13 ms·
The smallest and worst HDMI display
- makach 5y agoomg, i just bought and installed this display for my rpi4 and you tell me I can use it as a second monitor!? this is why I am a tech geek. :heart:
- jrockway 5y agoYou don't need to go through all the steps involving HDMI. Linux can create framebuffers on I2C/SPI displays like this. Many years ago, I connected two to a Beaglebone and it ran Emacs just fine. Much device tree hacking is involved, though, unfortunately.
- makach 5y agoyes, yes, this is exactly what I did. But connecting it to an HDMI port is infinitely much more cooler!
- blamazon 5y agoLink to the video demo at the end of the article: https://youtu.be/8UbVgUFfN8U https://youtu.be/8UbVgUFfN8U
- ironmagma 5y agoSide note, "Look around you" is an allusion to this video series: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t4CRCJUmWsM&list=PLsMUa0l1PW9Mnbzwy9gjaN0JlBuupQPQr https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t4CRCJUmWsM&list=PLsMUa0l1PW...
- blamazon 5y agoWrite that down in your copy book now.
- Hortinstein 5y agoWow this triggered some memories I cannot place but I love it!
- xwdv 5y agoWhat is this, a display for ants
- utopcell 5y agosmaller dpi and about the same size of an Apple watch that sells about 30M units a year :-)
- mikestew 5y agoUh, oh. The work project I'm working on uses an OLED display that uses an I2C interface. And I happen to have a spare one sitting on my desk. And I'm no electrical engineer, so let's see how fast I smoke this thing. :-) Should I succeed, TFA author will not have the worst HDMI display ever, as the one we're using is a two-line display looking something like this (it can do rudimentary graphics, though; we display a company logo at boot): https://www.mouser.com/ProductDetail/Vishay-Dale/O020O002ALPP5N0000?qs=odKRvHy9mbJh43b9jyKL0A%3D%3D https://www.mouser.com/ProductDetail/Vishay-Dale/O020O002ALP...
- dylan604 5y agoWhy not a simple LCD for this? What benefits from OLED attracts your interest?
- toast0 5y agoNot the OP, but small OLED displays are pretty low cost, and they don't need backlight management because the display is emissive. Viewing angles are usually nicer too.
- newaccount74 5y agoIf you put an OLED display behind dark plexiglass it looks really nice -- the border of the display becomes invisible and you see just the letters (or whatever else you are displaying). With LCD there's always backlight leaking.
- achairapart 5y agoI can imagine to look less DIY or "from the 90s". Vanitas.
- nicoburns 5y agoAt those tiny sizes (and in small quantities), the price difference is minimal but commonly available OLEDs and and LCDs often come in different sizes. So the choice may have been more about dimensions than display type.
- mikestew 5y ago
- v-yadli 5y agoSSD1306 can definitely do better than 6-10fps, which is close to the "software mode" driven by GPIOs, not an actual I2C interface. Either the DDC is running at very low speed, or... the I2C in HDMI in this laptop is actually a software thing?
- 58x14 5y agoI love this. What is it about pointless technical projects that are sometimes so alluring? I wonder if it's the removal of secondhand stress since there is no 'meaningful' success criteria.
- ncmncm 5y agoAnything that involves fooling with physical wires is fundamentally more satisfying than anything that doesn't.
- dylan604 5y agoKindred spirit! The one caveat to this rule for me requires that as long as there is wood and tools, it is okay to not have wires.
- _moof 5y ago<looks up from hand-riveting a wooden boat and grunts approvingly>
- JKCalhoun 5y agoLED-turn-on > pixel-change-color
- spacemanmatt 5y agoplot twist: pixels are LEDs
- ncmncm 5y agoBut, no wires.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoVery small wires.
- technothrasher 5y agoThis isn't so much an HDMI display as an I2C display utilizing the DDC channel in the HDMI interface as the I2C bus. I've seen folks utilizing this on the Raspberry Pi as a generic I2C bus as well.
- hunter2_ 5y agoEh, that's like saying phones don't charge over USB, just DC. We're referring to the physical connector more than to the typical bus.
- IshKebab 5y agoYeah I dunno, when I started reading I thought he had found a display that was coincidentally HDMI-compatible with the display HDMI signals. It's at least misleading.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoIt's not misleading to anyone casually familiar with those little OLED boards. They are cheap.
- Evidlo 5y agoIts not quite the same. I don't need to download a special host script to charge my phone on a friend's computer.
- LukeShu 5y agoI needed to download a special host script to charge a friend's iPad from my desktop.
