJonathan Haidt is not a random guy. I don't think you're being fair to the article or to this forum.
- throwaway787544 5y ago
- mung 5y agoSomewhat amusing that the article starts off using a parable from the bible. Maybe it's more amusing to someone outside the the US.
- rossdavidh 5y agoIf it was a parable from Greek mythology, would it be less amusing? I don't think you need to be Christian (I am not) to find it an apt metaphor.
- mung 5y agoBut it's not from Greek mythology is it? It's always Christian mythology that is used in these sort of openers. It's almost always the default goto here. What lessons can we draw from the good book today?
- JetAlone 5y ago>What lessons can we draw from the good book today? The lesson we fail to draw every single time is a masterclass in humility.
- rektide 5y agoRandom scribbling here, but, i feel like America has been the idiots wearing the dunce cap ongoingly for a long time. But we're finally seeing some real world events & consequences across the world that mirror our internal battle of values, seeing what heavily regressed shelted "anti-political" naivety & other declared antipathys & worse maledictions happening on the world stage look like, far & wide. It feels like there's a lot more examples of very ethnocentric, me & us thinking playing out on the world stage. Personally I find it scary but I think this system shock has a distinct potential to help the world reflect, to decide on stronger more pan-human values, in the face of these upswelling raging distinctionalisms. In some ways I do worry, that isolationist & nationalistic programmes may see some sucess. But by & large, I feel that there's some pretty clear moral groundings staking it out, have been for a while, and seeing a lot more cases on the world stage, seeing more consequneces of what exclusivist policymaking really looks like is a painful painful painful lesson, but one that will illuminate & recalibrate us all, will help remind us & scare us our of some of our pervasive & monstrous behaviors. I have some hope we can keep learning & watching, that the parallax view of other countries undergoing the sick battle for it's soul America has suffered & whether that & the law/system is for a very few or for a general public benefit-- I have hope.it carries the world towards caring & concerns. Tbings seem to decidedly be getting harder & worse. I feel like huddling closer has been a natural response, but ultimately has been tinged with cruelty & defeatism, and that we can start to recognize more how weak & scared & isolated responses- when we see them happening elsewhere- look bad, and dont help. I hope we can see the morality & logic of the situation better, seeing more of the world undergoe it's own self-crisis, it's anti-belief in structure & governance & trying, and find remewed vigor to work collectively for better. Just a hope, a small little one, but it feels so new to me to see this struggle playing out more widely.
- rektide 5y ago> We see it in cultural evolution too, as Robert Wright explained in his 1999 book, Nonzero: The Logic of Human Destiny. Wright showed that history involves a series of transitions, driven by rising population density plus new technologies (writing, roads, the printing press) that created new possibilities for mutually beneficial trade and learning. Zero-sum conflicts—such as the wars of religion that arose as the printing press spread heretical ideas across Europe—were better thought of as temporary setbacks, and sometimes even integral to progress. 100% one of my favorite books to have run into as a youth, a great great materialist philosphy book. Feels like a very weirdly reductionist take thought, making mock rather than taking seriously what cooperation enabled. There's scant recognition of what zero sum systems are, of how cooperation moves things out of stagnant points into better. Such a loved text & tbis article starts off paying some respect, but ultimately missing the point so so bad, only starting to re-entertain human possibility.
- rossdavidh 5y agoWhile I am a big fan of Jonathan Haidt, and have read several of his books, I can't help but feel that this is written from a point of view that is entirely too impressed with (if also afraid of) technology. Peter Turchin predicted escalating levels of polarization in the US, reaching a peak around 2020, without any need to look at social media. The level of political polarization now, while high, is less than the late 1850's. I also think he's more impressed with AI-generated content than is warranted; unpaid zealots can crank the stuff out in more than enough quantity. Turchin blames elite overproduction; it seems a much more fundamental issue than social media. Haidt even provides evidence for that here: "These two extreme groups are similar in surprising ways. They are the whitest and richest of the seven groups, which suggests that America is being torn apart by a battle between two subsets of the elite who are not representative of the broader society." Now, don't get me wrong, I am no fan of FB or Twitter, but I don't think Haidt's take on this is accurate. The stupidity of current discourse uses social media, of course, because that's the dominant media, but I don't believe they caused it.
