5 ms·
Hmm, yeah. The Witness. It was interesting for it’s puzzles, but having just come out of The Talos Principle -which had both great puzzles and a great story- i
by Aeolun 5y ago
Hmm, yeah. The Witness.
It was interesting for it’s puzzles, but having just come out of The Talos Principle -which had both great puzzles and a great story- it fell a bit flat for me.
The puzzles are fun, but the world looks it has a story behind it, and as you go along you find out that that’s just not really the case (or extremely minimal).
- dgb23 5y agoOne of the intriguing things about the Witness is that it feels more like studying a simulation than experiencing a story. It that sense it is remarkable. It feels a bit like some of the weirder niche games of the 90‘s but with incredible polish. Instead of guiding you literally, it communicates through taking your perspective while you slowly emerge yourself. It’s a game made with deep appreciation of their craft, respect of their players and almost something like a longing to communicate.
- dsego 5y agoHad high expectations for this game, anticipating with great excitement. I loved Braid, was following all the blog posts and videos with great admiration. And the game wasn't that bad, it was interesting for a while, but also frustrating. Talos on the other hand was a revelation, a thoroughly fun and enjoyable experience, very similar to Portal games. I think this was a fair critique of the Witness and why it lacks respect for the player: The Witness - A Great Game That You Shouldn't Play https://youtu.be/KZokQov_aH0 https://youtu.be/KZokQov_aH0
- mherdeg 5y agoThis video was my first introduction to the "long-form narrative game reviews" genre. I really enjoyed watching it -- I think the author made an interesting argument and presented it in a way that was more entertaining than playing 41 minutes of the actual game was.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoHow 'long form' do you want to go? Because if a six hour review of a genre-defining Japan-only dating simulator from the early 90s sounds like something you might be interested in then I highly recommend Tim Rogers's YouTube channel, Action Button.
- Tarq0n 5y agoTim Rogers and Noah Caldwell Gervais are the absolute masters of long form video game essays. Joseph Anderson too if you can stand exhaustive detail.
- dgb23 5y ago> I think this was a fair critique of the Witness and why it lacks respect for the player Just to put some counter weight to it - I had the exact opposite experience: Deep excitement and curiosity throughout the game. It felt like stepping into a different world of discovery and learning.
- mariusor 5y agoJonathan Blow is known to not like games that are heavily plot driven. Here's him describing some of the reason for that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aVb6-Rkz7W4&t=4409s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aVb6-Rkz7W4&t=4409s I think that's the main reason why Witness contains no meaningful conclusion or explanation to the world.
- agubelu 5y agoThe Witness does have a conclusion that explains the world. I can't explain what it is or how to access it without spoilers, but it can be found.
- tsimionescu 5y agoI think the Witness, while not having a story in any sense, had more to say to its players than most games. I came out of it with a new state of a mind - not some major change, of course, but somewhat refreshed and looking at the world ever so slightly differently. It's somewhat more like abstract art or perhaps lyrical poetry than it is to normal story telling, but that doesn't inherently detract from its quality. The quotes and clips it uses have a very clear theme and the idea of making a game about discovery, as the blog here I think correctly puts it, is interesting and at the very least different from most games.
- IHLayman 5y agoLet me preface with the fact that I loved both games in their different ways. While I understand your critique for the Witness being “plotless”, I found it a bit less depressing than the plot for Talos, which actually made Talos drag for me in the second and third acts. Also while there are meta elements in both, the meta elements in the Witness were far more striking than the ones in Talos.
- ehnto 5y agoI had done the same, but I loved The Witness also. There is a mood unique to games like that which I think The Witness had boiled down, which is a sort of "melancholic exploration". Exploration, fueled by a lack of distractions and freedom to explore, and uninturupted by big ideas or strong emotions. Was it a 90 hour immersive story, no way, but it's an atmosphere I love and that few games provide. It is probably why I also loved Fallout76 and Cyberpunk2077 from release day while others didn't, bugs excluded, to me both were huge worlds that I could wander and explore on my own terms. The gameplay mechanics best suited for that I think get discussed as "environmental storytelling" but I think in this case the storytelling was pretty light and it was the atmosphere that I was there for. Just existing in these worlds is enough for me to enjoy for a while.
- drc500free 5y agoI think you nailed it with "melancholic exploration." Very similar feel to Firewatch, where you can explore at your own place and there is no direct interaction with others - but there are signs that others have been there before.
- derbOac 5y agoI have so many questions of people here, it's as if I've stumbled onto this group of people who seem interested in exactly the same sorts of games I am. The Talos Principle and The Witness have always seemed interesting to me but I've never played them. I think part of it is that with both of them I've had trouble figuring out what they're like. Talos, the more I looked into it, seemed sort of like the puzzles were sort of arbitrary or contrived something? I'm not sure what the right words are. I tend to be more interested in adventure games per se, where the puzzles are ideally fully diagetic in nature, in the sense they're integrated well into the narrative. You're in X narrative scenario, and the problem to solve makes sense as a consequence of the narrative context. It doesn't feel added on post hoc. With both The Witness and Talos Principle I've had trouble figuring out what the gameplay and puzzles are like. I loved Portal and Portal 2 but felt like it was constantly tiptoeing this boundary of where the puzzles would feel too contrived, but without really going over that, maybe because of the testing environment conceit. I'm not sure what I'm saying other than that for me, part of what makes a great puzzle in a computer game is that the puzzle is seamlessly integrated into the narrative, and feels diagetic rather than nondiagetic in nature.
- ece 5y agoThe Talos Principle is about as normal a puzzle game as you can get, you can ignore the story bits if you want. Just go through the levels in a numerical order pretty much. The progression might be a bit slow in the start and middle, but the puzzles themselves were fun to solve for me (definitely not contrived), and the story and ending were satisfying. Much the same as Portal/Quell games. The Witness is part normal puzzle game and part more like Myst/Riven where you really have to dig deeper to find the answer. In a way they're about as diagetic as you can get, but some of that digging deeper can be a chore and wasn't fun for me, so I stopped playing The Witness after finding the normal ending and enjoyed playing it up to that point. I'd like to pickup the Outer Wilds though, and I like a balance of adventure/puzzles within games too. I suppose environmental puzzle games really have to click for me to enjoy them.
- ece 5y ago*diegetic
- memco 5y agoHaving never played Talos principle one interesting thing I found against it is tat the mechanics of the game can be exploited such that the speed run of the game skips huge portions of it; whereas the witness is much more direct: you can’t exploit the mechanics to get ahead. Not that that matters at all since as a casual player I’m unlikely to ever get good enough at those kinds of maneuvers to skip ahead myself but that knowledge makes me feel like there’s a certain level of craftsmanship to the witness that isn’t present Talos Principle. The other side to this coin is that the speed run for Talos Principle is way more fun to watch because it is less predictable and there’s room for creatively getting around whatever barriers the game throws at you.