7 ms·
Kerouac and Buddhism
- zabzonk 5y ago> Stylistically, On the Road is far superior. Possibly true, but Dharma Bums is perhaps funnier. Whch is the better hand? > Zen flesh but no Zen bones Better flesh than nothing. Or perhaps not.
- WaxedChewbacca 5y ago
- spurgu 5y ago> Over the 21 years since then, I’ve asked many American Buddhist monks and professors of Buddhist studies how they were first introduced to Buddhism, and several gave me the same answer: Jack Kerouac. Kerouac lead me too to multiple years of meditation practice. And I learned about On the Road in turn from Jim Morrison. > Both books are about freedom. Both depict a way of living free from 20-year mortgages, nine-to-five jobs, conventional relationships, and family responsibilities. They present the liberating idea that you can do whatever you want with your life—what you want to do, not just what you are supposed to do. This has been somewhat of a guiding principle for me I now realize. After reading On the Road in my late teens I might've spent maybe 25% of my years since doing a 9-5. Other things have influenced me as well obviously, but Kerouac has been a strong one, I've read all of his books I could get a hold of.
- tonguez 5y agohe died of vomiting blood from alcoholism, just like alan watts
- coldtea 5y agoSo?
- kragen 5y agoSo probably neither one of them had achieved much in the way of liberation from attachment to sensory pleasure (and the other four hindrances: hate, dullness, anxiety, and doubt) or the resulting cessation of suffering, which is the point of Buddhism. So either Buddhism doesn't work or Kerouac and Watts sucked at it. That, in turn, means that they are not reliable sources for information about how to do Buddhism. That might be okay if you read Kerouac and then go find guidance on the path from someone who really is liberated, assuming that's possible, but how do you as a novice layperson tell the difference between a liberated Zen master and a charlatan? If US seekers were good at it, Kerouac's and Watts's books wouldn't be the bestsellers in the category, they'd be eclipsed by somebody whose practice of Buddhism in their own life was actually successful and who had trustworthy, well-grounded insights to share. So you're likely to replicate the errors that led you to Kerouac in the first place by choosing someone like Richard Baker as your teacher. Then, instead of getting liberated from suffering, you just get sexually exploited. In particular, Kerouac kind of glorifies living heedlessly, and it was precisely that heedlessness that caused his death. Also, it was Richard Baker's heedlessness that caused so much suffering to his students, leaving scars in the community around the San Francisco Zen Center that continue to cause suffering, almost 30 years after his departure. If you're looking for someone to give you permission to live heedlessly, to tell you that living heedlessly is the path to liberation from suffering, you are going to assiduously avoid anything resembling orthodox Buddhism, which says that heedlessness causes suffering. It's kind of the opposite extreme, really: orthodox Buddhist doctrine is that you should do everything extremely carefully. And you can see this in Zen rock gardens, in the Japanese tea ceremony, in Thich Nhat Hanh's practice of singing a little verse to himself about washing his hands every time he washed his hands, in the absolute prohibition on drinking alcohol, and so on. As far as I can tell it's uniform across every branch of Buddhism. I'm no expert, of course—obviously I'm no enlightened being or I wouldn't be posting in this cesspit of ill-will and ego. So my understanding of Buddhism should also be suspect. But there is at least somewhat less evidence that I have Buddhism entirely backwards than there is for Watts and Kerouac. Not only have I not died vomiting blood due to alcoholism, the only drug I'm addicted to is caffeine. It's the same kind of problem we have with programming books, where incompetent fools like Herbert Schildt https://www.seebs.net/c/c_tcn4e.html https://www.seebs.net/c/c_tcn4e.html outsell Kernighan & Ritchie in the "learning C" category, and where the whole methodology and architecture category is full of snake-oil salesmen who have never successfully written a large program.
- noarchy 5y agoOne might say it means they had issues keeping the Fifth Precept (abstaining from alcohol, or sometimes interpreted to mean all intoxicants), which some Buddhist laypersons adhere to. But no one ever (or did they?) claimed these men were enlightened beings. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_precepts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_precepts
- damontal 5y agoPretty sure Watts never claimed to be a Buddhist. He styled himself as more of an entertainer who’s subject was religion.
- slibhb 5y agoHow people actually lived seems relevant as long as they're giving us advice about how to live.
- adolph 5y agoI want to make one thing absolutely clear. I am not a Zen Buddhist, I am not advocating Zen Buddhism, I am not trying to convert anyone to it. I have nothing to sell. I'm an entertainer. That is to say, in the same sense, that when you go to a concert and you listen to someone play Mozart, he has nothing to sell except the sound of the music. He doesn’t want to convert you to anything. He doesn’t want you to join an organization in favor of Mozart's music as opposed to, say, Beethoven's. And I approach you in the same spirit as a musician with his piano or a violinist with his violin. I just want you to enjoy a point of view that I enjoy. Source: https://quotepark.com/quotes/1935679-alan-watts-i-want-to-make-one-thing-absolutely-clear-i-am-no/ https://quotepark.com/quotes/1935679-alan-watts-i-want-to-ma...