- mfwit 5y agoWhat a lovely little collection of small projects.
- throwntoday 5y agoOh wow, I remember this guy from a Zelda forum I was on nearly 20 years ago. Glad to see he's still around.
- phh 5y agoArticle makes fun of how slow i2c is compared to the super high speed pairs next to it on HDMI plug. Well, please note that there is a bus that is literally a thousand time slower than i2c on that same connector. It's CEC. Contrary to i2c it only occupies one wire rather than two though. CEC, which is used mainly to power TV on/off or switch sources has a whopping bandwidth of 400bps. No missing multiplier. Maximum device name is 16B. If you have a TV, a tvbox and a game console, simply asking the name of those devices can take more than a second. I'm in the process of shortening my product's CEC name, in order to reduce congestion on the bus. Mainline Linux CEC developer jokes that Voyager 1 which is on the other side of solar system, made 40 years prior to CEC, is faster than CEC. Edit: Sorry for the atrocious original formating
- colejohnson66 5y agoVoyager is so far away that it's estimated data rate is only a hundred or so bps.[0] So CEC is actually faster now than Voyager! New Horizons still has the edge with an estimated kilobit/sec. EDIT: I was partially correct. It seems Voyager can transmit at up to 1.4 kbps for certain things.[1] [0]: https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/24338/how-to-calculate-data-rate-of-voyager-1 https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/24338/how-to-calcu... [1]: https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/spacecraft/ https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/spacecraft/
- satsuma 5y agowell, problem solved then! no need to update cec anymore
- dr_orpheus 5y agoVoyager still actually gets up to a whopping 1.4 kbps downlink! (but only 16 bps uplink) https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/spacecraft/ https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/spacecraft/
- perihelions 5y agoThat's a bit confusing; shouldn't it be the other way around? Because they're using the same antennas in both directions, but the power budget on the Earth-transmitting side is much higher. (Asked in the spirit of curiosity; I'm ignorant of radio physics).
- alana314 5y agoOh cool, I already follow mitxela for his crazy MIDI contraptions.
- amelius 5y agoI'm looking for a UART monitor with slightly bigger screen, and baudrate autodetection, to be used for debugging. It should be cheap. Any ideas where to look?
- threeme3 5y agohttp://www.technoblogy.com/show?TV4 http://www.technoblogy.com/show?TV4
- MrBuddyCasino 5y agoThis not cheap nor does it have a screen, but one of its many (many) uses allows interfacing USB to UART with auto-detection of both BAUD rate, voltage and whether or not its inverted: https://www.crowdsupply.com/1bitsquared/glasgow https://www.crowdsupply.com/1bitsquared/glasgow
- madeofpalk 5y agoWhat great timing. I've rearranged my desk and have trouble fitting a second monitor next to my ultrawide + big speakers, and I've been looking for a smaller monitor. This might be a tad too small, but worth considering!
- dghughes 5y agoThe slot machine company IGT (now Atronic?) on the AVP platform slots had buttons that were two colour small OLED screens using HDMI as a connector.
- trafnar 5y agoThe author should move the fun video at the end to the top!
- DannyBee 5y ago"I have a proclivity to stupid and/or pointless projects. " <scrolls through rest of project list> This is hilariously accurate, yet still somehow great.
- stretchwithme 5y ago20 years ago, we came across this tiny CRT display. I think it 4 X 5 inches. We pranked a coworker with it, replacing her large display with this tiny thing. And left a note explaining how the black and white display was an upgrade. :-)
- InCityDreams 5y agoA colleague of mine pranked a (much liked) co-worker: police and an anti-terrorism squad were called. Hilarity ensued....
- stretchwithme 5y agoI think we claimed it was an upgrade because it saved wear and tear on her rods and cones.
- lostgame 5y agoThese kinds of fantastic hackery are the reason I consistently come back to HN. This is an absolutely fascinating little piece of kit. It begs the question to as if there would be any actual utility to a display this small with it having to be directly attached to the laptop. Smartwatches come to mind, but tethered smartwatch-size displays...hmm...maybe add a wi-fi module and we've got something?
- teknopaul 5y agoQuite cool for an rPi. I have a project where only BPM (beats per minute) is useful and it would be handy that only the hdmi socket is occupied.
- Unit520 5y agoVery cool hack indeed! One thing I learned from this is that having an HDMI port gives you a free I2C port on top as well, as long as you have an old HDMI cable lying around to cut open. Small note on using these OLEDs with 5V: Typically they expect 3.3V Vcc and logic levels, although almost all of them seem to work just fine with 5V. In my experiments with a regular 5V Arduino some OLED modules made weird coil whining noises, I presume this is from the charge pump circuitry. Driving them with 3.3V as specified removed the coil whine completely.