- zeruch 5y ago"The stupidity of current discourse uses social media, of course, because that's the dominant media, but I don't believe they caused it. " And certainly based on past statements he's made, I took that the tech augmented the issue, but was not being posed as the root cause. Like you I think Turchin is on to something, but Haidt here is also largely pointing out a symptom that has immense influence in the current day. To that, I'm not sure if he is as much "afraid/impressed with tech" as much as pointing the human inability to think remotely (or even care most of the time) about laws of unintended consequences, let alone how to address them when they inevitably arise.
- nr2x 5y agoFacebook is mentioned 19 times, Fox News once, and talk radio zero. This is a very techno deterministic argument that utterly fails to acknowledge the main source of misinformation and division is boring old tech like cable news and radio. The main role Facebook serves is to make Fox and radio personalities more accessible.
- steve76 5y ago[dead]
- dominotw 5y agoweren't previous 10 yrs the stupidest to massacre millions of people in the middle east based on some phony and stupid wmd claims.
- 1270018080 5y agoThe color of their skin and religion are incorrect though, it doesn't matter.
- natsup123490 5y agoI have to speculate that the reason why "social media is indeed corrosive to trust in governments, news media, and people and institutions in general" is oftentimes because it highlights their apparent failings (biases, lies, etc). That is, the problem is not primarily one of people failing to trust in trustworthy institutions, but due to a hyper-focus (retweeting) on the failings of those institutions. As we communicate more, we find we don't agree as much as we thought we did, and that is divisive. Social media allows us to highlight and amplify the information about our disagreements.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DoingIsLearning 5y ago> Social media allows us to highlight and amplify the information about our disagreements. In theory. In practice most people are too busy living their lifes and going through their struggles to voice anything. Leaving these platforms to be flooded by a vocal minority or worse, actors with an agenda. This in turn provides a warped vision of reality to the 99% of non contributing 'listeners'.
- rmbyrro 5y agoIsn't that a description of traditional media? Doesn't seem this is a fundamental change that caused the current divide. It's something deeper.
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoTraditional media would not be flooded with extreme right or extreme left, or conspiracy theories without any evidence backing. The current Turner/Murdoch media in the US is definitely not my understanding of 'traditional' journalism of the likes of Associated Press, Agence France-Presse, Reuters.
- Miner49er 5y ago
- pyuser583 5y agoWhere it really feels like it started was the Democratic exuberance when they got the Presidency + House + 60 senate seats + complete collapse of neo-conservativism in 2009. Remember “The Death of American Conservativism.” There was a line in there about how it was hard to imagine Republicans using obscure parliamentary tricks to prevent popular legislation from passing.
