7 ms·
Democracy is pretty decent, but comes with some big flaws: tyranny of the minority, enormous amounts of back-and-forth to get anything done, big egos at any lev
by sph 5y ago
Democracy is pretty decent, but comes with some big flaws: tyranny of the minority, enormous amounts of back-and-forth to get anything done, big egos at any level can stop progress.
Debian is the very example of it.
Case in point: other distros forced the usr migration and very few problems were had. Debian put the idea through a committee, of course a minority wanted to keep the old behaviour so Debian decided to support both, guess what, supporting both means having two problems now.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- LeoPanthera 5y ago> Debian put the idea through a committee, of course a minority wanted to keep the old behaviour That is specifically not what happened, and the article is quite clear about it. The Technical Committee voted unanimously for merged usr: https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=978636#178 https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=978636#178 The problem is that dpkg, an essential component of Debian, has specific issues with symlinks: https://wiki.debian.org/Teams/Dpkg/FAQ#Q:_Does_dpkg_support_merged-.2Fusr-via-aliased-dirs.3F https://wiki.debian.org/Teams/Dpkg/FAQ#Q:_Does_dpkg_support_... So the issue is how merged usr is accomplished, not whether it is at all. Please don't spread this kind of misinformation.
- sph 5y agoI'm quoting the article: "Debian took a more incremental approach, in part because it strives not to make wholesale changes to users' systems like those required by a flag-day upgrade to a merged /usr. In 2016, the ability to voluntarily switch to that scheme was added, then some attempts were made for newer versions of the distribution to be installed with a merged /usr by default. [...] The location of some files was being resolved at build time to point into /usr/bin (for example), but those files only existed in /bin on the non-merged systems." The fact that the committee took a decision that the core package manager can't support is baffling to me.
- derefr 5y ago> The fact that the committee took a decision that the core package manager can't support is baffling to me. Why? Presumably the committee would be thereby deciding to drive development of the package manager toward whatever is required to support the high-level goal.
- sph 5y agoWell, this hasn't happened, and now we have the situation mentioned in this article.
- josefx 5y agoFrom a user perspective the high level problem would be merged directories. Which dpkg apparently already supports. Just not the way the committee wants it done. > deciding to drive development of the package manager Which is the hilarious part: No one seems to be working on it. The package maintainer for dpkg isn't required to it as long as he accepts reasonable patches, but only half finished patches (that identify themselves as such) are coming in when the reported issues are not outright ignored. Seems liked Debian suffers from the same issue every open source projects suffers from: A bunch of lazy and entitled as fuck users insisting on features without putting any effort in themselves.
- onei 5y agoThe committee took a decision that the package manager /doesn't/ support. If I've learned one thing, it's that there's very little that software can't be made to do. Whether it should is an entirely valid question, and hopefully figured out before assessing the "could" aspect.
- mjevans 5y agoIt doesn't seem too difficult to support; what are the edge cases? Who owns a file in a path that includes a 'well known symlink dir'? So maintain a list of well known symlink dirs. When checking a file path against the database, the normalization step should check if the known symlink dir is any point of the path; if it is the redirect should be resolved to the well known target instead. E.G. owns('/bin/bash') ... the path mutates to '/usr/bin/bash' because the location '/bin/' is already known to really be '/usr/bin/'.
- izacus 5y agoYou're spreading misinformation too: based on the article the dpkg maintainer is trying his hardest to obstruct fixes and implementation of the feature despite the voting and consensus.
- mschuster91 5y ago> Democracy is pretty decent, but comes with some big flaws: tyranny of the minority, enormous amounts of back-and-forth to get anything done, big egos at any level can stop progress. The problem is not in democracy itself as a concept. In both the open-source world and in society itself, the problems arise only when the demos (the population) either grow disinterested in democracy or is small in numbers. As for "tyranny of the minority" - I hope to never see that phrase again. Protections for minorities in democracies exist for a very good reason. In the case of projects such as Debian to reduce the chance of solo maintainers quitting over frustration about being overruled, in democracies to prevent atrocities and hold up human rights for vulnerable people (e.g. disabled).
