6 ms·
US will now offer gender-neutral X option on passports
- bitxbitxbitcoin 5y agoI can imagine some potential scenarios at the borders of some countries where this might not be such a good idea but this is exactly why they allow you to get a copy passport. Another example of needing a copy would be if you had an Israeli stamp and you needed to visit one of the countries that doesn’t allow that.[0] [0] https://thepointsguy.com/guide/israel-entry-exit-travel-requirements/amp/ https://thepointsguy.com/guide/israel-entry-exit-travel-requ...
- delusion 5y ago[dead]
- rchowe 5y agoIf there's a picture of the person on the ID, gender doesn't seem very helpful in verifying identity.
- delusion 5y agoThe New Zealand Passport Office reviewed the utility of the sex marker on passports [1], in the context of calls to remove it, and concluded: > The costs of the removing the requirement to display the holder’s gender on travel documents outweigh the benefits at this stage. The costs of the change would be more significant given the adverse affects on the operations of border authorities and the potential inconvenience for passengers. In particular, they noted that border authorities use this data for risk assessment, the significant cost of modifying existing software that processes this, and that many countries would not accept passports without a sex marker. [1] https://www.icao.int/Meetings/TAG-MRTD/Documents/Tag-Mrtd-21/Tag-Mrtd21_IP04.pdf https://www.icao.int/Meetings/TAG-MRTD/Documents/Tag-Mrtd-21...
- AvocadoPanic 5y agoNo? I've seen a few of the people likely to opt for an X. It's likely the picture will not be useful for determining their sex. This is why male / female was useful.
- Inityx 5y agoWhy would you need to determine their sex?
- dolni 5y agoBecause girls and women are targets of sex trafficking? Now you give abusers the ability to get travel documents with an "X" which makes them harder to spot. There seems to be this attitude taking hold whereby people who are (probably) overwhelmingly young and ignorant challenge everything they consider "not progressive". Clearly all the people who came before us were a bunch of idiots, so how could they possibly do anything right? It's an arrogant hubris. I say that as someone who is only in their mid 30s. What I have come to realize is that everything people do (including those things I consider stupid, like organized religion) has a purpose. Once in a while the justification is weak. But if you find yourself wanting to eliminate some social practice because you think it's stupid and can't possibly comprehend why we would do a thing, that's a sign of ignorance. Only after you understand the purpose can you start to talk about whether something is actually still useful.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nevermindiguess 5y ago
- prestonh 5y ago> The woke disease. Which has also taken our world close to WW3 recently. Reference?
- Jerrrry 5y ago[flagged]
- copperx 5y agoCan you explain?
- Jerrrry 5y agoAzov battalion was a Nazi regiment until it was in our interest to overlook it. Google CNN's coverage, a few months ago, then compare to now. One planted Nazi flag made the media paint all the Canadaian trucker as Nazi's. Yet, we are arming people who proudly claim to be Nazi's. Of course, all of this is Russian propaganda, and you will be banned on Reddit, Facebook, and other outlets for having inappropriate thoughts, if you were to doubt the narrative: putin bad! ukraine good! that simple! we were never at war with Eurasia.
- undoware 5y agoHandedness is a fact. I'm left-handed, but my passport doesn't need to say so. Why is it 'sensible' to include this? Shall we include my favourite foods as well?
- delusion 5y agoHere's an analysis of the utility of the sex marker in the context of calls for its removal, by the New Zealand Passport Office: https://www.icao.int/Meetings/TAG-MRTD/Documents/Tag-Mrtd-21/Tag-Mrtd21_IP04.pdf https://www.icao.int/Meetings/TAG-MRTD/Documents/Tag-Mrtd-21... They note several negative outcomes if the sex marker were to be removed - some excerpts: > Border authorities would be less able to establish the context of a passenger's travel and do risk assessments before passengers arrive. Knowing the passenger's gender is useful in determining if someone matches the profile of a person of interest. This cannot always be done using a passenger's name because some names are unisex. > A significant problem for border officials is the detection systems used to process passengers would be less reliable. Automatic systems such as watchlist checks would bring up more false matches if a passenger's gender information is not entered in border control systems. Excessive false alarms may undermine security as officials are more likely to ignore alerts if they are constantly dealing with false matches. These false matches would also decrease the speed passengers are processed. > Upgrading and modifying software would impose significant costs on border authorities and airlines. Ongoing costs would be high as the systems used to read travel documents would have to handle processing the two types of travel documents for a significant period of time. If ICAO made not displaying the gender field mandatory, this period would be around 10 years. If displaying the gender field became optional, this period of having to modify software to process the different types of travel documents would be indefinite. > The common secondary use of travel documents to provide identification in non-travel situations may be undermined if the gender field is removed. People issued a travel document that does not display their gender would lose an official way to prove their gender. This may be inconvenient where someone is required to provide an official document that displays their gender, perhaps to access a service restricted to only males or females. The same doesn't apply to whether a person is left-handed or right-handed. Usually, that information is recorded nowhere.
