5 ms·
- mix of supply sources - over provisioning - geographic distribution - biomethane - international grid ties
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
- mix of supply sources
- over provisioning
- geographic distribution
- biomethane
- international grid ties
- cm2187 5y agoHum. Over provisioning doesn't help when you have a month without wind (or you have to overprovision by like a factor of 100), neither does geographic distribution (cf UK electricity grid last year, the whole country goes down to a small production [1]). Is biomethane considered as green? Isn't it like natural gas? International grid ties basically means you are using coal/nuclear/etc from your neighbours, who will likely have shortage at the same time given they also have their own share of sun and wind. [1] https://gridwatch.co.uk/ https://gridwatch.co.uk/
- bally0241 5y agoIt's ok...we're over provisioned on solar generation capacity. So it doesn't matter that it is night :P.
- chess_buster 5y agoDo you work in the factory at night, bally0241?
- bally0241 5y agoI do sometimes work nights, but not in a factory. But your missing the point, there are lots of industrial processes that you don't just turn off for 12 hours because the electricity is not there or more expensive. Spooling them back up can take far in excess of that, so a 50% duty cycle is a non-starter. I'm sorry we can't all be laptop-class software devs, someone has to make the 'stuff'.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoThere has never been a single hour in the last 30 years where the wind has not been blowing somewhere in Europe.
- lazide 5y agoWhich is great when everyone likes each other. Which traditionally is a dubious bet to place in Europe when losing it results in serious things like ‘will all the old people freeze to death tomorrow because we don’t have enough electrical capacity’.
- cm2187 5y agoWell, the wind blowing on some hill somewhere in europe isn't of much help, it needs to be diverse enough that some countries can make up for the entire lack of production of other countries. I am not convinced there is much diversification. I just did some back of the enveloppe analysis to convince myself. I am using hourly wind electricity production data from this source [1] which is referenced on the europa website [2] (first source I found, I don't necessarily vouch for it). I only looked at 2014-2015 (the last two years of this time series), took the daily production at 2pm (seems to be peak production and peak demand), and then calculated a weekly average of the 2pm production by country for every day. I took the low points for the UK (arbitrarily, that's where I am now), and looked at the percentile of each country for those UK low points. So the way you read this is for the week ending 28 June 2014, when the UK was at its 1% worst wind production across 2014-2015, at that time Norway was at its 15%th worst production, Sweden 9%th worst, etc. "15%th worst" means that the norwegian production for that week was below that level only 15% of the weeks in 2014-2015. 2014-06-28 2014-09-09 2014-09-16 United Kingdom 1% 1% 2% Norway 15% 21% 20% Sweden 9% 0% 11% Netherlands 1% 19% 18% France 2% 9% 15% Germany 23% 1% 41% Italy 63% 9% 18% Portugal 32% 5% 60% Greece 55% 5% 8% so you do get some outliers (Italy and Greece in the first column, Portugal in the last), but overall, all the major countries are down at the same time, so it's not Portgual that will produce the wind energy for all the other countries. [1] https://zenodo.org/record/4803353 https://zenodo.org/record/4803353 [2] https://data.jrc.ec.europa.eu/dataset/jrc-emhires-wind-generation-time-series https://data.jrc.ec.europa.eu/dataset/jrc-emhires-wind-gener...
- lkbm 5y agoInternational grid doesn't mean "import whatever is on offer". You can contract for renewable energy, and fund international production capacity. Depending on Russian oil was a geopolitical (and environmental) mistake. Depending on French nuclear or Spanish solar seems much safer. International grid ties also means: * When it's cloudy or calm, you can import from somewhere sunny or windy. When it's sunny or windy, export to somewhere cloudy and calm. Shortages a thousand miles southwest aren't going to correlate strongly with shortages where you are, and if you if you have multiple sources a thousand miles in each direction you should be able to balance demand far better. Weather conditions are reasonably local. Demand patterns will also vary a bit. * You can import solar from somewhere sunnier, or sunny at different. You're not going to transmit your electricity 12,000 miles east/west, but Madrid has sunset an hour later than Berlin, and demand tends to be closer to 7pm than 2am. Yeah, it's a hard engineering problem, and there will be downsides, but we can do it if we seriously commit to it.
