6 ms·
Let's be clear, those workstations were hella expensive. (The Amiga was not in the true workstation range, but rather more of a glorified home computer. Their
by zozbot234 5y ago
Let's be clear, those workstations were hella expensive. (The Amiga was not in the true workstation range, but rather more of a glorified home computer. Their workstation equivalents would probably be the stuff from NeXT.) Their closest modern equivalent would probably be midrange systems like whatever Oxide Computer is working on these days. A workstation was simply a "midrange" level system that happened to be equipped for use by a single person, as opposed to a shared server resource. The descendant of the old minicomputer, in many ways.
- notreallyserio 5y agoNo kidding: https://daringfireball.net/linked/2019/12/17/sgi-workstations https://daringfireball.net/linked/2019/12/17/sgi-workstation... > The Octane line’s entry-level product, which comes with a 225-MHz R10000 MIPS processor, 128MB of memory, a 4GB hard drive, and a 20-inch monitor, will fall to $17,995 from $19,995. Really makes the M1 Ultra look affordable.
- usefulcat 5y agoThe Indy, which predated the Octane, started much lower ($5k according to Wikipedia, presumably in mid-nineties dollars), but yeah your point very much stands.
- twoodfin 5y agoThe Indy, though, was notoriously underpowered. Very much the “glorified home computer” the GP described, albeit running MIPS. Still, sure did stand out in the MIT computer labs!
- Epiphany21 5y agoIndys weren't truly that slow. The problem was the base models were memory constrained to the point where IRIX could barely boot. 16MB was not enough, and IRIX 5.x had memory leaks that made it even worse. An Indy with 96MB+ will run IRIX 6.5 pretty well.
- usefulcat 5y agoThat sounds right. I believe most or all developers at the place I worked had either 32 or 64 MB in their machines. At first (~1995) most were probably using IRIX 5.3, but by 96 or 97 I think most if not all had moved to 6.5. Whatever I had, I don't recall lack of memory ever being a problem. And the GUI was quite snappy.
- jacquesm 5y agoThe GUI was fantastic. Minimal got out of your way as much as possible and used the hardware acceleration to great effect. IRIX 6.5 was rock solid, I used it as my main driver for years before switching to Linux, we also had some windows boxes floating around because we supported a windows binary but that and admin were the only things done on those, everything was either SGI or Linux. I was still using my SGI keyboard two years ago but it finally died.
- bsder 5y agoI seem to remember a very classic rant about how bad Irix was back then but I can't seem to find it.
- vidarh 5y agoSGI some places did a great job at giving good deals to computer labs. When I was at university in Oslo, there were rows and rows of Indy's on one side of the biggest undergrad computer lab, and then a bunch of Suns with multiple monochrome Tandberg terminals hooked up on the other. No big surprise that the Indy side always filled up first, and that "everyone" soon had XEarth and similar running as backgrounds on the Indys... Of course "everyone" loved SGI and were thoroughly unimpressed with Sun after a semester in those labs.
- don-code 5y agoThere's a running joke about the Indy that it's the Indigo (its much-more-expensive brother) without the "go".
- guyzero 5y agoThat's just over $31,000 in 2022 dollars. I don't think I can even imagine what kind of modern desktop you could build for that much money.
- jeffbee 5y agohttps://zworkstations.com/configurations/3010617/ https://zworkstations.com/configurations/3010617/ 24x 4.5GHz cores, 96GB memory, 48TB NVMe storage, 2 giant GPUs, etc.
- guyzero 5y agoThat's wild, although it seems to be server parts in a workstation case. I guess none of Intel's "desktop" chips support a dual/quad CPU configuration though, so that's your only choice. Quad 8 TB NVMe drives is definitely one way to get to $30K of parts pretty quickly.
- sbierwagen 5y agoNeither Intel or AMD support SMP with consumer chips. To go dual-processor with AMD you have to buy EPYC skus, which are several times more expensive than their threadripper core-count equivalents.
- nullc 5y agoFWIW, EPYCs sell on ebay with $/core prices much closer to threadripper prices-- presumably that's closer to what AMD is selling them for to large companies after discounts. The MSRP on them is ... quite staggering though!
- Sohcahtoa82 5y agoI'm not even sure you could build a $31,000 desktop computer even if you wanted to without resorting to some ridiculous "expensive for the sake of being expensive" parts. Even quad RTX 3090 Ti's would only set you back $8,000 if you got them at MSRP. EDIT: Just saw the other comment and I stand corrected.
- api 5y ago> Really makes the M1 Ultra look affordable. The amount of power you can buy today for under $1000 let alone under $10000 is insane compared to back then. The M1 Ultra is not that expensive compared to mid-range workstations or even high-end PCs of previous eras.