- lkrubner 5y agoA contrarian take focuses on the increasing specialization of knowledge and the increasingly fine-grained international division of labor, which has had increasing impact on a government that fails to keep up. A rough history of that: In the 1700s the Western democracies established nominally omnicompetant, unspecialized legislatures. In the last 1800s, given the increasing specialization of knowledge, the first committees are established. At first this process is ad-hoc, one-off, disorganized, and often viewed as temporary. By the early 1900s it is clear that the system of highly specialized committees are the only way for the legislatures to keep up with the rapidly growing complexity of society. By the 1930s, in the USA, there is the growing sense that the general assembly of Congress should only act as a rubber stamp for the committees. All intelligent laws come from committees. In the rare case that a law comes from some random Congressperson, rather than a committee, their law is assuredly badly written, and full of unintended consequences. All good laws from committees, without exception. In 1946 the committee system reaches the peak of its prestige and intellectual coherence with the Congressional Reorganization Act: https://history.house.gov/Historical-Highlights/1901-1950/The-Legislative-Reorganization-Act-of-1946/ https://history.house.gov/Historical-Highlights/1901-1950/Th... If you follow the trend line, from 1850 to 1950, and then you project that trend line into the future, it seems clear that somewhere around 1970 or 1980 there should have been a Constitutional amendment that shifted the power to make law from the Congress to the committees. A possible system that could have worked well is if the Congress continued to exist only to appoint people to committees, and then the committees themselves gained the power to make law. Rather than asking Congress to act as a rubber stamp, Congress would simply lose its traditional powers, which would shift to the committees. Such a change would have formalized the idea that we live in a complex and highly specialized world, very different from the world of the 1700s, and so only a system of highly specialized committees can offer good government. The failure to push forward with necessary constitutional change means that the whole system began to stagnate, and then it became vulnerable to the accusation that the government no longer worked (more and more pundits then began to suggest that the answer was less government, rather than fixing the process of governance). The committee system was still widely respected till the 1990s. It is often said that Newt Gingrich, when he gained power in 1994, began an attack on the committee system. His goal wasn't great government, so it served his purpose to undermine the whole system. There is universal agreement that the committee system is less important now than it was 30 years ago. Republicans have lead the way with a populist style of government in which laws are pushed forward from the floor of Congress, rather than from the committees. Many of these laws seem to be designed to function more as attention getting devices, rather than functioning first and foremost as instruments of governance. If you buy this line of thinking, the answer is to declare the 1700s officially over and close down the nominally omnicompetant, unspecialized legislature, and implement a system of committees, with the committees holding all of the traditional legislative functions. This would require an amendment to the Constitution, which is difficult in the USA. Any Constitution can be transformed into any other Constitution by way of amendment, and therefore, in a sense, there is only one fundamental question of Constitutions, and that is how can they be amended. Every society needs to find a balance between stability and flexibility; every society needs to adapt to change while keeping the important fundamentals solid. Therefore there must be some ideal amount of time over which Constitutional change should play out. Too fast and it might be too easy for one moment of public hysteria to sweep away everyone's civil rights, but if too difficult, then people begin to ignore the Constitution because it no longer matches people's actual needs. What is the ideal speed at which a Constitution should evolve? At the current moment, the world offers us two countries as examples of the dangers of the two extremes: Hungary and the USA. In Hungary it turned out to be too easy to amend the Constitution, while in the USA it has turned out to be too difficult to amend the Constitution. I wrote an analysis of Hungary versus the USA, which got a lot of comment when I first wrote it. For anyone interested, it is here: https://demodexio.substack.com/p/thesis-1-there-is-one-correct-way?s=w https://demodexio.substack.com/p/thesis-1-there-is-one-corre...
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"He noted that distributed networks "can protest and overthrow, but never govern."" That's exactly right. Except it seems, so far, like those who effectively control the networks by acting as intermediaries between its users, can suppress protest and protect themselves from being overthrown.
- 1270018080 5y agoIt sounds like he's saying the solution is middle of the road centrism? That's not very convincing. Centrism is what we've been trying since after the civil war (minus FDR). The government can do nothing when things are going great. But when purchasing power is down, wealth inequality is high, healthcare/education/everything is more expensive, you can't just sit on your hands and do performative politics.
- lamontcg 5y agoHe's putting the cart before the horse. The problem is the stupid bankrupt politics in the USA. Social media is just gasoline being thrown onto the fire, with the billionaire class pumping as much gas into it as they can. I think there's one throwaway paragraph in the middle of the whole article that addresses the political shift in the 90s that led us to where we are. That should have been front and center. The USA needs universal health care, child care and college (and probably UBI) meanwhile the Democratic party has shifted to the right and fully engaged in punching left as hard as it can to avoid this happening, while losing elections to the right wing (which is on a slope towards outright fascism) because they can't deliver anything which significantly moves the needle for the average american. That is why the last 10 years have been particularly stupid. And the one thing that both sides pump up is the social wars and identity politics in order to avoid talking about the economic changes that have to happen.