- coldtea 5y agoDid Kerouac ever told you not to die an alcoholic? If anything, he advised travelling, drinking, experiencing stuff, and burning life like a candle from both ends...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pie42000 5y agoNot a bad way to go
- mwattsun 5y agoZen Buddhism by itself does not cure alcoholism, although it can be helpful in recovery to prevent relapse.
- artificialLimbs 5y agoIt seems these 2 examples don't contribute to that idea.
- nabla9 5y agoReading, studying, writing and thinking about Zen Buddhism like these guys did certainly does not cure anything.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoIt can help with craving.
- nabla9 5y agoBoth Watts and Kerouac were outsiders looking in. Watts was also a very scholarly book-learned about Zen Buddhism, but he never claimed he did the thing or meditated much, he just wrote beautifully and inspired others to try meditating. When I started meditating, I asked about Watts or Kerouac from long-term practitioners and Zen teachers. Pretty much everyone says that they wrote lots of "beautiful zen nonsense", but it's not bad because they have inspired thousands of people to try. From a daily practice perspective, zen feels more mundane. It's like going to the gym or brushing your teeth. More people like the idea of doing zen than actually doing it. Stopping and sitting with your daily shit every day does not feel cool. When the exotic, aesthetic and philosophical aspect wears out, most people quit.
- justinator 5y agoIf Kerouac piqued your interest in Buddhism, Gary Snyder is who you want to study.
- Alex3917 5y ago"stay together learn the flowers go light" That just about sums it up.
- justinator 5y agoBeautiful.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoThe Alan Watts lectures are very entertaining and are all on YouTube (audio only).
- julienchastang 5y agoI'm just finishing On the Road. My impressions of it are somewhat mixed. When I started it, the language was so free and beautiful that I thought it was the best thing I had ever read. But then I found the celebration of alcoholism and substance abuse tedious. There are parts I found frustrating such as when Sal goes to New Orleans to visit Old Bull Lee (William S. Burroughs), but doesn't really describe the city which must have been pretty cool in 1947 before the hyper-tourism of today. Some of the conversations between Sal and Dean are really touching and some of my favorite parts of the book like when Dean talks about his outlaw father. He also brings Denver to life which I enjoyed. There are funny parts as when he takes on a job as a security guard in SF, the most unlikely of jobs for Sal Paradise.
- tppiotrowski 5y agoAgree. But no author captures the sense of euphoria like Kerouac. Reading his prose can sometimes put you into a euphoric frenzy. But he will drag you down with him at times as well.
- verisimi 5y ago> But no author captures the sense of euphoria like Kerouac. In that book only.
- cassepipe 5y agoI personnaly did not like the book and found enjoying Scott Alexander's review quite a lot : https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/02/book-review-on-the-road/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/02/book-review-on-the-roa...
- thatjoeoverthr 5y agoThis review is brutal, I love it. > On The Road is, most importantly, a picture of a high-trust society collapsing. And it’s collapsing precisely because the book’s protagonists are going around defecting against everyone they meet It’s like the old cliche, “this is why we can’t have nice things.”
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoKind of ironic. Kerouac lived in the town I live in. He used to drink at Gunther's, in Northport Village. That place is not zen ...
- postingposts 5y agoI’d like to use this as an opportunity to highlight an under-appreciated bit of Kerouac’s work and in my opinion one of his more important releases. Jack Kerouac - Blues and Haikus https://YouTube.com/watch?v=UyktuCjOisc https://YouTube.com/watch?v=UyktuCjOisc This is a full album from Kerouac featuring poetry readings from him, being able to hear the voice behind the writing adds a distinct dimension to the experience of appreciating the art. I really hope anyone who comes into this thread takes the time to check it out. It’s pure distilled cool.
- sammalloy 5y agoThe important takeaway is that Kerouac was writing about real people with real lives and real challenges they had to face during real rough times in America. The opening lines of "On the Road" tell you everything you need to know: > I first met Dean not long after my wife and I split up. I had just gotten over a serious illness that I won't bother to talk about, except that it had something to do with the miserably weary split-up and my feeling that everything was dead. Philosophy and religion and ethics and morality and leisure and work and goals and success and failure—this is not what Kerouac was really writing about. He was writing about people and relationships as if they were a musical composition to be played and listened to, with friends and lovers as instruments participating in the song of life. He was not trying to achieve something but to fully live and experience the moment, to recapture the beauty and sadness of everything all at once. While Kerouac is more associated with Jazz, he was really an Impressionist, attempting to follow in the footsteps of Proust and Debussy.
- joe_the_user 5y agoThe important takeaway is that Kerouac was writing about real people with real lives and real challenges they had to face during real rough times in America. While the people Kerouac wrote about were very real, I would just want to correct one thing. Kerouac wrote about people voluntarily or otherwise in the lower classes at a time (the 1950s) when things were relatively pretty good to be poor, you could get bare survival with little effort, the hassles were limited etc, that's why you could have amazing cultural creations coming out of that group, that's why a bit later the hippies were OK with voluntary poverty, etc.