- logifail 5y ago> As for "tyranny of the minority" - I hope to never see that phrase again. Protections for minorities in democracies exist for a very good reason. There is plenty of evidence for the theory proposed by Taleb[0] on this one, he wrote: "It suffices for an intransigent minority – a certain type of intransigent minorities – to reach a minutely small level, say three or four percent of the total population, for the entire population to have to submit to their preferences." [0] The Most Intolerant Wins: The Dictatorship of the Small Minority https://medium.com/incerto/the-most-intolerant-wins-the-dictatorship-of-the-small-minority-3f1f83ce4e15 https://medium.com/incerto/the-most-intolerant-wins-the-dict...
- nix23 5y ago
- Eduard 5y agoComments section is only two levels deep and we have already arrived at Godwin's law.
- nix23 5y agoI don't compare you with a nazi, but you should understand that minority's can take over a country, that's what the nazis did but also the communists in romanov-russia...china is more complicated. It's something completely different, but maybe "nazi" is a red flag for you in comments...because not comfy. EDIT: And more actual, the Taliban's in Afghanistan, an absolute minority but the one with weapons, training, connections to local "war/land"-lords and the will to take over the country.
- agumonkey 5y ago> tyranny of the minority this is a trendy thing too, very often minorities who felt ignored, are now pushing to get more because of the tiranny of the majority had flaws (but to me is mostly unavoidable due to the natural economies of scale it grants). I don't know how one can design a social system where you balance both in the right way.
- q-big 5y ago> I don't know how one can design a social system where you balance both in the right way. The central problem is: how shall the "right way" in "both in the right way" even be defined?
- forgotmypw17 5y agoI think one possible solution is to create systems which are designed to fragment and split up from the beginning.
- hanselot 5y ago
- mwcampbell 5y ago> the tiranny of the majority had flaws (but to me is mostly unavoidable due to the natural economies of scale it grants). In a different context, this is a source of frustration for me as a (partially) blind person advocating accessibility for blind people. The world is designed around the assumption, correct for most people, that people have the high-bandwidth, low-latency sense of sight. And that does lead to the most effective interface for most people. That assumption is so thoroughly baked into everything that I sometimes think it might have been better if, through some kind of eugenics, I and people like me (blind from birth) had never been born at all, so the world could go on with that assumption (as it mostly does anyway) without leaving us out. I know eugenics is a taboo idea though, and it has its own problems.
- necovek 5y ago
- ssl232 5y agoHow much of Python's success is down to the BDFL(-delegate) approach of governance? It seems a lot of projects have adopted it and Python's PEP system for managing new features. I wonder if Debian could use a similar sort of elected presidential system.
- sph 5y agoI am of the opinion that BDFL style governance is best in software. In the real world the problem is a bit more hairy, but if you have an issue with a tyrant in open source, you can just fork the project. A BDFL solves the bureaucracy problem (they mandate, everybody implements) and the big ego problem (the biggest ego is at the top by definition). Also BDFL can have vision, something a committee will never have. In my humble opinion, people like Torvalds and Jobs are the secret to wildly successful software.
- hoseja 5y agoWhat does Jobs have to do with software.
- hanselot 5y ago
- petre 5y agoI find the role based FreeBSD core team approach more adapted to projects such as Debian. They also started with BDLF and then moved on to the core team approach. That's several BDFLs, every one of them with different responsibilities. It's 9 people in the case of FreeBSD. They've tried it with 20 people and then scaled back to 9: "Deadwood and apathy in the 20-member core team lead to creating bylaws that set up a 9-member elected core team First elected core team in 2000 with few carryovers from old core team" [1] It should also be an odd number if they vote, so that there won't be a tie in votes. The same approach is used in kendo and other Japanese martial arts examinations, the number of examinators is always an odd number. This also solves the "what if the BDFL is hit by a bus" problem: another member is appointed. 1. https://papers.freebsd.org/2018/bsdcan/mckusick-The_Evolution_of_FreeBSD_Governance.files/mckusick-The_Evolution_of_FreeBSD_Governance.pdf https://papers.freebsd.org/2018/bsdcan/mckusick-The_Evolutio...