- spupe 5y agoFrance, Canada, Britain and many other countries in the West that have everything you listed are also showing the same signs of division, all emerging in the same timeframe described by Haidt.
- alephnan 5y ago> That is also when Google Translate became available on virtually all smartphones, so you could say that 2011 was the year that humanity rebuilt the Tower of Babel. 10 years later, Google Translate is still not dependable in real world colloquial usage ( I moved abroad ). It works for simple things, but the risk of miscommunication is way too high. I’ve learned ( been trained) to restructure my sentences in less idiomatic ways to get Google to make sense, but it’s still a dice roll . There are certain ideas that are practically unreachable. Knowing the local language grammar a bit, you rely on Google translate for bits and pieces, then compose sentences / ideas / communication yourself.
- civilized 5y agoI got into the whole outrage game for a couple years. Then I got bored of it and dropped out. Maybe a lot of other people will too. I feel like it peaked in 2017-2020 and now people are just exhausted.
- mitchbob 5y agoArchived: https://archive.ph/SGeJ7 https://archive.ph/SGeJ7
- 8bitsrule 5y agoBabel? Nah: [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henny_Penny https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henny_Penny] (Chicken Little) It looks like every human era has its anxieties. Suddenly many of us got widespread access (if we dared), not only to 'all knowledge' (such as it is) including all of human history (much previously covered-up or lost), but to what's going through everyone's minds (and ever has). Bound to blow some of them. Biblicly speaking, "The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not grasped it."
- travisgriggs 5y ago> Recent academic studies suggest that social media is indeed corrosive to trust in governments, news media, and people and institutions in general. The author uses the term social media here in this statement without much differentiation. Elsewhere though, he has differentiated “old school” social media from modern “social media.” I think he should have made that more clear here. He expressed earlier that the effects of “old school” social media were pretty benign. I would like to propose that the term social media has become varied and ambiguous enough that it loses its value when introspecting on its modern effect. I’ve personally taken to no longer use the term “social media” and instead try to use variations on “profit media”, “engagement media”, and “highly mechanized.” These better capture (for me) the essence of what most modern supposed “social” platforms are really about.
- upsidesinclude 5y ago+ That's an interesting take. I have found myself using 'social media' lately in an unsatisfying way, exactly because it fails to describe anything at this point. If anything it is synonymous with 'communication' anymore
- chmod600 5y agoEverything about this article is great except the clickbait title: New information and number (new to me, I mean), historical context, and nuanced analysis on a charged issue. I feel obligated to re-subscribe.
- jimmydeans 5y ago
- jmyeet 5y agoThere's a ton to unpack here. Some select responses: > ... but many of them have been devastating for the mental health and education of children, who desperately need to play with one another and go to school ... I see this repeated a lot and pretty much every time I see it, it is implied that teachers (and, by extension, their families) are expendable. Sure children need socialization (to varying degrees) but someone has to supervise in-school learning. Those teachers are at higher risk than the children are of complications from COVID and their families might be even higher risk. I take exception to this devaluation. This belies a dark truth of people in general: many people (if not most people) absolutely do not give a fuck about people they don't know if it even mildly inconveniences them. > Of course, the American culture war and the decline of cross-party cooperation predates social media’s arrival. Yes it does. Can you spot the trend [1]? > The ideological distance between the two parties began increasing faster in the 1990s. Fox News and the 1994 “Republican Revolution” converted the GOP into a more combative party. It goes back further than that: White evangenlical institutions were weaponzed to deliberately foment a culture war because of white supremacy and racism. Consider abortion [2]: > In 1970, a poll conducted by the Baptist Sunday School Board found that 70 percent of Southern Baptist pastors supported abortion to protect the mental or physical health of the mother, 64 percent supported abortion in cases of fetal deformity and 71 percent in cases of rape. > Three years later, a poll conducted by the Baptist Standard newsjournal found that 90 percent of Texas Baptists believed their state’s abortion laws were too restrictive. What changed? It's a deep topic but in summary, Brown v Board of Education ended racial segregation in schools. Mississippi tried to get around this with private schools for K-12 education (where the white enrollment in public schools in Holmes County dropped to zero). In 1970, Green v Kennedy prevented such academies from receiving full tax exempt status. Fears of misagenation caused Bob Jones University (under duress) to admit a token handful of (married) black students. Starting in the mid-70s, efforts were made to motivate voters around abortion, which proved successful in the 1978 midterms and probably helped Reagan defeat Carter in 1980 when Carter refused to consider a constitutional amendment banned abortion. And the rest is history. But we see this culture war continue to this day as Republicans have been incredibly successful creating wedge issues to motivate their base around trans rights, gay marriage, critical race theory and the like. [1]: https://theweek.com/speedreads/454162/rise-filibuster-maddening-chart https://theweek.com/speedreads/454162/rise-filibuster-madden... [2]: https://www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/how-southern-baptists-became-pro-life/ https://www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/how-south...
