6 ms·
This demonstrates one of the particular ironies of Bitcoin: it's not an alternative to the US dollar insomuch as it's an extralegal way to acquire US dollars.
by woodruffw 5y ago
This demonstrates one of the particular ironies of Bitcoin: it's not an alternative to the US dollar insomuch as it's an extralegal way to acquire US dollars.
It sounds as if nobody in Lebanon is using Bitcoin to pay for milk and bread. Instead, they're exchanging it for a stable non-local fiat, which in turn pays for the milk and bread.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 5y agoBitcoin being used as an extralegal way to acquire anything isn’t an irony necessarily, just a part of functioning money.
- woodruffw 5y agoThe "irony" mentioned is that it isn't serving any of its myriad purported goals: it isn't a functional store of value and it isn't itself a mechanism of exchange or liquidity. Extralegality is merely a circumstantial property.
- everfree 5y agoBitcoin is a tool that can be used to enable something. If I want to get value out of a hammer, I don't care whether that value comes from me using it directly or indirectly, and I don't care whether the useful properties of my hammer are intentionally designed or are circumstantial.
- hdfjjbvcf 5y ago
- hiq 5y agoThe article mentions USDT (the stable non-local fiat) though, not Bitcoin. The article doesn't say whether people are interested in BTC for anything but mining.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 5y agoI am aware. I was responding to the comment emphasizing how using BTC (via mining or not) to get USDT is a known/anticipated use of Bitcoin and highlights Bitcoin performing at least one of money’s functions.
- trixie_ 5y agoIt's a sign of mistrust in their own currency. The easiest way to use crypto is to load a debit card with it and pay in your local currency as needed. Layer 2 networks provided by debit card providers avoid transaction fees and waiting for transactions to clear.
- skybrian 5y agoTheoretical arguments aren't very convincing. We need more real-world reports. How long do these transactions take, compared to credit card transactions in the same shop? What's the total cost for each?
- trixie_ 5y agoIt's not theoretical - coinbase, crypto.com, gemini, blockfi, etc.. all have debit cards. Use your crypto to buy stuff, get % rewards back in crypto as well.
- oh_sigh 5y agoDo any of those companies offer debit cards in Lebanon?
- el-salvador 5y agoBinance and Coinbase cards are not available for cardholders in Lebanon according to the FAQ on their sites. They are mostly for EU and US cardholders.
- trixie_ 5y agoThe cards should work wherever visa/mastercard is accepted. Here's one the specifically calls out Lebanon - https://spectrocoin.com/en/bitcoin-in-Lebanon.html https://spectrocoin.com/en/bitcoin-in-Lebanon.html
- googlryas 5y ago
- londons_explore 5y agoI believe this thinking is exactly the reason we haven't seen more government crackdowns on Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies. Think about it - Bitcoins stated aim is to remove government control of currency, something some governments have gone to war over. Yet bitcoin has relatively received very little attention from the US government. I believe thats because while the US government sees bitcoin as a threat to their currency monopoly, they also see it as more of a threat to other smaller countries with weaker economies. Hence, overall it benefits the USA.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- soperj 5y agoHow is it a threat if it's pegged to the dollar?
- hiq 5y agoThey were talking about non-pegged cryptocurrencies such as BTC.
- nradov 5y agoChina already started cracking down on cryptocurrency. Wealthy Chinese had been using crypto mining to evade currency controls and get their wealth out of the country. That still happens now but to a lesser extent.
- pirate787 5y agoAscribing a single actor and single motivation to "US government" is a common mistake (usually made by non-Americans). It misses the multi-polar nature of the US political and lobbying/advocacy system, and the fact that US policy is usually emergent. The reason there hasn't been a crackdown is that Bitcoin is traceable and intermediaries serving US citizens are abiding by Know Your Customer banking rules.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> while the US government sees bitcoin as a threat to their currency monopoly, they also see it as more of a threat to other smaller countries with weaker economies Bitcoin is no threat to the U.S. We have an open capital account. If Congress made Bitcoin legal tender tomorrow virtually nothing would change overnight. (Hell, if Congress abolished the Fed tomorrow and switched to exclusively Bitcoin, we'd just have to dust off old central banking books from the specie days. We'd also enter a deflationary recession.) For a capital controlled country, on the other hand, cryptos enable currency flight. Hence the lockdowns in China, Russia and India.
- ren_engineer 5y agocrypto is simply a hedge against incompetent/corrupt government, obviously blatant speculation has driven up the prices but at its core it still has value. I think the future is an abstraction layer to simplify converting to local currency and countries/governments having to compete for citizens by proving their competence
- kspacewalk2 5y agoNot sure how you can use an asset whose price is fluctuating so wildly (and is correlated/anti-correlated to indicators and trends having little to do with your local government) as an effective hedge against incompetent/corrupt government. I can certainly see its value for overcoming transaction barriers, whether they exist due to incompetence/corruption/backwardness of the financial system involved, or due to rule of law and anti-fraud legislation. When it comes to storing wealth, it seems to me that it's either speculative or illicit, and not much else. Illicit users find it attractive because its anonymity and "transaction smoothness" benefits outweigh the potential losses, much like losing 30% when laundering money is just cost of doing business.
- ceeplusplus 5y agoGold fluctuates +/- 20% vs. the dollar in any given year which I would consider quite "wild" and it's used globally as the currency of last resort. And the current demand for gold as a commodity in e.g. semiconductors hardly justify its lofty price. So I'd say gold is just as speculative as bitcoin in that sense, but perhaps less volatile. The value of bitcoin is predicated on the belief there is a limited supply, just like gold. The difference is that in one case the mechanism for limited supply is the Earth and the other is proof of work (which is more fallible than Earth obviously). In any case I don't think BTC is meant to be _used_ as a daily transaction medium (just like gold is not), no matter how much BTC bulls would have you believe it should be. But as a long term store of wealth holding BTC is like a riskier version of holding gold, with the same fundamentals driving the price.
- lottin 5y ago
- tomatowurst 5y ago> extralegal way to acquire US dollars This is so well put, I am going to take it. I would add that it is also a extralegal & illiquid medium to acquire fiat. The order books on Bitcoin is thin, its even thinner for Ethereum, even more so for Monero and dogecoin etc. Companies like Coinbase and Binance recognizes this, if they were to sell all the bitcoin in posession it would tank the prices due to illiquidity. Thus their main business model becomes quite similar: - easy onramp of fiat to crypto - difficult offramp from crypto to fiat (when price moves around, you can't even login as servers frequently "go offline") - in Binance's case, they are able to see all the orders in their books and routinely cause short/long position to be margin called - wash trading and other classic unregistered securities manipulation.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoSo what we needed the whole time was a digital settlement layer, not solely a currency? Hm. buys ETH
- rdtwo 5y agoEth layer 1 is too expensive for daily transactions.