- perrygeo 5y agoThis is an important point to me. These people were living (by relative standards, absolutely thriving) with very little income, coasting on what a post-war, peak-cheap-oil society could provide. Sure, in their writing they occasionally questioned the status quo. But reading it in retrospect just highlights how materially lucky they were to have those crazy experiences. Road tripping across the US in search of something greater is a privledge; if I met Dean Moriarty and Jack Kerouac today, I'd probably give them an "OK Boomer" eye roll.
- noident 5y ago> Both depict a way of living free from 20-year mortgages, nine-to-five jobs, conventional relationships, and family responsibilities Now it's a 30 year mortgage for a nine-to-six job, if you're lucky. Where's the new beat generation?
- duxup 5y agoPlenty of 9 to 5 jobs, folks just would rather not change jobs / want the pay associated with the commitment heavy jobs.
- goodpoint 5y agoAdd gig/temp jobs to that, loss of community, anxiety around climate change and social unrest, social network addiction and you call it the beaten generation.
- dkarl 5y agoI got into Buddhism through books on my dad's bookshelf. My dad became curious about Buddhism and Taoism through the writings of Alan Watts, Gary Snyder, and other people in that crowd, and he became fascinated with those people through the novels of Jack Kerouac. I always knew about this causal chain, but I never knew that Jack Kerouac himself wanted to be a popularizer of Buddhism! In my admittedly skewed perception, the glimpse he gave America into the Beat Generation was far more influential in promoting Buddhism indirectly than his own embrace of it.
- scythe 5y agoWhether or not Kerouac was responsible for bringing Buddhism to the West, the hole in his version of Buddhism certainly resembles that in the usual Western manifestation. The West often perceives Buddhism as endlessly transgressive, "no rules", but Buddhism does in practice usually have rules, and one of the rules that made the list of the five most important rules -- just five -- is "don't get drunk". ("Don't lie" is the really hard one, though!) Luckily for those of us in the modern day, much more has been translated from the Buddhist literature in the East than was available to the Beat Generation. I can't reasonably criticize someone's knowledge of Buddhism who learned about it in the '50s when I have Google and Wikipedia and Amazon, and there are probably more zen centers now, too.
- ngcc_hk 5y agoSeems strange a scan mainly about rejection of his book. Given he is totally into one kind of freedom to have drug, sex and his own idea of Buddhism (given he did not expose much to Indian, Tibetan, Hans and Japanese version … ) may be he is the Buddha otherwise you need to learn. And whilst seem really learning his Buddhism sorry I give it a pass. Buddhism is about freedom from something, depends upon the sect. But drug and sex (and girl friend fxxx sorry) is a strange bed fellow. And he is not one may I say. But what I know.
- AndyMcConachie 5y agoThe irony of the Beats is that while they may have turned lots of westerners onto Buddhism, they misinterpreted it terribly. When I was studying comparative religion as an undergrad I asked my professor of Japanese and Chinese religions if there were any American Buddhists that Chinese or Japanese buddhists viewed as detrimental to Buddhism and the western interpretation of Buddhism. She replied that there was only one, Alan Watts. He was largely disliked in Chinese and Japanese buddhist circles because he so completely misunderstood basic concepts and talked to eloquently about them. I later went to study in India for a semester where I had more exposure to many of the words that American buddhists such as Watts, or Kerouac throw around. I've seriously studied Buddhism in both American and Indian universities, and read books written by Chinese, Japanese, Indian, Tibetan, Korean, and Nepalese buddhists. I'm not a buddhist, but I can say with certainty that the Beats really didn't understand buddhism. Instead I view them as coming from a western tradition of capitalizing on oriental concepts by introducing them to an ignorant western audience. I doubt they did this intentionally, and it's not like I hold some kind of grudge against Kerouac for getting so much wrong. And in a way, good on them for introducing so many westerners to buddhism. If you are interested in Buddhism and your interest came from reading Beat literature, I highly suggest you seek out a teacher that does not draw their teaching from Beat sources, or anything that can be traced back to Alan Watts. Look for institutions that have been around for a while and that try to demystify complex concepts.
- bsenftner 5y agoGood points. As usual, the insightful posts asking the reader to think on HN get downvoted.
- bsenftner 5y agoIt dismays me how many idolize Kerouac. I've read him, the literary critiques, and the entire body of beatnik literature. How anyone can read the work and walk away idolizing the womanizing, self deception filled world of Kerouac is beyond me. Are you reading or are you idolizing because you've been told to idolize? If you idolize Jack Kerouac go back and re-read with modern empathy and you'll be ashamed.
- draw_down 5y ago
- douglee650 5y ago> … Sean Monahan, later said that though Kerouac’s “intuitions were right,” he “made up his Buddhism” and “didn’t know a lot about it, didn’t have a lot of training in it.” Watts himself said Kerouac had “Zen flesh but no Zen bones,” and poet and essayist Kenneth Rexroth wrote, “Kerouac’s Buddha is a dime-store incense burner.” The moss in this, is that Buddhism itself is purely a product of thought. Siddhartha himself did nothing other than thinking and writing (unsure on the writing vs. transcription). Everything else is lichen grafted on over the years as dogma creeps in.