- a_square_peg 5y agoThis is an excellent article - thanks for sharing. This decline of shared common reality and social trust has been both frightening and frustrating for me.
- sangnoir 5y agoI wish the article had expanded a little more into the political aspect of the past 10 years: Occupy had a passing mention, but deserves a deeper analysis. The populist movements of Occupy Wallstreet and its more effective mirror image - the Tea Party - were a direct result of distrust of the "system" (i.e. government, politicians and corporate America) in the aftermath of the great recession where people observed large-scale foreclosures, while the government was pouring billions to bail-out corporations and, justice wasn't seen to be done regarding those who precipitated the crisis. Social media didn't help,but IMO, trust in institutions was severely eroded and a lot of people felt left behind by the unevenly-distributed "recovery", which splintered people into self-reinforcing ideological echo-chambers. The third act was the Trump presidency, and I have nothing to say which hasn't been said before about polarization in that era.
- TedShiller 5y agoPeople will look back on this period and be amazed that giving out free crack pipes was actually a thing the US government did.
- __MatrixMan__ 5y agoGiven that the government was selling crack in the 90's I don't think an observer from the future would seize on this era in particular for that sort of thing. It's just a piece of glass.
- freshhawk 5y agoThey will absolutely study the use of sound bites/memes like this one in political discussions though. The "but that's definitely untrue", "yeah, ok, but ... you know what I mean, right?" type comments build a very interesting context for these weird talking point memes.
- linuxhansl 5y agoI am reminded of various quoates throughout my life: 1. "The human mind avoids nothing as much as thinking." -- Unknown, quoted by my dad 2. "We used to agree on the facts, and than argue about what do do. Now we simple disagree on the facts" -- Friend of Mine 3. "The quickest way to release stress hormones from the brain, unfortunately, is to 'beat' up someone else." -- My therapist (1) Leads to humans always gravitating towards an explanation that reliefs them from thinking. Simple, short, populist messages are perfect for that. (2) Has us end discussions before we even get to talk about what to do. (3) Has us make feel good when we can "beat" up someone else on social media. IMHO, it is bringing these three together in social media, and more importantly doing so mostly subconsciously, that makes this so toxic. Edit: Layout
- linuxhansl 5y ago"quoates", "than", "reliefs"... Re-reading my message. My spelling foo is truly terrible.
- HigherPlain 5y agoA great article which is ruined by politicising it as a "rightwing problem". Everything the author identifies applies equally to rhetoric from the left, as anyone who has spent time on the r/politics section of Reddit or Twitter will recognize.
- rpmisms 5y agoI suspect that politicization is to avoid backlash, as we all know which side of that dichotomy holds the cancellation/ostracization power.