- iforgotpassword 5y agoI recently learned about evdi, an out of tree Kernel module that can add as many virtual outputs as you want. Ideal for things like this, or where you'd normally use a dummy plug.
- follower 5y agoThat's exactly where my mind went when I read this post too. The link for anyone interested: https://github.com/DisplayLink/evdi https://github.com/DisplayLink/evdi It's unfortunate it wasn't accepted in-tree because while it was initially developed for a specific commercial product, I do think it has the potential to be generically useful. The ability to conjure up a display "in software" & then just have the rest of the system automatically treat it as any other physical display is pretty powerful. There's a couple of projects on my long "projects to do" that would make use of it...
- st3ve445678 5y agoBut can you play Doom on it?
- ByThyGrace 5y ago> You have to register to download the HDMI spec which is more effort than I have for this Wait, what? Register where? Is the HDMI spec behind IP bars?
- shakna 5y agoRegister with HDMI. [0] https://www.hdmi.org/requestform/clickrequestasync?docId=16 https://www.hdmi.org/requestform/clickrequestasync?docId=16
- mjlee 5y ago> Here is some trivia: did you know that the mouse cursor is rendered by hardware? Ah! That perhaps explains why often the cursor moves around just fine when other elements of the stack have completely given up.
- MayeulC 5y agoAs far as I know, it isn't really rendered by HW, but composited in HW. GPUs usually have multiple "Hardware planes" that are composited together in hardware before sending the signal. The OS is free to put whatever it wants there. Most HW include a designated "cursor plane", but it could be used to display whatever. IIRC a minimum of 3 HW planes is specified somewhere, it could be the Wayland protocol, or the Linux Direct Rendering Manager API. Some devices can have less though. That would be the case for that display, which could use an actual framebuffer driver (although planes could be emulated). You can thus have a layer for the background, one for the windows, and one for the cursor, and avoid re-painting too often, even though it should be pretty cheap for GPU-accelerated surfaces (like with compositors that rely on OpenGL).
- lisper 5y agoThis design is devilishly clever, but a tad misleading. It's not really an HDMI display notwithstanding that it is a display that plugs into an HDMI port. HDMI has an embedded i2c bus, and this project uses that to send images to the display. That's why you need a layer of software (xrandr) to translate images that the system produces into i2c.
- utopcell 5y ago(a) you're a buzz-kill; and (b) that i2c bus is part of HDMI so it is an HDMI display.
- lisper 5y agoIf you say so. The fact of the matter is that if you plugged that thing into, say, a DVD player with an HDMI output, it wouldn't work. Sorry if that kills your buzz.
- utopcell 5y agoIf you took the time to build this, then travelled back to the 1800's when people had standalone DVDs, and plugged this thing in expecting it to work, it would not kill my buzz: I'd find it quite entertaining to watch, really.
- gotaquestion 5y agoTo me the cool part is that you get a free I2C output over an HDMI port. I don't know any laptops that have native I2C output w/o a USB converter.
- killjoywashere 5y agoI feel like cable companies that have found a market with overpriced cabling for high-end entertainment systems, like Monster and Denon, could make a killing on this.
- goodburb 5y agoThis is pretty useful for NUCs, Qotoms, and x86 routers for showing stats.
- samstave 5y agoKinda unrelated, but I wish there were an HDMI std which also included power. I have two AOC 15" USB ONLY screens that I use with my laptop, and they all fit in my backpack... So I have a 3-screen setup in my backpack with one power supply (the laptop) ... its such a sweet setup. but an HDMI+power would be great (because then I could also have audio, and free up my USB ports.)
- detaro 5y agoI guess the answer for that nowadays is "USB-C", will all the complexity included with that...
