3 ms·
Who's building nuclear power plants now ? Renewable sources of electricity are stacked on top of non renewable ones so far > Are you proposing that replacing I
by lm28469 5y ago
Who's building nuclear power plants now ? Renewable sources of electricity are stacked on top of non renewable ones so far
> Are you proposing that replacing ICE vehicles with EVs is not an essential part of a long-term, low-carbon future?
Hm yes, a sustainable future won't be made of 3 tonnes personal steel cages transporting 1 person. There are 1.5B personal vehicles on earth right now, replacing every single one of them with the EV equivalent will just displace the problem (EVs generate half their lifetime pollution before even being driven on the street, then you have to take care about recycling, mining the raw materials, &c.)
This is just another chapter of the "don't worry we'll magically figure it out sometime in the future (_cough cough_ after I got my dividends and retire)"
- unholiness 5y agoI'm still missing a vision for a positive future which lacks EVs. Every vision of a low-carbon future requires many things to change. You're saying we should let the current slow movement on electricty generation be an excuse for not moving on EVs (despite the fact that they're an improvement regardless). You could similarly argue that the slow movement on EVs should be an excuse from not improving electricity generation (despite the fact that there are improvements regardless). Whataboutism about one vision is worthless until you have a better vision, where we can compare the practical and political tradeoffs between them.
- lm28469 5y agoSimple: no more personal cars But yeah that would require work, let's just cry about losing convenience and continue perpetuating the same cycle again, since we have no options but to commit to our clearly unsustainable model
- goatlover 5y agoHow is that going to work out politically? You think a majority of voters are gong to support banning all personal automobiles? In the US, banning personal firearms is non-starter, and car ownership is even more deeply embedded.
- JumpCrisscross 5y agoYou’re complaining about the environmental impact of reworking a few billion vehicles but blink at razing and rebuilding cities?
- afarrell 5y agoThat would not solve the problems like transporting goods from ports and warehouses to stores or transporting equipment that a plumber or drummer needs to do their job. We'll still need electric trucks and vans.
- throwaway894345 5y agoPresumably the parent has something more drastic in mind, like leveling every city and replanning it around bikes and extending public transit to every rural community. Basically treat every place like a dense urban area or force people to move into dense urban areas. At least those are the common, facile alternatives presented by the anti-car side of these debates. It's just urban chauvinism.
- afarrell 5y agoFaced with an overwhelming problem, is is tempting to seek simple solutions which would boil the ocean. Personally, I’d prioritize suboptimal solutions which prevent a rise in ocean temperatures.
- throwaway894345 5y agoMaybe I'm not very clever, but it's hard to guess what you're driving at here.
- afarrell 5y ago1. An argument (that others are also making) that we need to be willing to accept partial solutions. 2. A pun.
- throwaway894345 5y agoYes, I understand that. I'm not sure which is the "partial solution" in this scenario, EVs?
- 5y ago
- aperson_hello 5y agoAnd it would require massive amounts of time (building the new infrastructure to support this vision would take generations), which we don't have...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway894345 5y ago> Who's building nuclear power plants now ? Renewable sources of electricity are stacked on top of non renewable ones so far You're arguing against a straw man of your own making. No one is positioning EVs as the solution for generating clean energy. They are a solution for electrifying transportation which is a prerequisite for moving transportation from fossil fuel generation to clean energy. Moreover, the current average blend of energy sources in the US grid is already much cleaner than burning gasoline, and on top of that virtually all charging stations are powered by 100% renewable energy. > EVs generate half their lifetime pollution before even being driven on the street, This is an argument in favor of EVs. Solar panels also produce all of their emissions prior to being plugged into the grid. This is precisely the mechanism by which they reduce carbon output relative to fossil fuel energy sources which have a large upfront carbon cost and then an even larger ongoing cost. It's the same deal with EVs. > 3 tonnes personal steel cages transporting 1 person Well, we have to have some way of getting around, and most of the US is not dense urban area. Space is plentiful in the US, and anyway "steel cages carrying one person" isn't optimizing for space, not carbon emissions. Any sort of utopian restructuring of US transportation is going to involve way more carbon up front for decades to solve a relatively small part (transporting humans) of a problem that we need to have solved in decades. > This is just another chapter of the "don't worry we'll magically figure it out sometime in the future (_cough cough_ after I got my dividends and retire)" This kind of vapid, incorrect cynicism isn't helpful and probably violates the site rules. We already largely know how to drastically reduce our emissions--clean energy and electrification. EVs are part of the electrification story. There's not much to "magically figure out" except how to make renewable energy viable for base load generation economically, but since any anti-car transportation solution is completely ignoring economy (not necessarily to be confused with "the economy") anyway, we can elide the "economically" requirement for base load generation in which case we already know how to get from here to there. In whichever case, EVs involve much less "magic" to solve than any anti-car alternative.
- trgn 5y ago> We already largely know how to drastically reduce our emissions--clean energy and electrification I think the parent is arguing against this premise. You argue from a value system, in which cars for personal transportation, are an axiomatic condition. Not only that, cars, no matter their size, going as fast as geometry allows it, are an inherent fixture. Solutions like EVs are a solution to carbon emissions, but only within this value system. I can think of plenty of other solutions, all of them old-skool tech. Driving more frugal cars with high mpg (which will be lighter, smaller), would be a low-tech solution that anyone can implement today. However, since this is not in your value system, it does not occur to you. Since your value system is the dominant one, American car manufacturers no longer even want to put this solution up for sale. Not requiring people to commute, is another low-tech way we can curb carbon emission. Taxing cars by weight is a low-tech bureaucratic solution. A true forest of automated speed cameras to push top speeds down, and thus fuel consumption down, yet another one. Zoning which allows amenities in walking and biking distance is another, and infrastructure making walking and biking be safe, not having to worry about getting run over by 3-ton EVs, would be yet another low tech solution. None of the above curb quality of life. But rather, they exist in a world that cannot be imagined. > EVs involve much less "magic" to solve than any anti-car alternative. This quote is a perfect encapsulation of your solipsism. You cannot even imagine these other solutions, and if you do, they appear magic. While this "magic"is the reality on the ground in so much other parts of the world. Even within the US, they exist. EVs will not be a solution to curb carbon emissions. It is because EVs fundamentally do not address the root causes of why we have these emissions in the first place. The wasteful use of energy on personal transportation, caused by overly heavy, overly fast vehicles, having to drive over overly long distances, for even the most basic daily needs.
- barbazoo 5y agoSure it's not _the_ solution to the world's green house gas problem but as someone living in a province with about 97% of energy being hydro/geothermal/wind/solar, making the next car an EV should make a pretty big dent in one's personal CO2 footprint. You have to take your local energy mix into consideration.