- TomSwirly 5y ago> Everything the author identifies applies equally to rhetoric from the lef Looking from the outside (Europe), I'm sorry, but I just don't see this at all. A big example: Republicans have repeatedly claimed for over a decade now that the Democrats run an international child sex trafficking network I am in no way a fan of Hillary Clinton, but the right has spent almost forty years systematically lying about her, claiming she's a criminal, and when the whole "Democrats rape children" thing was invented, they dropped her into that. Tell me - what claim from the left is comparable to this horrific lie? And I could go on, and on, and on. Republicans claim that the climate change is a hoax, FFS! (I live in the Netherlands, so this is personal to me.) Your claim "both sides do it" is false and empty. My guess is that you are in fact an American right-winger - is this true?
- HigherPlain 5y ago"Republicans have repeatedly claimed for over a decade now that the Democrats run an international child sex trafficking network" You're referring to Qanon type people? They are fringe extremists. Why would you group all republicans in with them? Compare to r/politics section of Reddit, which is a much more mainstream group of people. On that website there are regularly top-voted comments with thousands of "likes" saying all republicans are pedophiles/fascists/racists etc. The article correctly identifies such rhetoric as poison for the societal good. But both the left and the right have to acknowledge that it exists everywhere in the online discourse.
- DoItToMe81 5y agoSocial media companies encourage manufactured outrage by providing controversial and divisive 'extreme' content for "engagement metrics". We know this from the Facebook leaks, court cases and common sense. The solution to this suggested in this article is to give them more power over individual information by making giving your name and address to the company mandatory. No thank you. I don't think expanding one of the core parts of the problem while annihilating the capability for people in repressive countries to shield themselves is any solution at all.
- spupe 5y agoIf anything, enforcing identification would be very damaging to these companies. Their user numbers are absurdly inflated by bots and fakes, and most of their engagement is also likely not coming from human activity. The author is not proposing a solution for people in oppressive regimes - those are already restrained in their access to internet and social media -, but for America.
- ggm 5y agoAn increase in people's ability to share views on complicated matters and a decrease in nuance understanding complicated matters. Everyone has an opinion on the Supreme Court. Few people (I do not include myself in that few) truly understand it's constraints around operation. Or something as simple as the separation of powers between arms of the establishment (government, judiciary, civil service) Take a subject like faithless electors, or proposals to disregard the popular vote and appoint electors.
- archhn 5y agoThis is an age of unprecedented pludering with the greatest circus in history--facebook, video games, TV, etc.--running diversion.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThe title has a very "make America great again" vibe. When exactly and in what way was the past better? > One result is that young people educated in the post-Babel era are less likely to arrive at a coherent story of who we are as a people, and less likely to share any such story with those who attended different schools or who were educated in a different decade. A consistent set of lies told to our children while they are impressionable? I'm not sure I'm willing to mourn that without some extraordinary evidence that it's causing harm. I don't really see the connection to social media, and the decades long battle over teaching evolution suggests it's not new.
- blunte 5y agoAs Roger Waters said: They repeated every test They checked out all the data on their lists And then, the alien anthropologists Admitted they were still perplexed But on eliminating every other reason For our sad demise They logged the only explanation left This species has amused itself to death
- iostream24 5y agoI’m going to propose something much simpler: Modern life has been on a trajectory for this tribalist bubble warfare since we outgrew small village life. The car and mobility for employment put the icing on the cake. If we want social cohesion, design for it, in real life.
- bmitc 5y agoMy theory as to what's going on: raging capitalism and corporatism that is worshipped and embraced, social media, rising inequality, and declining education. We slave everything in society, including primary, secondary, and university educations to the drumbeat of capitalism. It is corporatism and capitalism that abuses the right and the evangelical towards their whims. Social media, inequality, and declining education are an amplification feedback loop to all these issues. In addition, technocratic society is also out of control.