- goodpoint 5y agoWrong. Debian is a do-ocracy. Package maintainers have plenty of power to take decisions. The TC gets involved very rarely.
- MrBuddyCasino 5y agoEverything that works well is structured like a monarchy. Maybe the west shouldn't be trying so hard to export democracy?
- dotancohen 5y agoThe reasonable explanation for that is that in a monarchy, ostensibly all bodies are working towards common goal (as dictated at the top). Whereas in a democracy, in many cases there exist bodies with equal power yet conflicting interests. Monarchies seem to work well in cases where "the top" has interests that align with the interests of the subjects, and is well-informed. Jordan seems to be a great example. Yet history is full of examples of long-standing monarchy-type organizations where after only a short time of disconnect between the governing and the governed, the entire system fails. A Frenchman could probably provide good examples.
- goodpoint 5y agoThe biggest wars and massacres in human history always involved some monarchy/dictatorship.
- MrBuddyCasino 5y agoCommunism as the rule of "the proletariat" instead of a ruling nobility has created the worst horrors of the 20th century. You may think of monarchy and communism as the same thing "because they are dictatorships", because the frame of reference you are used to is contrasting everything to "democracy", but they really really are not.
- goodpoint 5y agofacepalm
- bamboozled 5y agoDemocracy is pretty decent, but comes with some big flaws: tyranny of the minority Did you invent this? Because it's freaking brilliant!
- sph 5y agoSomeone much smarter that me did: https://medium.com/incerto/the-most-intolerant-wins-the-dictatorship-of-the-small-minority-3f1f83ce4e15 https://medium.com/incerto/the-most-intolerant-wins-the-dict...
- wil421 5y agoIsn't that design by committee? A democracy would mean all the users would be able to vote on everything.
- ordu 5y ago> Democracy is pretty decent, but comes with some big flaws I'd argue you are overstretching one example of one broken system to a whole class of systems. We can reframe these big egos as people who do not believe in democracy, but great believers in feudalism. (Though I do not know all the details what is going on in Debian, may be I misunderstand the affair, and I don't want to mark some specific people as anti-democrats, but I don't know how to aviod it, sorry). We see how individual developers say "get off my lawn". The social dynamics of a collective decision making doesn't mean for them a thing. Any democracy needs a legitimate way to reach consensus. And everyone needs to conform to a consensus. Legitimacy of procedures must be enough for everyone to believe in the consensus or at least to believe in their obligation to conform. And the more power someone have, the more his obligations to conform are. I mean, if I'm a regular voter without any special powers to resist consensus, then I cannot brake the consensus, I cannot stop system from working without resorting to really destructive and antisocial behavior. But if I was a president, I would have power, I could resist. But if I did then it would be not a democracy but an autocracy. If I was something in between a voter and a president, then the situation would be something in between, though probably the president may interfere with my plans, use their powers to stop me ruining the system. In Debian it seems every developer maintaining something important enough have powers to resist any consensus reached. And moreover there are some who actually use their power to resist. And the system as a whole doesn't treat such behavior as them undermining the system and may be undermining the very idea of democracy. I'd say that Debian is playing democracy but didn't invested enough into building a mythology of a democracy, into making people believe in a divine right of democratic procedures to rule them all. Though from other hand, it may be not a bug, but a feature of a system, because it pays to people by handling them some power, I believe it helps them to not burn out too fast. It charges the community with struggles and a constant fight, it provokes people-centered procedures, not rule-centered.
- deknos 5y agoon the other side, debian is one of the most stable platforms, more than even commercial ones (binary compatible centos is just a blink in the lifetime of debian for example :D) . just because people care about the technology... and upgrading is important for small business with less money. and this shows how hard it is to achive an good upgrade path.