- paulmd 5y agoYeah, I don't quite get the way people sometimes reminisce about the hardware costs of the past. We used to have consumer CPUs topping $1000 back when that was some serious money, and big-boy graphics workstations could easily run the tens or hundreds of thousands.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoNon-toy computers were only available to the relatively wealthy for nearly a decade. The original Apple II was the equivalent of around $5000, which certainly wasn't a casual purchase for most people. If you look in back-issues of Byte the prices of early PCs with a usable spec are eye-watering, even before correcting for inflation. Prices didn't start dropping to more accessible levels until the 90s.
- rodgerd 5y agoAn Irix workstation is like buying a Countach. It's a thing you have because it's the thing that you always wanted.
- vidarh 5y agoI used to run an e-mail service with ~2m user accounts '99-'01. Our storage was an IBM ESS "Shark" stocked with 1.5TB of drives and two RS/6000 servers as the storage controllers. Add on web frontends and mail exchangers, and the entire system was slower and had less aggregate RAM and processing power, less (and slower) disk (well SSD in my laptop) than my current $1500 laptop.
- jmwilson 5y agoYep, the closest I ever got to a SGI was drooling over their product brochures as a kid. The cost of a modest Indy was about the same as a mid-range car. It's hard to grasp as a modern PC user that these workstations could handle classes of problems that contemporary PCs could not, no matter what upgrades you did. Today, it would be like comparing a PC to a TPU-based (or similar ASIC) platform for computing. From what I've read, Oxide is making racks of servers and has no interest in workstations that an individual would use.
- sleepybrett 5y agoWhen a game company I worked at went out of business and couldn't unload their aging Indigo Elans and Indys I picked up one of each for about a hundred bucks. I now have some regrets simply because their monitors have strange connectors, so i keep them around and they are heavy and annoying to store. That said I could probably pay off my initial purchase and then some by unloading one of their 'granite' keyboards (ALPs boards, collectors love them).
- tech2 5y agoThat 13W3 connector is the worst. I also had an Indy many years ago and getting an adapter together for it was a real challenge. These days I expect it to be somewhat simpler though.
- LinuxBender 5y agoAnecdotally a friend had a computer store that sold Amiga's and had his entire inventory bought out by the CIA of whom never paid him so they must have been powerful for something. This was in the late 90's. No idea what they were using them for. I used one to help a friend run a BBS. I could play games with incredible graphics whilst the BBS was running in the background.
- vidarh 5y agoIf it was late 90's, as much as I love Amiga, it would have been for niche stuff like replacing a bunch of information screens or something like that where they could have replaced it with PCs but would then need to change their software setup. In terms of "power" the Amiga was over by the early 90's, even if you stuffed it full of expensive third party expansions. It still felt like an amazing system for a few years, but by the late 90's you needed to seriously love the system and AmigaOS to hold onto it, and even for many of us who did (and do) love it, it became hard to justify.
- mysterydip 5y agoCould have been a case of designing a platform around the hardware in the early 90s, then being desperate for parts to keep the platform going while designing the upgrade.
- vidarh 5y agoMaybe, in which case it'd likely still be something video-oriented. The Amiga was never particularly fast in terms of raw number-crunching. As a desktop computer it felt fast because of the pre-emptive multitasking and the custom chips and the use of SCSI instead of IDE. Even the keyboard had it's own CPU (a 6502-compatible SOC) on some of the models - "everything" was offloaded from the main CPU, and so until PCs started getting GPUs etc. it didn't matter that much that Motorola from pretty early on was struggling to keep up with the x86 advances. But for video it had two major things going for it: Genlock, allowing cheap passthrough of a video signal and overlaying Amiga graphics on top of the video, and products like the Video Toaster that was initially built around the Amiga. So you could see Amiga's pop up in video context may years after they were otherwise becoming obsolete because of that.
- blihp 5y agoA loaded up Amiga (i.e. add a CPU accelerator board, more RAM than most PCs could handle, specialized video processing cards etc) could get into the low end of workstation territory. But you are right that architecturally, they had more in common with high end PCs than workstations of their day. The Amiga's main claim to fame from a hardware standpoint was their specialized chipset.
- sleepybrett 5y agoI'd say when you get into a fully kitted 2k video toaster you get into 'workstation' territory for my potentially personal definition of 'workstation'. For me a 'workstation' is a machine built and optimized for a task that primarily runs that task and that task only. It is sometimes the 'core hardware' that is interesting, but often many of the peripherals are more interesting. Things I consider workstations include Avid and other video editing systems, machines built for cad, and yes many of the 'desktop' sgi machines which generally did nothing but run software like softimage all day every day. The 'workstation' largely died because general off the shelf machines because fast enough to perform those task almost as well. You now see a more open market for the peripherals that help 'specialize' a general purpose computer. Wacom tablets, video capture devices, customized video editing controllers, midi controllers, GPUs, etc