- avidphantasm 5y ago“He described the nihilism of the many protest movements of 2011 that organized mostly online and that, like Occupy Wall Street, demanded the destruction of existing institutions without offering an alternative vision of the future or an organization that could bring it about.“ Calling Occupy nihilistic is strikes me as blinkered, and shows the neoliberal bias of the author. Occupy is where the 99% vs. 1% lens arose, which is a reasonable description of concentration of wealth and power across Western countries and especially the US. Occupy attempted to employ more empowering and less alienating peer-to-peer governance. Occupy didn’t “succeed”, probably due to both internal and external forces, but it wasn’t nihilistic.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoI also don’t like the disrespect Occupy often gets. Yes they didn’t have ready made solution but neither does Wall Street. The bailouts in 2008 and generally the rising inequality show that Wall Street is perfectly fine with making the lives of a lot of people worse as long as they can make money for themselves. To me the nihilists are the ruling class that only cares about them self and nothing else.
- game_the0ry 5y agoAgreed - media portrays OWS as broken movement with no goals and no hope of changing anything. That's neo-lib PR - corp media does not want you take OWS issues (pro-union, anti-corporate, Medicare for all, etc) seriously.
- BuyMyBitcoins 5y agoIn my home city the OWS movement denigrated into a homeless encampment with a handful of banners and sign waivers. I don’t think a neoliberal media was the culprit because from the beginning the local movement lacked any sense of cohesion or the coordination required to exert pressure on local politicians. The righteous anger burned bright for a few months then slowly faded and nothing really came of it. I distinctly remember a lack of a figurehead and a lack of specific reform they wanted to get people to support.
- giantg2 5y ago"But when citizens lose trust in elected leaders, health authorities, the courts, the police, universities, and the integrity of elections, then every decision becomes contested; every election becomes a life-and-death struggle to save the country from the other side." Perhaps the root cause of this is not misinformation but rather the increase in awareness of how corrupt and incompetent some of these systems are. I've witnessed these things myself related to political figures, police, prosecutors, the judiciary, and the organizations that are supposed to oversee them (the Bar, judicial board, internal affairs, the FBI, attorney general, etc). Rights violations are so common that nobody cares unless they resulted in bodily injury or substantial monetary loss. If nobody is standing up for or enforcing those rights, then do we actually even have them, or are they a fiction? If the oversight of the people comprising the system is ineffective, then that is what will lead to abuses and this idea that each election is a battle. It seems nobody can enforce the rulers to follow their own rules. And these rulers have consistently granted themselves more power and autonomy throughout history (really surprised they didn't bring this up).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rceDia 5y agoCannot recall anytime in modern history in which a major political party is influenced and supported by an ethereal conspiratorial group that only "exists" on-line and in the minds of its followers. A fanatical follower even showed up at the U.S. Capitol on 1/6/21 dressed in a shaman costume. Social media thrives on the concept of "followers", which sounds more like a "grooming" stage for authoritarians.
- blindmute 5y agoOverall, red side wants things to stay the same or go back, and blue side wants things to change. If the gap between them is widening, it's because blue side is trying to change things too rapidly. Red side seems to want to go back to 1950 at the earliest; it doesn't seem to me like they're increasingly backing up into 1800s or earlier. But the blue side is increasingly pushing for things that many are not ready to even consider: children transitioning into other genders, reparation-like policies, socially enforced changes to fundamentals of language. Many reds are still getting used to the last changes, like gay marriage. Society is just not set up to handle constant massive change to traditional mores. You can have one or two things change in a decade and people will adapt, but the current velocity is not sustainable.
- incomingpain 5y agohttps://www.visualcapitalist.com/charts-americas-political-divide-1994-2017/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/charts-americas-political-d... Put your finger on the median democrat line, leave it where it starts in 1994 and remember where republicans are in 1994 and 2017. There is no question the democrats moved left, republicans followed and then moved right back to where they were. The democrats than moved further and further left. >You can have one or two things change in a decade and people will adapt, but the current velocity is not sustainable. You are describing the culture wars that are over. What we reached now isn't so much this. Social factors aren't even a huge consideration. It's about UBI. It's about wealth redistribution. It's about people who ignored advice, got a liberal arts degree putting $50,000 in debt and can only pay the interest payments from their mcjob. I figure there was a period in time when this political division would turn into a civil war... but it won't. Imagine the democrats clean sweep the midterms in november. Imagine the republicans clean sweep the midterms in november. What do you think happens in either of those cases?