- samstave 5y agoSo, I tested this.. I am on a flagship HP Omen Gaming Laptop (I arguably got the very first literal laptop shipped from the factory (have provenance, long story) And this stupid machine ($3K) has a laughable casing (super chints, bends easily, not good) -- it has (3) USB ports, with (1) being SS, the other two std, and (1) USB-C port. ZERO power out of the USB-C port. I have purchased multiple USB-C "hubs" -- none have pwer, all require external USB power. So imagin this: You buy a USB-C monitor, but your USB-C port provides no power, so in order to plug in a USB monitor into your USB-C HUB connected to your laptop via USB-C, you need a secondary cable to go through a regular USB port on your machine to provide power to the USB ports on your USB-C hub, thus consuming BOTH the USB port AND the USB-C port on your machine.... What a fucking design flaw this machine is. The guts are all hyped around the 165Hz screen and the RTX... but the physicality of this machine sucks. HP OMEN 15" 5800 RTX 165Hz machine... "gaming laptop"
- bskrobisz 5y agoI'm sure that those with a lot more hardware experience than me have the intuition to make guesses like this but I was surprised at: >You have to register to download the HDMI spec which is more effort than I have for this, but the Hot Plug Detect pin has a pretty descriptive name. I guessed that this either has to be pulled up or pulled down to signal that a cable is connected. Sticking a 20K resistor to the 5V pin seemed to do the trick. With the oscilloscope, we can now see activity on the SCL/SDA lines when it's plugged into the laptop. Is it really not that concerning to just guess what amperage will/won't fry something? I mean, you could test from very high resistances downwards, but you might overshoot, right? Or is there an assumption that the hardware on either end will provide the appropriate resistance, in this case?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eternityforest 5y agoHDMI is a pretty crazy protocol. CEC, HDMI, and then on top of that a dedicated hot plug detect? Is all this really needed? Can't I2C do everything? They could use a 1M pull down on SDA, and pull it up at the display side instead of the host side, and have that be hot plug detect, and then just use i2c for control as well.
- kimburgess 5y agoIt doesn't stop there, you have an audio return channel and 100Mbps Ethernet too.
- eternityforest 5y agoEthernet is reasonable, but why not just have audio over Ethernet? Or for that matter, USB2.0 instead of ethernet, and then you can have a hub on the monitor, a webcam, Ethernet over usb if you want, and audio return over usb?
- stragies 5y agoMy Pet theory for "Why did 100MbitOverHDMI not see traction" is, that -apart from linux/BSD- no other mainstream OS had reasonable-if-any support for meshed ethernet. I always hoped for a future, where all the devices can ootb intelligently decide, over which of the available interfaces (Eth, Wifi, HDMI) to send data per peer device. It would substantially reduce WIFI congestion in lots of (MediaCenter) installations. Same with CEC: "Windows doesn't support it, so why add it to GFX-card hardware?" ARC: Same deal "Not-supported-by-windows" has led to the death/non_implementation of lots of useful things/tech not only related to HDMI. E.g. the Per-Port-Power-Control spec part of USB is only implemented by some rare USB HUB(-Chip) vendors, and never tested for in any review. On supported hardware it works great with `uhubctl`. Ubiquitous 802.11s Wifi mesh support is in the same boat. As I say, my "pet theory". Happy to learn specifics.
- eternityforest 5y agoFor how amazingly useful it is... networking is kind of hacktastic at the protocol level. It's a bunch of layers that don't know anything about each other, and any even slightly unusual setup is a nightmare of manual configuration. It happens to do exactly what people do with it very well, central web services and some limited LAN stuff on the same subnet. I almost think things would be better off without the OSI model, if we were to start over. Just one CJDNS-like mesh, with native support for encryption, firewalling, pairing and discovery, all in one place, under one version number. Everyone talks about the flexibility but I'm super not convinced things like 6LowPan are a good idea. Just being able to say "This isn't IP and has no way to get on your network" is a big advantage of things like ZigBee, in a world where nobody really trusts this stuff.
- w0mbat 5y agoI've got it. You could make a mini display like this to clip over the notch on a new MacBook Pro.
- jzer0cool 5y agoUnrelated but wanted to ask here since this forum may have the knowledge. Recently I bought one of those 1) USB-C 4-in-1, 2) USB-C 7-in-1 (Anker) to attach an external monitor with HDMI. When connecting to a laptop is there details how to retrieve more details of all the capabilities and ports? What might also be some easy recommended way to start understanding how something like this works. To start, just sending a "high/low" signal to a data pin either straight connection into HDMI port, USB port as a direct connection (and how about when using a multi-port)? Thanks!
- peterburkimsher 5y agoHackaday has some similar DDC projects, which include interfacing with a microcontroller: https://hackaday.com/2014/06/18/i2c-from-your-vga-port/ https://hackaday.com/2014/06/18/i2c-from-your-vga-port/ https://hackaday.com/tag/i2c/ https://hackaday.com/tag/i2c/
- epiecs 5y agoI saw the author looking for the hdmi pinout. For anyone who wants a quick reference you can check this website: https://pinouts.org/ https://pinouts.org/