- 5y ago
- wincy 5y agoI think when I get my passport soon I’m going to get this, and the same for my wife. Heck I wonder if I can get it for my two daughters too. The less information I have to give out the better. I do wonder if this would get my family hassled at the border to some countries.
- president 5y agoHas anyone seriously and honestly asked themselves why the US is so keen on pushing the LQBTQ agenda? Even if sincere, LGBTQ people are a very tiny percentage of the population so why go through such lengths to make large and sweeping systemic changes? It is totally distracting from much more serious issues. Very puzzling.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kn0where 5y agoIs it really a large and sweeping change, or a tiny change that’s far less difficult to implement in our politically gridlocked country than anything requiring legislation?
- version_five 5y agoI dont think it's fair to characterize an "LGBTQ Agenda" as if there is cabal trying to bend the country to their will. I think somehow it's become mainstream to be terrified of offending anyone, while simultaneously not really understanding what we stand for. And a very small minority of trolls exploit that to see how far they can push us on ridiculous directions. You look at how much harm this does to the public perception of people who may fall under someone's umbrella LGBetc acronym, and how everyone gets riled up while also looking ridiculous. Who does it actually serve. So don't think there is a coherent agenda, just look at it as trolling and try not to hold it against normal people who just want to live their lives.
- Saris 5y agoIs it really a large change? It's just a letter on a document. I wouldn't call the LGBTQ population a tiny percentage when ~14% of people in the US don't identify as straight. I have seen pretty much nothing from the US that appears to be “pushing the LQBTQ agenda”.
- meepmorp 5y ago> It is totally distracting from much more serious issues Which other issues? Which issues would be getting addressed now, but for attention consumed by "the LGBTQ agenda?"
- pyuser583 5y agoI’m not for or against this. I am against people automatically assuming this is good or bad. For better or worse, gender is frequently used as a piece of identifying information. This could cause problems. For example, many cisgendered privacy oriented folks could choice this option. The possible result would a very large chunk of the population having no gender marker on their passport. This might sound good - but it would make it very hard to study, for example, whether men or women receive preferential treatment from US Consuls. Or whether men or women face different threats abroad (some embassies keep statistics on sexual assaults). If we hypothetically assume that gender is no longer recorded, that means gender inequality becomes very difficult to study. Additionally, US Passports function as identity documents for US Citizend abroad. When I travel, I use it to pick up prescriptions. Most foreign pharmacies will accept it, but I occasionally run into trouble. I simply hope the State Department looked at these issue.
- ivraatiems 5y agoIf more cisgendered/non-LGBTQ people adopt it for privacy reasons, that could helpfully shield LGBTQ people who might face persecution for having it on their passport in other countries. So maybe a feature, not a bug?
- pyuser583 5y agoI can’t imagine a situation where a bigoted foreign police officer is going to say “oh this person is probably just a privacy oriented civil libertarian, not some <insert horrible name for sexual minority>.” I just can’t imagine that happening. I could imagine a situation in, say, Saudi Arabia where I need to prove in male in order to, say, drive a car. And not being able to do so could get me in a world of trouble.
- ivraatiems 5y ago> I can’t imagine a situation where a bigoted foreign police officer is going to say “oh this person is probably just a privacy oriented civil libertarian, not some <insert horrible name for sexual minority>.” They're not going to say that, they're going to say "oh, lots of Americans have this, who even knows what it means, the person in front of me looks [male/female] enough, whatever, go on."
- ivraatiems 5y agoI support this as a matter of policy in terms of recognizing LGBTQ people and respecting their identities. However, I think we'd need to make sure people who choose this optional are aware of potential ramifications when going to a country that doesn't share the current American government's relatively progressive social stances. For example, China or many middle eastern countries seem likely to add a lot of extra scrutiny to someone who has this on their passport. And even if you are just transiting the airport in such a country, it could increase the skepticism of local authorities or "out" you as someone "deviant" in the terms of that society's norms. It's unfortunate that it is this way, but we can't really control the behavior of every other country out there, so it's important for travelers to be informed.
- juanani 5y ago
- dfawcus 5y agoDo US passports have a "Gender" field? My British one has a "Sex/Sexe" field. A prior old style one didn't even have that[1], only listing the Sex of infants (if I included any). [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/bc/UK_Passport_Pre_88_change.jpg/337px-UK_Passport_Pre_88_change.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/bc/UK...
- Spivak 5y agoNo they have a sex field, the state is taking about allowing M, F, and X for that. There is really no distinction between gender and sex except as a way for people to explain the difference between “social sex” (i.e. the one people mean 99% of the time they say sex) and “chromosomal sex” (i.e. the one basically only doctors care about). Every one of my trans friends has their sex on their legal documents matching their post transition sex. Which like I get that it’s controversial round certain parts that it’s even possible for those two concepts to not be in lock step but you gotta remember that 20 years ago it was controversial whether one’s sexual orientation could not be in lock step with one’s sex.
- AvocadoPanic 5y ago
- NylaTheWolf 5y agoWow! Finally some positive news about trans people! It's a small step, but it's a step nonetheless!