- howinteresting 5y agoFYI trans children are not new and minors have been transitioning in the US for the last 50 years. It's only more recently that it has been turned into a vile political issue by the right. https://www.upress.umn.edu/book-division/books/histories-of-the-transgender-child https://www.upress.umn.edu/book-division/books/histories-of-... As a transgender person who was once a child but was not aware of the possibility of transitioning back then, I would have loved the opportunity to do so.
- giantg2 5y agoI just want my own land, to do my own shit on, not bother anyone, and not be bothered by anyone. Why is this so hard? Why do we want to be controlling other's actions so greatly through the implied threat of government violence? Edit: why disagree?
- metamuas 5y agoI think a good name for this is 'discontention'. Discontent + contention. People are now dissatisfied with their view of reality being challenged by people they know and talking heads, and because of that there is major contention (in the computer science sense) over what people want the narrative to be, and what decisions they want the people in power to make. For a long time I have thought Trump being elected was the greatest psy-op of all time. Do you have any idea how much time people spent talking about him, thinking about him, etc? I mean his presidency could have slowed down progress because of that by a percentage point even if you ignore every policy decision he made or opinion he shared. Now people are even more emotional, thus more irrational, and now you are looked down on for not having a strong bias. There are people who want to centralize power with the unitary executive theory, and make the president even more powerful, because then the president can bypass any level of 'discontention' by the public or other officials. So, basically, my theory is that by creating 'discontention', with either a left or right wing policies or presidents, will always lead to more centralization of power. Most people define power as the ability to control and influence others. Personally, I define it as resource allocation.
- wallacoloo 5y agoi feel like i'm out of touch. the premise is that most Americans don't like/agree with the political aspects of their social media: to which i wonder, why don't they disengage? even in 2022, it's not hard to find people who don't talk partisan politics. it's not hard to find people who value epistemics. the web-like portions of the internet make this easy. Google "rationalist community" and the first result is LessWrong. Google "neutral political news" and you get allsides.com. moreover, find just one person associated with a single thing you value and you can connect with them, chat with or browse who they're following, and recurse connections until you've embedded yourself in an environment of people you enjoy associating with. this stuff is in easier reach than it's ever been. if you expect to consume the firehose and enjoy it, you're disillusioned: never has a single source appealed to every individual on the planet. you have to select your peers. curate your connections. if a friend repeatedly blasts you with bad political takes, cut or reduce the connection. the digital web isn't that different from the irl web in this aspect. it's your responsibility to craft connections that benefit your life. FB/Twitter/etc are tools to use in that (and far from the only ones), but you cannot abdicate your responsibility and expect good results.
- harambae 5y ago>most Americans don't like/agree with the political aspects of their social media: to which i wonder, why don't they disengage? It gets dragged in a lot of places whether you want it or not. For example, I saw a discussion recently on a real estate forum where someone stated that US demographics show the population is about to tank and so real estate prices will crash when there are too many houses for the smaller population. Someone else pointed out the prediction wasn't compensating for illegal immigration and immediately the brigade went into action accusing them of being a republican. Even on motorcycle forums with regard to Chinese-manufactured bike engines and whether you're supporting the CCP by buying one, etc. It feels like it's getting unavoidable.
- rerbrerb 5y agoOh baby clutch those pearls tight with your wringed hand. So sick of this “it’s not us, it’s them” ignorant, blind, stupid fear mongering. STFU and do something about it. Talk to people on the other team for starters.
- dymk 5y agoThat's like telling the Titanic and the iceberg to just talk it out, but nobody is at the helm. This is a problem far bigger than "Just talk to somebody with a slightly different viewpoint!". This is a problem at the root of our society. It's an existential crisis that has been getting worse for decades.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]