- cm2187 5y agoif you look at my response to a sibling comment, I am not convinced there is that much diversification in europe [1]. And you can tell annecdoctically, when you have heatwave news stories in one european countries, you typically get similar stories in other european countries. Europe is not that big geographically. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30934588 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30934588
- lkbm 5y agoWow, thanks for putting together that data! I'm not surprised to see Germany, UK, Norway, Sweden, and Netherlands all be similar, since (I assume) they're all using the North Sea. I am surprised to see Germany's output is so similar to Italy, Portugal, and Greece. It does look like there's a decent separation between places I expect to use the Mediterranean vs. those I'd expect to use the North Sea, but yeah, we likely need a lot of excess capacity, a lot of storage, or a lot of not-wind-or-solar. (Or I guess a lot of flexibility on energy usage.)
- brugidou 5y agoA recent study on Germany based upon 35 years of weather data [0] shows that we would need about 24 days worth of storage to cope with this weather conditions. [0] https://twitter.com/QvistStaffan/status/1427625795355349004?t=OIfEEqlGLaRnR3wyfRZ8Cw&s=19 https://twitter.com/QvistStaffan/status/1427625795355349004?...
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoIt's always interesting to see what ridiculous limitation they place on these to make them not work out. Popular ones are: Refusing to allow energy to be traded with neighbours. Refusing to allow demand response. Refusing to allow over building (so the installed capacity exactly matches the yearly required energy and storage needs multiply). Refusing to target efficiency measures. Refusing to use existing low carbon power sources (hydro, biogas). Often they use low volume prices for a massive rollout but at least in this case they're estimating storage capacity rather than price so they won't have done that one. edit: reading through it now, they cite other people who didn't do the above, and then state that they know some of their choices will overstate things: > the fact that we model Germany as an island may lead to an overestimation Guess that bit didn't fit in the tweet. I don't fully understand this next one, but their headline number is based on running biogas as a constant baseload, which seems utterly ridiculous. They also claim that allowing that to flex with supply and demand has this impact: > "Adding other sources of flexibility for the example of bioenergy, the duration of period that defines storage requirements lengthens to more than one year." That's a very strangely worded sentence, with a very counterintuitive plain reading. Are they trying to intentionally confuse people? I'm not sure, can't figure out anything reasonable from the article. How can adding 8GW of flexible biogas generation increase storage requirements? Are they counting the storage of biogas?
- cm2187 5y agoI am not trying to defend the study, but I don't think any of your points actually mitigate the issue of volatility. 1. trades with neighbours: most european countries face similar weather conditions at the same time. The french will need their own nuclear capacity to make up for their own lack of wind. 2. demand response: switching off factories or heating when you need it? That's no solution 3. over building: the problem is that the volatility of wind is massive, if you look at the uk grid website [1], it can go to nearly zero for more than a week. If the volatility was smaller, over provisioning could be a solution (provided the economics work). 4. efficiency measures: you only make the size of the problem slightly smaller, but you still have a volatility problem. And with cars going electric and us not relying on russian gas for heating, I don't see the demand for electricity going down 5. hydro, biogas: there is only so much hydro you can build. And the places where you can build some (Sweden, Norway) leave you at the mercy of a russian submarine cutting the cable. Biogas: isn't that co2 emitting? [1] https://gridwatch.co.uk/ https://gridwatch.co.uk/
- solarkraft 5y agoAnd batteries. This is only viable for a few days at most though, it doesn't work for seasonal differences.
- panick21_ 5y agoIf every country main argument is 'we just use the international grid for balance' non of this will scale. Over provisioning one thing just means its not in another place for the first decades.